Something Really Strange Just Happened to the Bond Market

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
#financement
#finance
ST rates have dropped sharply in the past few weeks, the past few days, in particular. The 4w Treasury bill now yields less than IOR, repo, even the Fed's RRP "floor." That's not all: the 3m10s spread has reinverted again. At the same time another major central bank just hit the panic button, going with a 50-bps cut only a few months after getting started. Where is this all heading? Not in Jay's direction.
There is a lot going on on the U.S. Treasury yield curve, starting at the front end in the four-week
bill. Over the last couple of weeks, the four-week bill rate has been moving down,
but over the last couple of days of this past week, the four-week bill rate has
plunged to the point that Friday, the four-week rate was at 423, which you'll notice that's two
basis points below the Fed's RRP floor and therefore below a whole bunch of alternative
rates, which suggest heightened demand for four-week bills, and we know at Eurodollar University
what that's all about. But that's just where it begins. We also saw the three-month,
10-year spread re-invert again this past week. It kind of un-inverted again on Friday,
but re-inversion in the curve suggests that the market is thinking one thing about the
fundamentals in the economy and something different about what the Federal Reserve
thinks about the fundamentals in the economy. And on top of all that, we've got more central
banks cutting rates and cutting rates aggressively around the world. The latest was the Reserve Bank
of India, who dropped its policy rates by 50 basis points for a total of 100 basis points
in rate reductions just in the past four months, as the banking sector in India looks increasingly
shaky due to global uncertainty. That's the term that we keep hearing pop up. So we've got
lots of demand for front-end instruments in the U.S. Treasury curve. We've got stuff going on
on the long end versus the short end. Plus, not just the Reserve Bank of India, but all these
central banks around the world that are cutting, and the Federal Reserve is sitting here saying,
well, we're just going to wait and see. So Steve, where do you want to start? Let's start maybe at
the front end of the yield curve, the four-week bill. For some reason, all of a sudden over the
last couple of weeks, but really this past week, the market can't get enough of these instruments.
Yeah, Jeff, and it's like a very clear sign that there's something wrong in the financial system.
Now, it doesn't mean something seriously is wrong. It just means all of a sudden,
you have a demand for collateral. And the question is, as you said, it's lower than the
RRP rate. So why? Why are they after this? Now, we don't know exactly why, but it is a red flag.
It's telling us, look, this notion we're going to see inflation and growth, you wouldn't see this
in the four-week bill. If it was falling, well, that tells us that growth and inflation are coming
down, tells us there's problems in the financial system, tells us people want collateral. We don't
know why yet, and hopefully we don't find out why, but for the moment, it's telling us some
people are panicking. Yeah, Steve, I think you're right. It's not one of those catastrophic things
where you think, oh, God, this is the end of the world. It's one of those red flags that goes out
that you say, okay, this is something we want to keep an eye on. And the reason is just to be clear
for people who are maybe not familiar, when you see a four-week treasury bill rate at 4.23%,
what you have to do is compare that to other alternatives in the investment in the money
marketplace, because right now you can get 4.4% at the Fed's window, the IOR, or interest on
reserves. So if you just have spare bank reserves, the Federal Reserve is going to give you 4.4%.
So you wouldn't necessarily want a treasury bill yielding 2.23% when you can get 4.4%
for just leaving reserves on with the Fed. Money market rates in the repo market,
SOFR's been around 4.29 at the low, but really in the low 4.30s. So you have an alternative there
where you can just, if you've got spare cash, you can just lend it basically risk-free in repo
and get say 4.32 rather than lend it to the US government treasury for four weeks and only get
4.23. In fact, the Federal Reserve's RRP, which is at 4.25, at the very minimum, you can put some
spare funds with the Fed, you get 4.25% completely risk-free. So the very fact that the four-week
treasury bill yield is at 4.23, below all these other things, in no uncertain terms, what that
means is there's more demand for this particular instrument than it would be otherwise for the
investment characteristics, these returns on interest rates. So there's heightened demand
for specifically four-week bills, which, spoiler alert here, everybody at URUN knows the answer
to this. It's usually because there's some tightness in collateral. Now, to be clear,
we don't really see any other warning signs that are breaking out that suggest there's something
really bad going on. So right now, this is one of those things that happens every once in a while
that you have to pay attention to because it suggests there's something there, even if we
don't know what it is, nor do we know how serious it is, but it's serious enough that it's got the
four-week bill doing things it otherwise shouldn't be doing. Yeah, that's right, Jeff. As you said,
it's not about yield. If somebody was looking for yield, there's plenty of alternatives. This
is all about holding collateral. Now, again, if the four-week bill was plunging, if it dropped,
say, a full percentage point, yes, that would be okay. That would be the end of the world.
