Ancient Celts vs. Romans - Some Things to Consider

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
10 Video Views·May 23, 2025
Let's talk a bit about the ancient Celts, one of those cultures in history about whom there is
plenty of misinformation and myths and debates and a lot of uncertainty as well. So first off
the usual disclaimer, I'm not a historian. I don't claim to be an expert. I'm just giving you
some information here that I've read up on myself, but I really want to encourage you to do your own
research. You should never take anybody's word at face value even if they are a historian actually
because plenty of times historians have been dead wrong especially on things like fighting
techniques and you know martial arts in general where they fall for the same myths as everybody
else really. So okay I will link the sources that I've read recently down below. I've also read some
other things. I can't remember everything but I'm going to link what I do remember in the video
description so you can check that out for yourself. Okay so the topic is mainly Celts versus Romans.
Why were the Celts defeated by the Romans? I mean it's one of those idle questions that you can
always ask. You know why was such and such defeated by the Romans? You know why were the Carthaginians
defeated by the Romans? Why were the Greeks defeated or the Etruscans or the Samnites for that
matter? I mean undoubtedly the Roman military was a very efficient fighting machine. Everything about
its funding and organization and the way it adapted to new challenges and all that made it
very effective. But oftentimes their enemies are downplayed. You know history is written by the
and Roman writers are infamous for their bias and sometimes downright slander against the cultures
they encountered. So that needs to be taken into account when reading what they wrote. In some
cases we even have our direct archaeological evidence that disproves what they said. For
example Julius Caesar claimed about the British Celts that they had no agriculture and were just
living off meat and milk. While archaeology has shown that they had quite advanced agricultural
technology. You also have to consider that we don't have extensive written sources by the Celts
themselves. Now from the later post-Roman conquest period we have more material. So like old Irish
texts for example with Celtic myths that are described which I mean most likely are based on
oral tradition reaching further back in time. But we also see some elements in those texts
you know the way that equipment is described you know the material goods they had that seems to
really match more contemporary time periods rather than earlier ancient Celts. So again that's
there's not that much directly about you know pre-conquest Celts. There isn't that much outside
of a few cases of Romanized Celts writing about their background but that of course makes everything
a lot more difficult. The other thing is Celts are much more diverse than people generally think.
We tend to think of the Celts as a homogeneous group which they really weren't. I mean we can
tell by certain material styles and certain decorations which are Celtic which are found
in different regions and of course the language connects them. But they ranged from you know
British Celts to Celt-Iberians to Galatians in Anatolia and there were some differences
in material culture and also they didn't actually see themselves as a united group which
is a very important reason but I'll get to that later. So as far as the equipment is concerned
especially in the beginning they weren't terribly different from the Romans. You know early
Republican Roman soldiers were relatively similar in equipment. In fact there is some evidence that
the Romans took the scutum from the Celts because for one there is the etymological
evidence shows that scutum is most likely of Celtic origin. Some people have tried to trace
it to Latin words but it doesn't make a whole lot of sense and the Celtic origin seems more likely.
Now there is some debate. I've seen different statements about that. I don't know for sure
if that really is true but it is a possibility. And also other elements of the equipment.
Mail armor which the Romans called lorica hamata was according to Roman writers invented by the
Celts and that is confirmed by the archaeological record because we have finds of mail armor from
the third century in Latin graves. So they apparently came up with that. Also the Roman helmet
was based on a Gallic design. Now as far as the swords are concerned I wish I had a good accurate
reproduction of a Celtic sword but they are really hard to find on the modern market. I mean there's
plenty of less accurate quote-unquote reproductions but it's really hard to find a
properly done Celtic iron sword. There is of course there's Patrick Bartha at Temple who makes them.
