Real Road Test: Renault 4 - tested by a 2CV fanatic!

Screw Driver
87 followers
#car #automobile #business #consulting #salesagent
The third most-produced car in the world is the Renault 4 (after the Ford Model T and VW Beetle), and it comfortably outsold the Citroen 2CV. But what does a seasoned 2CV fanatic make of it?
This car is for sale with Chevronic Centre: 01462 455 280 or https://chevronics.co.uk
In this video, this heartened 2CV-er is testing the opposition. It's the Renault 4.
The Renault 4 was launched in 1961 and it doesn't take a genius to work out exactly
what they were trying to do. They were trying to build a rival to the Citroën 2CV.
Citroën responded by building the Citroën Dan, but we are getting ahead of ourselves.
Renault was very good at looking at Citroën and finding a different way to do exactly the same
thing. The Renault 16 is a prime example and it all came about because someone at Renault decided
that the problem with Renault is that Renault was building cars for city people like the Renault
4CV, rear-engined and slightly questionable handling on the limit and much more at home
in a city than out in rural parts. The 2CV was lapping up the sales because it was so practical,
it had such comfortable suspension and it could take a huge load in the back. All very practical
stuff. So Renault said how are we going to build a rival that is practical and comfortable and can
do all the things the 2CV can do and maybe a few more. And this was the result. Remarkably
utilitarian bodywork because it knew that that's what the market wanted and arguably one of the
first hatchbacks. Now the Citroën Traction Avant Commercial can lay claim to being the first
real proper production hatchback but this is the first small hatchback coming out a few years
before the Auto Bianchi Primula and I'm trying to think where the Austin A40 Countryman comes
into this story but it's there or thereabouts. Renault themselves kind of presented it as an
estate car which is why it's a bit more flat on the back than the 2CV but it's all about
practicality and simplicity. The bonnet on the Renault 4 lifts forward and here is a most unusual
engine layout because what Renault did was took the rear mounted engine out of the 4CV and moved
it to the front with the same layout so the gearbox is ahead of the engine so it really is
just a whole lot moved forward in the car. This long rod is the gear change and it's just simply
a hook that goes around this lever that goes into the top of the gearbox. It works surprisingly well
for such a simple and rather Heath Robertson arrangement. Now this is a later one so it has
slightly different running gear. When they first came out it really was the 747cc engine moved to
the front. There was also a Renault 3, not 3, I have a speech impediment, and that had a 603cc
engine that was designed deliberately to take on the Citroen 2CV but it was super cheap, super
basic and actually people didn't want that. They didn't mind paying a bit more for a bit more
luxury so the 4 became the standard model. This one has the 1108cc engine, the clay on front engine
sometimes called the Sierra engine confusingly, and this is a later overhead valve engine and a
bit more power than the earlier engines. The 747 was replaced by the 845cc engine out of the Dauphine,
also rear-engined, and that engine lived on until the 1980s and this engine became a larger engine
option in the 1970s. Initially gearboxes were 3-speed, this one has the later 4-speed gearbox so
yeah it's a very very strange implement that comes all the way over the top to that front mounted
gearbox. It does leave the gearbox rather vulnerable but that's not too dissimilar to other front wheel
drive French cars such as the Citroen DS and the Traction Avant. Exactly the same engine layout and
it's done so you've got the weight a bit further back, better handling. The structure is actually
quite interesting, it's a semi monocoque. Yes the body has some strength to it but there's a platform
chassis running underneath which allowed them to be very creative and create different versions
for different markets. Got the jack over there and the wheel brace. So the Rodeo was the Mahari
equivalent, that was a plastic bodied jeep based on the Renault 4 running gear and you could even
get four-wheel drive versions, the Sinpars and a Plan Ciel I think it was, no I'm thinking
Simcas, Planair maybe, which was basically a roadster buggy type Renault 4. So a lot of practicality
and ultimately refined into the Renault 6 which had slightly more normal bodywork but was very
much still the same under the skin. It's astonishing how Renault tried to make a 2CV but it's
actually really really different. One of the more interesting aspects is the suspension, it uses
torsion bars and that means that the suspension this side, sorry the wheelbase this side, is slightly
shorter than the wheelbase this side because it uses torsion bars that go across the width of
the car and we've got longitudinal ones on the front. Now the 2CV ditched torsion bar suspension
because they just found it too bouncy, they had no control and I suspect what's happened here is
in the 1930s damping technology wasn't very good. By the 1960s it was good enough to make the Renault
4 handle well and go well but very very soft, very supple suspension and they do actually roll like
2CVs. We'll go and have a look inside because again very very different, very very cosy. We've
got simple sliding windows and the door's shut with a clang but yeah it's quite cosy in here
when you leap in. One reason for that is the fact the engine is coming so far back so you've got
this big centre console area which is necessary to clear the back of the engine. I'll just get
myself comfortable. The steering wheel is slightly further away there than it is there so it's not
actually parallel with the driver. This later one obviously got a very plasticky dashboard
but a proper indicator noise. We've got little fresh air vents because obviously that's important
