'The Choice Between Virtue and Vice' (c. 1565) by Paolo Veronese

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
32 Video Views·May 21, 2025
Explore the symbolism and hidden meanings within The Choice Between Virtue and Vice by Paolo Veronese with Deputy Director and Chief Curator Xavier F. Salomon. This episode examines the fascinating allegorical elements, composition, and Renaissance ideals presented in one of the Frick’s major masterpieces.
Good evening and welcome to this episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
I'm Xavier Salomon, the Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator at The Frick Collection in New York.
Last week we met and spoke about the Allegory of Wisdom and Strength by Veronese at The Frick Collection.
And today, instead, we talk about the Allegory on the Opposite Side of the Wall in the West Gallery,
one of the two great works by Paolo Veronese at The Frick Collection.
Last week I matched the Veronese Allegory with a Negroni, a typical Italian cocktail.
And tonight I will match the second painting with what is called a Negroni Sbagliato, a wrong Negroni.
And this is a version of the Negroni.
The typical Negroni is gin, Campari, and sweet vermouth.
This is a version which, instead of the gin, it still has Campari and sweet vermouth,
but it adds Prosecco instead of the gin.
So it's somewhat lighter and fizzy and more of a summer drink.
Salute!
Paolo Veronese was one of the greatest 16th-century painters active in Venice.
As the name suggests, he was originally from Verona.
And here you see a 19th-century monument to Veronese,
which was erected in his birthplace in Verona.
It was originally, as you see on the left, in front of the Church of Santa Anastasia,
and then it was later moved to a small park near the river Adige, where you see it on the right.
Veronese was born in Verona in 1528 and studied there with a local painter called Antonio Badile.
He ended up marrying Badile's daughter.
And as a young man in his twenties, he moved to Venice in the early 1550s
and spent all of his life in Venice.
He remained married to Eleanor Badile throughout his life.
He had several children, some of whom were also painters.
He worked very closely with his brother, Benedetto, who was also a painter.
And from the moment he arrived in Venice,
he started working in some of the most prestigious locations in the city,
including the Doge's Palace and a number of prestigious churches.
He also worked for the local aristocracy, for many of the noble families of Venice.
But he also worked for patrons abroad.
As I said last week, we don't know who the two allegories at the Frick were originally painted for.
And one of the big questions is still, were they painted as pendants?
Or were they two independent pictures
that happened to be grouped as a pair
from the time they reached Imperial collection of Rudolf II in Prague onwards?
We don't know.
Technical analysis that was done in around 2005, 2006
showed that the paintings were actually painted on different types of canvas.
The preparation was different, and even the pigments used
were used in different ways in different configurations.
So this seems to suggest that these two paintings
were not created to begin with to go together.
It may be that one was made
and the second one was then created to match the first one.
They're about the same size, not precisely the same size,
but close enough that they could have been painted to be shown together.
Since the seventeenth century, since the 1620s at least,
these two pictures have always been together.
So the question about how you do read them together,
if the meaning of these two pictures is complementary
or they have nothing to do with each other,
is clearly a rather interesting point.
Veronese was a master at allegories and allegorical paintings.
He painted several ceilings for the Doge's Palace in Venice
with allegories, the ceiling of the Library of St. Mark's, also in Venice,
the frescoes in many villas, Villa Barbarormaser,
which is the topic of one of the
Travels with a Curator episodes,
but also other locations, other villas and buildings
in Venice and outside of Venice
were filled with these grand allegorical figures.
And sometimes these paintings are still hard to interpret today,
where we're not so used to the idea
of what these scenes actually mean and what these figures mean.
This painting is actually based on a mythological event.
While wisdom and strength is a combination
of different mythological and allegorical figures
to express a specific meaning,
this plays on an episode from the life of an ancient hero.
What you see is a broad landscape with ruins.
There is this ruined statue at the top left
and a man in the center flanked by two women,
a woman on the left, a woman on the right,
and he goes from one to the other.
This is a play on the so-called choice of Hercules
or Hercules at the crossroads.
And it is an ancient legend that centers
on the young figure of Hercules
who supposedly came upon a crossroad.
And on one side there was a very beautiful,
young, lusciously dressed woman
who pointed to a downhill road,
very pleasant to walk along,
and a woman, older, more sternly dressed,
pointing upwards to a steep uphill path.
And, of course, these two women represented two ways of life.
The woman that you see in this painting on the right
is a life of pleasure, which, of course,
is a life that eventually leads to a downhill path,
and a life of glory and virtue,
which is difficult but eventually brings you
to the top of the mountain.
And in this case, at the top of the mountain,
you see Pegasus, the winged horse.
This is a painting by Annibale Carracci.
It's a seventeenth-century painting.
Carracci was someone who looked very closely
at Venetian art and at Veronese,
so there are some echoes of Veronese in this painting.
And this was done for a ceiling
in the Farnese Palace in Rome.
But while this scene clearly shows Hercules,
you see the young man, not bearded,
but with his powerful body and his signature club.
The two figures are clearly easily identifiable
as Virtue on the left and Vice on the right.
Veronese's painting, however, is somewhat different.
And if we start looking at the figures in it,
we realize that this is not
a straightforward choice of Hercules.
So there is a woman on the left,
and the woman on the left is very cleverly depicted.
She is richly dressed
in this beautiful orange and blue dress,
which you can actually notice is unfastened at the back.
