"Not Dragon! SpaceX Starship To Rescue Nasa Hubble... === intro 0:00 (Hubble) 0:31 (Polaris Dawn) 1:53 Does Nasa actually give up on Hubble? 6:03 outro 8:42 === #techmap#techmaps#elonmusk#starshipspacex#spacex === 1) SOURCES OF IMAGES AND VIDEOS Lunprod: https://www.youtube.com/@Lunprod634 John Cargile: https://twitter.com/GroundTruthPics WAI: https://www.youtube.com/@Whataboutit https://twitter.com/FelixSchlang Evan Karen: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDN1X8Fz1oAXX-rBcOWjzmg Ryan Hansen Space: https://twitter.com/RyanHansenSpace/ https://www.youtube.com/c/RyanHansenSpace Everyday Astronaut: https://twitter.com/Erdayastronaut https://www.youtube.com/c/EverydayAstronaut ==== Not Dragon! SpaceX Starship To Rescue Nasa Hubble... This is a question given after Nasa officials rejected Jared Isaacman's proposal to save Hubble with SpaceX Dragon. One of the drivers behind this decision is the spacecraft's lack of technical capabilities. Of course, that is not the biggest reason. Honestly, the national agency has been hatching a bolder plan than ever with their great observers. Yeah, a giant vehicle like SpaceX Starship, not Dragon, is their top priority. Find out everything in today's episode of Techmap. Not Dragon! SpaceX Starship To Rescue Nasa Hubble... Nasa's Hubble Space Telescope is not just a simple telescope, but above all, it carries enormous scientific, spiritual, and economic value. Being a large space telescope orbiting Earth, it has made more than one million observations including detailed pictures of the birth and death of stars, galaxies billions of light years away, and comet pieces crashing into Jupiter's atmosphere. Scientists have learned a lot about the universe from these pictures, especially in estimating the age and size of the universe. In spiritual terms, this iconic telescope is among Nasa's Great Observatories and was launched in 1990 aboard the Space Shuttle Discovery during STS 31. Most notably, it is seen as the most productive science mission in the history of Nasa but is also the most expensive science mission in the national agency’s history. Not Dragon! SpaceX Starship To Rescue Nasa Hubble... Hubble's cumulative costs are estimated to be about 11.3 billion dollars in 2015 dollars, which include all subsequent servicing costs, but not ongoing operations. It's safe to say that due to its great scientific, spiritual, and economic significance, Nasa is always devoted to keeping it alive in space as much as possible. This explains why throughout Hubble's history, Nasa has conducted five expensive servicing missions to extend its lifespan from 15 years to decades.
Does NASA actually give up on Hubble? This is a question given after NASA officials rejected
Jared Isaacman's proposal to save Hubble with SpaceX Dragon. One of the drivers behind this
decision is the spacecraft's lack of technical capabilities. Of course, that is not the biggest
reason. Honestly, the National Agency has been hatching a bolder plan than ever with their great
observers. Yeah, a giant vehicle like SpaceX Starship, not Dragon, is their top priority.
Find out everything in today's episode of TechMap.
NASA's Hubble Space Telescope is not just a simple telescope, but above all,
it carries enormous scientific, spiritual, and economic value. Being a large space telescope
orbiting Earth, it has made more than one million observations, including detailed pictures of the
birth and death of stars, galaxies billions of light-years away, and comet pieces crashing into
Jupiter's atmosphere. Scientists have learned a lot about the universe from these pictures,
especially in estimating the age and size of the universe. In spiritual terms, this iconic
telescope is among NASA's great observatories and was launched in 1990 aboard the space shuttle
Discovery during STS-31. Most notably, it is seen as the most productive science mission in the
history of NASA, but is also the most expensive science mission in the National Agency's history.
Hubble's cumulative costs are estimated to be about $11.3 billion in 2015, which include all
subsequent servicing costs, but not ongoing operations. It's safe to say that due to its
great scientific, spiritual, and economic significance, NASA is always devoted to
keeping it alive in space as much as possible. This explains why, throughout Hubble's history,
NASA has conducted five expensive servicing missions to extend its lifespan from 15 years
to decades. However, the serious aging situation of this great space watcher and the shortages
in terms of both means and finance may have changed NASA's mind. In 2022, Polaris Dawn
commander and billionaire Jared Isaacman offered an attractive suggestion that he'd foot the bill
to take a maintenance crew aboard SpaceX Dragon to Hubble. According to that, under Polaris's
second mission, he would partner with SpaceX to perform a boost to Hubble and possibly service it
like NASA used to do, all for free. Polaris is a three-mission private astronaut series flying
with SpaceX hardware that plans to run the first-ever commercial spacewalk as soon as this
year, with Polaris Dawn. However, most NASA officials said no to him. The given reasons
include Polaris has not performed a spacewalk yet, that the SpaceX EV suits have not yet been tested
in space, that reaching Hubble is difficult even for NASA astronauts, and that any spacewalk near
the telescope poses a risk of damage to it. When it comes to this incident, the space community
has its own thoughts. If the Polaris's unprofessional astronauts cannot meet NASA's
requirement for a Hubble rescue mission, NASA will take full responsibility for the personnel,
and they can book reservations on SpaceX's vehicles to carry their astronauts. Because
the SpaceX Dragon spacecraft does not have a robotic arm to revolve and position the telescope
to make spacewalking easier, SpaceX Starship will do that instead. An interesting idea is to equip
Starship with a version of Canadarm. Canadarm, or Canadarm-1, is a series of Canadian robotic arms
that were used on the Space Shuttle orbiters to deploy, maneuver, and capture payloads. It was
also utilized in Hubble's previous rescue missions, helping to retrieve the telescope
and firmly mount the instrument onto a platform in the Shuttle's huge cargo bay.
