John William Godward - Part 2: A Closer Look at Formal Aspects of His Art

John William Godward
2 followers
We examine Godward's painting approach, and some of his compositional devices. We examine the role (or lack) of allegorical significance in his art. What was Godward's conception of beauty, and how did it differ from the views of 20th Century art critics?
"Neglected By Art History" - Episode #2.
Most of this part is based on my own observations, however, I also draw research from:
"J.W. Godward: The Eclipse of Classicism" by Vern Grosvenor Swanson, PhD
Welcome to Neglected by Art History brought to you as always by the Better Barbarians Bureau.
In this series we look at some great artists and artworks that have been buried by time but deserve
wider recognition. If you appreciate this video please like and subscribe. I'll be posting a lot
more like this. And now John William Godward part two a deeper dive into the formal aspects of his
art. In our first video we looked at the life and character of John William Godward. Today we're
going to be looking at his art. So it's going to be just focused on his art not so much biographical
information. If you're interested to know more about him and you didn't catch that first video
go ahead and watch that one. I will link it here. John William Godward had a pretty limited
repertoire. He's tended to repeat the same sort of motifs and compositional devices over and over
again. Always almost always focused on the classical beauty. That was his main subject.
Now within that limited repertoire there are some sort of tendencies or compositional devices
that you could use to make a make different groupings. And that's what I've done. So we're
going to look at several different compositional devices or groupings common themes within that
sort of restricted theme that he is obsessively focused on. And after we look at some of these
common themes then we're going to look at some pictures that don't fit the mold. Some paintings
he made that fall outside of those those common themes that he was sort of always returning to.
After we look at those pictures that like I said don't fit the mold that are sort of outside of
the usual. Then we're going to look at some examples of what I what I think are his best
artworks. And then we're going to ask the question where does John William Godward rank
in the in the grand halls of artists? Is he a great artist? Is he just a good artist? Is he
top tier? Is he second tier? Third tier? How should we think about John William Godward
in the in relationship to human artistic production on planet earth? Okay.
Hey this is a note from post-production. I realized I can't fit all of that into one video
unfortunately. So I'm gonna have to break it up into two videos. I am really ready to move on
from Godward because I've got a lot of other things that I want to cover in this series.
But I think that there's just so much to say about Godward and he really deserves
time and attention because he hasn't received it from almost anybody over the last century.
So we're gonna spend a little bit more time with Godward than I intended to. I hope you'll
enjoy it anyway and we will be covering a lot more different artists moving forward
and bringing in a lot of interesting themes. So please do stick around to see what will
be coming up after these next two videos with the deep dive into Godward's art.
One more thing I recorded all of this while my baby daughter was asleep in the next room and
so my voice like right now is very low and quiet and kind of gravelly and I do apologize for that.
I will try to make the next video with a more normal sound. Again, I'm not trying to do an
ASMR type thing here. It was unintentional but if you do have trouble falling asleep at night
maybe it will help. So we're gonna start with portraiture and portraiture is not one of his
most common genres. However, he made hundreds of paintings in his life and probably portraits
amount to maybe I want to say 10% or less than 10% unless you count those full figures as
portraits which I don't really think that's an accurate way to look at them. So for portraiture
I'm mostly talking about works of art paintings where it's really the head, you know, and upper
shoulders and really not much else. So I've selected five different portraits for us to look at
and I chose them because I like them. Some of them are kind of notable for being a little different
than things he usually painted but also because each of the faces in these is distinct which I
tend to think of as something important to portraiture. You know, you're supposed to capture
the likeness or essence of the individuality. Whereas I feel that many of his figures
he tends to gravitate towards a single type, especially a single type of face that he seems
you know drawn to over and over again. So whereas each of these show a face that's you know very
different, I would say the face type that he seems most drawn to is the ones that you see depicted
in these two paintings. So it's sort of a round face or a face with soft rounded edges and full
lips, you know, nice proportioned kind of face but sort of soft and not very angular. So let's
and talk about them individually. I chose the first two because I like the facial structure
of these models. They're very recognizable and I think he did use both of them frequently.
This one I think is the color in the photo itself seems off a little bit. It's a little
oversaturated and a little bit too red. I don't think that the original looks this way. But this
one seems pretty true and you can see just his characteristic clarity. Clarity and smoothness.
