Ancient Artifacts that confirm the Bible | Wes Huff lecture

Ancient World
292 followers
We just heard about artifacts that confirm the Old Testament, and now we're going to
be talking about the New Testament.
Last night, Andy mentioned that the New Testament is the culmination.
The Old Testament was a story in search of a conclusion, and that conclusion found its
final fruition in the New Testament documents.
I am always encouraged in my academic study that although I believe the Bible, we do things
like stick shovels in the ground, and we confirm and corroborate so many different things.
There was a thinker and theologian in the Middle Ages named Anselm of Canterbury, and
he says that as Christians, we have to strive to pursue faith-seeking understanding.
It's one thing to believe the Bible, and we should, if we claim to be a Christian, believe
the Bible.
But that understanding aspect brings the reality of this isn't just a story, or it's no less
than a story, in that it finds its founding and its place within actual times and events
and places.
And what I want to do is I want to go, like Dr. Kennedy did, through a number of archaeological
artifacts, through artifacts that we have discovered that do things like corroborate,
come alongside the text of the scripture, and give confidence to us as Christians to
be able to, when we open our Bibles, see the actual times and places and people come into
existence.
Because the Bible did not exist in a vacuum, and the New Testament did not exist in a vacuum.
The New Testament has a historical context that it stems from.
It is thoroughly a Second Temple, First Century Jewish document.
And we find its origination and its context, historically and sociologically, in there.
In that the New Testament, that last section of your Bible, isn't one book as much as it's
a collection of 27 books written over the course of 60 years by at least nine different
authors, writing to multiple audiences in multiple places, in the language of the ancient
world, that being Greek, at that time.
And so, by acknowledging the historical realities of the New Testament, and evaluating them
on those terms, that these are historical documents, they're theological documents,
but ultimately they are historical documents.
By evaluating them on those terms, via the evidence presented, it only helps us to understand,
to seek that faith-seeking understanding, that these ancient texts, even as we find
ourselves 2,000 years after the most recent one was written, have a framework and context.
When we look back at how we actually go from ancient papyrus to modern-day print, the history
of the Bible is not some sort of layered web of translations.
In reality, what we find ourselves with is a single step, going from the original Hebrew
and Greek directly into our Bibles today.
The translation of the Bible takes into consideration an amazing collection of archaeological evidence,
from discoveries in Israel like the Dead Sea Scrolls, to papyri dug up in places like Oxyrhynchus.
Over time, as we've uncovered more of these fragments and manuscripts, they have uncomplicated
our understanding of the Bible, but clarified it.
The documents that sit behind the history of the Bible, and the way that we translate
them today, gives us confidence in their reliability to go from the original languages into our
own.
Even though we're almost 2,000 years removed from the last book of the Bible that was written,
as discoveries are made, we are not getting farther away from the text, but getting closer.
This evidence confirms and gives us good reason to trust that our Bibles have been faithfully
and accurately copied, and that what we have now is what the original authors wrote.
The archaeological artifacts that I want to look at are the manuscripts themselves.
The thousands of copies that the ancient world was very prolific in terms of the Christians
translated these documents very early, very quickly.
You know, Dr. Kennedy highlighted a number of ancient writings.
Tablets were the first form of writing.
We would inscribe things on tablets.
Now tablets were eventually replaced by scrolls, which was a more easy kind of formative form
of technology.
Scrolls were then replaced by the codex, what we call the book.
Now today, we scroll through books on tablets.
Going forwards, going backwards, not sure.
Nonetheless, when we look at the documents, when we look at these manuscripts, there are
multiple ones that we could highlight.
P66 is a late 2nd, early 3rd century copy of the Gospel of John that preserves for us
a near complete copy of what John's Gospel looked like 1,800 years ago.
A Codex Sinaiticus is arguably our first, what we would think of as a Bible, in that
it had Genesis to Revelation all in one unit.
It comes from the 4th century, and it took 260 sheep to make.
That's a lot of sheep.
I don't want to bleed around the bush about it, but it's a lot of sheep.
It was an expensive document.
P1, the first page of the Gospel of Matthew, dug up from Oxyrhynchus, was the first manuscript
of those near half a million papyri that were dug up.
This one was dug up on January 12, 1897, and it kicked off a slew of manuscript discoveries
that really build up the basis of those copies that we have of the Old Testament.
Or we could talk about GA777, a more than 1,000 year old Gospels collection, and one
of our earliest illuminated manuscripts, which alongside the Greek text has detailed and
intricate paintings of the life of Jesus.
