94 The UN Security Council (II)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jun 19, 2025
And finally, Chapter 7. Chapter 7 is entitled Action with Respect to Threats to the Peace,
Breaches of the Peace and Acts of Aggression. Chapter 7 is a central part of the Charter,
under which the Security Council has the power to take resolutions that are binding on the UN
member states. Under Chapter 7, the resolution of the Security Council can be recommendations,
but they may also be binding decisions. And Article 48 of the Charter compels member states
to comply with the measures decided by the Council. I quote,
the action required to carry out the decisions of the Security Council shall be taken by all
the member states of the United Nations, or by some of them as the Security Council may determine.
End of quote. Later in the course, I'll address the legal effects of Security Council resolutions.
But let me concentrate now on what is required for the Council to exercise its powers under Chapter
7 in a concrete situation. In order to trigger its binding powers under Chapter 7, the Security
Council must first determine the existence of any threat to the peace, breach of the peace,
or act of aggression. Those words of Article 39 are central. A situation, a crisis, must be
qualified by the Council as constituting either a threat to the peace, or a breach of the peace,
or an act of aggression. And there is a clear gradation of seriousness in those words.
And you can think of them as concentric circles, with the act of aggression at the core,
then the breach of the peace, and then the threat to the peace as being even more encompassing.
And as we have seen earlier this week, Resolution 3314 of 1974, adopted by the General Assembly,
offers some guidance as to the definition of what is an aggression. However, the Council has so far
refrained from going as far as speaking of an act of aggression. Even when Iraq invaded Kuwait in
August 1990, which was a blatant act of aggression, the Council preferred to refer to, I quote,
a breach of international peace and security as regards the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait,
and that's Resolution 660. For the rest, there is no definition of what constitutes a breach
of the peace, and even less of the concept of threats to the peace. To make it short,
a threat to the peace is what the Security Council determines to be a threat to the peace.
Saying that does not mean that the Council would make frivolous determinations,
because the procedure to reach a majority with no veto is rather cumbersome and requires to engage
in delicate diplomacy. But be that as it may, the concept of threat to the peace is wide and not
limited to crisis situations between states. The notion of peace is not reduced to the absence of
armed conflict between nations. Peace is a much wider notion, and threats to the peace also.
And the Security Council made that very clear in the landmark declaration of 31 January 1992,
when it met at the level of heads of states and heads of government at the end of the Cold War.
On many, many occasions since then, the Security Council has qualified purely internal situations
and conflicts as being threats to the peace, therefore opening its powers under Chapter 7.
Under Article 2, Paragraph 7 of the Charter, I quote, matters which are essentially within the
of states fall beyond the competence of the UN. But this is precisely without prejudice
to the enforcement powers of the Security Council under Chapter 7. Therefore, the sacrosanct
internal affairs of states can be interfered with by the Security Council when it determines that
a threat to the peace exists. Very often, it is because grave breaches of international law
have occurred that the Council determines the existence of a threat to the peace.
However, it is important to remember that qualifying a situation as being a threat to the
peace is not a judicial qualification, but a political qualification made by a political organ.
And it is in any event independent of any legal finding. Absent any breach of international law,
the Council could determine that a threat to the peace exists. And for instance, a natural disaster
having important repercussions could give rise to a threat to the peace. And let me take a stupid
example in order to make this point clear. If extraterrestrial creatures were to invade
our planet, there would be no breach of any international law because international law
is the law of humanity. But such invasion could still be qualified by the Security Council
as a threat to the peace. And the Council could, for instance, forbid the Member States to conclude
any separate peace agreement with the invaders coming from deep space. So, there is no relation,
necessary relation, between threat to the peace and a breach of international law. Let us turn
now to what the Security Council can do with its powers under Chapter 7 once it has determined
the existence of a threat to the peace, a breach of the peace, or an act of aggression.
