I Feel Like I May Be Enabling My Family Members 📈 Are you on track with the Baby Steps? Get a Free Personalized Plan. https://ter.li/5h1r0i
Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/63m1lp • 🏘️ Find a Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Agent - https://ter.li/ni98m5 • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
So, you know, I understand that you guys promote outrageous giving,
and I am in a position in my life where I'm able to do so. But, you know, I also think about
cheerfully giving, and where do you draw the line? So, I recently had a niece who reached out to me
to help her with her down payment on a new apartment. She did state that she just found
out she was pregnant. She hadn't told anyone, but just shared that with me, but has a past
of asking a lot of family members, including me in the past, for money, potentially for drugs and
bad boyfriend experiences. And I feel like there's a bit of manipulation in terms of making sure I'm
the only one who's been told about her pregnancy, where we don't really have a solid relationship
either. But my sister, her mom had passed away when she was seven, and unfortunately,
dad and stepmom didn't treat her well. So, I feel some sort of an obligation. Like I said,
I'm in a position to, but where do you draw the line? Where do you draw the line on being
cheerfully giving and sort of that nagging? Sure, yeah, because you don't want to enable,
and that's a little bit of the feeling with this situation. So, not every chance we have to give
is going to be the right situation to give, just because the opportunity's there doesn't mean that
we actually have to take it. And I think this would be a situation that, you know, finding
that balance between helping and enabling, you know, on this show, we are always teetering on
that line because a lot comes into play, right, to decide that actual boundary. There's not this
like hard and fast rule, but I think what you have to discern in the situation is how can you best
help her? And I think acknowledging, you know, her situation is hard, right? And I mean, I think
there is a level of like, yeah, if she's not done any level of healing or growth, like having a
parent die at a young age like that, and then being in a toxic situation growing up, it's kind
of like, yeah, of course, this is probably her road, right? Unless she decides to do something
different. And I think that would be your hope as her aunt, is that she can start to make different
choices with her life. Because if she continues to be consistent in these choices, she's going to
keep getting what she's been getting, and it's not a fruitful, peaceful life, right? She's not
feeling that. So, when it comes to the financial side of it, you know, how can you best love her
well and help but not enable is the big question. Right. So, one of my thoughts was, hey, happy to
help, but I'd like to directly pay your potential landlord. Yes. Yeah. You know, when you said down
payment, is she trying to buy a house? It's going to the right place. No, it's for an apartment.
Oh, like a deposit. You know how you put first and last month's rent. Oh, yeah. I do think that
one of the best ways to help is to do it directly, because you don't know if she's going to use this
for something else. So, say, yeah, I'd be happy to help. Give me the landlord's name. I'll work
with them directly to handle the deposit. Okay. So, you could do it that way. You can also say
no. That's also an okay answer. Yes. I don't know that anyone's told her no. Yeah. And, you know,
she has no one else. Like, I think a lot of people have said no, but because of her bad behavior
previously. Yeah. She just moves on to the next person, and Bank of Sierra was up next.
That's right. What's your relationship like with her? Are you involved in her life at all,
or is it just you hear from her when she needs money? We kind of go on and off. So, you know,
dad had cut us out of their life. We held financial money from when my sister
passed that it wasn't to be given until they were 21. So, when we reconnected, when they were both
her and her brother were 21, to give them the money, they, you know, they were told that we
stole the money. Oh, gosh. But that wasn't the case. Yeah. Yeah. It's a horrible, horrible. I
mean, I could, it would take me days, but I'm so sorry. Anyways, yeah. And so, they did get the
money, and at that point, we thought we were sort of, you know, kindling, you know, a building of a
relationship that was broken. And then, from there, it just, you know, she spent the money,
I guess, within three months and started asking people for money. And we understood that she had
a boyfriend in her life that was deep into gangs and drugs. So, we, you know, when she asked,
I said, I'd love to buy your groceries, but can I take you to the grocery store? And then she
wouldn't respond to you. Okay. There you go. I think this is your way out, is to start giving
directly. And if she says, nope, then you know the red flags were there and you did the right thing.
Yeah. And Sierra, what George said earlier too, like, I do want you to have permission that this
is your money and you want to see it being used in the best, wisest way, right? I mean, I think
there is a responsibility there. And I'll say with the caveat, you know, just because there's a family
member who is in need and is asking, does not mean you automatically have to, or you're a terrible
person, right? So, you could have your own conviction of that, that you don't want it,
right? That you don't want to give. Or your heart may be, and again, I think this is up to you. This
is not a right or wrong. I think it's just two different options. It's either like, I don't feel
good about this. I don't, the responsibility, it doesn't feel right to me. I don't like it. And I
just don't feel good engaging it. So that's, that is one option. And then the other is that you love
her and you're like, no, I do want to be able to help. I just want to do it in the right way. So
that right way to me would be going straight to the landlord and helping with food, shelter,
utilities, transportation, like the four walls, you know, helping her in those ways, not going
on vacation or something like that. And then talking to her and saying, you know, because I
love you so much, like, I want to see you do better. So you're not having to depend on people
for money. So let's look at job opportunities. Let's look at doing a budget. Let's put you
through Financial Peace University and go through and learn how to manage money. Like, I also want
to give you these resources. You know, maybe you pay for therapy for her, right? I mean, like,
seriously, I don't know what, what else is out there, but it's like tools to help her
become a healthier person. How can we do that and sustain that? Right. So,
so that that's option B, but option A is okay too, Sierra. I want you to feel that like that,
that is up to you. Yeah. But then there's option B if you feel that way. But I think
what you're saying is wise is going, you know, straight to, to the things that you can help.
And, and even, you know, and it's, and it's so sad, but it's the reality, you know, she's pregnant.
So like, I don't know what health insurance looks like for her and all of that. So it's like,
there's a part, like, we need to understand the reality we live in,
niece, whatever her name is. But also maybe Sierra, you say, I feel like I do want to give,
and maybe it's maybe through the medical baby route and you help pay for medical bills, you
know, to help with that. Right. So like, I think there's ways to help her, but also helping her
to become a healthier whole person in the process is going to be the best gift that you can give her.
Yeah. I really like that. Cause I think I haven't taken time to do that. And I think I was also
struggling. I'm kind of in a position in my life where I haven't always outweighed,
outrageously given, right. Like I've, you know, and I've kind of turned the corner where I feel
like I have to, Oh, I can help there. I can help. Yes. Like, I think I was trying to find that
balance. And so I think that just even having a, you know, we've kind of chatted back and forth
and I've kind of gone a bit, a bit radio silent, actually just to sort of discern and pray about
I think that answer is, is just, you know, just having a proper conversation with her and how she
can grow and sort of determine from there, but also maybe directly help her with the four walls.
We have pre health care in Canada. So baby care. That's true. Be good. Okay, good. Yeah. That's
great. That's fantastic. Yeah. Well, I love your heart, Sierra. And I think, you know,
this is the thing about money. It's a tool to help, but we want to help and not enable.
And with family members, I think it's sometimes that hard line that can happen.
Giving should be intentional, just like spending or saving. Yep. That's right. You're doing this
the right way. Yeah, for sure. Sierra, thanks so much for the call. Well, that puts this hour
of the Ramsey show in the books. We'll be back. Create your free every dollar budget today.
The simplest way to budget for your life.