"The Truth About China Protests - Is This The End Of Communism In China?
Protests are erupting across the country as thousands of people take to the streets to demand that the China Communist Party end its persistent and extreme ""Zero COVID"" policy, which has caused so much suffering for people and decimated the economy over the last three years. Calling on President Xi Jinping and the CCP to step down, demanding democracy and freedom. Such unbelievable words cannot and should not be used in mainland China, a country ruled by authoritarian communism known for its serious human rights violations against religious and faith minorities, as well as dissidents. These images haven't been seen in China since the greatest mainland student demonstration of the late 20th century, which led to the Chinese regime's massacre in Tiananmen Square in 1989. Why do protests break out in China? What effect do they have on the ruling party?"
This is China.
Communists must be killed!
Xi Jinping must be killed!
We don't want a dictatorship!
Protests are erupting across the country,
as thousands of people take to the streets
to demand that the China Communist Party
end its persistent and extreme zero-Covid policy,
which has caused so much suffering for people
and decimated the economy over the last three years.
Calling on President Xi Jinping
and the CCP to step down,
demanding democracy and freedom.
Such unbelievable words cannot
and should not be used in mainland China,
a country ruled by authoritarian communism
known for its serious human rights violations
against religious and faith minorities,
as well as dissidents.
These images haven't been seen in China
since the greatest mainland student demonstration
of the late 20th century,
which led to the Chinese regime's massacre
in Tiananmen Square in 1989.
Why do protests break out in China?
What effect do they have on the ruling party?
Zero-Covid turns China into a massive jail.
The Covid-19 pandemic,
also known as Wuhan pneumonia,
broke out in China in 2019
and then spread globally,
killing millions of people in China
and all over the world.
The Xi Jinping government implemented
the zero-Covid policy,
with the primary goal of reducing
the number of people infected
with the Covid-19 virus to zero
in order to reduce mortality.
According to Chinese government statistics,
the whole Chinese mainland
has recorded only over 5,000 deaths
out of 1.5 million infections.
In comparison to the United States,
where 1 million people die
for every 100 million infections,
Beijing sees the zero-Covid policy
as indicative of the regime's supremacy.
So, as the rest of the world
returns to normalcy,
no quarantine, no tests,
no masks,
the CCP maintains its extreme policy,
even though it has caused countless tragedies
for the people and strangled the economy.
Rare photos and videos
of Chinese people's suffering
have been broadcast to the world
in the last three years,
provoking anger in the international community
due to the regime's tyranny.
Quarantine officers locked people's doors.
They were imprisoned in their homes
for months without food.
Some died of starvation.
Some jumped to their deaths in desperate need.
And agonizing screams were heard
from blockaded apartment blocks
in Shanghai earlier this year.
It's straight out of a dystopian sci-fi movie.
Or an elderly man on his knees
begged the checkpoint staff to take his feverish
grandson to the hospital,
but he was completely neglected.
You might be able to go outside if you're lucky,
but every time you open your eyes,
you'll have to take a nucleic acid test.
Keep testing until you have a positive result,
and you will be taken to the isolation center.
There is information that people
will eventually be transported to prisons
for isolation due to a shortage of
COVID-19 isolation facilities.
On March 7, 2020,
a hotel used for isolation in Quanzhou,
Fujian Province, collapsed,
killing 29 people.
On January 6, 2022,
a pregnant woman had bleeding
but was forced to wait two hours in the cold
to get tested for COVID-19,
which resulted in the death of her 8-month-old baby.
On September 18, 2022,
a bus transporting COVID-19
quarantine officials in Guizhou
was involved in an accident, killing 27 individuals.
On October 29, 2022,
thousands of workers at Foxconn's
factory in Zhengzhou, Henan Province,
China, Apple's largest iPhone
assembly facility, fled overnight
because they couldn't endure the severe
quarantine measures and terrible living
conditions, including a shortage of food
and medical treatment. On November 24,
there was a protest at Foxconn.
Hundreds of workers jostled
with white-suited security guards.
Tear gas was used in one video,
and workers were seen taking down
quarantine barricades.
The last drop was a deadly fire
in a high-rise building in Arumqi,
the capital of China's western Xinjiang
region, where some people had been under
lockdown for more than 100 days.
