#kunstgeschichte#hamburg Das Videoprojekt "Kunstgeschichten" beruht auf dem Gedanken, Kunstwerke ausgewählter Künstler und Künstlerinnen und aus verschiedenen Epochen von Expertinnen und Experten der Kunstgeschichte vorstellen und erläutern zu lassen. Die leitenden Fragen beziehen sich dabei auf das Objekt, die Entstehungsgeschichte, das Material, das Kunstverständnis und die Rezeption. Abschließend folgt eine persönliche Ein- und Wertschätzung des ausgewählten Kunstwerks.
Konzipiert und verwirklicht wurde das Videoprojekt "Kunstgeschichten" gemeinsam von der L.I.S.A.Redaktion und dem Kunsthistoriker und Videoproduzenten Timur Alexander El Rafie. Unser Dank gilt den Expertinnen und Experten vor der Kamera, den beteiligten Museen für die Erlaubnis in ihren Häusern drehen zu dürfen sowie der VG Bildkunst für Ihre Unterstützung.
My name is Alexander Klar, I am currently the director of the Hamburger Kunsthalle.
I am an art historian, born in 1968, maybe you can see it programmatically this year.
I am a specialist for the 19th century and probably that's why I ended up in front of this painting.
The painting is called The Entry of Charles V in Antwerp, painted by Hans Mackart.
We see a wide-screen cinema scope format, a moment in the entry of an emperor.
We know in Antwerp by title and by title that the emperor is Charles V.
Antwerp is its almost birthplace, he was born in Ghent, so he comes home.
We also know that it took place in September 1520.
I think I can remember the 23rd and a month later he is to be crowned in Aachen, that will still play a role.
We know from the fact itself about a protagonist of the painting, Albrecht Dürer.
The painting depicts a crowded crowd of people, leading from the light, starting at the top left,
driving down to the middle and how such a big W sets the lighting.
In it, there are crowds of 50 people, walking, standing, cheering, shouting, populating the picture.
The emperor, Charles V, is prominent, of whom there were many portraits,
which can also be seen on the lower lip, which is slightly hanging forward,
which Habsburgs describe or describe.
Hans Mackart took contemporary portraits, but he designed the young emperor a little more lively.
He really looks almost like a photojournalist in front of us,
and also in this casual and slightly blazed gesture on the horse.
You can see in ways on a person dressed in Titian red, smiling a little dirty.
Contemporaries claimed, and the similarity is not entirely denied,
to see the painter Mackart himself, who often appeared like this.
The similarity is almost closer in the costume than in the physiognomy.
He wore a beard, but there is no photo of him so dirty.
And another person that you can find quickly is Albrecht Dürer.
You can see him a little further away from Mackart, and he looks slightly grim.
The Dürer, whose role model Mackart took from the self-portrait with fur,
which is now in the Penacotheque, and he applied a little fringe.
From the full frontal image he made a three-quarter portrait,
and Dürer looks in the direction of the emperor and the painter, and he does not look satisfied.
This may be due to the fact that the emperor obviously lifts out Mackart with his gesture
and forgets Dürer about it.
Mackart himself studied in Munich,
that is, the tradition on which he is called is a Munich painting school,
which was born perhaps one generation, two generations before him,
under Ludwig I, who actually wanted to plant Italy after Germany
and with Italy also the Italian way of life and Italian history.
And this use of history to control images,
that's what Mackart learned.
Contemporaries like Piloti, who actually paint historical events
and claim they were like that.
This comes from the Munich painting school,
which says that history is our source for good paintings.
And that's what shaped him.
And historically, of course, he is characterized by the very big names
Titian, Veronese, Velázquez, Dürer, which he also refers to in painting.
The edition is a small note in the diary of Albrecht Dürer,
who was present there, after which he was present at the entrance,
saw a lot of young women there and built delicious buildings.
And in the end, these two numbers are the outcome of this picture,
nothing else.
Because the history of this picture is, as I said, relatively simple.
There is nothing world-historical happening.
In fact, it has been historically proven
that Burgundian entrances worked with naked tableaux vivants.
However, these tableaux vivants were settled on stages
and did not jump around in front of the horses.
That means you have to imagine it as a very free-spirited theater.
According to Huizinga, painting avoids the naked at this time.
