On the Edges of Knowledge | Rupert Sheldrake vs. Michael Shermer

Science & Spirituality
12 followers
2 Video Views·May 28, 2025
Michael Shermer and Rupert Sheldrake go head-to-head over science, skepticism, spiritual claims, and the boundaries of knowledge itself.
Can you feel it when someone is watching you? The two thinkers challenge each other on where the edges of knowledge truly lie. Hosted by Güneş Taylor.
Chapters:
00:00 Introduction
01:32 Michael Shermer pitch
05:48 Rupert Sheldrake pitch
13:58 Who is censoring you?
17:39 Psychic research evidence
20:30 Consciousness
22:02 What is evidence?
22:52 Alternative theories of physics
25:35 Mechanistic materialism
27:37 Roger Penrose
29:28 How do ideas become accepted?
30:45 Burden of proof
32:24 Scientific conservatism
34:28 Alternative medicine
36:30 Everybody thinks they're Galileo
Hi, everybody.
Oh, thank you.
That's very kind of you both.
It's a pleasure to be here.
Thank you, everybody, for joining us.
We have a short session here,
so I'm not going to take up too much of your time.
But my job here is to set the scene
for what we would like to hear
these two illustrious gentlemen to discuss.
So what I would like to say
is that we will be discussing on the edges of knowledge.
So the question is, what is it possible to know?
Is the physical universe all there is?
Or is the immaterial part of reality too?
So we're obviously joined by radical scientist,
Rupert Sheldrake, and world-leading skeptic, Michael Shermer.
And they're going to go head-to-head
on the subject of where the edges of knowledge lie.
That's what we're here to do.
I personally love the idea of you two
just having a full-on conversation,
and we just get to spectate this.
But I've been asked to get the conversation going
with a particular question,
and each of you will get three minutes
to sort of set up your stall,
and then we'll just go from there.
How does that sound?
Great.
All right, so this is the question.
What are the limits of human understanding?
Rupert, I think you said that Michael may go first.
How gentlemanly of you.
Michael, you're up, three minutes.
No pressure.
All right, well, what are the limits of human knowledge?
How would I know?
If I knew, I would change my beliefs or whatever.
We're stuck in the 21st century, and we know what we know.
So I begin with the Copernican principle
that we're not special, and I apply it to myself.
I'm not special.
And so I'm not God, omniscient and omnipotent.
You're not God either, so we're in this together.
Or if you prefer the secular version,
there is an objective reality,
but I don't know what it is, and you don't either.
So we have to kind of collectively go through what we know
and try to evaluate what we should believe.
And I don't wanna believe things
that have to be believed in to be true.
That is, reality is that which,
when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away,
as Philip K. Dick said.
So that's our goal, and how do you get there?
Well, through the tools of rationality and science.
Reason and arguments, logic, and empiricism.
You actually go out there and look out the window
and see what the world is actually like,
and see if it matches your ideas,
which may or may not be right.
And to the best that you can, collect data from out there
to see if it matches your ideas
of what you think it should be like,
and then try to hone those.
So I guess it depends on the particular topic
of how confident we could be in the current theories.
The theory of evolution is over 150 years old now,
and it's pretty well established.
But if we take a kind of a Bayesian approach
by assigning some probability of something being true,
true with a small t or not, somewhere between one and 99.
So the Cromwell principle in Bayesian reasoning,
Oliver Cromwell, I beseech you in the bowels of Christ,
you might be mistaken.
Now, he was talking about some political issue.
But in Bayesian reasoning, this is,
you never apply a zero or 100 to anything,
because you never know.
You may be wrong on this end,
you may be wrong on this end.
So let's just put, so the theory of evolution,
it's like 99% probably true with fine tuning
if you're a neo-Darwinian or punctuated equilibrium
or some little aspect of it.
But it's not like the creationists
are suddenly gonna find something new,
because they've been looking for a century and a half,
and they haven't been able to overturn the theory.
So it's possible that Darwin was wrong, probably not.
And so we don't assign 100% to it,
we always have an open mind just in case.
And the Big Bang theory, it's probably true,
here's a whole pile of evidence for it.
Now, it's possible it could be wrong
and this could be overturned, probably not overnight,
probably not one experiment's gonna overturn it.
It would have to be a convergence of evidence
to some other theory that explains everything
the Big Bang theory explains and these other anomalies.
