Seit August 2020 ist das gigantische Gemälde der Einzug Karl V. in Antwerpen von Hans Makart in der Hamburger Kunsthalle erneut zu sehen. Doch nicht nur die Größe macht dieses Bild zu einem Gesprächsthema, sondern auch die darauf abgebildeten Frauen. Sowohl in seiner Zeit als auch heute, schaffte es Hans Makart mit seiner Inszenierung Diskussionen hervorzubringen. ---------- Ein Beitrag von Beyzanur Dönmez Kamera: Beyzanur Dönmez, Emily Dakers Sprecher:in: Beyzanur Dönmez Redaktion: Robin Schmidt
Frauen in der Kunst Wie werden Frauen in der Kunstszene wahrgenommen? Mikiko Feldmeier zeigt den Weg, der sie hoffentlich zum Erfolg als Künstlerin bringt. https://youtu.be/YFDlg4pXYMw
The Entry of Charles V. at Antwerp, a work of art on a 50 sq.m. canvas.
Hans Mackert provides a lot of subject matter with this depiction,
because it is unusual in several ways.
The event itself didn't have such a big meaning,
because he was on a journey to his coronation,
which was supposed to take place in Aachen.
And it's amazing, you can really ask yourself,
why is Mackert focusing on this event
and not focusing on Aachen,
where you could really stage and exaggerate the whole thing.
But what was important for him was Albrecht Dürer,
who was sort of the witness,
whom he also puts into the picture,
whom he puts into the picture without any misunderstanding,
with his long curls.
Of course, he was immediately recognizable to everyone at the time.
Albrecht Dürer was on site in 1520
and documented the Entry in his diary.
This source was an inspiration for Austrian Mackert.
But in the tradition of historical painting,
a simple depiction of the Entry is not enough
to attract the audience.
That's why he depicts a lot more pompously than it actually was.
He gives the visitors the impression
that they are equally part of something significant,
something significant historically.
And then come all his other strategies,
how he managed to turn this picture into a scandal picture.
The faces of the depicted women play an important role here.
They are not freely invented,
but deliberately chosen by Mackert.
They are ladies of the Viennese society,
who he partially positioned undressed in the painting.
He also tried to present his staged art as a historical fact.
After all, Dürer personally reported about so-called Ehrenjungfrauen.
But in truth, one knew that this couldn't be the case.
Mackert planted this alleged contemporary witness with Dürer
and said, yes, but that's how it was.
I read the written sources and Dürer speaks of the Entry.
But everyone was aware that this couldn't have been the case.
And that was also the scandal.
Because one knew that Karl V was buried in Antwerp,
that was in 1520.
But these five naked women at his feet
would not have walked in with him like that.
The controversies play into Mackert's cards.
Because when the painting was presented in Vienna for the first time after its completion in 1878,
thousands came to see it.
The painting and Mackert became famous overnight.
So this is somehow a Mackert who, if you will, was an artist
who already fed the press with the right things at the time,
who also let the audience into his studio.
That was already a half-open action of him.
He did that very consciously.
He is an artist who was able to stage himself incredibly well.
Actually like a media figure of today.
Even today his painting reaches a large audience in the Hamburg Art Hall.
What caused a stir at the time now opens up a new debate.
What is of course still very current is the accusation of sexism,
which is above all in the room today.
Because here we have a ruler sitting on a horse
and naked women are depicted at his feet as pure decoration.
So this is not about the personalities themselves that we see,
but we see women whose bodies serve as a decoration of a rule.
And that is of course a problem.
We don't really want to see that.
And we don't want to have anchored that in our society.
That is why the Art Hall is trying with the exhibition
to uncover the marketing strategies of Makart,
at the same time to convey the contents of the work
and to encourage the discourse of sexism.
Visitors should deal specifically with the topics.
The questions should encourage exchange.
Also on social media and in the guest book
is discussed under the hashtag MakartNow.
I hope of course that the work can be shown here for a very long time
with the message concept that many people come
and are not frightened by the sheer size and the topic,
but that one manages to deal with it,
that one can perhaps also re-sharpen one's own values and moral ideas
in comparison with this historical ham.
That is of course a wish that we have.
From the scandal in the Austrian nobility
to the sexism debate in Hamburg.
Makart's work of art will probably also arouse attention in the future,
not just because of its size.