A Rainha Que Sumiu Sem Deixar Rastros!

Archaeology Chronicles
17 followers
She is one of the most enigmatic figures of Antiquity.
Some celebrate her as a pioneer ahead of her time.
Others see her as someone who broke with the dogmas of her own belief.
Today, many scholars recognize her not only as a queen,
but as a pharaoh of full right.
Married to a radical religious leader and stepmother
of one of the most famous rulers of Egypt,
Nefertiti continues to intrigue generations.
For more than a century and a half,
archaeologists and Egyptologists have searched for material clues
and old records that try to reconstruct her trajectory.
But the truth about this legendary woman remains shrouded in mystery.
Unlike other rulers of the New Empire,
such as Seti I and Ramses II,
whose bodies were skillfully preserved and studied,
Nefertiti's mummy was never found.
Or at least, it was never identified for sure.
Her absence raises speculations for decades.
Several theories try to explain what would have happened to her,
feeding from scientific hypotheses
to the most fanciful conspiracies that circulate on the internet.
After all, what do we really know?
And what can still be just an assumption?
In an attempt to unravel this millennial riddle,
filmmaker and Egyptologist Curtis Ryan Woodside
joined forces with some of the greatest experts on the subject.
Together, they investigate whether Nefertiti's body
had already been discovered without our knowledge,
or whether he even resisted the wear and tear
of more than 3,500 years of history.
One of the goals of this work is precisely to provoke a reflection.
Could the true Nefertiti finally be recognized?
Next, among the most promising clues,
is a mummy that has been pointed out as a strong candidate
to be the legendary queen.
This body was found in a tomb in the 18th dynasty,
in the Valley of the Kings, known as KV35.
Curiously, the mummy did not originally occupy that tomb.
It was relocated there, possibly to protect it from looters.
It was accompanied by two other figures,
an older woman and a young man.
With the help of DNA tests and relic analysis,
researchers identified the older woman as Queen Ti,
Tutankhamen's grandmother and mother of Akhenaten,
Nefertiti's husband.
The decisive evidence came from the comparison
between a strand of hair found in Tutankhamen's tomb
and the mummy's mortal remains,
whose genetic analysis confirmed the kinship.
The identification of Ti, a central figure in the royal lineage,
led many scholars to suspect that the other two mummies
discovered in KV35 would also be members of the same family.
The younger woman, nicknamed Young Lady,
soon became the center of attention.
Many wondered, could she be Nefertiti?
The idea makes sense,
especially if we consider a possible re-burial
of real figures of the same family in times of crisis.
However, DNA tests indicated that this woman
would actually be Tutankhamen's mother,
which creates a conflict,
since according to the known records,
neither Nefertiti nor another wife of Akhenaten,
named Kia, would be real sisters,
a necessary condition for a fraternal marriage
to be recognized as such in the Egyptian tradition.
Professor Aydan Dodson, from the University of Bristol,
is one of the authorities who studied this Young Lady the most.
In his book published in 2020,
he presents complex arguments about the possible identity of the mummy.
One of the central points of the debate is the genetic lineage.
The data suggest that Tutankhamen's mother
was the result of a union between brothers,
which, in turn, would imply that she herself
would also have this type of ancestry.
Some theories seek to fit Nefertiti
in this genealogical tree
by means of first-degree ties
or blood-related marriages between cousins,
something that was not uncommon in Egyptian royalty at the time.
For the Young Lady to be, in fact, Nefertiti,
it would be necessary to prove that she descends
directly from a sister of Pharaoh Amenophis III,
which has not yet been documented.
However, Ancient Egypt is far from offering us complete records,
and gaps still leave room for plausible interpretations.
In addition, it is important to remember that
artistic representations of the time
rarely showed sons-men alongside kings,
which makes the argument of Tutankhamen's absence
among Nefertiti's daughters
in the less conclusive murals of what seems to be the first sight.
Estimating the age of the mummy is also a challenge,
since the aging of ancient bodies is not always exact.
Still, specialists believe that
this woman would be between 25 and 35 years old when she died,
an age range compatible with Nefertiti,
who would have married in adolescence
and lived for about two decades in power,
including the years in Minnesota,
which ruled as Pharaoh after the death of Akhenaten.
A disturbing detail is the condition of the body.
Deep facial injuries suggest a violent death,
probably caused by looters
who raided the tomb in search of treasures.