Reality is looking for the naked.
That is, it was completely normal to put naked figures in public,
I don't know, Adam and Eve, the judgment of Paris,
on stages during entrances.
Here, of course, it is very speculative.
The naked figures were put in front of the horses
and now run in front of the entrance,
which is of course much more sexist, you could say.
Perhaps it was said more erotically at the time
than in these stage situations.
And that is, of course, a vehement difference,
which Macker is very aware of.
The painting is oil on canvas.
The dimensions are 5.20 by 9.56 meters,
so approximately 50 square meters.
The frame is, interestingly, a new ingredient from the 20th century,
when the picture was taken under Werner Hofmann.
According to my information,
it was the stage designers of the State Theater
who made the frame.
Because the frame was rarely used for travel.
It was then made on site and it was flown in the same way in the 20th century.
The canvas itself is probably several canvases,
although it is not so easy to find the seam.
Restorers find that.
In view of the size, of course,
a piece of canvas for such a picture
would have been almost impossible.
The color spectrum of this picture
is generally in brown, reddish-yellow.
Of course, this has very strong associations
with Venetian painting,
to which Maccart referred heavily.
Paolo Veronese, Tizian.
He himself is represented in this Tizian red.
So it plays a very strong role
in the big, lush, permanent painting of Venice.
However, as a 19th century gem,
it introduces a certain polystylistics,
insofar as it picks up various things,
such as the Dürer portrait,
but also in the upper area a quote from a Manet figure,
this laundress who is leaning there.
So he also proves
that he can choose from all styles.
And he leaves that in the perniture,
in the color choice.
Yes, that's quite fascinating.
The light of this picture is of course very strongly directed.
It starts at the top left
and leads in a long beam
to the first group of the two naked virgins.
Then it jumps back to the emperor,
who is illuminated by several lights
And it goes down again
and then up through the other group,
so that you have a kind of W-situation of the light.
Whether the light now comes from the left
and once from the right,
or whether it is actually a train from the left,
you don't like to say.
And that helps, of course,
with the movement representation of this picture.
This makes the whole thing so incredibly movable,
because the light focuses on certain places
and then leaves others lying in the dark.
I think the essential aspect
of Hans Makart's art understanding
is the virtuosity,
the absolute ability
to be able to do pretty much anything.
In contrast, there is the upcoming
avant-garde movement of the impressionists
who are looking for the truth,
the truth of the light, of the picture.
His truth is the ability to be able to do everything.
And Makart is also one
who continues
to try to make illusions.
This picture is as if we are
entering a historical picture,
as if we are making a time travel.
This illusion of a time travel,
I think that is his great ethos,
until the moves are brought to Vienna
and then people from the 16th century
walk through Vienna.
So the illusion of time travel,
the illusion of being able to think
into other eras,
to the detriment of the truth,
we would say today,
because that was, of course,
what he could research,
he did, but he did not manage
to revive the year 1520.
This is pure Makart fantasy here.
Hans Makart is one of the few artists
after whom a whole era was named.
The Makart period,
that is the climax and the catharsis,
the overcoming at the end of the salon painting.
Makart comes
to Vienna at the end of the 15th century
and is the figure
that not only makes great painting in Vienna,
but also leads a very royal atelier.
Also the painter-prince
as a kind of, how shall we say,
symbol of the era.
He actually also reasons
the reference of the imperial court
to painting, purchases through the imperial house,
all that. He gets a state-financed
atelier at the end of the 15th century,
that's why he comes to Vienna.
So he reasons the Makart period,
which culminates, above all,
in the staging of spectacular festivals.
So he had a kind of
unique feature with the festivals,
historical, historical festivals.
The whole thing was also, I guess,
described by critics as a carnival.
And his painting was actually
driven by great ability to quote,
i.e. the absolute knowledge
of epochal strengths.
He was able to copy everything
from Velázquez to Titian to Dürer
and reproduce it in a lively way.
That means incredible virtuosity
comes across
a great joy of life,
let's put it positively,
an ebullient, overwhelming
desire to stage.
Which may also be the reason
why this painting is here.
Because when you come in,
you see with one stroke
what painting is capable of,
in the fantastic as well as in the abstract.
And that's probably what
Hans Makart and his time stand for.
The contemporaries
let themselves be controlled a little
by Makart, you have to say.