The manuscripts are incredible pieces of evidence that lead us to being able to contrast and
read and compare, and we're able to look back and trace the original text back.
But as cool as all of those are, and believe me, they are cool, I want to capitalize on
a very particular manuscript, much, much smaller than any of the other ones I just mentioned.
And it's called P52, also known as John Ryland's 457.
This manuscript is a fragment of the Gospel of John, which is only about the size of a
credit card.
And this fragmentary piece of papyrus is housed today at the John Ryland's Library in Manchester,
England.
It was discovered in 1934 by an individual named C.H. Roberts.
He was recently doctored from the University of Oxford, and he was rummaging through drawers
of manuscripts that had been brought over from places like Israel and Egypt and Syria,
and were just housed in the basement of the library.
And he was doing some research, and he was rummaging through these, and he pulls out
this tiny credit card-sized manuscript from one of these drawers.
And he notices something very particular about it.
Because the script, which was ancient Greek, and because it was written on both sides,
it was identified as coming from a book.
Now in the ancient world, scrolls were the preferred medium of writing.
They didn't actually like the book.
They would write things on scrolls and roll them up.
It was by far and away the medium that was chosen within ancient antiquity.
Christians, however, for various reasons which we're still not entirely sure, very early
adopted and preferred the use of the codex, or the book form.
Christians did not invent the book, but going from the ancient world into the Middle Ages,
they were the ones who popularized it.
And so, for this small scrap to be written on both sides, because of its text and the
way that it was written, and the fact that it was probably from a codex, this outed it
as a Christian writing.
And so, Roberts takes note of this, and he says, this could be important.
I think this is very, very old.
And sure enough, it was a biblical document.
It contains a section of John 18 on both the front and the back.
Now just about a century prior to Roberts making this discovery of P52, there was a
man named Ferdinand Bauer in Germany who had come up with a theory.
Now Ferdinand Bauer was a biblical scholar, but he was a student of an individual named
Hegel.
And Hegel had come up with this philosophical theory that's sometimes referred to as Hegelian
dialectic, where you have an idea, which is a thesis, and then on the opposite side is
an antithesis, and then there's a measure in the middle that's called a synthesis.
Thesis, antithesis, and synthesis.
And so Bauer, being a student of Hegel, applied this to the datings of the Gospels in the
New Testament.
And he surmised and said, okay, Mark is arguably the oldest gospel, and it portrays a very
Jewish Jesus.
Mark's Jesus is a first century Jewish rabbi.
But then he thought Luke is the latest of the three synoptics, Matthew, Mark, and Luke.
And it portrays much more, in his mind, of a Gentile Jesus.
So you have Mark with the Jewish Jesus, you have Luke with the Gentile Jesus, and then
he, through a number of different arguments and reasonings, said, John comes along and
he is the antithesis.
He's the synthesis of the thesis and the antithesis.
He measures the two, and in John you get a Jewish and a Gentile Jesus coming together.
And based on this and a number of other internal things which he argued, he said that the Gospel
of John could not be dated any earlier than 160 AD, thus making it far too late to be
in the time of the eyewitnesses, and therefore completely unhistorical in its content.
Now this reasoning, which was a little bit convoluted and complicated, but it was a German
This stood as the reasoning for basically the next hundred years within critical biblical
scholarship.
That John was this picture of this measuring between Mark and Luke and was ahistorical
in its content.
Now the interesting thing about P52 is that when Roberts identified it as a Christian
manuscript and text and sent it off to a group of individuals who were paleographers
and papyrologists, individuals who date manuscripts, all of them unanimously put it at the beginning
of the second century.
And basically what this means is, I mean I've done a lot of school, and you can forgive
me for being a student at the University of Toronto, but even at the University of Toronto
we're taught that copies come after originals.
Think about it for a second.
You don't need doctoral level education to figure that one out.
And so what that meant is if P52 is coming at the beginning of the second century, then
John has to be in at minimum the end of the first century.
Now there have been lots of individuals even in the last number of years who have questioned
the dating of P52, but nonetheless the consensus remains that it is a second century document.
John most likely wrote in Ephesus.
Ephesus is about 1700 miles or 2700 kilometres away from Egypt where P52 originated.
And so you have to wait for time for John to write, for it to be spread around, it to
be read, and then eventually copied and find its way to Egypt.
