Supreme Court Rules 9-0 in FOURTH AMENDMENT Case

Facts Matter
2.9K followers
🇺🇸 Try Epoch Times Sale: https://bit.ly/4lAyebk
🟡 Buy One Gold Oz., Get One Silver Oz.: https://ept.ms/3biH9MN
Episode Resources:
🔵 Supreme Court Ruling:
https://bit.ly/3SHoWwS
🔵 Fifth Circuit Ruling:
https://bit.ly/3FkhdSt
🔵 Full Dashcam Footage:
https://bit.ly/3ZoL7M4
-
#4thamendment #FactsMatter #supremecourt
© All Rights Reserved.
In a new decision, the US Supreme Court
has just ruled 9 to zero in a case that
involved the fourth amendment to the US
Constitution. This unanimous decision
from the court, it was in favor of a
woman who lost her son when a police
officer killed that son during a traffic
stop. Now, the story itself obviously
comes with a lot of nuance, but the key
takeaway is that the American citizen in
this particular case, she prevailed
against the state and therefore this
unanimous Supreme Court decision expands
all of our rights under the Fourth
Amendment. But funny enough, the
specifics of this case, they might not
make that a universally good thing
because it might make the job of a
police officer that much more difficult
and dangerous. But in order to explain
what that means, I need to go through
the details of this case together with
you. To start with, let me give you a
bit of background on what actually
happened here. Nine years ago, on April
28th, 2016, at approximately 2:45 in the
afternoon, an incident took place over
in Harris County, Texas, a police
officer named Roberto Felix Jr. received
a radio alert about a vehicle that had
outstanding toll violation. Officer
Felix, while driving down the highway,
spotted that particular car, turned on
his lights, and pulled it over. Now, the
driver in that car, 24y old Ashton
Barnes, he pulled over to the side, and
he stopped on the shoulder of the
highway. So far, so good. Everything is
by the book. Officer Felix then got out
of his police cruiser. He walks over to
the car, and he asks to see Ashton's
driver's license as well as his proof of
insurance. Now, Ashton, he says that he
doesn't have his driver's license on him
and that the car is actually a rental,
which was true. It was actually his
girlfriend's rental car, and it was the
rental car that had these unpaid tolls
on it, meaning it really didn't have
anything to do with him. Also, it is
perhaps worth mentioning that driving
without having your driver's license on
your person in the state of Texas is
technically a crime, although it's a
very minor one. According to the Texas
State Transportation Code, specifically
subsection
521.025, drivers in the state must have
their driver's licenses on them while
operating a motor vehicle. But if you
don't have your driver's license on you,
you'll just be given a ticket, which you
can actually dismiss if you go on over
to the courthouse and just prove that
you do have a license. It'll just cost
you a $10 dismissal fee. meaning as a
practical sense that not having your
license on you is a very minor issue in
the state of Texas. Okay, so that's the
situation that Ashlin found himself in.
He's in a traffic stop. He's driving a
car that has unpaid tolls on it because
it's a rental car. He doesn't have his
license on him and he's now rumaging
through some papers in the car trying to
find the insurance paperwork. This is
though when things take a bad turn. Here
is how this chain of events was
described in the court filings. Quote,
"During this interaction, Ashton was
digging around in the car. Officer Felix
warned Ashton to stop doing so and
claiming that he smelled marijuana,
asked Ashton if he had anything in the
vehicle officer Felix should know about.
In response, Ashton turned off the
vehicle, placing his keys near the gear
shift, and told officer Felix that he
might have the requested documentation
in the trunk of the car. What happened
next was captured on Officer Felix's
dash cam." Now, we do actually have that
dash cam footage, and fortunately, it's
pretty clear visually, but just because
of the angle, it's a little hard to make
out what's going on. And so, let's do
this. I'm going to show you the footage,
and then I'll give you a momentby-moment
breakdown of what actually happened
because otherwise, you might not
actually know what you're looking at.
And also mention that all of this took
place within the span of roughly 20
seconds, but it's a very, very densely
packed 20 seconds. And so, let's start
with the dash cam from the officer's
car.
Sure. Go ahead and put that cover off
the top for me.
