Host: Václav Peričevič ze Spolku Šalamoun | Moderátor: Milan Kajínek, deník The Epoch Times | Střih: Kateřina Kudláčková ml.
Případ Petr Kramný v roce 2014 zaplnil titulní stránky českého bulvárního tisku, obsahuje řadu neobvyklých zvratů i nestandartních postupů na straně ostravských patologů, policie či státního zástupce. O jeho novém otevření se začalo u soudu jednat na přelomu listopadu a prosince 2022. Před soudem promluvilo několik významných českých expertů z různých oborů, kteří případ a důkazní materiály analyzovali a poměrně tvrdě kritizovali hypotézy obžaloby, které podle nich nestojí na věrohodných důkazech.
Jedním ze závažných okamžiků celého případu je událost, během níž byl úmyslně zničen hlavní důkaz obžaloby. Paradoxně jej zničil soudní znalec obžaloby, přednosta Ústavu soudního lékařství (ÚSL) při Fakultní nemocnici v Ostravě MUDr. Igor Dvořáček, Ph.D., a to navzdory naléhání obhajoby, aby byly vzorky tkání uchovány pro další možnost přezkoumání případu.
🔴 Více naleznete na https://www.epochtimes.cz/ ------------------------------------------------------ Názory vyjádřené v tomto rozhovoru jsou názory autora a nemusejí odrážet stanovisko Epoch Times.
Dr. Dvořáček's approach was based on the suspicion that the necrophilic material would be destroyed.
Of course, we all knew for a long time that they would destroy it,
because the more people look at it, the more people will be categorically certain
that they have never come to the murder of those electrical circuits.
We have information from our sources that it basically came to the destruction
immediately after the visit of Dr. Pilín.
And yet they destroyed the material because they were afraid
that when other experts would see it, the construction on the island could collapse.
Today, I invited Mr. Václav Peričevič,
deputy chairman of the Šalamon Association, to the interview.
We will talk about important issues in the case of Petr Kramý,
whose case has just been decided by the Austrian court.
We will focus mainly on the event during which the main evidence of the crime was destroyed,
and these are samples taken from the bodies of two deceased women.
Good day, welcome to the interview with Danny Epoch Times.
So, based on the examination of necrophilic samples of two deceased women,
Petr Kramý was sentenced to 28 years in prison.
Now, the Austrian court of justice is concerned that the case will be reopened,
and you can find more about the background of the whole case on the link below the video.
Today, we will focus only on the main evidence of the crime of necrophilic samples.
Could you please tell us for starters what these necrophilic samples are?
Necrophilic material is basically material obtained during the battle.
This means that during the battle,
for example, from the places where there are signs of the cause of death,
part of the organs such as the heart, lungs, etc.
are taken away, which is then prepared in a very simple or very precise way
for the histological preparation.
How much of the material is taken away from the bodies?
These are basically a few centimeters of the material.
These are not some huge pieces.
Let's say, for example, that it is a cube about a centimeter in size.
Roughly a cube, for example, 2x2 in size,
which is then cut with a special knife,
which is then cut into thousands of millimeter pieces,
which are basically put on the glass,
then the cover glass is put on the glass,
and thus the histological preparation is created,
and this is the necrophilic preparation.
Necrophilic means obtained during the battle.
So let's say someone, a pathologist,
takes away tissue 2x2 centimeters,
or 2 centimeters of lung tissue,
and then it is stored somewhere in some kind of, I don't know, a tank?
No, no, no.
This is usually poured into some kind of a spout,
so what was interesting about the Kramnýs was
that they took away the material from the skin,
then the so-called base blocks,
so there was relatively a lot of histological material
at the beginning,
and yet all of it was destroyed afterwards.
So who was actually collecting those histological samples?
Well, of course, it is related to the fact
that the first battle took place in Egypt.
There is a question, because part of the steam organs
never made it to the Czech Republic,
not even the stomachs,
and there is a question whether they were collecting
any histological preparations there,
because from their point of view,
they did not see the death by violence there.
The battle was actually held on June 31, 2013,
and then the bodies were transported here,
to the Czech Republic,
and the so-called re-battle was held here,
which is a battle after a battle,
where some histological preparations were collected again,
and only one sample was collected from the heart,
from Clark and two from Monika.
And who was actually conducting the Czech re-battle?
Who was dying here in the Czech Republic?
Smatanová Dokoupil.
They were experts from Ostrava,
who were basically entrusted with the task,
that is, they were conducting the re-battle.
So Ostrava pathologists.
And court doctors.
The samples, or the so-called glasses,
that is, the necrotic material,
were actually only three.
So who collected the samples, you say?