the 2CV had that fresh air system but we've got a proper heater and the 2CV just uses heat
exchanges off the exhaust. The Renault 4 was always going to be water-cooled but Renault worried about
losing sales to the simple air-cooled 2CV created a sealed for life system with a header tank
which is quite unusual for the 1960s so they claimed you would never have to top it up or do
anything it should always be fine just as simple. The stalks will be recognised by anyone who's
owned a 1980s Renault they're very much of the same sort of ilk and the pedal placement is quite
peculiar the throttle is all the way up here tiny little button so the pedals on a 2CV oddly are
much better for heel and toe but the Renault boasts extra door pocket stowage and a bit more
space generally so it's actually I think more comfortable here even though it still feels quite
cozy. No full length sunroof I believe you could specify that as an option but most people didn't
just stuck with the windows and simple they are and the French absolutely love hiding door handles
so it's actually in here you push down a little flap to open the door and yeah many people have
been trapped in various French cars because they just love hiding things. Lots of lights on the
dashboard light up for various things fog light heated rear window that's about it we haven't got
a lot else. There's a foot operated squeegee for the screen wash that's up here that's the
same as a Citroen Diane so we'll give that a squeeze oh yeah it works quite well and they go to wipers
oh the blades have seen better days on this one sadly two speed they get two speed wipers on a 2CV
but yeah sadly those blades are degraded somewhat but yeah it's quite posh in here
look this is how you go hot waters up there cold water down there got a lever here to where you
want that hot air or cool air to go and then this is the bonnet release which you push bizarrely
we've actually got a heater blower and whoa it's two speeds now 2CV has a heater blower but
unfortunately it's the big fan on the front of the engine a conventional handbrake down here the seat
adjusts back and forth I'm not sure they actually adjust the backrest angle oh no they do luxury of
luxuries now you don't get that on a 2CV and I'm just having a look over there yeah so it's
exactly the same seat so the control knob is also on that side over there as well let's see how it
compares in the back now a key difference here is this door is cleared it's designed to clear your
head as you get in that is very different to a 2CV which curves the other way and you have to kind of
fold yourself into the back so I shall get in behind me oh it's a bit tight for leg room oh
there's a sign on the floor I don't want to tread on and uh we're in but uh good good head room it's
just the leg room is a bit pinched there for what is um it feels like slightly larger car than the
2CV and to be honest I don't really fit in the back of a 2CV either but uh yeah the fact the
more luxuries denied to 2CV is reverse lights how very very fancy tailgate pings up like so
and has this locking mechanism there so that's better than the 2CV because the 2CV has a fixed
rear window generally there's a little parcel shelf here which it looks like you've got to lift
out um seems about as practical as a GSA one ie not at all uh in fact I don't think it does lift
out I think it just folds down with the back seat of a car cover in this example um but yeah look at
the floors beautiful condition this example is very very lovely I'm just going to see if it does
one-handed operation yes it does so it's designed to just lock enough but then you can pull it down
so you don't have to flick a switch that's better than a diane a diane you have to release the pole
so you find yourself balancing the tailgate on your head to release the pole to do it one-handed
so there we go that's what it's like um inside and out we're going to see what it's like actually on
the road I've got my seat belt on so we'll start with a gear change uh it's not like a 2CV pattern
so that's neutral there we're going to first second let it spring third fourth and reverse
is down there uh it's it's not as good as a 2CV gear lever I'm not saying that just because I'm
a 2CV it rattles and it's just not as accurate as the rifle bolt of a 2CV it's just a different
coupler this just has that hook and ring arrangement and it is a bit vague I actually
owned a Renault 5 with a dashboard gear change very early one and it was much the same going to
open that for a bit more ventilation but start the engine and a very different soundtrack because
it's conventional four-cylinder water-cooled engine sounds good right into first we go first
of all we're going to have a drive around this field because one thing the Renault had to do
was be just as good over bumpy terrain as a 2CV and it is if not better it's an astonishingly
good ride it's very very supple and very well damped so uh that's a big success for Renault
and we haven't got the 2CVs a very very loud first gear whine either that's a key difference here
all right feels so far much more refined we'll see if that continues shall we
this example was built in France in 1990 ironically the final year of 2CV production
and UK sales ended in about 1987 but French sales continued until 1992
and actually production continued in Morocco and Slovenia until 1994
and what a lot of people don't realize is that this car was a massive sales success it was sold
in 27 sorry no it was built in 27 different countries and in terms of total sales uh they
sold over 8 million which is considerably more than the 2CV in fact it's the third
most successful car of all time that's quite extraordinary only the Volkswagen
Beetle and Model T Ford have sold more yet where have all the Renault 4s gone
you still see quite a few of them in France but here in the UK they've become a very rare sight