You know, Godward was not an artist who cared for sort of brushy texture, what people tend to call
painterly style. I don't like this word painterly. I don't think it's an appropriate word. Obviously
a painter who paints like Godward is also painterly. He's painting. He's using paint. He's
a master of paint obviously. I think it's just silly to call expressive or loose brushwork
painterly. But whatever you want to call it, Godward is definitely the opposite of that. He's
the opposite of that loose brushy expressive sort of style you might associate with the
impressionists or the romantic painters like Turner or who's the other guy? Delacroix. These
sort of people who had very open brushwork. I have quite a lot to say about that, but I think
I'll save it for a little later on. Anyway, again, I chose these two portraits because I felt that
these two models had a very particular facial structure that was unique and recognizable.
Whereas Godward seems to gravitate more towards this type of feminine beauty that is a little
more generalized. He seems to like this very soft face that recurs over and over again. Honestly,
I don't think he makes it up. I think he does just seek out models who sort of have this tendency
and he prefers them to models who like these two have more sort of unique facial structure.
Now these next two are probably my favorite two portraits that Godward painted. I find them both
alluring and mysterious and just gorgeous. So let's look at them a little bit. I want to let
I don't know anything about these in terms of the historical context, in terms of who these were.
I'm just going off of the art. This one, maybe if we want to read into it context,
there is this relief behind the figure, which I was looking at it and trying to figure out
what culture that is. You might think Greek on first look, but it's actually not. That does not
look very much like the archaic Greek style, which would be the closest style of ancient
Greece that it would be. You might think Mesopotamian, but the Mesopotamians didn't really
draw the faces and hair like that. So then looking a little bit closer at the hands
and the particular shapes of the beard and the hair, I'm thinking this is actually Canaanite.
So it looks to me a lot like that hybridized style that existed in ancient Canaan that was a
mixture of Egyptian and Mesopotamian. So then, if I'm right, this would be some sort of a Canaanite
princess. It looks to be with her golden crown of leaves. Again, that's very reminiscent of
ancient Greek, but could just as well have been any part of the ancient Mediterranean.
And I just love the subdued colors in this one, how he was able to make such an evocative
painting just with a little touch of burgundy and this splash of light right in the center of that
golden crown. Just such an alluring painting. The look in the model's eyes,
a very beautiful model. This one definitely is more Godward's type in the sense that she has
these very soft features, sort of like I've called before, almost nondescript. You know,
she could almost be anyone. This seems to be the type that Godward really gravitates to. But
at least in this particular painting, I am cued into whatever he's cued into. It's very beautiful.
And he does seem to be playing with the paint here. The way that he's painted the hair is sort
of soft and a little bit brushy. I was talking about how his brushwork is tight and not loose,
not painterly, as people like to say. Except here, it almost is in the hair. So he's playing
with the tightness in the face and the way he's rendered the clothes. And yet this looseness
in the hair and this sort of very warm, nondescript background. Just a very beautiful,
simple, elegant painting. Now, this one is very unique in Godward's repertoire
for a couple of reasons. One, she looks modern. Something about the way she's wearing her hair
reminds me of the 1920s style or something. She doesn't seem to fit in with this sort of ancient
women that he tends to depict. So it's interesting that she looks like she could be
from modern times. Of course, she probably was meant to be an ancient Greek or something,
who knows. But like I said, just the fact that there is something reminiscent of the modern
era in this painting. Again, the looseness in the hair and that wonderful contrast between the loose
brushwork of the hair and the tight brushwork in the face. And in this one, again, a very striking
model who actually, he's captured sort of a little bit more unique facial structure
than he typically gravitates towards. And then the background in this one is just
totally careless. It's almost like some Leonardo da Vinci paintings where he just
doesn't care so much about the background and just puts in something dark. So something about
this combination of the oscillation between the tight and the loose is very pleasing in this one.
And of course, the model's native features there, that wonderful red hair, that's just such a
beautiful thing. And he's depicted it so well. And now this one, I don't know how anyone could
not be amazed and astounded by this artwork. This is an incredible, incredible painting.