And so even if you want to date P52, even in the latter half of the second century,
by all accounts the way that manuscripts spread around the ancient world and for it to eventually
get to Egypt still pushes John back into the first century.
This was a monumental discovery because it completely refocused the perspectives of how
the Gospel of John was read back to being early eyewitness testimony within the lifetime
of the witnesses of those actual events.
And so every time we stick shovels in the ground, we're doing things like corroborating
theories, even if certain consensuses are the opposite.
P52 is a rock star of the manuscript New Testament textual criticism world.
The second pieces of archaeological artifacts that I want to highlight are three, one of
which have already been mentioned, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and then Josephus' writings,
and Jewish ossuaries.
Now an ossuary is a bone box.
If you think about the Easter pictures that you've often seen where Jesus' body was put,
have you ever thought about the fact that when Jesus is put in the tomb, they lay him
on a slab?
Well, this was a family tomb, right, of Joseph of Arimathea.
So what are the rest of his family going to do if Jesus is lying on the slab?
Well, what was the burial practice of the days that you would wrap the body, you would
put it on that slab, the body would disintegrate, and the bones would be left.
They would collect the bones, they would put it in a box, they would inscribe the person's
name on the side of the box, and they would stick the box in a hole in the wall, much
like a mausoleum would have it today.
These were how family tombs, largely in ancient Jewish antiquity, operated and looked.
And so, a number of scholars have taken the fact that you have these different sources
that all give us a lot of information in regards to what names looked like in the ancient world.
Because names are important for historians because names change in popularity over time.
Even from not just decade to decade, but year to year.
And these sources, although the Dead Sea Scrolls come before Jesus, Josephus is writing after
Jesus, and the Ossuaries are kind of in this timeframe around Jesus, what these various
sources do is they give us a frame of reference for the data of names.
And then we can analyze this and do what is called onomastic congruence.
That's a fancy word, isn't it?
You can drop that one in the next party you're at.
Onomastic congruence simply means names that can be matched and corroborated.
A series of scholarly studies has shown that, though Jews were located in many places
across the Roman Empire, people's names often tended to be geographically located.
By observing literary and archaeological artifacts, a list of common names can be clearly identified.
By narrowing down the most popular names in places that Jesus lived, traveled, and ministered,
and by comparing these to the list from the studies, an interesting correlation can be seen.
Just as we see today with popular names, a qualifier or nickname is often used.
For example, notice that when Matthew lists the disciples in his gospel,
certain names have a qualifier or nickname and others do not.
Simon called Peter, and Andrew his brother, and James the son of Zebedee, and John his brother,
Philip and Bartholomew, Thomas and Matthew the tax collector, James the son of Alpheus,
and Thaddeus, Simon the zealot, and Judas Iscariot, who also betrayed him.
As we would expect, the most popular names are those that have an added description.
When we compare the most popular names in Judea and Galilee during the first century
with the names we see listed in places like the biblical gospels, we find that all of the names
with qualifiers match with what we'd assume if they were actually written in the time and place
they claim to be narrating. In contrast, the Gospel of Judas only has two names that would fit,
Jesus and Judas, but contains a host of other characters whose names match not with first
century Galilee and Judea, like biblical gospels, but with names that were popular in Egypt during
the 2nd and 3rd centuries. Consider how difficult it would be for someone living outside of the
locations and times that these events took place to get the right names with the right qualifiers.
We have four biblical gospels with four different named authors, and yet each gets this test of
naming frequency and attribution right every time. A test and standard that the
Apocryphal and Gnostic Gospels simply do not pass.
It shows the accuracy of the text. What do I mean by that? In the last half of the book of Acts,
Luke mentions two names that are completely outside of the data points of onomastic congruence.