One of the problems we face in all theories
is what's called the residue of anomalies.
No theory explains everything,
so you always have this residue of stuff
that's not explained.
And you have, so I use this example for UFOs, UAPs,
you've seen these grainy videos and blurry photographs,
what is that?
And the pro-UFOlogists say,
well, we acknowledge 95% of all those sightings
are fully explicable by terrestrial phenomenon,
geese and drones and Chinese spy balloons.
So here we have this huge bin of 95%
and then you have the other little bin,
it's aliens or it's the Russian-Chinese drones or whatever.
So you have a new sighting, which bin do you put it in?
Well, it's 95% likely to be in this big bin.
So, and it's 2.5% for each of the two little bins,
it might be there, keep an open mind,
just in case this is the one, probably not, right?
So, as the saying goes, if you hear hoofprints outside,
think horse, not zebra, or I guess here in Wales,
think sheep, not zebra.
I've seen a lot of sheep here.
So that's the approach,
just assign some probability to it.
I keep an open mind with Rupert's ideas.
He might be right, but we'll see.
Okay, well, oh, there we go, there's a bit of that.
Rupert, can you tell us what your thoughts are
on the limits of human understanding?
I think there are certain intrinsic limits to understanding.
There are certain things our minds may never be able to grasp.
I mean, after all, we live in a cosmos 15 billion years old
with an incredible number of galaxies and so on.
It'd be very strange if human minds in the 21st century
could grasp all of it.
But I agree with Michael that one of the best methods
we have is science, reason, discussion, evidence.
We don't disagree about that.
Where we disagree is where we think the limits of science
are or should be.
I think that there are many things that we can investigate
scientifically which are at present taboo
within the academic and scientific world.
And those taboos are maintained by organized groups of skeptics.
And Michael's, as it were, one of the archbishops
of the skeptic movement.
And so, and many skeptics patrol the frontiers of knowledge
and there are vigilante skeptic squads set up
all around the world and Michael's trained many of them.
He used to give workshops with the late magician
James Randi on how to be a skeptic.
And I know that they're very effective
because their slogan was,
next time a charlatan shows up in town,
be the skeptic who the media ask their opinion of.
And how can you be an expert on this?
Just say you are.
Anyway, I know that because when I show up in town,
all these trained skeptics feel that they ought to cancel me
because I'm doing research that goes beyond the boundaries
of what they think science should be.
So this is an issue that's not just an academic issue.
It comes in, it feeds into cancel culture.
I had a TED talk that was, a TEDx talk that was censored
because it ran foul of some pretty dogmatic scientists.
So I think that there are realms that we can investigate
which are at present almost impossible to study
or get funded within the university
or academic or scientific system.
I call them the mysteries of everyday life.
Some favorite skeptic slogan is extraordinary claims
demand extraordinary evidence.
But I'm dealing with ordinary claims.
95% of people say they've had the experience
of being looked at from behind,
turning around and seeing someone looking at them,
the sense of being stared at.
About 85% of people say they've had the experience
of what seems like telephone telepathy,
thinking of someone who then calls.
About 50% of dog owners say their dog knows
when an owner's, when a person,
a member of the family is coming home.
Now these are ordinary claims.
They're made by millions of people
and lots of people say they happen on a regular basis.
They're not weird, strange things like miracles
that happened 2000 years ago.
They're ordinary claims.
So can we look at them scientifically?
For example, when people think someone's looking
at them from behind, is it because people turn around
all the time and occasionally someone's looking at them
and they think, aha, there's some mysterious sense?
So, or is it more than that?
So you do controlled experiments with randomized trials
in which people are looked at or not looked at
and they have to say whether they're looked at or not
and they're right or they're wrong.
And is it above chance?
And the answer is in many experiments
there have been many published papers, yes it is.
It even seems to work through closed circuit television.
People who work in the surveillance industry
are completely convinced this is real.
We've interviewed lots of private detectives,
security officers, surveillance officers,
the drug squad at Heathrow,
the stall detectives at Harrods,
places, people like that whose job it is to watch others
and in that world there's almost no doubt this is real
because they see it all the time.
Yet, move into the world of academic science
and the world, the citadel that's defended
by the skeptic movement patrolling the frontiers
and this is just pseudoscience, it doesn't exist.