That would get the hell out of us. Right, sound the fire alarms, we have a problem. But this is
still telling us people want collateral, there's a reason they want it, but we also know when we
go out and look at the 310s, what are we seeing? Inversion is back. So we're seeing signs that,
yes, the US economy is slowing, financial conditions are tightening, the worry about
inflation, well, if there is going to be inflation, we know it's only going to be transitory,
of course, demand being, of course, weaker as well. So yes, you're right, we're seeing all
across the curve, a lot of things are starting to pop up. Again, nothing to sound an alarm,
but just telling us the trajectory of the economy is going to go in a different direction than a lot
of the central bankers think. Well, sticking with, I know we want to talk about the three-month,
10-year spread, which is an important thing too, but before we get to that,
one last note on the four-week bill, what we have seen is that dealer coupon holdings,
and I know coupon holdings and treasury bills, it kind of gets mixed up there.
But what primary dealers do when they anticipate collateral scarcity to become a profitable issue,
what they'll do is they'll hold lots of treasury collateral of not just bills, but also in coupons,
and they'll hold it because they anticipate that other market participants are going to
be in high demand for US treasuries specifically, and they seek to profit off it. They also do it
defensively too, like they protect their own balance sheet by making sure they have availability
of treasury coupons in case they need it for their own purposes. But what we see happening
is that primary dealers will load up on treasury securities, anticipating difficulties in repo
markets and collateral circulation that will then allow them to either profit from it or be insured
against it because they have treasury bills. So we have seen dealer holdings of coupons stay near
record highs for the last several months. It surged to a record high in January and February,
and it kind of stayed around more than $300 billion, which is an enormous amount for primary
dealers to hold an inventory. It's been above $300 billion or close to $300 billion ever since then,
and the latest weekly data, which just came out for the prior week, was right there at $300 billion
too. So what that suggests is very modestly, like we're just talking about the four-week treasury
bill, dealers are seeing something that they think might be worthwhile holding additional
collateral in the form of notes and bonds in their inventories, maybe because there's something
happening behind the scenes, and that behind the scenes is starting to peak out in terms of the
four-week treasury bill yield that's going below all these other alternatives. So there is
corroboration in certain places for not necessarily catastrophic collateral conditions, but
some form of strain and stress that has heightened demand for at least four-week bills as well as
primary dealer demand for coupons. So that's the front of the curve. That's the stuff that
relates to collateral. Now let's talk about the yield curve shape. What we saw this week,
Wednesday and Thursday, is that the 10-year treasury yield that's been moving lower over
the past several weeks of de-risking and risk aversion across the marketplace that we've seen
in a number of different ways, like the Swiss franc got stronger for one, swap spreads that
continue to be incredibly negative. So we've seen the 10-year kind of move lower, but the three
month is relatively steady to the point that the 10-year moved below the three month, which
as Steve will tell you, that tells you the market is saying, J-PAL is going to be slow.
Yeah, absolutely, Jeff. So when we look back at the four-week, we understand the financial systems
collateralize and there is a demand to hold those. But as we move out the curve, we find out some
very interesting relationships. You mentioned the three-month, very correlated, of course,
to the central bank's policy, to the funds rate. And what is it telling us? That the Fed's probably
not going to cut rates at their next meeting later this month. But I think that's the general
knowledge of the financial world. Everyone believes and is telling the Fed you're not going to cut.
And the Fed's saying, hey, we're probably not going to cut. And the bond market is validating that.
But the 10-year, inverting below it. Now, this is where it starts to get interesting,
because we can look and say, OK, maybe there's some issues and tightness in the financial system
at the four-week level. We know the Fed's not going to cut. But the 10-year, that's telling us
the growth and inflation expectations are coming down at a time. What is the Fed telling us? We're
worried about inflation. At the same time, they can't see what's happening with the labor market.
So yes, this is, to me, is far more interesting than what's going on in the plumbing,
because it's validating that all this hope that the economy was going to turn around and boom,
that consumers were going to absorb these higher prices and spending was going to persist.
What we're seeing is kind of the opposite here. 10-year is telling us that there's other problems
that could be far more severe than just a short-term collateral issue.
Yeah, I think that's part of the issue with the Treasury curve itself is that there's
this belief that the, I mean, a lot of people believe, like Jay Powell does,
that the economy is resilient and we need to be worried about inflation expectations. But
with the 10-year falling and with the yield curve acting the way it has, what the market is kind of
suggesting is that there's no short-run pattern. Like you said, Steve, the Fed is going to hold
here. They're not going to cut in June. I mean, as much as the president certainly wants Jay
Powell to cut, that's been his message all week, the Fed's not going to do that. They don't see
anything that would suggest some kind of immediate need for dropping interest rates.