In her hair, there are cyclamen flowers,
which were considered to be flowers used for love potions
and were also somewhat considered poisonous.
And you don't see the face of this woman.
In her left hand, she holds a pack of cards.
And she is sitting on the statue,
a statue of a naked woman with lion paws.
And that is an identification of the sphinx.
And the sphinx is another mythical creature,
the famous mythical creature
that would present riddles to voyagers, to travelers.
And if the riddle wasn't answered,
the sphinx would kill the person passing by.
And so it's an image of danger.
And in front of that sphinx,
there is a very large butcher's knife,
a sort of dangerous weapon.
So what we, the viewer, see of this woman
is not what the man dressed in white sees.
The man dressed in white sees her face,
which we cannot see,
presumably the front of her body,
which we can imagine, since it's unfastened at the back,
must be open at the front.
But he doesn't see the cards behind her back.
He doesn't see the sphinx.
He doesn't see the knife.
And the other detail about this woman
is that her claws are very sharp.
And you see her right hand
with which she has just attacked the man and scratched him.
Here is a detail of this beautiful open dress.
And you see the jewelry that she is wearing.
So again, she's a very richly,
very beautifully dressed woman.
This is a detail, of course, of the sphinx and the knife.
And you see also the pack of cards at the top.
The opposite woman, instead,
is clearly more somberly dressed.
She wears a crown, a wreath of laurel leaves in her hair
to signify glory and military victory, usually.
Her dress is less rich
and is clearly more somber and austere than the other woman.
The man is clearly going towards her and embracing her.
But the man is not Hercules.
The man is not dressed up in a lion skin.
He does not have a club,
and he does not have the typical beard
that Hercules is expected to have.
The detail of his legs is telling.
He has been attacked by the woman on the left,
who has ripped part of his trousers off
and his stockings,
and you can see that his flesh
is actually wounded and bleeding.
The final detail is the sculpture at the top.
And the sculpture at the top has an inscription in Latin,
like the Allegory of Wisdom and Strength of the Frick.
And in this case, it's somewhat incomplete,
but it says,
honor et virtus post mortem floret,
and honor and virtue will flourish after death.
So what is this painting about?
It's clearly a play on the choice of Hercules,
on Hercules at the crossroads.
Here is a man choosing between two figures.
The figure on the left,
clearly a figure to do with vice and lust and danger.
And behind this figure lies, of course,
ultimate danger, the sphinx and the knife.
And on the right, the figure of virtue,
which stands upright and tall in her somber dress.
This is not a man who is effectively choosing
between the two figures.
He's made his choice.
He's clearly going towards virtue,
and he is embracing virtue and going towards her.
The inscription adds the detail that the right choice,
the choice of leading an honorable and virtuous life,
will be rewarded after death.
So who is the man in the middle?
And there's been various theories.
People thought this could be the patron of the painting.
This could be Veronese himself.
It could be the typical sixteenth-century Venetian man.
He is the only figure in both of these paintings
who is wearing contemporary outfits.
You have to imagine that the outfits in the other allegory
and the outfits that the two women are wearing
in this painting are fantastic outfits.
They are inventions of what an ancient-like costume
may look like from the eyes of a sixteenth-century
Venetian artist like Veronese.
But the man in the middle is wearing a contemporary outfit.
I always explain that this painting
is almost as if you had a man in a t-shirt and jeans today
surrounded by two figures wearing fantasy outfits.
So for any viewer in the 1560s in Venice,
this would have been immediately recognizable
as a jarring image of a contemporary man
with these two timeless figures.
Is he a portrait?
And I've been thinking about this for many, many years,
and I've finally decided that I think it probably is.
And this is probably the person the painting was painted for.
The fact that his outfit is white suggests
that this person may actually be dead.
And he's young, but he may have been someone
who is celebrated in this painting
after his untimely death.
White represents purity,
and no one in Venice actually wore fully white outfits,
partly because that was impractical,
partly because they were always considered
this otherworldly color in a number of ways.
And in some countries, white, in fact,
was the color of mourning.
So this painting clearly relates to an individual
and to the idea that this individual
has chosen virtue over vice.
This is further strengthened by another painting by Veronese,
painted a few years later,
which is in the Prado Museum in Madrid,
and it shows exactly the same scene.
But in this case, it is a boy
who's choosing between virtue and vice.
And this was, we know,
commissioned by a member of the Soranzo family.
So this is a boy of the Soranzo family
who's clearly choosing virtue and following virtue
and leaving vice on the left behind.
So clearly this is something
that Veronese did more than once,
and it is a very appropriate message
for virtuous patrons of the time.
How this picture with this man
choosing between virtue and vice and choosing virtue
relates to the other allegory about wisdom and strength
is still unclear.
It is likely that they may have even been made
for two different patrons
and then put together at a later stage.
But clearly both of them are about moral issues,
virtuous living,
and good examples for the people
looking at these paintings.
It is worth thinking about them
and unpacking all these details in these wonderful works
to get to the ultimate message.
And as I said, in both cases,
it is a message of virtuous living and moral standards.
I hope you enjoyed looking at these two paintings
over the last two weeks
as much as I love Veronese,
and it's always a pleasure to talk about him,
one of the greatest artists of the Italian Renaissance.
I hope you enjoyed your Negroni last week
and that tonight you're trying your Negroni Sbagliato.
And I look forward to seeing you all next week
with another episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