Every inch of it is masterfully painted. It's all tight. Whereas those other ones,
obviously, I did say it is pleasing to have the oscillation between the loose brushwork and the
tight brushwork. But it's also very pleasing here to see just this insanely tight brushwork everywhere.
And yet, it doesn't feel forced. It all feels very lucid. And you get a sense of the joy that
particular artist had in rendering surface details. He just loved it. He lived for this.
And it really comes through in this painting. And this isn't my favorite, but it is an amazing
artwork. And I would say probably more amazing than those other ones, just that you don't tend
to see something like this in a portrait that often. And it's a cliche at this point to speak
of an artwork that is lifelike, or that feels like it could spring into action any moment.
It's a cliche because throughout the ages, artists and people who are speaking about art have
talked about things that way. And we're used to sort of looking down our nose at that type
of description nowadays. But this artwork really does have that feature where you really do feel
like you could reach in and touch her like she could move at any moment and you almost wouldn't
be surprised. And that is an incredible feat for an artist working at the time that he was working in
with oil paint. I found these really delightful closeups that and there's only three of them.
This is the only one that I know which larger section it comes from. The other two that I'll
show you, I actually wasn't able to find the whole portrait that they're taken from.
But let's look at each of them. It's really, really beautiful to see up close. I mean,
you still can't really see any individual brushstrokes, which, you know, again, we're so
used to praising brushy, again, quote unquote, painterly works. And we're sort of we tend to
want to roll our eyes when people talk about, oh, wow, you can't see the brushwork as if this is
some sort of a great, you know, sign of mastery, because supposedly, you know, we've moved beyond
that. And certainly I can appreciate both. But, you know, I mean, it there's really, I think,
no reason not to be sort of awed by the fineness of his attention. I could probably go back and
find whatever portraits these these are close ups of it. But if I had unlimited time,
unfortunately, I don't. Please like and subscribe. It will help me to get to the
point where maybe I actually can do this as a full time job. And then I will be able to
offer you that higher level of service in, you know, the academic accuracy of all this.
But, you know, let's just take what we can take from this. I mean, again, here you see
Godward's love of this very round, nondescript type of general generalized, almost generalized
female face. And then this one is much more a face to my liking. There is just something
incredibly beautiful about this woman. And I really do wish I could see the whole portrait
of this one. So I will probably one day I'll go back and try to find this one. Oh, my God,
what a beauty. And you get the sense that Godward poured over these women's features
with his eyes because he couldn't pour over them with his body. He would have probably loved to
have made love to all these women. And I'm sure he probably did make love to a few of them.
I did talk about his sort of reclusive and silent sort of Asperger's syndrome
kind of personality in the previous video. And it seems that that his sort of social awkwardness
would have precluded him having that many dalliances with models. It is known that he,
you know, he did so-called run away to Rome with one of his models. And, you know,
like I said, I'm sure he had a few affairs with different models, but he doesn't seem to have
come across as as a real Don Juan type. And so it's tempting to kind of see him and his fixation
on feminine beauty through this lens of just adoration of this object that he would like to
touch. But he can only touch with his eyes. He can only touch with his optic nerves. And
and at least he thinks at least he can do that. He can worship their beauty through tracing it
with his with his visual senses. And I suppose with his hands as well. Right. Because painting
at the end of the day, it is a physical thing that you do with your with your arms, your hands.
Is this overall total involvement in it? And now, ladies and gentlemen, we come to
the marble bench category. This, in my opinion, is the most iconic compositional device of Godward.
However, he did not invent it. It comes from the work of Alma Tadema. And I think it is also one
of the best pieces of evidence that we have to prosecute the case that Godward indeed did study
with Alma Tadema. He's he's basically just lifted this compositional device straight from Alma
Tadema and and employs it probably more often than Alma Tadema even used it. But anyway, let's take
a look at it. So it's not just the use of a marble bench that that checks this one off. I think there
have to be at least these three things to really make the to really qualify the artwork to fall
into the marble bench category. First off, it's always outside. Second, it's got a marble bench
or a low marble wall that could be either one of those curved marble benches or a straight one.
And whether it's a marble bench or a wall, it separates the foreground from the middle ground.