Telephone telepathy, is it just coincidence?
Do people think of others all the time?
Occasionally someone rings when they're thinking of them,
they imagine it's telepathy but they forget
all the millions of times they're wrong.
Well, we do tests, four potential callers,
the person's filmed the whole time,
landline phone, no caller ID,
we pick the caller at random,
ask them to ring the person, their friend
and when the phone rings they have to guess
which of these four people it is
before they answer the phone.
By chance they'd be right 25% of the time.
In our film trials they're right about 45% of the time.
Hundreds of trials, it's very significant.
Dogs that know when their owners are coming home,
we film the dog, we have people come home
at non-routine times, they don't know in advance,
traveling by unfamiliar vehicles,
does the dog still go and wait at the door
10 minutes or more before the person comes home?
Yes, at least with the dogs we've studied.
So I think the evidence is quite strong
these things are real but if you try and do a PhD
on these things at a university,
except for two or three exceptions,
most of them here in Britain actually,
you can't because these are completely taboo topics
and these taboos are maintained in force by active skeptics.
So Michael's a very nice chap,
you know, he's friendly, he's funny
but where he and I differ.
I knew that was coming.
Where he and I differ you see is that
I think these, to investigating things
we don't understand, that we don't have necessarily
a theoretical explanation for,
is the very essence of science,
to explore what we don't know.
Whereas some people, well, he says he's open-minded,
let's say he is but some of his colleagues
are very definitely not open-minded
and they just want to shut this down
and stop what little investigation
there is on these subjects
because it doesn't fit their model of reality
which is usually the model of mechanistic materialism
that says the mind is nothing but the brain
and therefore all your thoughts and intentions
are inside the head,
so how could they possibly affect someone's distance?
These things are impossible,
therefore the evidence for them
is not worth taking seriously or even looking at.
Now just, I'll finish by saying
that that's not just a vague accusation.
Steven Pinker in his book Rationality,
where he argues for a rational and scientific approach,
says that there's no need to look at the evidence
for psychic phenomena that is so improbable
on Bayesian statistics grounds,
so incredibly improbable,
it's a waste of time looking at the evidence.
James Alcock, a leading member
of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry,
which is one of the other skeptic organizations,
Michael runs the Skeptic Magazine,
they run the Skeptical Inquirer.
Ours is the good one.
Well, I subscribe to the Skeptical Inquirer, actually.
I will make you an honorary member of the Skeptic Magazine.
Well, James Alcock,
who's one of their most informed luminaries,
a professor of psychology,
wrote a paper in the American Psychologist two years ago,
saying exactly arguing that,
that there's no need to look at the evidence
because these phenomena are simply impossible,
therefore it's a waste of time investigating them
or looking at the evidence.
Now, that, in my opinion,
is dogmatism which holds back science.
Okay.
First of all,
first of all, let's debunk the notion
that these subjects are taboo
and you're not allowed to talk about them.
Here we are, in a packed house,
talking about these ideas.
You're one of the most famous
public intellectuals in the world.
You have numerous best-selling books.
I see you on TV all the time talking about that.
Who is censoring you?
Nobody.
So that's not what you mean.
You mean mainstream scientists
that you're trying to convince
are not convinced of your evidence.
That's the real argument I think you're making.
Why is it that the Steven Pinkers,
myself or whoever, don't accept them?
Now, acknowledging that some skeptics are,
as you described,
but there's often a good reason for that
because the evidence has not cumulated enough,
converged to a particular hypothesis
that overturns the mainstream theory
and nudges us to accept that.
It's just not there.
And again, it's not that these things are taboo
and no one is doing this research, as you know.
By the way, Rupert and I have a book
called Arguing Science.
You can order it on Amazon,
in which we go back and forth, back and forth,
back and forth on all these.
And most of the hypotheses he just described,
staring at the back of the neck,
the dog knows when the owner's coming home and so on,
have been tested over and over.
They fail to replicate most of the time, not all the time.
There may be an experiment or bias.
So the most famous one here was the replication
by Marilyn Schlitz and Richard Wiseman.
Richard Wiseman is a skeptic.
Marilyn Schlitz is a believer.
Okay, those terms are problematic, but whatever.
They're kind of in those two different camps.
And they each found different results.
So, okay, where's the bias?