I'm actually on his waiting list right now for a Celtic sword but the waiting list is years long
so it's going to take a while. Regardless supposedly the Celtic swords bent very easily and had to be
straightened after striking. I think it was either Livy or Polybius who said that. I'm not
quite sure. I'll annotate that. So this is probably a case of well some were like this and some were
of better quality. Like we should never assume that all the equipment was the same way. I mean
in case of Roman soldiers you can get away with that more easily because then you can assume okay
the equipment the swords and such were mass produced so they were much more likely to be
fairly uniform and consistent. Whereas in case of Celtic swordsmiths it depended a lot on the
individual skill and resources so there may have been quite a lot of variation in quality. To give
you two examples one Peter Connolly a scholar of ancient history wrote about a 2,000 year old sword
that it could bend double and flex back to straight. And then also I read a book by Mike
Lodes who talked about a very accurate reproduction of a Celtic iron sword which he tested and he
found that it did bend after several strikes but it took definitely more than just one cut
and it was quick and easy to straighten out. I mean if I compare that to a bronze sword I did
some abusive testing with this one here and yes it did bend and twist with hard use but it was
gradual. It definitely took several swings for that to happen and it didn't deform dramatically
and that is bronze. Of course it also depends on whether they were work hardened or quenched
tempering from what I've read wasn't done until later so it does seem likely that some at least
some of the blades were rather soft. But overall the difference in equipment between Celts and
Romans isn't that dramatic. I mean the gap gets a little larger in later times you know during
Caesar's conquest of Gaul the Roman equipment was a little more advanced like the kind of armor
that they had and the swords and such so there was possibly a bit of an appreciable gap but
overall I mean they had helmets, shields, spears, swords, javelins. It's not like a dramatic
difference although to be fair male armor was rare among the Celts. It would only be chieftains and
nobles who could afford it. Anyway so then there is the idea of the whole you know uncivilized
barbarians who just rush into battle shouting and being all crazy but really sucking at fighting
according to some Romans and all that so that also needs to be taken with a grain of salt.
Oddly enough some of the sources are contradictory. On the one hand you have the image of the
but then you also have accounts of more sophisticated fighting tactics. For example
Livy in a particular battle mentions that the Celts were raising their shields above their
heads and locking them. Now that sounds a lot like a testudo and in fact Julius Caesar says
specifically about some Gauls that they were forming a testudo and he also said about the
that they assumed a phalanx. Now whether that is a real phalanx or something that vaguely
resembles it or something that is more akin to later shield walls who knows but it is kind of
interesting to see that. Livy also said that they were standing in close order behind their shield
wall so that really runs counter to the idea that the Celts just gathered in this huge
masses and completely loose random formations and were just rushing at them and you know not really
knowing what they were doing. I mean they couldn't have been too terrible on the battlefield. The
Greeks respected Celtic fighting ability. They often used Celtic mercenaries. The Carthaginians
used Celtic mercenaries. The Celts of course sacked Rome after the battle of the Alia.
They defeated two Macedonian armies in 279 BCE so they had a lot of success. It's just you know
Rome at a certain point just steamrolled everything. That's kind of how it went. But probably
the most essential factor to consider is societal organization. The Celts didn't have centralized
power the way that Rome did. They for one they were all organized along separate groups so it
wasn't just the Celts or even just the Gauls. It was you know the Belgae, the Arverni, the Aquitani,
the Senones, the so on and so forth, the Gaesatae. And even though in some cases they did have a
sense of shared cultural origin or a kinship and they were in contact. They traded and sometimes
they helped each other out and sometimes they formed alliances and all that fought together.
But there wasn't this idea of unity and sometimes they were in conflict with one another. I mean
Julius Caesar actually invaded Gaul on the you know excuse basically that oh yeah I'm just going
to help you out against your neighbors. So they were actually invited to help out with an internal
conflict that two Gallic groups had. And so in some cases it didn't really occur to them. It
wasn't on the table. It wasn't an option to band together and form this confederation. It happened
occasionally but generally it just didn't occur to them that they could just you know gather all
their neighbors up and just band together against the invading Romans. And let's not forget that the
Gallic chieftain didn't have the power of life and death over his warriors the way a centurion had
over his legionaries. Celtic leaders had to earn their authority through charisma, through their
ability to fight and lead and trade and otherwise maintain their status. Which means that warriors
could theoretically at any time say screw this not worth my time I'm going home. Try that as a Roman
soldier. There may also have been more of a focus in their martial training on single combat as
opposed to fighting in formation. Now some of the Roman sources seem to indicate that they were
quite adept at advanced battlefield tactics but at the same time they had a strong emphasis on
you know dueling man-to-man single combat. Often on the day of battle when the two armies met
a Celtic champion would actually come forth and start insulting the others and boast about his
deeds and his ancestors and whatever and would expect someone from the opposing army to come
forth and meet his challenge. And then in some cases the battle would be decided based on the
outcome of that duel. Not always but you can see this strong emphasis on you know personal
honor and glory and you know they may have had more of a focus on training for a dueling situation
which of course is completely different from fighting as a unit on a battlefield. Now that's
just my personal speculation I could be off on that but yeah this is really what I've read so
far. If you want to do your own research about the Celts without running into a bunch of bogus which
randomly has the name Celtic assigned to it I would suggest looking up information about the
Hallstatt culture which is from 800 to either 500 or 450 BCE and the later Latin culture which is
either 400 or 450 to 15 BCE. So yeah I hope you found the video interesting and thanks for watching.