which is perhaps why this one was imported from France in 2005 it's a GTL spec so it's got the
1108cc engine although this is a saverne special edition which i think relates to the upholstery
travel like this there we go yeah it's not a quick car but um compared to a 2CV i think it has the
upper hand there's a certain amount of road noise coming through um because there's very very little
sound deadening and an awful lot of painted metal but uh it feels yeah very pleasant i don't like
this offset steering wheel though that isn't actually straight in front of me that's very very
bizarre yeah when you look at the countries the Renault 4 was built in it was built in Ireland it
was built um in Uruguay and other South American countries uh it really did become a world car for
Renault and to be fair Citroen had tried to do that with a 2CV the 2CV was produced in Argentina
and a few other places Brussels even the UK briefly but perhaps because the Renault 4 is
that bit more car like it just sold in extraordinary numbers there was a very pleasant van version as
well complete with a giraffe hatch above the rear door so you could have um long things ladders and
stuff maybe even super long baguettes sticking out the roof it's very well mannered but you know
a 2CV just has so much character and charm and uh these cars just don't quite have that
the fact that the 2CV looks like a snail it's got such a characterful face and i think i think the
4s do don't get me wrong but uh it's just not the same is it another luxury we've got in this car
compared to a 2CV is the rear windows open only British built 2CVs had opening rear windows
it's a very simple gear change uh you just let it bounce back to its natural place and you're
on the third fourth gate so you twist for first pull straight back for second let it twist for
third and into fourth could not be simpler really although still conservative British buyers might
and i will say this is a better window solution than the flappy windows of a 2CV
that was never going to be the best solution oh another key difference synchromesh on first gear
i mean generally that gearbox feels a much more refined unit than the 2CV one in terms of noise
but of course the gearbox is so far away as well also unfortunately the interior mirror gets right
in my way whoops hello where's this van going i'm only going to use the middle of the road
and both lanes to go right that's impressive work sir oh wow i know it's pulled out in front of a
truck that's just incredible yeah that decently brisk roundabout acceleration that's where you
often find yourself needing to get a bit of a shift up it does apparently do that but yeah
ultimately acceleration is still rather leisurely even with this larger engine you didn't buy a
Renault 4 if you wanted to go quickly brakes don't inspire as much confidence as the 2CV but that's a
very mushy feeling pedal later 2CVs boast disc drum brakes and they really are quite good but here we
we're closing in on 60 miles an hour and there it is and i'll tell you that's not actually all
that much better than the 2CV engine noise is fairly quiet but there's so much road and wind
noise but it's still feeling quite loud but here's a big bump floaty floaty so one interesting tip
is the engine in this Renault 4 turns in the opposite direction to the smaller engine the 845
and the 747 so they had to change the differential to make sure you didn't end up with four reverse
gears so if you're considering doing an engine swap i guess that's something you have to bear in
into the roundabout oh body rolling body rolling oh yeah that's plentiful but there's nothing wrong
with body roll body roll is fun you don't have to rev the engine like a 2CV engine a 2CV you kind
of find you've always got to gun it and uh there's a few reasons for that uh one is with air-cooled
engines it isn't a good idea to um lug them so to speak because you've not got much airflow over
the engine uh the other one is simply that the 2CV engines were always much smaller when the uh
Renault 4 came out in 1961 its 747 cc engine was quite a lot larger than the 425 cc engine of the
yeah i think so far this car is very much what i expected yeah it's arguably a better car than
the Citroen 2CV and i think the sales figures certainly confirm that but it's not as much fun
it just isn't i got my foot flat to the floor at the moment there's still not a lot of power
now she didn't fancy looking also the horn is not as cute as a 2CV horn i will say the
handling is actually quite good fun uh it's very very grippy and doesn't quite feel as front heavy
as a 2CV 2CVs you really do feel that um engine weight on the front axle this feels a little more
balanced i'll try and demonstrate on this roundabout so as we pitch it in it does roll
and it seems to grip quite tenaciously actually
incredibly that is the first time i've driven a Renault 4 on the road and i'm very glad to have
finally um done that it's been far far too long i think ordinarily that would be a very likable car
for me but i cannot help but make comparisons with a Citroen 2CV and is that a car that's
not a bit of it 21 years i've had that 2CV i'm not about to swap it for a Renault 4
but i am not most people i'm definitely not ordinary and for ordinary people i think this
car was everything they wanted the 2CV to be it's just that little bit less weird and it's
a little more practical you haven't got kingpins to faff about and uh yeah it's just an ordinary
engine it it makes a lot of sense to a lot of people and it's a great car the ride is
astonishing people think Citroen are the masters of ride control but i'll tell you what many 60s
Renaults especially the front wheel drive ones are remarkably comfortable i'm waffling that's
a great car it's for sale with Chevronix for £6,795 seems to be in lovely condition and it
drives very nicely thank you very much for watching don't forget you can head to the store
and buy lovely hub nut merchandise and i look forward to seeing you in a future video farewell