Is it on the part of the skeptics to not accept the data?
Is it on part of the believers
to accept data that's not sound?
Well, you just have to read the evidence.
And so, you know, like, well,
here I have these replicated experiments.
Well, sort of, but, you know,
half of all psych experiments have failed to replicate.
You know, since the replication crisis began in 2008,
not just your research,
but half of all the most famous psych experiments
you've ever heard of
should have probably never been published.
They were based on, like, one experiment
in which all we know is the one that was published.
The experimenter ran nine different experiments.
Eight of them found non-statistically significant results.
They published the one.
The rest go in the file drawers,
called the file drawer problem.
And so, this is very common,
not just in psychical research, but all research, right?
So, acknowledging that,
Pinker is skeptical of half of these psych experiments.
You're standing at the top of the escalator.
You give more money than at the bottom of the escalator.
Or you have the power pose.
You know, if you put your shoulders back
and your chin up and so on,
your testosterone goes up.
And this is what women should do.
They should have the power pose when they go, yeah.
That's what I was doing right before we came in here.
I noticed that.
It was working.
I was intimidated.
That failed.
This was one of the most famous TED Talks.
It was like 40 million views of this power pose TED Talk,
never replicated.
So, now, the Pinkers of the world
are skeptical of all that, too.
Not just yours, because of the failure to replicate.
So, it's not enough to just have,
I have this one experiment
in which I found this statistically significant result.
That's not enough.
You have to have it replicated over and over and over
until it's really obvious.
And almost everybody looking at it goes, yeah, okay.
That probably really happened.
And you get kind of a consensus.
Again, not 100%, but the majority.
Like, climate consensus.
What does that mean?
It's not a vote.
It's that most of the scientists
that study climate change agree.
It's probably human-caused.
It's all on.
It's happening.
You know, that kind of thing.
Well, we agree that most papers in psychology
don't replicate.
Most papers in biomedical science don't replicate.
Exactly.
But psychic researchers were accused of this.
So, they've been subject to much more scrutiny
than any other branch of science for much longer.
And in psychical research,
people publish negative results and failed replications.
In most of science, they don't,
or didn't until the replication crisis.
And it's simply not true
that most of these things don't replicate.
The sense of being stared at
has been replicated many, many times.
And even skeptics who've tried doing the experiments,
most skeptics don't do any experiments,
but there's a few who do.
And most of them got positive results
when they tried this.
Susan Blackmore, a leading British skeptic,
had a PhD student.
They got positive results.
They were never published.
And when I asked to see the raw data,
they'd been lost.
Richard Wiseman, who did staring experiments,
got positive results first time around
when the students were doing the staring.
So, he replaced them with himself as the starer,
and then he got the results he expected, no effect.
In his experiments with Marilyn Schlitz
that Michael referred to,
they were looking at people through CCTV,
measuring whether they could be,
whether their skin resistance,
their emotional arousal changed
when they've been looked at at random times
through closed circuit television.
She produced positive effects.
They changed when she was looking at them.
Richard Wiseman, when he was looking,
they didn't produce positive effects.
Now, it's not symmetrical.
She couldn't produce positive effects in this
just by wanting to,
unless there was a real sense of being stared at.
But he could produce non-significant effects
by not looking very hard.
And when he was interviewed afterwards,
he said it was such a boring experiment.
He just didn't look very hard.
So, these are not symmetrical.
And so, if you go into this actual literature,
you'll find that the idea it just doesn't replicate
is not true.
And the sense of being stared at's been replicated,
telephone telepathy's been replicated independently
at Freiburg University and Amsterdam University.
There's a much more persuasive body of literature
than Michael's summary would lead you to believe.
And the result of this is that if you listen to skeptics,
say, oh, it's all inconclusive, it's been replicated,
all disputed, et cetera,
then what's the point in going into the detailed literature?
It just seems like a waste of time,
even though there is all this evidence.
But the main reason, I think,
for the rejection or dogmatism or prejudice
against these phenomena,
by prejudice, I mean prejudging the issue,
the main reason is the materialist theory of mind,
which is very much the belief system
of most card-carrying skeptics I know are materialists.
For them, the mind is the brain and it's inside the head
and it shouldn't be able to do all these other things.
Therefore, the prejudice is much greater.
It's not just a matter of evidence.
