Art & the Esoteric:The Annunciation

Vintage Visions
7 followers
#GJWculture #Antiques #Art #ArtExplained #Paitting An exploration of the Symbolism in pivotal depictions of the Annunciation in Medieval, Renaissance, and Baroque Italian Art.
Hello, my name is Mary and this is my YouTube channel where I talk about art and the esoteric.
This past March my husband and I spent a month in Italy which was something we had been trying
to do for the past seven years. We have a 24-hour flight time from here to Europe
so it has to be worthwhile to go all that way, hence us taking a month to go and see as much as
Unfortunately my Italian is not very good, but I try. I love Italian history. I also like the Baroque. Baroque sculpture is my favourite.
We visited the big galleries such as the Borghese, the Uffizi, the Vatican Museums,
very luckily a special Caravaggio exhibition at Palazzo Barberini and countless churches with
incredible artwork collections. One of the great things about Rome is that all the churches are
free to visit including St Peter's which is not the case in some of the other major tourist cities.
Churches often have some of the most spectacular artworks so it's very much worth visiting them.
So coming back to everyday life, I wanted to talk about some aspect of the works I'd seen in Italy
because I was so moved by being in front of these pieces in real life. For this video I knew I needed
a series of works with an esoteric aspect and I think I've got the perfect topic. It's one of my
favourite themes from this era, the Annunciation, the biblical event where the angel Gabriel
announces to the Virgin Mary that she will conceive Jesus. This moment holds a profound place in
Christian mysticism and given its significance the Annunciation became a favoured subject
in Christian theology, spirituality and artistic expression from the earlier centuries through the
Renaissance and Baroque eras. The imagery within these depictions is deeply symbolic and extremely
beautiful. I understand you know some viewers may not enjoy Christian art themes but in the West
Christian mysticism and esotericism are inextricably entwined and this is particularly
so in art from this period where there are many artists also interested in esotericism.
Leonardo da Vinci of course springs to mind and I will be talking about one of his works later.
I'm going to talk about the symbolism of these works from the biblical point of view
and not go into details on the esoteric symbolism in a really didactic way. I think the thing to
remember when looking at these works and what they are depicting is that this is a meeting
between the human and the divine and that at the heart of it this moment is when the divine
word is made flesh. So when looking at it from an esoteric point of view keep that idea in mind.
There are certain images and symbols that appear in Annunciation paintings which I'll point out
and expand upon as we go. The most important to look out for are the gestures and poses of
Gabriel and Mary. Also the symbols of the lily, the dove, the book and the garden. I'm only going
to use Italian works in this video as that's the theme I'm doing today but there are many many
other amazing depictions of the Annunciation throughout European art from these same eras.
Many of these photos I'm showing are my own particularly the close-ups but I've also
searched online for a few photos of the gallery settings so you can see the size of the paintings
in situ. I didn't take many photos like this myself as it was quite busy and there were
always someone standing in the way when I was trying to get a picture from further back.
So the first work I'm showing here is one I saw in the Uffizi Gallery in Florence.
This is an exquisite Gothic altarpiece from 1333, the Annunciation with Saint Margaret and Saint
Ansanus by Sienese painter Simone Martini. It is one of the earliest landmark annunciations in
Western art. It exemplifies the Gothic style with its elegant elongated figures and lavish gold
background. Gabriel kneels with flowing robes and golden wings leaning towards the Virgin Mary while
she appears startled even recoiling slightly and nervously pulling her mantle over her chest.
The angel's cloak is billowing out behind him suggesting he has just arrived and he kneels
leaning towards Mary in reverence holding out an olive branch symbolising peace and divine favour.
Between them sits a luxurious golden vase of lilies which is a symbol used often in
signalling Mary's purity. Above the scene in the apex of the central arch is the dove
representing the Holy Spirit. In Luke 1.35 Gabriel tells Mary the Holy Spirit will come upon you and
the power of the highest will overshadow you. So the dove is usually seen descending from the heights
of heaven towards the Virgin. In this depiction the dove is surrounded by the winged faces of
seven cherubim. I find the stylisation of the faces in this work appear as quite angry but it
seems typical of this Gothic period that the expressions aren't as natural as they become later
with their long noses and stern expressions making way for a softer countenance.
The other very interesting element in this painting is that Gabriel's words are shown
in 3D relief as if they have very form themselves. He pronounces
which translates to hail full of grace the Lord is with you.