Fragments located in the breasts of the face,
during a tomography,
indicate that the wounds may have been inflicted
while the victim was still alive,
which points to a possible tragic death,
marked by extreme pain and rapid blood loss.
If this woman was Nefertiti,
or even just Tutankhamen's mother,
the end of her life was all the less peaceful.
Although there is no definitive evidence
that allows us to declare the identity of this mummy,
the accumulated evidence is intriguing
and suggests that she may very well be Nefertiti.
Even so, the mystery remains.
Without a categorical confirmation,
all we have are loose pieces of an ancient puzzle.
With scholars divided as to the identity of the young lady,
the search continues.
Several other mummies were considered over the years,
but many of them were ruled out
for belonging to wrong dynasties
or for not presenting characteristics
that indicate noble origin.
At the moment, there are only two unidentified female mummies
found in an unfinished tomb in Vale dos Reis,
known as KV-21.
These two mysterious women
have been forgotten by specialists for years,
but have recently returned to the attention of the scientific community.
The egyptologist Sophia Aziz, among other researchers,
has investigated these little-studied bodies in more depth.
Who knows if one of these anonymous women
is, after all, the legendary Nefertiti.
A team of specialists has been working
on the mysterious KV-21 tomb,
and the results of this investigation have drawn a lot of attention.
The mummies found there
went through extremely adverse conditions,
which makes the simple fact that they still exist surprising.
The story of this tomb begins in 1817,
when it was located by a remarkable character in archaeology,
Giovanni Belzoni.
This Italian of imposing stature and cunning intelligence
was a true adventurer.
Before embarking on the exploration of Egyptian treasures,
he even considered monastic life
and showed great interest in hydraulics.
However, his destiny led him to Egypt,
where he found his true vocation
breaking down temples and tombs,
facing rivals,
escaping from dangerous situations
and contributing significantly
to the birth of modern Egyptology.
When Belzoni found the KV-21,
the place was still in a reasonable state,
and the two mummified bodies resting there
were well preserved.
He even recorded that the mummies' hair was long
and was surprisingly intact.
However, the scenario changed drastically
when the tomb was reopened in 1989.
This time, the researchers came across
a completely different environment.
The interior of the tomb had been flooded for a long time,
and as a result, the bodies were submerged
for an indefinite period of time.
In addition,
the hair that had been praised by Belzoni
had disappeared,
possibly taken by visitors as a souvenir.
It is almost unbelievable that the bodies were still there.
The fact that the tomb is simple,
without inscriptions or decorations,
may have contributed to it becoming unnoticed
by looters more interested in valuable artifacts,
now classified as Mummies 21A and 21B.
These figures underwent modern tests,
including computerized tomographies
that revealed impressive details.
The younger Mummy 21A
had post-mortem fractures
and several missing limbs,
in addition to having lost its head.
The 21B, which appeared to be around 40 years old,
was more preserved.
It kept its head,
although the right eye and nose were absent.
Apparently,
its brain was not removed by the common nasal method
in the mummification process,
and its heart was also not present.
However,
a sign of real mummification.
The presence of osteoarthritis
reinforces the idea that it was a middle-aged woman.
The age differences between the two
suggest a possible family bond.
Many scholars believe
that the two could be mother and daughter,
a hypothesis reinforced
by the position of the folded arms and closed fists,
typical of real mummification,
which also suggests a high status,
possibly of royalty.
Between 2007 and 2009,
a molecular genetics study
was conducted with several bodies
from the New Empire period,
including Tutankhamun's mummy,
the two fetuses found in its tomb,
and the mummies 21A and 21B.
The technique used was that of genetic printing,
based on the analysis of short repetitions
in non-coding regions of DNA,
called microsatellites.
These repetitions vary from person to person,
and are widely used in family tests,
criminal investigations,
and the identification of mortal remains.
However,
extracting ancient DNA is extremely challenging.
Over the centuries,
genetic material has undergone severe degradation,
both by natural processes in the body
and by the burial environment.
Physical and microbiological chemical factors
directly interfere with the conservation of DNA.
In the case of the KV21,
the scenario of prolonged lag
and the repeated manipulation of the bodies
made preservation even more difficult.
Despite these difficulties,
the team took rigorous precautions
to minimize modern contaminations.