Officials report that the fire
killed 10 people and injured 9 others,
but human rights organizations allege
that the death toll is four times higher.
Videos from the tragedy
showed a desperate woman yelling for help
and firefighters unable to approach the apartment,
sparking outrage and concerns
about whether the COVID restrictions hampered
residents' escape and rescue efforts,
claims that officials disputed.
This provoked a wave of protests,
which began in Arumqi.
People flocked to the streets,
calling for the lockdown to be lifted
and raising their fists in the air.
A video showed people in a plaza
singing China's national anthem with the line
Rise those who refuse to be slaves.
Then, since the deadly fire,
there have been 51 public protests
across 24 cities in China
and about 80 universities in Beijing,
Shanghai, Nanjing, Chongqing
and Wuhan, with slogans
such as Better Dead Without Freedom
and bolder than calling for President Xi Jinping
and the Communist Party to step down,
according to Nathan Reuser,
a researcher at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute.
They chanted,
We don't want to covet things, we want freedom,
we don't want a dictatorship, we want democracy.
Notably,
a movement known as the White Paper Revolution
emerged during a series of protests.
Thousands of young protesters
brandished blank sheets of paper,
a metaphor for what remains unsaid,
and have become a powerful tool for dissatisfied Chinese,
adding fuel to a movement
that has expanded to unprecedented proportions
in recent decades.
As a result, groups of overseas
Chinese students in the United States,
Australia, and the United Kingdom,
among others, have responded strongly
to this movement with a series of rallies
outside Chinese embassies in these countries,
where it terrified them and was tightly controlled
but is now a place to speak out for freedom
and democracy.
According to analysts, this is the biggest
rage in China in the last 30 years
since the Tiananmen Square Massacre on
June 4, 1989.
Ma Jian, an award-winning Chinese
writer who witnessed the 1989
democratic movement firsthand,
stated that he had not seen so many young mainland
Chinese demonstrators in a long time.
He described the white sheets
as sparks of fire that express the people's
true feelings. It's a legacy of
resistance against tyranny, censorship,
and totalitarianism.
These students may face expulsion and
imprisonment, be shunned by their parents,
and struggle to get international support,
similar to the students in Tiananmen Square
in 1984 and Hong Kong,
but they have held up a light of hope.
Censorship at an Emergency Level
On November 28,
the leaked directive was reportedly issued
following a meeting at China's Cyberspace
Administration, which urged Internet platforms
to activate Level 1 Internet Emergency
Response, the highest level of
content restriction. On Chinese
social media, all widely shared
protest videos and appeals to action
were quickly censored. Signal
jammers are following the protesters,
preventing them from posting on the Internet or
communicating with others. Websites
and applications, including Weibo
and WeChat, went down to prevent people
from sharing information about the demonstrations.
A video
shows police in Shanghai checking
people's phones on the subway for protest-related
videos. The cat-and-mouse
game between millions of Chinese Internet
users and the country's massive censorship
system has escalated.
To avoid censorship, Chinese people
have found clever ways to express their
dissatisfaction. Some,
for example, posted blank white
paper photos, which have become a sign of
displeasure with the government's suppression of free
speech. However, censors
move quickly to control comments and
photos on white paper.
Another approach is to use
Chinese homonyms, such as shrimp
moss, which sounds like the words for step
down, and banana peel, which
has the same initials as C, to
elicit demands for Chinese leader Xi Jinping
to resign.
The demonstrations in Guangzhou
escalated into a clash between police
and residents on Nov. 29.
In particular, dozens of
riot police in white hazmat suits raised
their shields as people threw stuff at them in a
video posted on Twitter. Another
video shows a tear gas canister
landing into a crowd on a side street,
forcing people to flee.
According to CNN,
several people were arrested and brought
into police custody shortly after.
Several more were arrested behind
police lines.
The CCP tightens security.
According to the
Epoch Times, the Chinese regime's
highest law enforcement agency, the
Central Political and Legal Affairs Commission,
issued a veiled warning to demonstrators
on Nov. 28.
The commission committed to resolutely crack down
on infiltration and sabotage activities
by hostile forces under the law.
Political and legal organs must
take effective measures to resolutely safeguard
national security and social stability.
Previous demonstrations
in Beijing and Shanghai were met with
heavy security. Protests in
the capital on Nov. 28 were reportedly
canceled amid foot patrols and
flashlights from police vehicle lines.