This painting was groundbreaking in its time for the emotional interaction it portrays and its
fine detailing. It set a precedent for showing the drama and divinity of the Annunciation in
one single striking image influencing artists for generations and also establishing visual
conventions like the lily and the textual greeting that would recur in later works.
The next important image I have is Dominican Fra Angelico's Annunciation.
Now I didn't see this work even though it's in Florence. The thing about these works is they
tend to belong to different churches palazzos etc and you can only see so much while you're
there. We were there for four days and I didn't get to the convent of Saint Marco to see this work
which is painted onto one of the walls there. This fresco is earlier Renaissance around the
1440s so it's moved away from the stylisation of medieval art and is beginning to take on
a naturalistic feel. This fresco is often celebrated for its simplicity serenity and peace.
It shows Mary and Gabriel in a loggia a sort of open-air portico bathed in a soft light. It's very
different from the previous depiction as instead of being set against a flat gold background it is
actually showing the meeting of the two figures in a real world setting with depth and perspective.
Both figures incline their heads gracefully. Gabriel crosses his arms over his chest in
reverence and Mary mirrors the gesture modestly crossing her arms in an almost identical manner.
There is no overt drama in this scene only a quiet meeting of two figures in an attitude
of mutual humility which is interesting because it's placing Gabriel and Mary a divine being
and a human on an equal footing. This fresco captures the sacred stillness of the moment
with soft colours and gentle expressions as if the angel has just tiptoed in rather than made
a grand entrance with a great fanfare. You may notice that classic annunciation symbolism is not
present. No lilies, no dove, no sacred texts. So if it wasn't for the halos and Gabriel's rather
lovely coloured wings it could be two humans meeting in a lodger. We only know what's happening
here because we know the story. That being said this painting has something the previous one did
not but which we will see again in later works. This is the walled garden. This motif is drawn
from the Song of Solomon 412. A garden enclosed is my sister my spouse a spring shut up a fountain
sealed which Christian tradition applied to symbolically to Mary's perpetual virginity.
This depiction has been tremendously influential and is considered one of the most beloved
annunciations in sacred art. It exemplifies the dawn of the renaissance integrating realistic
understandings of space with medieval devotional clarity. This next work is probably known by a
It's Sandra Botticelli's renaissance painting the Cestello Annunciation from 1490.
Every time I look at a picture of this from now on I'm going to be disappointed
as I have never seen a reproduction that even begins to capture how beautiful this painting is.
It is just stunning. The birth of Venus and the Primavera get all the press and the excitement
for Botticelli but for me this painting surpasses them. These are my photos from the Uffizi
and I'll also just show you one for scale as the work is bigger than you might imagine.
Botticelli's take on the Annunciation reflects the graceful linear style of the early Florentine
Renaissance. He sets the encounter in a refined architectural space open to a landscape. You can
see the walled garden but there is also a single tree very prominently rising in the background
above Gabriel's head. There are varying ideas as to the symbolism of this tree and the one that
resonates with me is that it indicates a bridge between heaven and earth and very literally to
the tree of life. I also got quite taken by the idea of the fountain sealed from the Song of
Solomon and was struck by the shape of the tree and its similarity to a fountain. The aspect of
this painting that I find most interesting is the gestures of the two figures. Gabriel isn't just
kneeling he is bowing before the Virgin gazing at her with awe as he alights from heaven into the
room. She collapses to one side so that she nearly falls from the frame of the painting with her arms
stretched out in this gesture of perhaps uncertainty or humility and her eyes are downcast as he offers
her a stem of white lilies. The way that the angel and the woman's hands mirror each other is truly
beautiful creating a strange focus in the space where they don't touch which reminds me a bit
of the space of potentiality between the fingers of God and Adam in Michelangelo's
creation of Adam. This dynamic yet elegant interaction creates a sense of theatricality
which is quite fitting as Botticelli is known for exaggerating gestures for their expressive effect.