And then the third thing is there's almost always the ocean in the background, at least in all the
most iconic versions of the marble bench category. You should see the following three things outside
marble bench or wall and the ocean in the background. Now, you know, needless to say,
there should also be a beautiful woman in there, too. But I mean, we've already established that
that is pretty much always present in every painting by Godward. This is one of my favorites,
and I love the color, the composition. It's a really pleasant artwork to feast your eyes on.
I mean, I guess it's got it all, right? It's got everything that Godward sort of
is known for. You've got the fur, the marble, the beautiful woman with the flowing dress,
slightly see-through gauze. You've got the lily pond and then the atmospheric landscape,
this sort of sense of a Greek or Mediterranean climate. Speaking of the landscape, there is one
thing that I could criticize, and this is something that is probably one of the only things that
bothers me a little bit about some of Godward's paintings, which is the color he uses for the sea.
In this one, you can tell that he's used two different pigments of blue, one for the sky and
one for the sea. And I find, I don't know, I just find that that's sort of, I mean, I don't know,
it doesn't feel right to me anytime that I've ever tried to paint a body of water.
It generally is going to be reflecting the same base pigment and then you'd just be adding some
darker tones or lighter tones depending on what's going on with the reflection. But
there's something odd to me about that, the fact that he seems to have used a cerulean blue or
something like that for the ocean and then an ultramarine for the sky.
So, you know, maybe a little bit technical, maybe not like a big deal for a lot of people. I just
feel, I also feel like in general, his oceans are too saturated. And this is an interesting thing
because Alma Tadema, I think, tends to make his oceans a little too dark or like all over dark
and you don't get the glimmering light on the ocean that you would expect in Alma Tadema.
And Godward, yeah, it's also sort of like there seems to be less attention given to the water
and, you know, and his are just too saturated. Whereas Alma Tadema's are too dark, his are too
saturated. And yeah, I can't recall seeing too much interesting things with going on with the,
with, with like reflections, that sparkling sense that you can get on the water sometimes.
So, you know, maybe Godward as a landscape painter, that's just, that's not where he shines.
His landscapes tend to be sort of backdrops for these classical beauties that he loves to focus
on. And they're not, and they're good backdrops. I mean, they're, they're, he has a great sense of
the atmospheric perspective. Very, you know, pretty where he places each cypress tree. They're
okay, but yeah, they're more backdrops, aren't they? Interesting. Something that you could easily
miss in this one are the little mosaic tiles on the floor or like near where she's sitting. It's
incredible, the sense of perspective, you know, that would have allowed him to create these in
such a sort of, in such a believable way. And just, again, this, this insane level of attention
to detail that he had. And this is a, another classic kind of example of the marble bench
sub-genre and this curved marble bench that I spoke of before. I really like this one too.
I think, I mean, I asked myself, you know, what is it that makes me like one Godward more than
another? There's just, there's some that stand out and, and this one stands out. The saturation
of the colors is very pleasant. I am, you know, critical of the oversaturated sea and some of his
flowers. Yeah, I guess you could, you know, you could complain a little bit about the oversaturation
in the flowers, but I do like the saturation in the dress, the ochre and the red. And it's just
a very pretty model for this one. She was, you know, he had a, he had something good to work
with in this model, her graceful pose. And this thing playing with the kitten, this was something
that he did from time to time. You see a lot of these, the peacock feather, you know, again,
things that resurface time and time again with Godward. I love this very realistic effect that
he, that he often employs with this sort of, I don't know what you would call it, this, it looks
like maybe some sort of algae that grows in between the cracks of the white marble. It's,
it's something that I can recall seeing in, in white marble constructions of a certain age,
you know, when they're, when they're a certain, when they've been around long enough. But,
you know, so obviously something he's paid a lot of attention to. If I, again, if I want to be
critical, I could, I could complain a little bit about the shadows in his marble sculptures.