But there's more of a debate and more of a consideration, more of an argument about
when the Fed actually moves again, because I think there's, across the entire marketplace,
there's an expectation they're going to have to do it at some point. And to me, it's starting to
look a lot more like last summer. I mean, it's eerie how similar it is. If you remember, last
summer, we got into April and May, and then June, a lot of the economic data started to turn
negative. We started to see the same things in the yield curve. Our longer-term rates were coming
down. The two-year yield was coming down. The Fed kept saying, no, we don't believe there's any
reason to cut. We're worried more about inflation. And then when you got to June and into July,
we had this discussion, remember, Steve, in the July meeting, where the Fed came out publicly and
said, no, we're still worried about inflation. We're still not anywhere near a rate cut. But
then a couple of weeks later, they said, oh, we actually were considering a rate cut in July.
We just don't want to tell anybody. So they were ready to cut in July because the situation had
shifted that much over the first couple of months of summer. And I think we're laying the groundwork
for something similar here, where the Fed's going to say, right up until the end, we don't want to
cut. We're still worried about inflation. But you can see all the economic data and these market
signals suggesting, like last summer, they may not want to do it today. But at some point very soon,
they're going to be forced into doing what they did last year.
Jeff, I couldn't agree more. I think that's exactly what happens. I think Powell's going
to say, again, we're not going to cut rates. We're worried about inflation. And when you think about
it, they have a dual mandate. They have to worry about inflation in the labor market. The problem
is they worry about inflation until it's too late for the labor market. Again, we talk about why
central bank policy doesn't work. Well, there's one key part of that is people that are out of
work, they can't get a loan. So it doesn't matter. You can lower rates all you want. But when you go
to the bank and they ask, well, what's the first question on the loan app? Tell us about your job.
And you say, well, it's called my unemployment check. It doesn't matter. You're not going to
get a loan. So what we see here from the Fed is the typical Fed expectation. We're worried about
inflation. We think tariffs are going to drive inflation higher. There's absolutely no evidence
that's going to happen. Now, we do see some companies saying, look, we're being pressured
into raising prices. We've done everything we can. So they're going to go up. But does that mean
we're going to see the CPI shoot higher like we saw in the expectations from the University of
Michigan survey? Probably not anywhere even remotely close to that. But what we're seeing
when we look at, say, the nonfarm pay report, which we know Jay Powell will come out and say,
look, this is A-OK. But reality is we have 95,000 in revisions. We also have, on average,
55,000 in revisions on any given report. It tells us the labor market here is weakening.
Again, problem, I think. Fed doesn't want to be a peer. They're pandering to the Trump
administration. I think they're way behind the curve if I did believe it worked. But nevertheless,
I think from Fed's perspective, they're behind the curve. They will cut probably in July. But
only response will be is, yes, we've talked about it. We're considering it. And then after the
meeting's over, we're going to hear all kinds of Fed speakers saying, yeah, yeah, we talked about
it. We're really thinking about it. If things go down, we're going to have cuts later this year.
I think that's what happens. Yeah, it's the psychology, right, Steve? They'll come out and
say, OK, things are starting to turn bad. And the first thing they do, like last summer,
in the wake of that July meeting where they didn't cut, things started to turn really bad in July
before the September meeting. What did they do? They released the meeting minutes and said, oh,
by the way, we were actually talking about cutting. And then a bunch of Fed speakers came
out and said the same thing. Oh, no, no, no. We were actually discussing rate cuts. We didn't do
it, but we were talking about it. It's the same thing as you and I talked about last week or the
week before with the Reserve Bank of Australia, how the Reserve Bank of Australia said, oh,
we talked about doing a 50 because they think the psychology is part of this. As you say,
the other side of what you just said, a worker who's out of work as a consumer,
rate cuts aren't going to help them. Same thing for the business side of this, right? Employers
who are having to trim hours and fire workers, which we're seeing more and more happen in the
real economy, rate cuts don't help them either, especially in this environment. You and I were
talking before we started recording about all of these different businesses like Lululemon and a
bunch of other ones, Dollar Tree, that have said our costs are going up and we cannot pass those
along to consumers. So how is lower interest rates going to help Dollar Tree that's facing a massive
profit hit? Well, lower interest rates are going to help it all. Dollar Tree is going to say,
well, we're going to take the profit hit for a month, maybe two, and hope that it turns around
in a couple of months. But if it doesn't, what's going to happen? Well, lower interest rates are
going to happen either way and low interest rate going to help them. What they're going to do is
they're going to start looking at all their workers. And they really don't have as many.