They extracted DNA from the internal parts of the bones
and also sequenced the researchers' own DNA
to avoid false positives.
Even so,
the recovered data was limited,
reinforcing the suspicion
that the genetic material was severely deteriorated.
The mitochondrial results
extracted from the DNA transmitted by the mother
were later published,
but were also inconclusive.
The next step would be to use
new generation sequencing,
a much more sensitive technique
and suitable for degraded samples.
However,
even with scarce genetic data,
archaeologists turned their eyes
to the context of the burial.
The fact that the two women were together
in a simple and anonymous tomb
with real mummification evidence
raised bold hypotheses.
The 21B mummy,
with its advanced age
and signs of degenerative diseases,
could be none other than Nefertiti,
one of the most enigmatic and powerful figures
of ancient Egypt.
The 21A, young,
with genetic similarities to Tutankhamun's fetuses,
could be her sister,
wife and mother of her children,
Queen Ankhesenamon.
This theory creates an impressive genealogical line.
If 21A is really Ankhesenamon
and her mother is 21B,
then we have in front of us
the bodies of mother and daughter
belonging to the real Amarnian lineage.
This would explain the absence
of a genetic profile of Nefertiti to this day.
She would be there,
but still not identified definitively.
Nefertiti would possibly have been
the daughter of a character called Ai,
who was titled
God's Father,
suggesting that her daughter married a pharaoh,
a sign that he would be
the father of a queen, probably Nefertiti.
The connection between Ai and other important figures,
such as Queen Ti and the Councilors of the Throne,
makes this theory even more intriguing.
But the clues don't stop there.
When we observe the skull and facial features
of the 21B mummy,
even more clues emerge.
Despite being damaged,
especially on the face,
it is possible to identify a long neck,
a well-defined jaw
and even traces of eyeliner,
features associated with the famous bust of Nefertiti.
An artist who did a digital facial reconstruction
used mirroring techniques
to simulate the damaged side of the face,
and the result revealed impressive similarities
with the well-known representations of the queen.
The lines of the face,
the contours of the eyes,
the structure of the nose and the lines of the mouth
align surprisingly
with the iconography of Nefertiti.
Although it is not possible to say with 100% certainty,
the KVV-21B
is still, so far,
the strongest candidate to be the legendary queen.
And perhaps we are facing
one of the greatest discoveries of modern archaeology.
Buried for centuries,
ignored for decades,
and now, slowly,
resurfacing from oblivion
with the help of science, art
and a generous dose of mystery.
This dilemma puts us in front of an intriguing impasse.
Many specialists in Egyptology
remain suspicious of the results of the mummy's DNA,
known as KV-21A and KV-21B.
There are those who firmly believe
that the true mummy of Queen Nefertiti
has not yet been found,
and that it may be waiting to be discovered
in a place that has not yet been excavated.
The academic community, therefore,
continues to seek more conclusive answers.
But we need to keep in mind
an essential point.
The visual representations of ancient Egypt
did not follow the Western concept of realistic portraiture.
The images of the queen we know today
are stylized and idealized,
not being faithful reproductions of her appearance.
In the Brooklyn Museum, for example,
there is a sculpted torso of a female figure
where the cartridges, inscriptions that identified
pharaohs and members of royalty,
were purposely destroyed.
This reveals a deliberate attempt by the Egyptians
to completely erase the memory
of certain historical periods,
such as the reign of Akhenaten, husband of Nefertiti.
Therefore, it is essential that Egyptologists
align themselves with professionals from other areas,
such as doctors, legists, geneticists,
and specialists in genealogy,
so that together they can reconstruct,
based on scientific evidence,
the fragments of this lost chapter in Egyptian history.
Currently, two mummified bodies
are considered the most likely candidates
to represent the mortal remains of Nefertiti.
The first is known as Younger Lady,
located in the KV35 tomb.
The second is the mummy identified as KV21B.
This generated a real battle of theories among scholars,
a dispute between two currents that try to prove
which of these mummies would be the real queen of Egypt.
As it is known that Nefertiti did not have a twin sister,
only one of these identifications can be correct,
and the other inevitably needs to be ruled out.
To come to a conclusion,
it is necessary to understand the arguments on both sides.
In 2019, genetic tests carried out on the KV35 mummy
revealed DNA markers that align it convincingly
with the royal family of the 18th dynasty,
which strengthens the hypothesis
that this Younger Lady may in fact be Nefertiti.