He, I tend to feel that a lot of the shadows in the marble sculptures,
they depart from the light logic that, that like I expect. And this one has a more subdued light,
like this is obviously not supposed to be like a direct overhead, you know, afternoon light. It
seems more like kind of a late afternoon, almost getting to where the sun would be a little more
golden, but not quite there yet. This is kind of what I'm picking up. And there's like some sort of
maybe a big shadow being cast by a building that's sort of diffusing the light and preventing like
direct sunlight from hitting anything. But I'll show a few other instances maybe later on where
I think that sometimes he fails when we've got like direct sunlight to sort of calculate the
right kind of shadows, especially on sculptures. He does, he does pull it off sometimes, but he
seems to do better with a more diffused light situation. So this one's called Idleness. It's
one of his more famous artworks. And again, you can see the kitty with the peacock feather,
one of those common themes that he liked. Again, we've got the curved marble bench with the ocean
behind it. These things seem to always go together. Anytime you see the curved marble bench,
it's usually outdoors, and there's an ocean behind it. It's just, we've just got a few plants here,
like these oleander flowers, and a very pretty yellow dress. Again, the pose, kind of similar
pose to a couple of these other ones we've looked at. And there's just, there's something about the
model in this one. Just, again, a very pretty model, something nice to start off with. And
she's just framed in this wonderful white marble that Godward loved. Again, we can see that the
light, even though it's outdoors, and you know, it's kind of a bright day, the light is still a
bit diffused. It's not harsh light. The color of the sky indicates that it's also not like
too late in the afternoon, but maybe, you know, a little bit late. Or, again, maybe there's just
some sort of shadow that's like being cast that isn't, you know, very dark, but it's enough to
diffuse the light. Again, Godward seems to stay away from those sort of situations where you've
got really harsh light and shadows. He seems to enjoy the diffused light. And whether he did that
on purpose, because, you know, maybe it's just a challenge that he didn't like, you know,
confronting. Maybe he liked sticking with the things that he knew he could do well. Or whether
this is just what he, what pleased him. You know, I'm not sure. It might be a mixture of both. I
think that he loves form. He loves symmetry. He wants his models to be consistent.
And so, you know, he's not as interested in light. He's just not. He's interested in form.
He's interested in physicality. And light is almost a distraction, I think, for him.
Okay, now this one is fun. Time and, what's this one? Youth and Time. Youth and Time, 1901.
So this one is likely a self-portrait of Godward. It's not, I don't think it's for sure,
but it just seems likely that this may be a self-portrait of Godward.
And, you know, so in that sense, it is touching, I think. There's something touching about this.
Even if it isn't a self-portrait, he definitely projected a lot of himself into that male model,
that figure. So the male figure there is definitely a stand-in for Godward, if it's
not Godward himself. And you can just get a lot of, a sense of Godward's personality from this
in many ways. In the previous video, I joked around calling him a simp. And, you know,
I think there's some truth to that. But then, by the same token, I'm going to kind of argue
for him a little more in this. Like I said in the video, being sympathetic to the simp.
I think that there's something beautiful about his level of dedication and passion for feminine
beauty. The sad part of it for me is the way he holds himself aloof. He is so respectful of
the woman, of this feminine goddess that he worships, that he doesn't let himself
embrace the sort of manly vigor that most women—I don't know if it's fair to say most,
I think it's fair to say most—a significant amount of women tend to be more attracted to.
And again, that's, I think, why the simp thing comes to mind. Because the man who conforms to
image, the image of the simp that we kind of have now, he's so in love with this idealized
feminine beauty that he places himself in a position that makes him—he wants so badly to
be of service to demonstrate his gentleness because, you know, men can be scary because of
their strength. And he wants so badly to show himself to be a gentle man and a supportive man
and a man that she can be safe with that he renders himself less attractive to the object
of his desire. And there's something very sad about that. Now, you know, you may have noticed
I'm not diving too deeply into the meaning that Godward himself intended. This is sort of like
what I'm taking away from it. But this—and one of the reasons that I haven't been doing that
so far is because Godward, I don't think, really puts too much meaning into any of his artworks.
They are what they are. They're surface level and the surface is the depth and there is depth
in the surface, you know, so to speak, in the sense that beauty is a deep subject and it touches
deeply even when it is surface level. So, you know, instead of really going deep into figuring
out like, you know, what is the meaning of idleness or what is idleness, you know, interest
Godward so much, which, you know, I suppose somebody could make an interesting exploration
into that. I'm going to save it for the works like this where he—you can tell that there is something
that he's trying to say here. Now, the something that he's trying to say is indicated in the title
youth and time and by the fact that there is a sundial behind the woman. So, you know, I'm just
making this up off the fly here, but I'm guessing that, well, I'm guessing that there's something
about time that's either preventing them from being together, whether it's that they need to
wait until they can be together or that's threatening them the possibility of them being
together. So, it may be that, you know, he's losing his opportunity to be with her because time is,
you know, is bringing them towards a situation that where it will no longer be possible.