Botticelli includes the usual elements of Marian symbolism. One can see an opening in the wall
behind the figures subtly suggesting the door of heaven and in the background a walled garden
symbolizing Mary's enclosed virginity. Botticelli's colour palette is restrained with muted blues and
pinks and earth tones. You've probably noticed that colour symbolism plays a large part in these
paintings with blue and white for the virgin symbolizing her role in blue as the queen of
heaven and white for her purity. Gabriel often appears in red or pink, red expressing divine power
and pink as a symbol of love and grace. The Cestello Annunciation remains one of the iconic
renaissance interpretations marrying symbolic depth with the renaissance era's attention to
naturalism and emotion. This next work I also saw in the Uffizi gallery. It's a high renaissance work
from 1472 by Leonardo da Vinci. Now I've seen images of this painting over the years and I'm
very sorry to say I didn't pay it that much attention. When I saw it in real life I cannot
believe how beautiful it was. It's hard to explain but there's something luminous about the paint and
the depth of colour and coupled with the chiaroscuro technique that he uses which is the juxtaposition
of light and dark. It's just amazing. The only other paintings I saw the similar depth and
luminosity were Caravaggio's works and of course he took that juxtaposition of light and dark a step
further into tenebrism which is an extreme use of light and shadow. This was an early work for
da Vinci but it exemplifies the high renaissance's drive for naturalism, scientific perspective and
subtle emotion. In Leonardo's scene the Virgin Mary is seated outdoors at a decorated marble table.
She has been reading a book when Gabriel appears. He presents her with a white lily and makes a
curious gesture like a benediction with his outstretched hand. Mary appears calm and thoughtful
with her body mostly turned towards him and one palm raised perhaps in slight surprise.
Both the figures poses are really very naturalistic although there are a few anomalies
like Mary's right arm appearing a bit too long possibly because the intended viewing angle
was from the side below given it was meant to be on a church altar. I have to show you a close-up
of the angel as he is just so beautiful. I actually can't believe I've got such a good picture.
You can see that da Vinci studied bird's wings from life for this for the angel's wings and look
at all the um the botanical details. Da Vinci manages to communicate the miracle in a very
natural way. No golden heavens or written speech just a beautiful quiet encounter at dawn in
an idyllic landscape. It captures that moment where the human and the divine meet.
While in Italy I was lucky enough to see a lot of amazing works by Baroque painter Caravaggio
who is one of my favourites but I didn't see this particular painting of the Annunciation from 1608
so we have to make do with a picture off the internet. I wanted to show this work because
it has some interesting differences or progressions from the ones we've seen so far.
Caravaggio's style is markedly different from artists in the Renaissance era. His Annunciation
is dark, intense and emotionally charged. The scene is stripped down to only the two figures
of Gabriel and Mary set against a shadowy background. Only one aspect of traditional
symbolism is present in the lilies carried by Gabriel. He is depicted not gently kneeling by
Mary's side but rather hovering in mid-air and actually looming over her. His figure is um it's
foreshortened and projecting forward nearly coming out of the picture which is an illusionistic
effect not usually used by someone like Caravaggio and more akin to later Baroque ceiling painting.
Mary is bowed over holding her hands tight across her chest appearing submissive and overwhelmed.
If you think about it this is a much more human reaction to an angel appearing in front of you
which would be incredibly frightening. Gabriel's face is hidden making you wonder what his
countenance is like and whether that is why she is looking away in fear. Caravaggio's signature
tenebrism I mentioned earlier is evident in the harshly lit robes and arm of the angel
as the rest of the image is swallowed in shadow. While Caravaggio's Annunciation wasn't as widely
famous as his other works it stands as a pivotal reinterpretation. The Annunciation not as a gentle
dialogue between two figures but as a moment of almost shocking divine intrusion emphasizing the
human fear and wonder in Mary and the urgent mission of the angel to contact her. It paved
the way for other Baroque artists to depict biblical events with heightened drama and emotional
realism aligning the Annunciation with Baroque theatricality while preserving its core symbolism
the angel, the lily, the virgin and the divine light. I think this work is dark and frightening
but full of wonder and I can't wait to see it in real life one day. It's pretty amazing looking
at how depictions of the scene changed over just a couple of hundred years and just in Italy
but each stage in the artistic journey is so beautiful. If you have any extra interesting
information to add about Annunciation paintings please do leave it below. Also if you like these
videos but you would rather read and look at pictures and listen to me I put essay versions
of these on my website which is in the video details below and I often include extra imagery
and things in those. It's quite funny I started making these videos for myself to force myself
into more formal research because you know if I'm researching an idea and I make it into a video
it has to be done to a higher standard and I also wanted to practice presenting because
as an artist I sometimes you know give artist talks and things like that so that's why I started
doing this. It's quite surprising that other people seem to enjoy it too so I will endeavour
to do some more. Have a great week everyone, go and look at some more Annunciation paintings
you won't regret it.