The same materialists are perfectly happy
to accept the theory of physicists
that there are quadrillions of universes beside our own,
the multiverse theory, without one shred of evidence.
Dark matter and dark energy, 95% of reality,
physical reality, just theories, no evidence at all,
except they make the equations balance.
So you can add in the fudge factor
of just as much as you like,
titrate in as much dark energy
to make the equations of physics balance
to explain the universe as it is.
That doesn't provoke anger or attacks from most skeptics.
Physicists have a get-out-of-jail-free card,
but as soon as you come to anything
that challenges the central belief,
the mind is nothing but the brain,
and therefore there's no consciousness
out there in the universe, there's no God,
there's nothing beyond consciousness
limited to human and animal brains
and possibly the brains of extraterrestrials.
Then when you challenge that worldview,
that's where the problem kicks in,
and almost no amount of evidence is going to be enough
because we're dealing here with a fixed belief system
highly aided by confirmation bias.
Today.
Well, I just wanted to say, for the audience's sake,
so I'm also a scientist, I'm a researcher,
I work in the bench, and what's remarkable
about this conversation that we're seeing unfolding
is, of course, there's multiple subjects,
but the central point is about what is evidence,
whose evidence do you believe,
and therefore what constitutes actual knowledge, right?
And this is the type of conversation that happens
regardless of whether or not you're talking
about a particular phenomenon within a cell
or whether we're talking about the kind of phenomena
that Rupert's discussing here.
So I think, actually, there's a really big subject
happening that we're touching upon here
about, basically, knowledge and whose knowledge is,
what is knowledge, but the evidence
provided by different people,
and who do you choose to believe, right?
Yep, yep, that's the hard part.
So, you know, again, it's a social community
of people that work in a field,
and then there are the people that are kind of
on the margins, and then the people that are way out here.
And so, you know, Rupert and I both get
these alternative theories of physics.
There's hundreds of them.
You get them every week.
And, you know, what do you do with those?
And why don't they have a platform here?
Well, which ones?
And so the mainstream scientists,
sort of by necessity, have to think,
well, they're probably in the little bins
that are not gonna likely to pan out.
So we have to kind of concentrate on the mainstream
and just the few challenges from maybe some,
I don't know, renegade scientists or whatever.
They're here.
I mean, there's several people here
that are challenging the dark energy,
dark matter of the Big Bang and so on.
I've heard them, and they're not fringe.
They're not tinfoil hat wearing wackadoodles.
They're like professors, like real scholars.
Okay, so again, where's the censorship?
They are out there.
They are books about string theory
as just being complete bullshit.
So, and I get them all the time.
So where's the censorship?
The problem is that you want those kind of anecdotal
or fringe or challenging ideas
to become the mainstream.
Why aren't they?
And I would argue,
you just haven't made the case strong enough
because it is an extraordinary claim in a sense,
saying that 400 years of physics is wrong
because I ran this experiment
in which somebody could detect somebody staring
at the back of their neck,
or the BAM experiment of subjects looking
at computer screens, trying to guess
which side the erotic image was gonna pop up
versus the neutral image, left or right.
And BAM ran nine experiments.
This one gets published 50, 50,
but 53% of the images that were erotic,
basically pornography, were detected by college students,
more than the neutral image, right?
So when BAM goes on the Colbert report,
he called this extrasensory porn-ception, right?
And that, you know, so what's more likely?
That 400 years of physics is wrong
because some social scientists showed porn pictures
to college students, or he's just mistaken in there.
There's some error he made.
He just screwed up the methodological problems, right?
So before you overthrow the 400 years of physics,
maybe we should look at this one a little more carefully
and really make sure it replicates over and over and over
before you throw out the big theory there.
That's my response.
Well, that's a rhetorical argument
I've heard many times, Michael.
Well, thank you.
Overhearing, overthrowing 400 years of physics.
I mean, you know, Susan Blackmore, for example,
used this against me in an article she wrote
in the Times Educational Supplement.
What's more likely?
That 400 years of physics, the whole edifice of science,
all modern technology, mobile phones, TV,
all of that is wrong, or that Chael Drake's right.
That is a false opposition.
Damn, I thought I came up with that argument.
That was Susan's argument.
Nobody's saying 400 years of physics is wrong,
except for some physicists who are right here in Haigh-on-Wye.