On the other hand,
the KV21B also underwent genetic tests,
but both in 2016 and 2021,
the results presented significant gaps.
The amount of data recovered was less
and many crucial information was absent.
Faced with the fragility of the genetic data of the KV21B,
the defenders of this hypothesis looked for another way.
They used computerized tomography
and comparative skull analysis.
The idea was to find similarities between the mummy's skull
and representative images of the queen.
However, this type of comparison is questionable from an academic point of view.
The images used show figures in different phases of life,
a young and an older one,
which makes it extremely unlikely that it is the same person.
It is illogical to imagine that a single mummy
can reflect two different stages of a woman's life.
These conclusions, based only on visual comparisons,
are subject to many criticisms.
Modern science, with its advances in genetics and forensic medicine,
offers much more precise and reliable tools
for this type of identification.
Therefore, the decision as to who really was Nefertiti
must be based on the weight of scientific evidence
and not on visual assumptions or artistic coincidences.
In parallel to this, other researchers raise an even deeper question.
Are we focusing too much on finding the queen's mummy,
while we should focus on understanding who she really was?
Professor Acara, an experienced researcher,
proposes a more reflective view.
For her, the obsession with finding mortal remains
can divert us from what really matters,
Nefertiti's historical and political legacy.
After all, discovering a mummy does not guarantee
that we will learn everything about her life.
There is a notable example.
When the pharaoh's mummy, Hatshepsut, was discovered,
there was a media frenzy
that ended up eclipsing her achievements as a ruler.
Instead of valuing her career as one of Egypt's most powerful women,
the focus shifted to her mummified body.
This phenomenon, according to Acara,
reveals how the fascination for the physical
can overshadow the intellectual and historical value
of such important figures.
The researcher also highlights
that unless a mummy bears a clear identification,
such as a name written on an amulet or bandages,
it is almost impossible to say for sure who it belongs to.
In Nefertiti's case, there is no definitive mark,
and this perpetuates the mystery.
Even DNA tests have limitations,
especially because Nefertiti
may not be directly linked by blood
to Tutankhamun's lineage,
which makes comparisons even more difficult.
In addition, she raises an interesting question,
and if the woman found with DNA similar to Tutankhamun's
is not Nefertiti,
but one of her sisters or unknown relatives,
by forcing an identity to a mummy,
we run the risk of making a historical mistake,
distorting the facts to fit them into a desired narrative.
It is not like the cases of the mummies of Sept I or Ramses II,
whose names were clearly identified.
Here we are dealing with possibilities,
and not with certainties.
Another important point of this discussion
comes from the theories of the Egyptologist Nicholas Rives.
He proposes that Nefertiti's tomb has not yet been found,
and may be hidden in a secret chamber
inside Tutankhamun's own tomb.
This would explain the disappearance of artifacts
related to Smenkare, a mysterious figure
who may also have been Nefertiti,
if she reigned under that name.
Rives believes that there are still unexplored sealed doors
in Tutankhamun's tomb,
and that these hidden passages
could lead to an unknown funeral chamber.
This theory reignites the debate,
and if we are in fact on the brink of
one of the greatest discoveries of modern Egyptology,
and if Nefertiti is hidden under our feet
in a tomb inside another tomb,
this possibility, although controversial,
continues to feed the hope and curiosity
of many researchers around the world.
Finally, what all this reveals
is that more than discovering a mummy,
perhaps the real enigma
is in what the ancient Egyptians chose to remember,
and in what they deliberately decided to forget
about powerful female figures like Nefertiti.
Understanding these choices
can be as revealing as finding
the queen's own mortal remains.
And this is where we come across an intriguing impasse.
Many Egyptologists remain skeptical
of DNA tests carried out in mummies
known as KV21A and KV21B.
While some scholars believe
that one of them may be the legendary Queen Nefertiti,
others still go through Egypt
in search of more convincing evidence.
The reality is that, to this day,
Nefertiti's true identity remains a mystery,
and, as a famous presenter would say,
may the true Queen Nefertiti please rise.
But there is an important detail that we cannot ignore.
The ancient Egyptians did not have
the concept of a faithful portrait as we know it in the West.
The artistic representations of that time
were idealized and symbolic,
not realistic records of someone's face.