So he mastered the contemporary reception
of this painting very virtuously,
by launching it
at the first presentation of this painting
in the Künstlerhaus in Vienna.
On the one hand, he painted it very quickly,
supposedly in two months.
We know such a period of creation
from 1875 in individual sketches.
Maybe he painted quickly, but in two months
it is difficult to depict.
He also supposedly painted it alone.
At least the horses know
he painted a student.
And he also launched in the wild
known personalities,
in brackets, the naked women from Vienna.
Driven by this, plus of course
this virtuoso painting itself,
I think 3,000 people came to Vienna
That means he also controls
the reception incredibly skillfully.
And exactly what you can imagine happened.
On the one hand, it was a scandal.
The criticism was especially ignited
about Catholic or Protestant accusations
that naked women were shown here.
What is of course also interesting
from the contemporary point of view,
when you realize, yes, it is actually so.
There are five very speculatively
painted naked young women
who have to look for the painting there.
At that time it was from
Christian orthodox,
I would almost say,
rejection was regularly fought.
It was also tried again and again
to ban the exhibition of the picture.
He controlled all of this very skillfully,
because he knew with so much scandal
the picture would come so far.
The picture also offered a lot,
that is, everyone was well served,
they came and this picture was
then also sent on tour,
so that other capitals
could stand in line in a similar way.
So the reception,
Maghaz in general,
ends abruptly with his death.
This is actually a very mature art.
In his lifetime he is a legend.
With his death, a memorial album
will be released again and then
it also ends.
There is a local reception in Vienna,
which is in progress,
the pictures were not immediately
hung up. In Hamburg,
the picture hung up in 1881
and the first real director
of the house,
before that the commission was always active,
Alfred Lichtwacht,
hung it up in the second half
of his office time in 1907
and rolled it into the depot.
That means so much for the reception.
Then it was stored in the depot
for decades and the first
who took it out in Hamburg,
and that is now the interesting
middle of the reception,
that is Werner Hofmann,
on the one hand the director
who made himself famous
through great historical exhibitions
around the early 19th century.
So he was very busy
with art around 1800.
That means that didn't fit
into his budget scheme.
However, as a Viennese,
he was able to start something
with Maghaz.
And under Werner Hofmann
this picture was hung up again.
At that time the frame was added
and shown here again.
And there is also a very nice movie
where you can see people discussing
about the picture and what is mentioned again?
The five naked honourable young women.
So we are not alone with our criticism
and we have not invented anything new.
It goes through the decades
of the history of this picture
that this picture of course
plays one in the foreground,
five naked young women
outside the context there.
I chose this work
because on the one hand
I studied as an art historian
at a time when this was still
completely unspeakable.
I had a professor for contemporary art
who once referred us to salon painting
and said, look at this.
It is very unspeakable
but it is very interesting
and she was completely unsuspecting
of any male fantasies.
She said, look at this.
After that, among other things,
I was inspired by Maghaz.
I thought, this is really interesting.
At that time, he was again
in the Kunsthalle.
This was set up here in 1981
but that was against all time.
And then I got into salon painting
as someone who also finds history interesting.
And then you are very quickly
with all the contradictions of this time.
So that means the whole double morality
of these pictures, they are colonialist,
they are sexist, they are militaristic
and now I come from a family of pacifists.
My mother is a feminist.
All that didn't fit in.
You were never a colonist.
That means the interest for the ambiguity
of this picture was there for me from the beginning.
And when I came,
the picture was not shown.
It was stored behind a wall
and I really wanted to bring it forward
with all the problems that this picture poses.
Among other things, the inherent sexism
of these five men and women.
Because I have the feeling
that you have to show this today
for two reasons.
To show how far the way has been
since 1881.
How far you have come
and what actually remains.
And the interesting thing is of course
the reaction of today's audience
to this picture,
which of course does not run away
and does not take the role models
of this picture as exemplary,
but sees the picture as a painting
and the expression of a time.
And that is the fascinating thing
about such pictures for me.
Because they stay.
Our ideas may change.
And then we realize that our ideas
are not so new.
Because already in 1881 there were people
who said, what do these five women
do in a picture of history?
And this break fascinates me
and makes this picture
an ideal entry-level discussion picture
of Hamburg art.