Asian and Middle Eastern swordsmen and thrusting

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
2 Video Views·Jun 7, 2025
Hey there, Matt Easton, Scholar Gladiatoria. So I was asked such a good question in the comments
under one of my videos by Rami Sabrua that I'm actually going to make a short video response
to it because it's interesting enough to do so. And the question was, there are many historical
accounts from the 19th century saying that Eastern or Asian, not Eastern as in me, but
Asian swordsmen didn't know how to deal with thrusts very well. Does that mean that tulwars
and shamshirs and swords like this were useless for defensive purposes? Let's examine that point.
So Rami Sabrua's question was absolutely excellent. There are indeed lots of, particularly British but
also French, 19th century sources stating that Asian, North African, Middle Eastern swordsmen
using curved swords like this tulwar I'm holding here didn't use the thrust very much and also
weren't very good at dealing with thrusts. In India it was pretty much standard advice for
British swordsmen to use the point, to give point, both on horseback and on foot. And one of the
reasons for that was it was discovered that essentially very often Indian swordsmen were
not very good at dealing with thrusts. Now this might seem surprising when you consider that of
course spears and bayonets were used all over India and indeed pretty much everywhere else.
So you would think that if people had encountered bayonets and spears they'd know how to deal with
thrusts. And that's one of the big kind of unknowns. It's the question why was it, and it is
numerous sources state this. Personal accounts, official papers, books talking about things,
all sorts of stuff. All sorts of different sources and non-related sources. It wasn't just
a couple of sources and it wasn't just word of mouth or rumour. It was very clearly based on
experience that very often, certainly with swords, when thrusts were given there seems to have been
a vulnerability, particularly in India but in other countries as well, to this. The thrust is
clearly a very simple thing to do with a sword. It's not like a secret mystical super ninja attack.
It's just sticking the pointy end in the other person so to speak. But it does seem to have been
particularly more effective in the East, shall we say, from a 19th century western point of view.
Now I think there's a few elements to this and indeed there's one other element to answering
Rami Saburo's question. So first up, if you're in a place where 95% of people who use swords
use things like tulwars or shamshirs, here I've actually got a European style hilted sword made
for an Indian officer with essentially a shamshir blade and you'll see it's extremely curved. Now
whilst these swords are pointy and you could technically stick them in someone, I've done videos
talking about this before, curved blades that are highly curved, it's just not very easy to thrust
with them in actual swordsmanship. People like Lynn Thompson on the Cold Steel videos
will demonstrate that a 1796 cavalry saber, which is curved pretty much like this, can stab into a
lump of meat. Yes it can. Clearly any pointy piece of metal, pointy object in fact, doesn't need to
be metal, can stick into a lump of meat. That's a no-brainer, everyone knows that, or should do.
However in actual fighting and actual fencing it becomes very difficult in practical terms
to thrust someone with a very curved blade, largely for two reasons. Number one, because
the blade is very very curved it means that you have to move the sword in such a way that very
often it's not practical to stick it in the other person because you don't have a line of opposition
very easily. So with a straight thrusting blade such as this small sword, if I cross, if I defend
and parry essentially, if I block, then my point is on line to thrust. If I block with a curved
sword my point's not on line to thrust, that's the first reason. The second reason is reach.
Quite simply with a curved blade if you thrust with the arm straight you'll see that my point
is not on line, it's offline. So to get the point in I would have to thrust from the side in a
and this is incredibly, this is punching distance okay, so you can do it if I was in, if I'd grappled
with someone for example or I was at shield range, yes absolutely I can stab and thrust around a
shield with this point at extremely, at punching range essentially, it's the same range as my fist
but compared to something like a small sword or any straight sword that's incredibly short range
and you're going to get run through before you ever get close, unless you have an armour or shield,
you're going to get run through before you ever get to range to do this type of motion.
The next thing I want to say is, so if you're in a culture where you've got these curved blades,
very clearly people by natural selection are not going to use them for thrusting very much,
especially when it's human nature to do this, to hit with a stick or a sword or a dagger or
anything else. When people are under stress this is a very natural action to cut with the sword,
it's less of a natural action to actually thrust. I know a few people who go against that grain,
I know some people who are natural thrusters but having taught hundreds of people over the last
nearly 20 years, I can tell you that 90 something percent of people are natural hitters,
the people who naturally thrust are very, very, very rare in my experience. So if you're in a
culture where you know naturally human nature means you're going to want to do this and you
have a sword which is better designed for doing this, for cutting from different angles, then
clearly that's what you're going to do with it. You're not going to try and thrust if it's not
a very practical thing to do. And the other factor that comes into it is shields. So if shields are
in play then it's a different style of swordsmanship right from the bat. I'm going to
come back to talking about shields a bit at the end. So if you've got curved swords they are not
generally speaking in practical terms very good for thrusting. If you have a culture which is
full of curved swords as they did in India or Arabic areas for example or Persia where we've
got blades which are highly curved like Shamshir's or even Turkey with the Kilich, then very clearly
you're not going to be as used to facing thrust. Now this is the important part I think
and this is the centre of this discussion is that why did British soldiers in 19th century
warfare in India or Afghanistan find that the people there were particularly vulnerable to
thrusts? I think it's because when faced with a sword wielding opponent in that instant they
didn't expect a person to thrust. Because if you're in a culture where whether it's an Afghan
or Khyber knife or whether it's a Tulwar or a Kukri or a Kora or a Kanda or all of these swords
that are predominantly cutting swords, if you're used to your opponent having a short side arm like
a sword or a big knife they're going to cut at you and if that's what you've practised against
with your sword and buckler with your Tulwar and Daal, if that's what you're trained to do
then that's what you're going to expect them to do. If they suddenly thrust at you or maybe