Although such a robotic mission, as Jared Isaacman said, may be a taxpayer expense depending on what
NASA wants to do, I'm sure that it would be much cheaper than the missions on Shuttle, mainly due
to Starship's low cost per launch. With the volume and payload capacity of SpaceX's Starship, it
should be fairly easy to fit a robotic arm and other fittings from the Space Shuttles. You could
even use the design of part of the Shuttle orbiter pressurized crew module as a start, for
example, for the arm control and the airlock. Shuttle-type fuel cells could be used, along with
some experimental deployable solar panels. NASA should ask SpaceX to start thinking about it now
since Hubble often needs a servicing mission to replace some components. On the other hand,
some analysis indicated that it would be quite a job to fit a Canadarm to a Starship depending on
what configuration of Starship you start with. Canadarm is long and needs a large cargo bay door
to reach out of, so the cargo Starship variant could be a suitable choice. Also on the Shuttle
was a large control panel to manage and control the Canadarm. Fitting a suitable control station
would probably be much harder than providing the electrical power for the arm. Do you try to use
one of the Canadarms saved from the Shuttle program and cannibalize a Shuttle for the
control panel or have a new one built? In 2019, there was news that Canada would develop and
contribute a smart robotic system, Canadarm 3, that will repair and maintain the Gateway.
Being evolved from Canadarm 2, Canadarm 3 will be an expanded version with enhanced AI systems.
The CSA's website says that Canada's smart robotic system and other autonomous computer systems will
tend to the Gateway when no humans are on board, including operating science experiments aboard
the lunar outpost. The combination of Starship and Canadarm 3 will help to reduce the risk for
astronauts in dangerous missions and cut down the cost significantly. So how about you? Do you prefer
the idea of equipping Canadarm 3 with Starship to rescue Hubble? Say yes if you agree. Anyway, if you
find this useful, please give us a share, like and subscribe. Your support will be a huge motivation
for us to release more quality videos in the future. And now, let's come back. In my personal
view, I am happy to see this unique combination used in important space missions and I'm pretty
sure NASA would be too, but most likely they will apply it in practice in future missions,
not Hubble's service missions. So why? An unavoidable truth is, despite large efforts,
that the telescope is aging and continues to be constantly bombarded with potentially damaging
radiation from space. A reboost or enhancement might become moot if critical components break.
Keith Kalinowski, a retired Hubble operations expert, is one of the first to realize the problem.
In an email to a Hubble manager at NASA, Kalinowski wrote, I'm very wary truly of predicting failures
and I'll forever be a Hubble hugger, but there does come a time when you have to ask whether
putting more money and effort into making more Hubble data might provide less return on investment
than putting the same money and effort into new mission. Kalinowski's voice may represent the
voice of the American astronomy community. From 2019 to 2021, the U.S. astronomy community was
engaged in a planning exercise for the coming decade and beyond. Also, NASA is planning the
development of the new Great Observatories. The result of that effort is the decadal survey
pathways to discovery in astronomy and astrophysics for the 2020s. Commonly known as
ASTRA 2020, it envisages an ambitious set of new Great Observatories as the community's top
priority. The new Great Observatories, some of which are shown in this picture, would collect
measurements that span the electromagnetic spectrum from far IR to X-rays with orders of
magnitude gain in capabilities over their renowned predecessors, the Spitzer Space Telescope, the
Hubble Space Telescope, the Compton Gamma-ray Observatory, and the Chandra X-ray Observatory.
The early design concepts contained the Louvoir Observatory, Origin Space Telescope,
and the Lynx X-ray Observatory. The SpaceX Starship launch vehicle is expected to bring
those observatories to space before the middle of the century. To keep within the NASA astrophysics
budget, however, their launch dates have been pushed to the 40s and 50s. While there are many
discussions around this forbidding timeline, mostly because of the shortage of competent
experts at that point, in terms of Starship's readiness term, the timeline is totally feasible.
Based on Starship's tight timeline for the present, the vehicle has the capability to
be operational and server for NASA's Artemis 3 mission in 2026. Astrophysics missions to space
have always been tightly constrained by the capabilities of the launchers, which have not
changed substantially in two decades. The three changes that Starship would bring are a much
larger mass to orbit, much wider cargo bays, and no increase in and potentially lowering the cost
per launch. And that just about wraps it up for today's episode. Thank you, and we look forward
to seeing you next time!