Ostrava experts Smatanová Dokoupil.
Smatanová Dokoupil are court experts,
and they work in the institution of court medicine in Ostrava.
And is it associated with some hospital?
They are part of the Faculty Hospital in Ostrava.
Faculty Hospital Ostrava.
How many samples were actually collected?
I guess they were collecting this histological material
from different parts of the body.
There are also arteries, there is a heart, there are lungs.
I guess there were about 26 of them in total.
And are there also skin samples?
There are also skin samples.
Tell me, what exactly were found on the samples that were collected?
That's the uniqueness of the thing.
Because, of course, they collected the histological material
on the 9th and 8th,
then some laboratory worked it out,
so in a day or two they already had the so-called glasses,
where they would basically know,
if it came to death or diagnosis
and gastrointestinal heart failure
in two or three days,
that there are some fragments on the heart
that correspond to electrical current.
But that didn't happen.
So they got to this conclusion
only after half a year of searching for the food.
That's another uniqueness.
They then later found
that there is a so-called Leib syndrome on the heart,
in Czech it's called Vlnení,
which can be caused by electrical current.
And because they excluded all other causes of death,
such as the food,
they finally looked at the glasses after half a year
and said that the so-called Leib syndrome on the heart
can be caused by electrical current.
So, let's say, in August they conducted an epitym,
collected the samples,
and five months later they issued the first report.
Exactly.
So, let's say, the judges came with the hypothesis
that women died as a result of electrical current.
Peter Kramlík was eventually acquitted
for allegedly being a victim of electrical current.
But the problem is that in November and December 2022,
four Czech experts from various fields
and basically rejected the claim of the Ostrava pathologists
that the skin and heart of these two women
are not a sign of electrical current.
Can you describe for us what was said
in front of the Ostrava court?
We can say that it was about a new opening of the case.
What are the reasons for that?
The reasons are quite simple.
Because basically the whole time,
which we are interested in,
that is, until 2014,
it was clear that the actual case,
as it is constructed in Ostrava,
is a murder of electrical current.
It never happened, nor could it happen.
And of course, the only proof of this
is the necrotic material,
that is, the samples of the skin and heart
of Monika and Klára.
There was a great demand here
to make it independently investigated.
Because, of course, we consulted it
not only with experts here in the Czech Republic,
but also with foreigners.
And basically the conclusions were that
it had something to do with some kind of miracle.
So that's why we appointed
Professor Steiner as our biggest expert
on the heart and soul of the case.
And there was a significant moment
when they refused to provide him with the material in Ostrava.
It was very important to say here
that he, as a renowned expert,
was a representative of the state
in the Parliament of the Finished Things.
He worked for the then-President of the Judicial Institute
on the head of the paper of the state representative.
He was a kind of legal representative.
The court argued that he would defend the experts,
which is their absolutely indisputable right,
but he refused to provide the samples
of the heart of Monika and Kláka.
So we basically forced the Constitution
into the last interpellation,
because otherwise the right judgment would have been made.
So they basically provided the material
and Professor Steiner went there to investigate it.
Let's put it this way.
I was also present at the trial.
It was about Professor Steiner,
who spoke at the end of November
in front of the court in Ostrava.
He was investigating the samples.
We could make a retrospective
of how he ended up in those samples.
I know he got involved in it.
At that time, Ms. Černochová,
who interpellated the then Minister of Justice,
Mr. Pelikán,
made a statement that there is no reason
for the experts not to be allowed
to investigate the samples.
Only then would the experts be allowed
to investigate the samples.
Which is exactly what you're saying.
That's why we appealed to Ms. Černochová,
and that was the only way to force
the Ostrava Constitution
to release the evidence to the independent experts.
And that's exactly what the case is about.
Because every other expert will tell you
that if there is a clue in the heart,
it will be provided to other colleagues,
experts with whom you can't reach a conclusion
Here they were completely vehemently
against anyone looking at it independently.
Of course, they knew very well
that if an expert like Prof. Steiner
would look at it, it would probably be a big problem.
But only with the help of Mr. Pelikán,
they released the evidence.
And then the case was closed.
Why did you choose Ms. Černochová?
We have been working together for a long time,
and she had a press conference with us
and it was at that press conference
that Prof. Steiner's first categorical conclusion came out.
He said that he knew about the appeal,
that is, he bought Smatenová,
and that was the basis of the terminology.
So she was already familiar with the case?
We informed her that the process
was showing significant flaws,
and that in our opinion,
the actual case for which Petr Kramlý
was sentenced to a primary sentence
could never have happened.
So then the Ministry of Justice interpellated Mr. Pelikán
and several experts began to examine the samples.