They're going to start looking at all the workers they do have and saying, you're going to be part
time, you're going to be part time, you're going to be out the door, you're going to be out the
And it's not just Dollar Tree, all these businesses that are saying we're taking a profit hit
from tariffs and rising costs, they're not going to continue to do that.
They're not charities, as you always say, Steve.
They're not here to just pay people no matter what.
So that's really the environment that the markets are starting to pick up on, is that,
OK, there's a lot of business trouble here.
It's not just about consumer sentiment turning sour.
It's real world economics, I mean, small E economics.
Yeah, absolutely, Jeff.
And you can go up to the manufacturing level and you can find there's a fantastic relationship
between commercial and industrial lending and new orders.
So you think about what just happened, right?
We had all this front row tariffs.
And what are we hearing from suppliers across the chain, manufacturers right down to the
retailer?
We've got a lot of inventory.
Now, in some cases, we could argue they have a lot of the wrong inventory.
But nevertheless, they still have a lot of inventory.
But it starts to make sense because when a manufacturer gets a new order in, they don't
have piles of cash around to fund it.
They go to the bank and they borrow against that so they can manufacture.
And then, of course, there's all this lending that goes on right through the supply chain
all the way until it gets down to the retailer who is already borrowing money again to get
that inventory.
So when you see a slowdown in demand, rate cuts really don't matter.
Because if I'm a manufacturer and my fax machine isn't roaring with a bunch of new orders,
I don't need to borrow any money.
In fact, maybe I need to go out and I've got a lot of things out there that I need to collect
money on.
But the bank's saying, look, why do I want to lend against that?
Because we don't know when that inventory is going to sell.
So people really think rate cuts matter.
They do to the stock market because, again, that's the form of liquidity getting injected.
And that's bullish for stocks no matter what the case is throughout history.
And yes, if Fed cuts, stocks will go up.
But in terms of the real economy, it won't make any difference.
Yeah, we're already seeing that around the world.
Like I mentioned, the Reserve Bank of India following reducing rates by an aggressive
50 basis points here, even as, and here's the other thing, even as bank loan growth
in India has really fallen off sharply because there's actually a direct relationship rather
than inverse relationship between interest rates and lending.
You think that, you know, with central banks cutting rates, first of all, central banks
don't control market rates to begin with.
That's a myth.
That's a legend that, you know, don't fight the Fed, the central banks are all powerful.
That's not true either.
But what you actually see is that as central banks are chasing this weakness and lowering
interest rates, banks are already risk averse, as Steve just said, because the other side
of these businesses that are saying we don't need more loans because our business is falling
off, the banks are saying, well, good, I don't want to give you any more loans because I
see the same thing that you do.
Your business is falling off.
I don't want to lend to you.
So in India is a perfect example.
The Reserve Bank of India, which hadn't cut before this year up until February, they hadn't
done anything.
Now, all of a sudden, they're cutting rates.
At the same time, loan growth is falling off sharply because they're both reacting to the
same thing.
And it's not just India.
We see it in Europe.
This week from now, we're going to have the Swiss National Bank, which is going to be
right back at zero interest rates for the central bank rate, maybe even negative if
the Swiss franc strengthens some more, and you go one by one at central banks all around
the world.
The Bank of Mexico has cut by 50 basis points three straight times, too.
And it's all for the same reason, the same reason the Fed doesn't want to talk about.
And that's economic uncertainty.
That's actually not uncertainty.
The economy is becoming more and more certain, not less.
And so central banks outside of Jay Powell are reacting to that, as is the marketplace.
That brings us back to the four week Treasury bill yield and what may be happening up at
the front of the curve.
Yeah, Jeff, I would say this just brings us right back to where the show started at four
week, because what is the where banks tell us right now, look, they're wanting collateral.
Why would they want it?
Because the economy is slowing.
And what happens when the economy slows?
People go into delinquency.
Then they go into default.
Banks start to panic because of the economy is booming.
They probably wouldn't need the collateral that they want to have now.
Again, just a red flag popping up in the system telling us that trajectory of the economy
is going in the wrong direction.
And it's like I said, it's just a small one of those red flags that you want to pay attention
to.
But the point here is you've got a red flag in the four week Treasury bill.
You've got a red flag in the Treasury curve.
You've got a red flag over here in the Reserve Bank of India.
You've got a red flag over here in the jobs report and actually what was in there.
I talked about that in the live stream video yesterday.
So you have all these red flags that are popping up.
None of them say the world is ending.
It's catastrophic.
But you've got all these red flags popping up and it's it's you not only have to pay
attention to it, you have to realize what all of this stuff means and what it means
is that Jay Powell is not going to be able to hold rates where they are for very long.