I'm certainly not saying that.
What I'm saying is that mechanistic materialism,
the dominant orthodoxy or paradigm of science
for more than 100 years,
is at its very weakest dealing with consciousness and minds,
precisely because it denies that consciousness
is anything but the activity of matter.
And its least successful areas are to do with minds.
And they're the least understood things, really.
That's why consciousness studies
is such an important field in science now,
the last 20 years or so,
because we understand, oddly enough,
least of all about the nature of our own minds.
And we don't even know the extent of our minds.
And so it's not as if physicists have actually studied
the nature of consciousness or minds.
They've studied quantum particles and galactic movements
and planetary orbits and the behavior of electrons.
So the fact that physicists
haven't studied these subjects at all,
it means that physics is almost irrelevant to this question.
There may be properties of minds
that go beyond anything that physicists study
in quantum particles have found,
just as there are properties of life
that go beyond what physicists would.
But, Rupert, Roger Penrose is here.
He's one of the greatest scientists of all time.
He wrote a book about the hard problem of consciousness
being somehow explained by these quantum fields
inside the microtubules of neurons and so on.
And his whole theory that you, I think,
would be attracted to,
because he's challenging the mainstream,
and he's a physicist.
So what are you talking about?
Well, his theory of quantum nonlocality,
he applies quantum theory to consciousness,
but he confines it to microtubules,
which are small macromolecular structures
inside nerve cells.
And I think the mind is extended far beyond the brain.
I think my image of you is located where you're sitting,
not inside my head.
I don't think there's a little Michael inside my head.
I think my image of you is projected out to where you are.
And because it's projected out,
if I were looking at you from behind
and you didn't know I was there,
it might affect you because it's projected out.
And I did once say to Roger Penrose,
you believe that consciousness is extended,
but why stop at sort of 10 microns inside the microtubule?
Why not let it extend for hundreds of yards,
or even miles, when we're looking at distant things?
And he hadn't really got an answer to that.
He only said, you've got to start somewhere.
I mean, that's as good an answer as any.
But, you know, if you look up,
just look under Wikipedia of hard problem of consciousness,
there's like two dozen theories, right?
So you have one, Roger Penrose has one,
but they're not the only ones.
And none of them have convinced
the majority of neuroscientists and so on
that that's the right one.
So what do you do?
Well, you just wait.
Let's just keep trying to figure it out.
So we don't have very long left in the debate, unfortunately,
but in these last five minutes,
I actually want to pick up exactly where you just left that,
which is, all right, so of course,
even academic science is the pursuit
of many different theories,
and some theories are less likely,
but there are many things that we now hold to be true,
the classic one, of course,
being that we are in a solar system going around the sun.
That used to be a fringe idea, right?
That was very much to the edge of academic acceptance.
And now it's just true.
So here's my question,
and for the last sort of few minutes of this debate,
how is it that ideas go from being an idea to being tested
to actually becoming accepted?
And of course, evidence is a big part of it.
I'm a scientist, so I would say that.
But also, we all kind of have that human experience
of knowing that popular opinion
tends to also sort of seep in on occasion.
Even when talking about scientific theories,
we'll be like, oh, well,
everyone sort of agrees on this one, right?
So what happens in that uncomfortable interface
between actual evidence
and the fact that we are sort of susceptible
to what everyone else thinks,
and how does sort of the prevailing knowledge
and dogma come into formation through those two interfaces?
Well, that is the hard question,
and it's kind of a sociology of science question
or a history of science question.
And it really, so it's a burden of proof argument.
Who has the burden of proof?
You know, the mainstream person to refute your arguments,
or is the burden on you?
And you end up with this,
what Dan Dennett calls burden tennis.
No, the burden is on you, whack!
No, the burden is on you, no, whack!
And everybody has their data sets.
And just different fields, say climate skeptics.
There's a lot of them in America, you may have heard.
And so they write me all the time,
and they wanna know why the climate community
won't accept their alternative theories of global warming
that it's not human cause,
it's volcanoes or sunspots or whatever.
And the answer is, is because,
A, you're not a climate scientist.
You know, you're a lawyer or whatever,
and you're not publishing in mainstream climate journals.
You don't go to climate conferences.
You don't know anybody that works in the field.
And your evidence isn't very good.