[ __ ] shot fire. Shot fire. Okay, so
let's unpack what we actually just
watched there. Starting at 2:45 p.m. 28
seconds, Officer Felix orders Ashton to
open the trunk of the car. At this time,
you'll notice that the left blinker on
that car is still on, indicating that
the keys were still in the ignition and
that the car itself was on. 5 seconds
later, Ashton opens the trunk of the
car. Three seconds later, the left
blinkers turn off, indicating that the
car itself was turned off. Six seconds
later, Officer Felix tells Ashton to get
out of the car. 1 second after that, the
driver's side door opens. However, 3
seconds after that, you see that the
left blinker turns back on, indicating
that the car itself was turned back on
and the key is in the ignition. 1 second
after that, Officer Felix draws his
weapon. And then one second later,
Officer Felix points his weapon at
Ashton and begins shouting, "Don't
effing move." as the car begins to move
forward. At this point, the court
document describes what happened. Quote,
"Officer Felix stepped onto the car's
doors with his weapon drawn and pointed
at Ashton and shoved his gun into
Ashton's head, pushing his head hard to
the right. Then the car started to move.
While the car was moving, Officer Felix
shot inside the vehicle with no
visibility as to where he was aiming.
The next second, Officer Felix fired
another shot while the vehicle was still
moving. After 2 seconds, the vehicle
came to a full stop, and Officer Felix
yelled, "Shots fired!" into his radio.
Officer Felix held Ashton at gunpoint
until backup arrived while Ashton sat
bleeding in the driver's seat. At 2:57
p.m., which was just 12 minutes after
the trunk was opened, Ashton was
pronounced dead on the scene. Now, the
relevant piece of information that we
really need to take away from this
shooting in order to understand the
legal case moving forward is that
officer Felix chose to jump into the car
as the car started to move forward. And
within just 2 seconds of being on the
car that's moving, he decided to shoot
his gun at Ashton. Just 2 seconds of the
car moving after he jumped on it
himself. meaning that you can make the
argument that officer Felix created the
life-threatening situation that he found
himself in. Now, I'm of course not
saying that he did, only that an
argument could be made that the police
officer created the life-threatening
situation. Now, after the shooting took
place, there were two separate trains of
legal activity. The criminal
investigations as well as a civil
lawsuit. On the criminal side, you had
the homicide division of the Houston
Police Department investigate this
entire incident and they compiled their
findings into a report. This report was
then presented to a grand jury who found
no probable cause of an indictment,
meaning that officer Felix would not be
prosecuted for murder. Also, the local
precinct conducted a separate internal
investigation and they found that
officer Felix did not violate their
standard operating procedures. This
meant that from just a criminal
perspective, there was nothing that
officer Felix had to worry about in the
eyes of the law. From that perspective,
he followed police protocol and he
killed Ashton only while acting in
self-defense while he truly and
rationally believed that his life was in
danger. So, that's all on the criminal
side. However, on the civil side,
Officer Felix was not as lucky. You see,
Ashton's parents, they filed a lawsuit
on behalf of their son, arguing that
what Officer Felix did during that
traffic stop amounted to excessive force
under the Fourth Amendment to the US
Constitution. All right, just to pause
here for a super quick moment. Listen,
it's obvious that the financial system
is not looking too great after being
pumped up with trillions of virtually
free government dollars for many, many
years now. Well, the stock bubble might
actually burst in the near future. And
in that process, unfortunately, it could
take away the nest egg of anyone who
happens to be exposed to it. And so,
consider taking this opportunity to
diversify into something which is beyond
the grasp of Washington DC and Wall
Street, physical gold and silver. And
the best company to use in my opinion is
the sponsor of today's episode, American
Hartford Gold, who I should mention is
also my own personal gold and silver
bullion dealer. And besides myself, they
have thousands of five-star reviews from
other Americans. And they also have an
A+ rating with the Better Business
Bureau. And working with them is rather
simple. They have a huge selection of
coins, bars, and rounds to choose from.
They have super friendly staff who you
can call and they can set up either gold
delivery directly to your doorstep or
they can even set you up in a gold IRA.
And then lastly, best of all, if you
tell them that Roman sent you, they will
throw in a free gold coin with your
first qualifying purchase. So give them
a call. The number is
8662422352. That's
866242-22352 or you can simply text
Roman to
65532. I'll also throw a link to their
uh web page. It'll be down there in the
description box below. And in case you
haven't been in a high school civics
class in a while and you forgot what the
Fourth Amendment is, let me read you the
entirety of the text. Quote, "The right
of the people to be secure in their
persons, houses, papers, and effects
against unreasonable searches and
seizures shall not be violated, and no
warrants shall issue, but upon probable
cause supported by oath or affirmation
and particularly describing the place to
be searched and the persons or things to
be seized." Now, initially at the lower
court level, Ashton's parents lost the
case. The district court, they issued a
judgment in favor of officer Felix,
saying the following quote, "At the
moment in time, the officer fired his
weapon. He reasonably believed that his
life was in danger. Therefore, the
officer did not violate the Fourth
Amendment." Ashton's parents, they then
appealed that decision to the Fifth
Circuit Court of Appeals. However, the
appeals court also ruled against them.
