Surprising the audience without a twist

Anime paradize
12 followers
806 Video Views·Jun 16, 2025
Support me on patreon!
/ peythemusician
Curious where I get my music?
Sign up for Epidemic Sounds with the link below to access all the music I use in my videos for your own content:
https://share.epidemicsound.com/8mrdwu
Over the last year I've talked a lot about how Freerun has a remarkable way of both embracing
and subverting tropes and in thinking about that recently I noticed just how engaging a good
surprise can be. I also came to the conclusion that there's an important distinction between
surprise and shock. I think when a story has twists it showcases this. People can often
immediately name examples of media directors and stories that are defined by their twists,
shocking the audience with a sudden realization that recontextualizes a lot of what's been going
on. But sometimes surprises are subtle, they don't hit you over the head with a big grand
realization. Because while twists are easy to see and define, I think surprises are just as
important and a lot harder to recognize. Welcome to a running series called Exploring Freerun,
my name is Pei and today we're exploring how a show can be so surprising but rarely shocking.
This entire video feels like it's focusing on something that's really hard to define,
so the argument is absolutely semantic. I'm using words like shock and surprise to mean
different things when it's just as reasonable to interpret them as interchangeable. But this
distinction is important for today's video, because when I'm differentiating between the two
I'm placing shock as a subcategory of surprise. Like not all fruit are apples but all apples are
fruit. But the question still lies in why I think this distinction is so important.
Twists or shocking turns of event in stories feel drastically different than the thing I'm
trying to highlight. But they're built off of the same foundation, engaging the audience through
unexpected writing decisions. So to understand this better let's start by looking at the audience
as a collective. Obviously anyone that's reading a book or watching a show is having an individual
relationship with it. But creators often lump all those people into a larger collective,
an individual thing. It's really hard for me to see the statistic of how many people watch my
videos each month and think of them as individuals. I can't conceptualize it, it's too many people with
too many varying perspectives. So instead I look at general trends. What is the reception across
hundreds of thousands of people? This is where tropes come into play. A narrative device used
across multiple stories that audiences start to recognize as recurring. The interesting thing
about tropes is ultimately I think they're determined by the viewer and what media they've
consumed in the past. But creators have to work off of a more broad landscape. What tropes have
been overused? What will people recognize? And how can a writer use that to their advantage?
Some probably immediately come to mind when it comes to storytelling. But YouTube videos offer
a really obvious example. YouTube is full of many different tropes. Have you noticed that thing I do
where I say my name is Pei and today we're talking about blah blah blah that I put at the front of
every one of my videos? I do that for very specific reasons. I don't really put my face in many videos
and the subject is always a different anime people already care about so there's not really much for
people to attach onto when it comes to my channel as a brand. I add that little producer tag so when
people stumble across my videos three four times they start to realize oh I keep coming back to
this one guy's arguments. If you look at a lot of successful video essayists they tend to include
some sort of intro. A tag that makes their content more recognizable for recurring viewers. Hi my name
is Tony and this is Every Frame a Painting. Now a more common trope that all of you will recognize
is all the different strategies people have used for engagement. They're often referred to as calls
to action. Asking people to subscribe, like, or comment. There have been whole metas to it where
people adopt different strategies that become widely popular. For example pointing towards what
percentage of viewers are subscribed to a channel that are consuming the content. As far as I know
that was popularized by the Minecraft YouTuber Dream and then everyone started to adopt it. I
tend to lean towards less calls to action but I do it too and the reason so many people do it is
because most of the time it works. There's huge statistical differences between an effective call
to action and a video without one but they also wear out quick. As soon as a call to action becomes
a cliche suddenly it'll hurt more than it helps. Disrupting the flow of a video and inclining people
to do the opposite of what a creator is asking. So the way it tends to work is your creator comes up
with an effective strategy, other people start to emulate it, it is over adopted, over saturated,
and then eventually becomes a cliche. This is also true of other forms of media like storytelling.
There's kind of an inherent paradox to telling stories because there are so many norms,
structures, and tropes that are used regularly. But that has to be balanced with not being too
predictable. If stories are too predictable it often gets in the way of engagement and immersion.
Emotional beats will fall flat. But if you break away too much from standard storytelling structure
it actually alienates audiences. It's harder to follow what's going on. Audiences at large have
been trained to have expectations about the general flow of a story and stories that are
too non-conforming generally won't do well on a wide scale. It's a weird and really interesting
part of storytelling. Because stories are often influenced by the environment they're released
into. Like this weird meta fourth wall thing. Now sometimes good writers will factor in that
context. Using tropes to subvert the audience's expectations. Because something I've noticed in
all of my favorite pieces of media lately is that they consistently surprise me. Finding new,
interesting, fresh ways to explore an already comfortable structure. Viren on paper is an
incredibly cut and dry fantasy story. And I really don't like that style of world building.