There were about two or three of them.
There were two of them,
because then the so-called inter-court trial was created.
That is, it was a joint trial
between the Ministry of Justice,
Electro, Elektra and Forensic Biomechanics.
And then, of course, a foreign team was prepared.
Everyone was saying all the time,
because it was the only evidence,
and with the problems that the island was causing,
that they would do something to destroy the samples.
We appealed to the courts all the time,
even to the State Prosecutor's Office,
to ban the destruction of the material.
Because all the experts told us that
because it was the only evidence,
and everyone knew what kind of fraud it was,
so the only evidence was destroyed.
That's why you saw the chronology there
and wrote about it yourself.
Professor Steiner and Professor Pelik
examined the samples personally.
And we know that Viktor Steiner
spoke to Mr. Dvořáček,
who was the chairman of this institution,
and he told him to put the samples in the court storage.
As you said, the defense expressed dismay
that the samples were not destroyed
and were kept for further examination.
Ms. Černochova interpelled for this,
and it was Ms. Obhajkýně Rýšková.
You also interpelled someone else.
Ms. Viktorka Parvýková.
And she was...
She was the parent of the victim.
So four subjects.
They all warned to protect the samples
so that they would not be accidentally destroyed.
Because in the interpellation of Ms. Černochová
there is a clearly written sentence
that Dr. Dvořáček's approach
was a suspicion that the necrophilic material would be destroyed.
Of course, we all knew all along
that they would destroy it,
because the more people looked at it,
the more people would be clearly and categorically angry
that it never came to the murder of those electric currents.
How long after Professor Steiner
and Dr. Pilín examined the samples,
did the destruction of the samples actually take place?
This is a good question,
because we have information from our sources
that it basically came to the destruction
immediately after the visit of Dr. Pilín.
Because there were already signs
that another team of experts would like to look at it.
Officially, I found a document
that the samples were officially liquidated
on March 28, 2018,
but there is no protocol for it,
no abbreviation, no record.
So the question is what kind of information it is.
The fact is that it is a common procedure,
and that the case after the women was re-examined.
And yet they destroyed the material,
because they were afraid that if other experts saw it,
the construction on the island could collapse.
But there is no court order for it?
Of course there is not.
It was clearly the fault of the manager,
who was afraid that the whole construction would collapse.
So basically there is no order from the court,
the state representative, or the police.
He simply destroyed it on his own will
and refused an internal document,
which is a report on the waste,
which is officially controlled by the government.
We managed to get the report,
or the internal report,
which deals with the waste in the faculty hospital on the island.
I don't have to say that there is no necrotic material.
It's about how to liquidate papers,
how to liquidate used gloves,
but there is no necrotic material.
So let's say that you can't put waste in a waste bin
on the level of necrotic material,
which is preserved for some court case,
on the basis of which a person was deported to prison for 28 years,
and on the basis of the main evidence,
which is also about the renewal of the case.
Of course, there is a lot of fiction,
because if you look at other court cases,
which I did,
you will find that, for example,
in Brno, the necrotic materials,
even if it is not such an exposed case,
and it is not a proven evidence,
last at least 25 years,
in the case of Králový they last at least 30 years,
and here in Prague they even have,
I guess, since 1940.
Because it basically goes into a cigarette box,
all the histological preparations from this case,
it does not require any special storage,
if you stick it somewhere in a book, it will last 100 years,
because it is covered with a cover,
so it does not undergo any damage.
And what did the hospital argue,
or the court of medicine,
that they destroyed it, that they do not have enough space?
That's right, they argued about the lack of space,
which, of course, makes no sense,
because, as I said, it goes into a cigarette box,
those necrotic materials.
I also noted that you warned the state representative
who supervised the case, Mr. Vít Legerský,
about this reality,
that it may be a criminal act,
in the case of the destruction of the samples.
What was his reaction?
It is a typical reaction
of the entire Austrian population,
because they consider this process
to be legitimate, common,
and they do not consider it to be illegal.
You can see that today, in the public space,
there are cases all over the world,
where after 20-30 years,
after 16-15 years,
they suddenly find out that the relevant
perpetrator is not the perpetrator,
and he was sitting for 16 years,
I don't know what happened to him recently in the United States.
Here, in this case,
he knew very well that this was the only evidence,
because there was nothing else.
So he covered it up like this.
Tell me, in conclusion,
that another hearing on the renewal of the trial
is scheduled for February 8, 2023.
Petr Kramník spent 10 years in prison
and he will decide
whether the case will be opened or not.
Thank you for the interview
and maybe next time we will discuss the case
a little more in depth.
Thank you and goodbye.