And or it may be that too much time has gone by. Maybe he's supposed—he looks a bit ageless. It's
kind of hard to tell what age the man is there. And it could be that, you know, he is too old
for her now. And so, maybe that's what is going on here. There's a lot of different things you
could read into it. And, you know, I should revisit the book on Godward by Verne G. Swanson
because I do remember he talks about it a little bit, although I'm not sure if anybody really
knows. But anyway, now, because I felt a little bit bad about beating up on Godward over his
shying away from light and shadow, I did want to show you three interesting images of his paintings.
Paintings where he really did advance towards that challenge, meet it, and succeed. Now,
one thing you will notice in all three of these images is that while the light and shadow does
feel very convincing on the surfaces where you see strong shadow edges, it's not really
displayed on the models quite so much. There's a few areas on these models sitting on their
marble benches, and there's a few areas in the back of the neck, you know, the wrist or whatever.
But the shadow edges aren't that strong on the models. They're still a little bit more diffused
compared with the marble bench. However, I mean, this is really striking when we look at this
image of a woman in some sort of an exterior kind of garden space where there's a beautiful
dappled light. You know, you get the sense of the light being filtered through the leaves and,
you know, shining on the wall there. But again, we don't see that on the body or the clothes
of the woman herself. So again, there is still this sort of tendency to shy away a little bit
from displaying that sort of a strong light and shadow on the form itself. Anyway, I really do
think that especially these two of the marble bench are very impressive examples of light and
shadow. And so I just did want to kind of share that with you so that I'm being fair to Godward.
Okay, well, I didn't get through as much as I wanted to, but I think it is time to wrap it up
for now. A couple final observations based on things that we looked at today.
The first has to do with this topic of meaning versus superficiality. I was looking through
Vern Swanson's book on Godward again today, and it struck me that Godward has more complex
arrangements with more figures earlier on in his career. And he actually gets less complicated
and starts focusing only on that single female figure as time goes on. So I think this is even
more evidence to suggest that he was indeed studying with Alma Tadema in the beginning.
And I can imagine Alma Tadema influencing him to try bigger arrangements, more figures,
more complex dynamics going on in his paintings, urging him to be more allegorical like Alma
Tadema was. And yet over time, what we seem to see is Godward distancing himself more from
the influence of Alma Tadema and coming into his own, maybe embracing his Asperger's type of
single-minded dedication to that one thing he loved, highlighting the classical beauty.
And I had this insight while I was asking myself why his paintings of full-figured women
don't feel like portraits. This was an important question when I was selecting portraits to talk
about in the beginning of the video. And I kept coming back to this, well, why don't I think that
these full figures are portraits? And it struck me that this isn't a portrait because it is,
in fact, an allegory. Godward does paint allegorically, but his only allegory is beauty.
It's the only allegory he cares to paint. The classical beauty is a stand-in for the broader
term of feminine beauty. And feminine beauty, in turn, is a stand-in for beauty in general,
in the most basic sense for him. And this explains why it is that modern art critics despised Godward
so much. Beauty became taboo in the modernist era unless it was found in unexpected places.
Godward is not out to challenge anything and certainly not out to challenge notions of
the beautiful. Or what is beauty? This is not a question that he is interested in. For him,
beauty is simple, direct, and his response to it is honest, uncomplicated,
and very sincere. And to me, that is very beautiful. Thanks for watching Neglected by
Art History. Tune in next week for more on Godward. I just made a very exciting discovery
about him, his life, and a very interesting turn of events involving a model that he was in love
with. I will be tying this story into a continued analysis of his art. So if you enjoyed that and
you enjoyed the first video, I think you're going to really like it. And as always, if you appreciate
the work that I'm doing here, please like and subscribe. It helps me out a lot. Ciao for now.