Luke mentions 19 Greek names. Two of those names are completely unique. Damaris and Lydia. These
are completely unique Greek names, and we have no uses of them in any inscription or literary
documents anywhere within this time period. However, because there has been such extensive
studies on name frequency and popularity throughout the ancient world in the last few decades,
we now know that in the region where the last half of the book of Acts was written and took place,
this northern Mediterranean southern portion of Asia Minor, 10% of people had completely unique
names. So the fact that Luke has 19 names, two of which are completely unique, fits the data
perfectly if we assume that Luke is actually describing real people in real places and says
he's doing this while he's accompanying Paul during his missionary journeys in the Acts of
the Apostles. So onomastic congruence with name frequency shows the trustworthiness of the New
Testament in something like the clip I just showed with the Gospels. Ironically, in a couple of
instances where there are outliers, given the data that we're working with, this also happens
to fit in regard to the reliability of when that doesn't happen. And because the New Testament
books, whether it's the Gospel authors or whoever, are writing when the Gospel authors are writing
their biographies of Jesus, or when Peter, Paul, Jude, and James are writing their epistles, they're
making sure that they're communicating a level of authenticity through their writings to make sure
that you know they're talking about real people in real places at real times. Luke goes to lengths
to demonstrate that his narrative is placed within an actual time and location. In the first three
verses of Luke chapter 3, we are not only given seven historical characters that mark out the
beginning of the ministry of John the Baptist, but within these three verses alone are 22 historical
references to locations and people that have been verified by archaeology and ancient literary
sources outside of the Bible. This places Luke's account within a historical framework, making sure
his readers know he's not merely making up a story, but pinpointing when and where these events
actually took place in history. And the Gospel authors do this in multiple different ways, with
names, locations, as well as with accurate plant and animal life related to the areas within the
narratives they are describing. The Gospel authors get these types of facts right, even when other
ancient writers of the time don't. That narrator sounds like a smart guy. You know, I mentioned in
the end of that clip, right, that the Gospel authors often get this right when other ancient
historians don't. Let me give you an example of that. There was a very important, arguably one of the
four most ancient biographers and writers in the Greco-Roman period. His name was Tacitus, and
he makes two minor errors in a particular very important writing that he has. First, he actually
mentions that Christians believe in Christ. The problem is that he assumes wrongly that Christus
is a name, not a title. So he gets that fact wrong. He assumes that Christus, that kind of sounds like
a Greek name to him. He doesn't have the framework for that being a Jewish translation into the Greek
of the Hebrew word Messiah, and he says these Christians derived their name from a man called
Christus. But the more important historical aspect is that where he describes what happened to Jesus,
particularly being crucified under Pontius Pilate, he gives Pontius Pilate the wrong title.
Pilate was commissioned not as a procurator, but as a governor. And this is backed up by
numerous written sources, such as Josephus's Antiquities, which I mentioned before,
as well as the records of what appear to be his removal of the handling that he did of this period
in Judean history that we read about in the Gospels. He was removed from that position
eventually under not Tiberius, who was the emperor, but the next guy, Caligula. And along with that,
we can look at archaeological discoveries, and in particular, and this is my next artifact,
a stone that was found in Caesarea Maritime in Israel in 1961. Because in 1961, we discovered
this stone that once again, along with Josephus, along with some other ancient writings that we
have that describe the political situation in the ancient world, it says that here, for the Caesareans,
Pontius Pilate, governor of Judea, dictated this particular project. And so we have written
sources that corroborate who Pontius Pilate was, and we have archaeological sources and
discoveries that corroborate who Pontius Pilate was. And guess who also gets it right?
Luke and the other Gospel authors. Where prominent ancient writers get it wrong,
the Gospels get it right. They want to make sure that you know that you are reading history.
That Luke doesn't need to preface John the Baptist's ministry with naming everybody he
can possibly think of, everybody who is ruling, where they were ruling, and why they were ruling.
He didn't need to do that. But he did that because he wanted you to know that what he was writing
about was actually history. Events that took place in real times and real places.
My final piece of archaeological artifactory... I set that sentence up wrong. My final artifact
is the very first depiction, we think, of Jesus on the cross. And it's in a piece of 1900-year-old
Roman graffiti. Now if you go to Palatine Hill in Rome, the Palatine Hill Museum, you can actually
see this. It's on a wall, and there etched into the wall is a man on a cross with the head of a
donkey. And off to one side, there's a figure standing, arms raised in worship. And the caption
scrawled on the side says, Alexa Menos worships his God. You know, this is meant to be biting.
This is meant to be mocking. What this graffiti artist is saying is that anyone who worships the
God of the cross is worshiping a donkey. It's ridiculous. It's stupid. Absurd. Dare I say asinine.
And yet, that is... Thank you, I'll be here all day. That is the Christian claim, isn't it?
That we worship a crucified God. The Alexa Menos graffiti tells us a number of very important
things. That the early followers of Jesus worshipped Jesus as God. This isn't something
that was invented. This isn't something that was written into the Bible hundreds of years later,
aside from all the manuscripts that clearly identify Jesus as God. Even those who are
criticizing, mocking Christianity, reveal that as early as we can push it, Christians are
worshiping the crucified Savior. Not only that, but that Jesus was crucified, and particularly
on a cross. Now, why is this important? Well, I highlight this just as a side note, because there
are groups, like the Jehovah's Witnesses, who want to deny that and say Jesus was crucified on a stake.
