Modern International Law

General Principles of Law
24 followers
8 Video Views·Oct 25, 2024
In the previous lesson what we did was take a look at the history of international law going
all the way up to the beginnings of the 20th century. In this video what we're going to do
is talk about the state of international law as we can understand it to this day
and this involves still examining the history to an extent but still focusing on more the
parts of international law that were retained and that still have application to this day
and parts that while not retained were replaced with very similar substitutes.
Okay and you'll understand what I mean when I say these things in a second.
Okay like I said previously we examined some of the early histories of international law
talking beginning out of the imperialism of the Spanish empire. We'll talk in more detail in the
continuation of this story by examining the historical development of modern conceptions
of international law and I want to just pick up where we left off really from the last video
because one of the things that happens as we go on throughout this series of lessons and throughout
the history of international law is something of a europeanization of international law.
Now to some extent international law has always been a European concept or at least it began out
of the intellectual ideas of Europe because obviously Europe had a lot of imperialism
and exported a lot of its ideas across empires across the world across centuries essentially.
So there is sort of this European western characteristic of international law and this
is something that is being increasingly challenged more and more by the global south
with things like third world approaches to international law or even critical approaches
to international law which is gaining in more and more popularity as time goes on as people begin to
challenge the western-centric approaches that have been utilized in international law and one
of the reasons for this is because it seems to be the case that in at least in modern conceptions
and at least in the last 30 or 40 years it seems that western states have consistently contravened
elements of international law and seem to have no real concern for this contravention of international
law. One such example is the invasion of Iraq in 2003 and this is obviously something that
would shatter or at least falter somebody's commitment to and belief in these western
states places like the UK and the United States and it would really question their ability to
believe that these countries will actually adhere to the basic principles of international law.
So to suggest that international law is an entirely European concept is of course not true
because international law is useful and there is an equality of states regardless of where the state
is on the planet but there is this European-centric element to international law to this day.
The developments in international law at the turn of the 1800s is marked with an increased
Europeanization of the discipline so it begins to reflect the ideals of the states of Europe as
time goes on specifically in the 1800s and these developments in the field were almost limited
entirely to the continent so we see at the end of the Napoleonic Wars at the start of the 1800s
and the Congress of Vienna which really ends the Napoleonic Wars we see a new international order
in Europe be established and this is a very Euro-centric power balance that is created
as a result of the Congress of Vienna. Couple this with the Industrial Revolution,
the increasing nationalistic sentiments of the unifications of both Germany and Italy in the
mid to late 1800s and the increasing tensions as we erupt into the world wars of the 20th century
and you get an increasingly Euro-centric interpretation of international law.
Add into the mix even more by the way the fact that all of these European states pretty much
all of these European states were empires and so exported all of these ideas across
the imperialistic world, across into Africa, across into Asia, across the Americas.
All of these things really solidify the view that international law is inherently a European
concept and even to this day a lot of international law is adjudicated in Europe. The Hague for
example with the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court. You have
various European-centric elements of international trade law within Geneva, Switzerland, the World
Trade Organization or the UNCTRA which is the UN's trade commission which is in Vienna. All of
these things obviously give more deference to this view that international law is an inherently
European concept. Despite this there were still developments in what I would define here as the
quote spirit of international law and this is really where we're going to start to talk about
the things that began in the 1800s, began in the sort of just before the modern period of
international law but that were picked up and carried on with and one of the most important and
easiest to understand is the International Committee for the Red Cross and the Red Crescent,
the ICRC. Now the ICRC was actually formed and founded following the Battle of Solferino in 1859.
For those of you who want to know more about this you can look at our lessons on international
humanitarian law that are coming out in conjunction with this. Essentially a Swiss businessman by the
name of Jean-Henri Donat witnessed the aftermath of the Battle of Solferino while he was in prison.
He noted quite significantly the suffering of wounded soldiers and as a result of that he began
a campaign which would ultimately lead to the establishment in 1863 of the International
Committee for the Red Cross and the Red Crescent and it would also begin with the first spate of
Geneva Conventions in 1864. The aim here was to humanize armed conflict and essentially would
form the practice of international humanitarian law, the laws of war, and so as a result of this
the International Committee for the Red Cross and the Red Crescent continue to work in not just war
situations but also in disaster situations as well to this day and provide humanitarian relief
and support to people who are suffering as a result of war and armed conflict. And the state
of international humanitarian law is arguably one of the oldest areas of international law, coupled
with arguably international law of the sea in my opinion. These are the two sort of real old
elements of international law. Now between the world wars, between 1914 and 1939, you have the
establishment of what is arguably the older brother, if you will, of the United Nations. This was the
League of Nations. So the brutalities of the First World War led the international community to
establish both the Treaty of Versailles as well as the League of Nations. The League of Nations
can be seen as a preamble to the modern establishment of the United Nations as we have
today. There are lots of similarities between the UN and the League of Nations. A lot of the downfalls
of the League of Nations were mistakes that weren't repeated by the United Nations. One major
element of the League of Nations was that the United States was not a part of it. The United States
between 1914 and 1939 went about a period of isolationism. They cut themselves off from the
rest of the world and then they enjoyed the 1920s and then had a depression in the 1930s and then
went back to war again in the 1940s. So there are definitely parallels between the United Nations
that we have today and the League of Nations that we had between 1914 and 1939. A lot of the principles
and doctrines of the League of Nations, for example, were codified into the UN Charter. You also have
some more menial but symbolic things. So things like the League's permanent Court of Justice
being in the same location as the UN's current International Court of Justice. And we will
actually get to some cases that were established and founded by the permanent Court of Justice
in future lessons time because they lay down legal principles which are still relevant to this day.
Just because the UN was created at the end of the Second World War does not mean that principles
of international law prior to the Second World War aren't important. However, as I've mentioned
already, the League of Nations was fundamentally flawed. There was a lack of membership from major
powers such as the USSR and the United States, and for a lot of the time Germany as well. They joined
and then they left again and then they went to war, so that's problematic. The League of Nations
also failed to deal with a number of major challenges that it should have been able to deal
with. So the Japanese invasion of China, the Manchurian crisis, the Italian invasion of Abyssinia,
modern-day Ethiopia, as well as the German invasion of Czechoslovakia, and then eventually
the invasion of Poland in September 1939, as well as the Soviet invasion of Finland.
All of which could have been dealt with or should have been dealt with by the League of Nations.
That's what the purpose of the League of Nations was, none of which were dealt with by the League
of Nations, showing quite a significant failure on their part and ultimately devolving into a
Second World War. Now the vast majority of international law that you will study today
in university or in school, it comes from the post-World War II settlement. So if you study
a lot of public international law, a lot of ICJ cases, for example, are post-World War II,
because the ICJ didn't exist before World War II. The international community establishes in 1946
the United Nations Organization. There are currently, at the time of recording, 193 members
of the United Nations, the most recent being the 2011 recruitment of South Sudan to the United
Nations. There are a number of candidate states that could maybe one day become members of the
United Nations and receive full statehood, and we'll get to maybe that in future lessons time.
Now, like I said, modern international law, the majority of studies of international law today,
are talking about legal principles that developed after the Second World War. So pick any part of
international law that we study and you will find that the majority of the instruments or cases or
principles come after the Second World War. International criminal law was developed after
the Second World War with Nuremberg and with the ad hoc tribunals and the ICC in the 1990s.
International trade law was established in the 47 General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade
and then the 1995 establishment of the World Trade Organization. International law of the sea,
for the most part, is regulated by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, the
UNCLOS treaty. All of these different things are established post-World War II and so it really
shows the influence of international law and the growth of international relations at the end of
the Second World War.