I kind of have an inherent bias against it. And part of what I think makes Viren so special is
the way they use those tropes to make the entire story more interesting. Viren in its origin was
initially created to be a gag comedy. I think this is a big reason as to why trope is such a
major component of the story. In my brain that idea feels reminiscent of things like Konosuba
or One Punch Man. Satire utilizing tropes for the sake of comedy. Now I still think Viren is a very
funny show. But I also think it uses tropes in a way that feel emotionally significant too.
I think this is a major component of why the story is so consistently surprising. There's
a self-awareness that it uses time and time again leading to decisions that consistently
catch me off guard. I think the more you analyze media and look closely the more predictable it
starts to become. Kind of like being able to predict a rhyme at the end of a verse in a song
you've never listened to before because of context clues. And I've noticed recently that I really
value stories that consistently surprise me. And this is where the difference between surprise and
shock really comes in. Take for example a theoretical horror movie where a character's
walking down a dark hall. You can know that something shocking is going to happen. A jump
scare or a reveal and not be surprised at all. Another good example is how M. Night Shyamalan
has kind of written himself into a corner. Every movie he makes there's an expectation that there'll
be a twist at the end. When you know a twist is coming you're less surprised by it which undermines
its effectiveness. Being shocked and surprised are not the same thing. They can overlap but they don't
have to. My favorite stories recently are ones that consistently surprise me. There's this fiction
series I've been reading lately called Dungeon Crawler Carl that I think is outstanding. It really
engages in this in a way that feels very reminiscent of what I love about Freerun. It's such
a powerful tool and it doesn't have to be big or grandiose. These decisions don't have to come as
shocks and I almost think they're more sustainably used when they don't. So when in Freerun do I
think that this is used most effectively? Let's take a look. Here's a quick spoiler warning for
anyone that needs it for season one of Freerun Beyond Journey's End. The first example that comes
to mind is zine as a character. There's this classic structure that we've seen time and time
again especially in Shonen where a party slowly adopts new members. Having a character fit in
neatly with an ensemble that the audience loves is very difficult and it's especially impressive
when they shift an already interesting dynamic to make it even better. I really believe Zine is an
outstanding character and for me everything in my gut indicated that he'd stay with the party
after his introduction. In Freerun's original party there was a warrior, mage, priest, and hero.
So when Zine was introduced he filled the obvious missing role in having a priest.
It also created this possibility where Freerun could step into that role as a hero. I don't know
that's interesting. The whole story is built around running parallels between the old party and new
one. It's a brave decision to let go of a character that was working so well. It surprised me but it
felt beautifully in line with both the character and themes of the story. It was a decision I never
expected but also wouldn't change in retrospect. Another surprise comes in the way Freerun
navigates Fern and Stark's budding romance. Romances often take a lot of space in a story
but with rare exception Fern and Stark's developing relationship falls to the background.
Even when they're given big moments more often than not it's multifaceted serving some purposes
outside of just their dynamic. There's generally an expectation that if romance is going to be
introduced between important characters something that's going to be delved into and in the future
it probably will continue to develop but they're taking their time in a way that really works.
It's not at all how I'd expect a slice of life or fantasy adventure to treat romance.
To me it feels kind of singular. I can't think of another story that does a budding relationship
in the same way. The exact opposite direction of love and romance, or maybe full circle,
is the action in Freerun. Especially in the first half of the season this show occasionally dips
into extreme action for just a brief moment. Anime, especially old shounens, have a tendency
to really draw out conflict. It's so common for fights to span many episodes but some of the best
fight sequences in Freerun are so brief. Another surprise comes in re-watching Freerun and
realizing some of my favorite little stories are only half of an episode. I've made whole videos
praising Freerun's ability to tell entire stories in only a couple minutes and when I finally got
used to that they changed it up, creating a mage exam, taking a leap of faith to tell the story in
a different way, and it ended up being so crucial developing some of my favorite characters in the
first season. Denkian had so much more substance and significance than I originally expected.
All of these little surprises I probably could make an entire video about if I haven't already,
and kind of the point of this video is I wouldn't really classify any of these as shocking.
They're not twists, they're just unexpected directions that hold up under scrutiny. They
don't undermine any of the setup, they don't act in opposition to what I would expect from a
character, and they're still super satisfying. Almost more so. I think this is an exceptionally
difficult thing to do in storytelling. Recently I've been working on my own writing and seeing
this is almost discouraging because no matter what I do I'm kind of gonna be bad. Analyzing media
and creating it require different skill sets that do inform one another but aren't one-to-one.
So as I'm analyzing stories that I think are really well written I'm noticing just how engaging they
are and I'm admiring how difficult it is to do that as effectively as they have. It's very hard
to do this. To me it's a sign of expertise or coincidence. When a story does it time and time
again it seems like chance isn't a major component at play. That's why I find this entire concept of
surprising without being shocking so interesting. Because as easy as it is to get caught up
analyzing any piece of media, sometimes they come along and are just engaging.