In their decision, you had the fifth
circuit lay out the legal standard upon
which they evaluate these types of
officer involved shootings. And they
explain how according to their legal
test, it does not matter what happened
prior to the shooting. As long as at the
moment of the shooting, the officer
believed that his life was in danger.
Well, it did not matter how he got into
that situation. All that mattered was
that the officer was in a life ordeath
situation. Here's specifically what they
wrote. This was again from the fifth
circuit court of appeals. Quote, "We may
only ask whether officer Felix was in
danger at the moment of the threat that
caused them to use deadly force against
Ashton. In the circuit, it is well
established that the excessive force
inquiry is confined to whether the
officers or other persons were in danger
at the moment of the threat that
resulted in the officer's use of deadly
force. This moment of threat test means
that the focus of the inquiry should be
on the act that led the officer to
discharge his weapon. any of the
officers actions leading up to the
shooting are not relevant for the
purposes of an excessive force inquiry
in this circuit. In the totality of
their decision, they reciting an earlier
precedent that created that legal
standard. Meaning that according to the
legal standard that the fifth circuit
court of appeals was using, the
so-called moment of threat test, it did
not really matter that the police
officer put himself in that situation by
jumping into the car. The singular
question is whether or not at the moment
of danger did the officer have a
reasonable fear that his life was an
imminent threat. The appeals court found
that he did and therefore there was
nothing else to discuss. However,
Ashton's parents, they appealed this
decision as well all the way up to the
US Supreme Court. And the central legal
question that Ashton's parents brought
up to the US Supreme Court was simply a
question of timing. Whether courts can
look only at the last two seconds right
before the shooting, or whether they can
also consider the earlier events, the
ones that led up to those two seconds.
And after hearing oral arguments from
both sides, the US Supreme Court ruled
unanimously in favor of Ashton's
parents. And in doing so, they
effectively eliminated the so-called
moment of threat test. Writing the
opinion for the majority of the court,
you had Alina Kagan write the following
quote. The question here is whether that
framework permits courts in evaluating a
police shooting or other use of force to
apply the so-called moment of threat
rule used in the courts below. Under
that rule, a court looks only to the
circumstances existing at the precise
time an officer perceived the threat
inducing him to shoot. Today, we reject
that approach as improperly narrowing
the requisite Fourth Amendment analysis.
To assess whether an officer acted
reasonably in using force, a court must
consider all the relevant circumstances,
including facts, and events leading up
to the climactic moment. Now, the entire
federal legal system works exactly on
these types of rules, tests, standards,
and precedents set forth by the US
Supreme Court. Meaning that moving
forward, any other officer involved
shooting in the whole country will no
longer be judged by this moment of
threat test. That test is literally no
more. Moving forward, the courts will
have to quote, "Consider all the
relevant circumstances, including facts
and events leading up to the climactic
moment." This is a brand new fourth
amendment legal standard, which on the
one hand is a good thing for US
citizens. It gives all of us more
protections under the fourth amendment.
We are now all better protected from
police escalation. However, for police
officers, this creates more hurdles
because now it won't only matter if at
the very moment of the shooting they
believe their life was in danger.
Instead, the courts will now look at the
totality of the events that led up to
that particular moment. And while you
hope this will just lead to more
justice, you can easily imagine a
scenario where a police officer does
everything by the book. He still finds
himself in a dangerous situation with
someone trying to kill him. the officer
shoots, injures, and or kills that other
person, but now that officer might be on
the hook if you have a DA who's making
the argument that the officer himself
somehow created that dangerous
situation. However, I would love to know
your thoughts on this particular
decision that just came out of the US
Supreme Court. Do you think on net this
is a positive? Do you think that the
fact that this creates more protections
for us under the Fourth Amendment is a
good thing or do you think that it's
outweighed by the negatives that are
going to be incurred by police officers
across the country? I'd love to know
your thoughts. Please leave them down in
the comments section below. I'll be
reading through them later today as well
as into the week. If you'd like to read
the either the Fifth Circuit Court of
Appeals opinion or the US Supreme Court
opinion, I'll throw those links down
into the description box below if you
want to peruse them for yourself. And as
always, if you appreciate content like
this, I really do hope you take a quick
moment to smash that like button so that
this video can reach ever more people
via the YouTube algorithm. And also
consider smashing that subscribe button
as well. That way, you will be informed
of any new videos that we publish on
this platform as soon as we publish
them. And then until next time, I'm your
host Roman from the Epic Times. Stay
informed and most importantly, stay
free.