So the burden is on you
to convince all these climate scientists,
you've got some viable alternative,
and they haven't done that.
And this is where this 97% figure,
97% of climate scientists say,
well, that just comes from a sort of study
of the abstracts of 10,000 papers on climate science.
And the 3% are over here,
and they go, well, I have all my alternative theories,
but they don't converge to anything
that would overthrow, you know,
the anthropogenic theory of climate change.
Okay, so that's it.
And that's true for all fields.
It's just, that's just the way it goes.
You're not the only one.
There's a bunch of people with alternative theories
of consciousness and so on,
and they haven't convinced everybody,
so too bad, keep working.
Well, I mean, you're basically,
your position is basically one of conservatism.
You're a scientific conservative.
Not politically.
No, not political conservative.
No doubt a social liberal.
We haven't discussed that, but scientific conservatism.
Basically, what the authorities say,
what's published in Nature and Science,
what gets funded by the National Science Foundation,
that's science.
And that's really part of the paradigm
or sociological aspect that Ganesh talked about.
What Thomas Kuhn showed in his famous book
on the structure of scientific revolutions
is it's not just about evidence and reason and logic.
It's to do with what is collectively,
a collective belief system at a given time.
And if you have really good evidence
that doesn't fit into that system,
it'll be ignored or treated as anomaly or marginalized.
And then a scientific revolution occurs
which incorporates these anomalies.
Like in the early 20th century,
when the idea of continental drift was first put forward,
because if you look at the globe,
the continents fit together
and they might have drifted apart.
When Wegener produced that idea,
it was ridiculed for decades until a mechanism was found.
And then it's now it's the standard view, plate tectonics.
There have been many cases in the 18th century
when people found hot stones falling from the skies.
They were denounced by the scientific authorities
as being credulous peasants
because there couldn't be stones falling from the sky
because there are no stones in the sky.
We now know they're meteorites and so on.
So it depends really on a larger consensus change.
And I think we are actually on the threshold of a change,
a larger change which would,
and part of it would be a change that includes consciousness
as part of our model of reality
instead of marginalizing it
as to an epiphenomenon of the brain.
And when that happens,
I think we'll have a much broader view.
It will lead to knock-on effects in areas like medicine
where at present official medicine and mechanistic medicine,
physics and chemistry, surgery and drugs,
there are many alternative therapies.
And if we have a broader, more holistic worldview,
then I think, I'm not suggesting
we accept every claim of every therapy,
but we could have, as there already is it
to some degree in the United States,
comparative effectiveness research, finding out what works.
And it may be some of these therapies work as well
or better than traditional mechanistic medicine.
And then skeptics will say,
well, it's just the placebo effect.
But then say, well, okay, that's really interesting.
The placebo effect is itself a healing modality.
And if one treatment can unleash more placebo effect
than another, it may work better.
So we can open up a whole new way of thinking
instead of just closing down.
Here in Britain, the Medical Research Council,
as far as I know, funds no research
on alternative or complementary medicine.
Its focus is more on mechanistic medicine.
And so I think this worldview which would,
I think it'll also be propelled by political factors
because mechanistic materialism,
which treats the whole earth as devoid, inanimate, et cetera,
underlies the exploitative model we have of nature.
It's led to the great imbalance
between humanity and nature.
That itself, the political, the climate crisis
will, I think, force a change in the way we think.
I think we're on the threshold
of a major shift in consciousness
in which the kinds of anomalies I've been talking about
that don't fit into the mechanistic picture
will become part of a new world model.
Now, I'm someone rooting for that.
Michael's on the other side saying,
let's keep, it works well enough as it is.
Let's keep things as they are, business as usual.
Well, that's a bit unfair, surely.
I'm putting words into your mouth, Michael.
This is what's called the survivorship bias.
It is, he just gave examples
where the scientists turn out to be wrong
and the alternative theorists turn out to be right.
Play tectonics with continental drift
and meteorites and so on.
But what about the 10,000 alternative theories
that turn out not to be right?
Where are those people?
No one writes biographies of them.
All the alternative people think they're Galileo
going up against the church.
But most of the people in the past several centuries
that had these alternative theories, they were wrong.
And that's why we never hear about them.
Well, as is always the case in these situations,
we really don't have enough time.
Please, can you put your hands together
in thanks to our wonderful speakers.
Thank you.