Now, this debunks that, because this is coming from a source who would have understood crucifixion,
who would have seen crucifixion. And although it is true that we have examples of individuals being
crucified with their arms upright on a stake, Jesus almost certainly, based on what's described
in the Gospels, of what we know as just the normative position of Roman crucifixion, and
from the Alexa Manos Corfido, was crucified, in fact, on a cross with his arms outstretched.
And this is, as I said before, meant to be mockery. The Roman philosopher, just prior to Jesus,
Marcus Tullius Cicero, said the very mention of the word cross should be far removed not only from
a Roman citizen's body, but from his mind, his eyes, his ears. It is a most cruel and disgusting
penalty. He viewed it as a curse word, as vulgar. You didn't just go around saying the word cross
because of what happened during a crucifixion. This was the penalty for the lowest of the low.
And so for Alexa Manos, whoever that is, to be worshiping a crucified God, that is nonsense
to the ancient Romans. This was a point of both misunderstanding and mockery for non-Christians.
And I think we should take this to some degree as an encouragement in 2024, on the cusp of 2025,
because our culture, likewise, often misunderstands and mocks what we believe.
It's not something new. And we can take cues from the ancient church, from the Jesus revolution
that Glenn was talking about last night, in how they then fundamentally overturn society and
culture with the love of Jesus. You know, we read in Paul that he says that in 1 Corinthians 1.23
that we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to the Jews and foolishness to the Gentiles.
You know, the two Greek words that are translated there are skandalon and moronos.
It's a scandal to the Jews and it's moronic to the Gentiles. I think we can relate to that to
a certain degree. Our faith, this proclamation of a crucified savior, is a scandal to some
and it's moronic to others. And yet, nonetheless, Paul says we preach Christ crucified.
So in all of this, archaeological artifacts, I do want to say, just as a preface,
have their limits. These aren't proofs that the Old Testament, in what Dr. Kennedy was highlighting,
and the New Testament that I've highlighted here, is true. However, combined with the internal
evidence from the New Testament texts themselves, the corroborative data of artifacts I've highlighted,
and many, many, many more, they all correlate with the accuracy of the 27 books that we call
the New Testament. And when things are in doubt, like certain theories that date the Gospels late,
every once in a while we find a P52 that upturns the consensus. And that doesn't mean we need to
be disparaging on the consensus. The consensus is the consensus for a reason. But I am always
encouraged that the more and more we explore these things, the more and more we find corroborative
data. This creates a cumulative case that gives us confidence that when you pick up your Bible
and you read through its pages, this is actually Pastor Tim Woodcock's Bible. I'm going to be
auctioning it out later today. I can feel the holiness just radiating.
But when you pick up your Bible and read through its pages, you can at minimum
see its trustworthiness as historically accurate documents. However, whether or not you then choose
to embrace the Christian faith depends on far more than historical evidence. It just does.
The very quick examples Dr. Kennedy and myself have highlighted, I've shared with you this morning,
are not going to convince you that Jesus is the Son of God, that he did miracles, died for his sins,
and rose again to guarantee eternal life. At the exact same time, the best lines of historical
reasoning today can and do, and probably should, lead a fair-minded inquirer to the conclusion
that the New Testament contains good, accurate, and trustworthy testimony from the time that
Jesus was living. By people who are actually there, who claim to have seen what they saw,
and that that testimony corroborates with other evidence in the form of tangible artifacts that
we can look at in stone and in papyrus and inscribed on walls. And the information found
in its pages can be weighed against, scrutinized by, and verified with a host of internal and
external lines of data that show its reliability and accuracy. Because Jesus is no less than a
historical character, but he's also so much more than that. And it's via historical analysis of
artifacts such as the ones we've just seen that lead us to the confident judgment that you can,
in fact, trust the New Testament. Not just as simply a reliable collection of ancient documents,
but as something that contains the words of a man who really did predict his own death and
resurrection, and really did die on a cross 2,000 years ago, walked out of the grave,
and invites you into perfect and right relationship with him as your Lord, your Savior, and your friend.
That is historically reliable eyewitness testimony. Let me finish with this.
C.S. Lewis said, Christianity, if false, is of no importance. And if true, of infinite importance.
The only thing it cannot be is moderately important. Thank you very much for listening.