cut and then thrust it's really going to throw you off and it's very disconcerting and you know
the funny thing is in my club we train a lot the use of the point in our sabre play but we often
comment when we spar people from other clubs or just generally from outside the group that a lot
of people out there doing sabre, backsword and single stick don't use their points anywhere near
enough anywhere near as much as they should be doing and I think this is partly due to the
training partly sometimes due to the sources that they study some sources don't accentuate
the use of the point very much and lastly human nature human nature as I mentioned is to give
blows because it's more of a caveman thing to do it's more natural to do than to thrust so
and it's very interesting against those people using the point a lot is highly effective I know
someone some of you might guess who I'm talking about who is a highly highly skilled fencer
but his experience is mostly in LARP and a little bit of SCA combat and he was despite being
incredibly difficult to beat he is definitely most vulnerable to thrusts so quite simply
even someone can even be you know generally speaking a really good fighter but still the
most the thing they're most vulnerable against is thrusts as a result of either their training
or the weapons they use or the type of practice they do bear in mind that historically some
training forbade the use of thrusts to make it safer you know we see this in some late
German longsword traditions we equally see it potentially in some sword and buckler
stuff from the 16th and 17th centuries more 16th century Elizabethan period
and there's also hints that perhaps in other traditions as well some single stick traditions
perhaps some Indian Gatka that the use of the point was forbidden or at least frowned upon
because it was unsafe and they were training essentially a combat sport so there's many
complex reasons why someone might not be very good at dealing with thrusts but absolutely it
was a historical thing not just in India but in all sorts of different areas and you know you
could say that perhaps in 16th century England with the the kind of the backsorders of the day
perhaps they weren't as good at dealing with thrusts as people trained in Italian rapier were
and who knows. I'm sure that will cause lots of lots of arguments. So the final thing is in Rami
Saburo's question he said does the fact that Indian swordsmen or let's say Asian swordsmen
of the day were not very good at dealing with thrusts mean that these types of swords weren't
meant for defending with? Well the basic answer is no these swords were definitely meant for
defending with and numerous British sources of the 19th century say what good swordsmen
Indian swordsmen were for the most part better than British swordsmen and this also accentuates
the fact they they said on one hand you know it wasn't there was no sort of in this case anyway
there was no cultural sense of superiority involved there are numerous British sources saying
oh yeah Indian swordsmen are way better better than our British cavalry troopers they're far
better trained we don't need to teach them anything because they already know what to do with their
swords and they use them far more effectively than we do. They even let them keep their own
toolbars in many cases at least for irregular cavalry because they were more effective often
than the regulation British cavalry swords which weren't always properly sharpened and were kept in
steel scabbards. So absolutely the British recognized the quality of swordsmanship in India
but even nevertheless even recognizing that they still weren't but they're really vulnerable to
thrusts because they don't really train for them. So it's all really about training and sometimes
the training that you do is dictated by the weapon that you use and sometimes it's dictated by
cultural things the way that you train for example if you're just using wooden sticks
with no protection you can understand why in sporting competition contexts you might say well
let's not use thrusts let's only hit with the sticks because you're less likely to get bad
injuries that way. But to finish up absolutely these swords were meant for defending with they
have cross guards and you know they have all of the features of a weapon that is meant to be
defended with however there are two things which I would say which do generally speaking make them a
little bit different from European swords which have sort of these types of hilts and springy
blades. First of all the use of woots and other types of very hard edged steels in India and the
Middle East means that these swords are more likely to take bad edge damage through defensive actions
than a European sword is. Very often Tulwars and Shamshiyas have really really thin fine edges
which is fantastic for cutting but not very good for defending so in that sense they were
more geared towards attack and offence and effective cutting than necessarily thinking
about defence. The other aspect to remember though is one of the reasons why that came about
was because of these again okay and so in whether you're talking about the Middle East so Persia
all of the Arabic countries, North Africa, Algeria, Morocco if you're talking about India or Afghanistan
all of these countries predominantly used shields with their swords and the shield was the first
weapon of defence and this was for attacking so if you're in a culture where you're nine times out
of ten you're going to if you're using a sword you're also going to have a shield then this
weapon becomes more geared towards attack because this can take up most of the weight as far as
defending is concerned. So there we go I hope that sort of answers the question. I think were
certain areas of the world bad at defending against thrusts in the 19th century? Yes I think there's
enough historical evidence to say that was evidently the case. Why? I think it's a combination of weapon
design and also weapon training and they connect together because if your weapon is of a certain
design you're not going to train against thrusts very much you're not going to encounter thrusts
very much and therefore you're not going to be very good at defending them when you do encounter
them. And lastly were these swords not designed for defence? I think that they were more geared
towards offence than defence largely because of the use of shields however when used by themselves
and we know they were also used by themselves they weren't always used with shields especially as we
get into the era when more firearms were available and it wasn't necessarily practical
if you're carrying ammunition and a firearm and a sword and blah blah blah it's not necessarily
practical to carry a sword and a shield in that period therefore these took over the role of
defence and offence more and certainly by the end of the 19th century in India the Talwar was used
by itself without a shield most of the time so absolutely they were used to defend with as well.
So there we go I hope that's a fairly thorough examination of Rami Saburo's excellent question.
Thank you. Thank you for watching please subscribe follow us on Facebook you can
buy t-shirts through Spreadshirt, support us on Patreon or follow us on Pinterest. Thank you.
