40 The validity of treaties: jus cogens

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
May 25, 2025
Next to capacity and defect of consent, the last reason for invalidating a treaty is that its very
object is illegal because one of its obligations conflicts with a fundamental rule of international
law. Under article 53 of the Vienna Convention that I quote, a treaty is void if at the time
of its conclusion it conflicts with a parametric norm of general international law. For the purposes
of the present convention, a parametric norm of general international law is a norm accepted
and recognized by the international community of states as a whole as a norm from which no
derogation is permitted and which can be modified only by a subsequent norm of general international
law having the same character. End of quote. In the title of article 53, parametric norms of
general international law are called in Latin Euskogens norms. Let us first try to understand
the very notion of Euskogens before turning to its normative status, the ways it is formed and
finally give some concrete examples of parametric norms. As such Euskogens is opposed to
Eus dispositivum. What does that mean? Well, simply that some norms can be derogated from by
agreement between contracting parties and those norms are called Eus dispositivum, they can be
freely disposed of. While other norms cannot be set aside by mutual agreement and those norms
are parametric, they are Euskogens. This dichotomy exists in every domestic legal system.
Some legal provisions apply in the absence of any particular contract while other legal provisions
apply despite any contract and contracts that do not conform with those parametric provisions
cannot be upheld in a court of law, they are invalid. Parametric norms embody the notion of
ordre public and if the notion of Euskogens is not difficult to understand, it is nevertheless
quite troubling in a legal order based on the sovereignty of states and resulting from their
consent. And indeed Euskogens means that despite their sovereignty states are not entitled to
validly consent and make treaties about whatever they wish. Euskogens is out of the reach of states,
it is above them and they must always comply with it since they cannot escape it by concluding
treaties which would pretend to dispose of it. Any such treaty would be null and void from the start
or as stated under article 64 of the Vienna convention, it would become void in case a new
parametric norm arises after the treaty has been concluded. The conceptual novelty introduced by
Euskogens and the perceived limitation to state sovereignty it entails were not easily accepted
and for many years the issue of Euskogens has been very divisive. However international courts
and tribunals, the european and the inter-american courts of human rights, the international criminal
court, the international criminal tribunal for the former Yugoslavia and finally the international
court of justice, those courts and tribunals have gradually referred to the concept of Euskogens
so that its very notion is undoubtedly part of today's international law. But what is the nature
of Euskogens and how do Euskogens norms come to existence? Well there have been endless debates
about the nature of Euskogens. Is Euskogens part of customary international law or is it something
completely different? Does it belong to the category of general principles or to another
specific category of sources? In a case between Belgium and Senegal about the failure by Senegal
to prosecute the former head of state of Chad accused of acts of torture, the international
court of justice briefly said this and I quote, in the court's opinion the prohibition of torture
is part of customary international law and it has become a parametric norm, Euskogens, end of quote.
The court went on to refer to practice and to opinio juris. So from the ICJ's point of view
it seems undisputable that Euskogens norms are part of customary international law. They come
to existence through the usual customary process. However and because each and every rule of customary
international law is not parametric, Euskogens norms are a special category of norms within
customary international law and this is because of the specific opinio juris that is required
for their formation. Article 53 of the Vienna Convention makes this very clear by saying this
and I quote again, a parametric norm of general international law is a norm accepted and
recognized by the international community of states as a whole, as a norm from which no
degradation is permitted and which can be modified only by a subsequent norm of general international
law having the same character, end of quote. This is the specific opinio juris. This is all good and
well but which concrete norms can be set to a pertinent to Euskogens? If one takes the threshold
expressed by article 53 seriously, not many rules of customary international law can be set to be
parametric and it is of course very tempting to resort to the language of Euskogens in order to
affirm that a rule is very important but this should not be done lightly. So for the time being
Euskogens is made of only a few norms and the collection of norms is not extensive.
There is no official exhaustive list of them but from the case law the following Euskogens norms
can be gathered. The prohibition of wars of aggression, the prohibition of genocide, of crimes
against humanity and of war crimes, the prohibition of slavery, the prohibition of apartheid and
probably also of racial discrimination or ethnic cleansing, the prohibition of torture as recalled
from the Belgian Senegal case. There may be other rules pertaining to Euskogens and I do not pretend
that this short list is exhaustive but the prohibition I mentioned certainly belong to the
felt necessities of contemporary international law and it is good to take stock of the progress
they represent in the common conscience of humanity. Let me make two final remarks about Euskogens
and the first remark is as follows. The concept of Euskogens was introduced in the Vienna
Convention as a ground for contesting the validity of treaties but so far states have hopefully
refrained from concluding treaties that would be contrary to parametric norms. So invalidity of
treaties for breach of Euskogens is rather hypothetical. However this does not mean that
Euskogens is not important as a legal concept. On the contrary having parametric norms within
international law profoundly changes that legal order as it conveys the idea that certain
core values are common to mankind and must be protected by norms that cannot be transgressed.
Moreover and as we shall see later when discussing international responsibility,
serious breaches of parametric norms entail specific consequences. My second remark under
the Vienna Convention Euskogens is the only content-oriented ground for treaty invalidity.
In other words the fact that the treaty is substantially unequal, that one party takes
all the benefit from the treaty while the other bears all the cost of it, this is not a ground
for invalidating the treaty and this may sound unfair but the substantial inequality of the
respective parties obligation under the treaty is not a legal ground for considering that it is
null and void. And this of course is without prejudice to a possible defect of consent
as we have studied earlier.