According to Reuters, the streets
of Shanghai were sealed off with metal
fences on the same day to prevent crowds from
gathering. As police cars and
motorbikes passed, cops in luminous
vests patrolled in pairs.
Large barricades have been put up along
Shanghai's main protest route, and
police have made many arrests.
Universities in China have been ordered to ban
student protests and to send students home
early for the New Year holiday.
Despite growing public anger and the terrible
effects on the world's second-largest economy,
Chinese leaders pledged to stick
with the policy.
Xi Jinping's Dilemma – Placate
or Crack Down
As of Dec. 3, CCP
President Xi Jinping has made no public
remarks regarding the wave of protests
sweeping the mainland. The current
question is whether Xi's government will back
down. After a decade in power,
Xi's biggest political challenge may
be suppressing protests, which may
quickly weaken his influence.
If the zero-COVID policy is quickly
canceled, there may be an increase in the number
of deaths, but if the blockade remains
unpopular, protest movements may
become more dramatic and spread throughout China.
Following the CCP's
20th National Congress in October,
Xi seemed to have been tremendously successful,
breaking the law for a third term
and promoting his tried-and-true loyalist
to positions of power. Xi not
only put his zero-COVID policy to the
test at the 20th National Congress,
but he also appointed Mr. Li Chang,
a former top assistant in charge of the
Shanghai blockade, as a second character
in the CCP.
Charles Parton, a former
British diplomat based in Beijing,
said, whatever happens,
it will overshadow the start of Xi Jinping's
third term. If he implements
zero-COVID and the consequence is negative,
he would easily show mistakes and damage
people's faith in him and the party.
The issue will only worsen if the economy
continues to deteriorate.
While there has been no sign that China will
use force to suppress the protests,
the memory of Tiananmen Square from 30 years
ago still casts a long shadow over the
period when pro-democracy demonstrators
were brutally crushed by armed soldiers.
Estimates of the death toll range from
a few hundred to several thousand.
Beijing supported
the Hong Kong police in 2019
to crack down on the anti-extradition protest,
particularly before China passed the
Hong Kong national security law and
utilized it to persecute dissidents.
According to
Yasheng Huang, professor of global
economics and management at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology's Sloan School,
one possible scenario is that the authorities
could appropriately ease the zero-COVID
policy while cracking down on some of the
protest leaders, which would give them some time.
Earlier,
CCP foreign ministry spokesperson Zhao
Lijian avoided a related question from
reporters, saying,
what you say does not reflect what happened.
China has always followed the flexible
zero-COVID policy and made adjustments based
on the actual local situation.
As a result,
how the government responds to future protests
will be determined by how far the protests
expand and how open and compatible the
challenges to Xi's power become.
Harry Link,
professor of UC Riverside at the University
of California, Riverside.
The repression is predictable,
and a kind of person like Xi Jinping's
willingness to respond to protests is
clear.
According to the Epoch Times, a bipartisan
group of U.S. senators sent a sharply
worded letter to Beijing's ambassador to
Washington, Qin Gang, on December
3, warning of grave consequences
for the U.S.-China relationship if the
communist regime carries out a crackdown
reminiscent of the 1989 Tiananmen
Square massacre. According to
the letter, we are following the current
peaceful protests in China over your
government's policies very carefully.
We are also closely watching the Chinese
Communist Party's reaction to them.
According to
Gordon G. Chang, a China analyst,
if President Xi Jinping decides
to shoot protesters too soon,
he will anger the Chinese people even more.
The economy is
now in a death spiral, unlike in
1989, and he can't buy anyone
off. The decision
not to ease zero COVID will not
be accepted in the whole of China.
The era when the CCP could threaten the
Chinese people is over.
More people are expected to resist
the CCP's ruling.
According to Bloomberg, the risk is
that a forceful approach produces its own
response, trapping the country in a cycle
of escalating repression and resistance.
That is highly unlikely.
The CCP has a long history of
dealing with potential challenges, and
today's China is far from the liberal intellectual
climate that allowed the Tiananmen Square
movement to thrive.
But, as Mao Zedong once said,
a single spark can start a prairie fire,
citing an ancient proverb.
The Communist Party understands this better
than anyone else.