The famous torso attributed to Nefertiti
today in the Brooklyn Museum
had its cartridges,
inscriptions with the real name,
deliberately erased.
This happened because the Egyptians,
at certain times,
tried to erase any memory
linked to the Amarnian period
associated with the pharaoh Erege Akhenaten.
For this reason,
reconstructing this chapter erased from history
requires Egyptian multidisciplinary collaboration.
Egyptologists have sought the help of doctors,
specialists in genealogy,
and forensic scientists
to gather clues that help
unravel Nefertiti's whereabouts.
A true example of how science
can be put at the service of humanity.
Currently, there are two mummies
at the center of this controversy.
The first is the so-called Young Lady
from the KV35 tomb,
and the second is the KV21B.
And as in every good archaeological mystery,
we have here a real clash of titans.
One of the main evidences in favor of KV35
is that genetic tests carried out in 2019
revealed consistent markers
with the royal lineage of 18 dynasties,
suggesting that it would be directly related to Tutankhamun.
The KV21B was analyzed in 2016,
and again in 2021,
but the DNA data obtained
were more scarce and inconclusive,
with significant gaps
that make any solid statement difficult.
Faced with the fragility of genetic evidence,
KV21B defenders
began to use computerized tomographies as an argument.
The idea was to show similarities
between the mummy's skull
and known artistic representations of Nefertiti.
However, this approach was harshly criticized
for being academically questionable,
as they compared images
of different phases of a person's life,
which compromises any serious attempt
at facial superposition.
After all,
a mummy cannot look young and old at the same time.
In the end,
it is up to each one to decide
which theory seems more convincing.
Do you prefer to rely on DNA scientific evidence
or on visual reconstruction attempts?
The Egyptologist interviewed in this documentary
raises a striking point.
Even if one day we found Nefertiti's mummy,
what would that really tell us about who she was?
And if, eager to discover her identity,
we were only projecting hypotheses about bodies
that may never have belonged to her?
She remembers that not always
finding a mummy solves the riddle.
In the case of Queen Hatshepsut, for example,
her identification generated such a great uproar
that it ended up overshadowing her political trajectory,
her achievements,
and the legacy she left as a pharaoh.
Are we repeating the same mistake with Nefertiti?
Unless a mummy is accompanied
by a definitive inscription,
a label,
a cartridge,
something that identifies her in an unequivocal way.
The truth is that we will never know for sure
who she belongs to.
This is the limit of archaeological research.
Without a concrete clue,
everything becomes an assumption.
And in the case of Nefertiti,
as well pointed out,
it may be one of those questions
without a definitive answer.
Even more intriguing is the hypothesis raised
by Nicholas Reeves,
a respected Egyptologist,
who believes that Tutankhamun's tomb
actually hides secret chambers,
one of them perhaps containing
the mortal remains of Nefertiti.
He points to the absence of any funeral evidence
linked to Pharaoh Smen-Karé
as an indication that there is still much to be discovered
in the Valley of Kings.
Reeves suggests that Nefertiti
would have become a co-regent
under the name of Smen-Karé
and that her tomb may be hidden
behind the walls of her father-in-law's tomb,
Tutankhamun.
However, as the researcher warns,
many of these theories
are driven by academic vanity
or the desire to gain notoriety.
The desire to find the discovery of the century
can often eclipse the rigor of research
and turn archaeology into a spectacle.
But what if Nefertiti's mummy
has already been discovered and ignored?
It may be that it is forgotten
in the deposit of some museum,
without identification,
waiting for someone to recognize it.
Or worse,
it may have been sold as a curiosity in the 19th century,
when the Europeans,
especially the Victorians,
consumed mummies literally.
Yes, that's right.
For centuries,
it was believed that the mummified remains of the ancient Egyptians
had medicinal and even magical properties.
They were ground
and turned into powders used in dyes,
potions
and even in the manufacture of a pigment called brown mummy.
There were even parties to unravel mummies,
where the public watched in ecstasy
the opening of real sarcophagi,
as if it were a theatrical spectacle.
The last of these public parties
took place in 1908,
destroying in the process
countless mummies
that can never be studied or identified.
It is therefore possible
that Queen Nefertiti
was the victim of this wave of Western consumption
and that her mummy had been reduced to dust,
literally or figuratively.
But it can also be that she is still intact,
resting under the sands of Egypt
in an unrevealed tomb.
