John William Godward - Part 1: The Last Painter of the Victorian Age

John William Godward
2 followers
A look at the tragic life of a painter who outlived his era's aesthetic paradigm, and was condemned to obscurity by the changing tastes of the art critics and historians who dominated the 20th century.
"Neglected By Art History" - Episode #1.
Draws heavily upon research from:
"J.W. Godward: The Eclipse of Classicism" by Vern Grosvenor Swanson, PhD
On Wednesday, the 13th of December, 1922, the artist John William Godward put a blank canvas
on his easel. What would he paint? Maybe one of the classical beauties he was known for,
executed with his signature precision and insane level of technical skill. But no,
not this time. It was 1922, after all. Modernism was in vogue, and work like his was now seen as
extremely passé. Instead of starting a painting, he changed his mind. He scribbled a note that read,
this world isn't big enough for me and a Picasso. Then he pulled out a revolver
and shot himself in the head. Except, this story isn't quite true. First off, this isn't John
William. It's a picture of his father. No photos of John William Godward exist because, after his
suicide, his mother, who was deeply ashamed of what her son had done, destroyed all traces of
him from the family record, even going so far as to clip him out of family photographs. Second,
that quote that was supposedly from his suicide letter, that quote, this world isn't big enough
for me and a Picasso. Yeah, he never said that. It's out there on a bunch of websites, but as far
as I can tell, that quote comes from the artist's nephew, Peter John Godward, who said of his uncle,
the world wasn't big enough for Picasso and John William Godward. It seems the only thing John
William wrote before committing suicide was a note that said, gas, which he pinned to his door. Which
brings us to the third thing, he didn't shoot himself. He killed himself by turning on a gas
stove and insulating his head in with it. It was actually very considerate of him to warn whoever
came to his door that the apartment would be full of gas. What is true is that he died with a blank
canvas on his easel and that he was very depressed about the rise of modern art and the sharp decline
of the public's regard for classical art. It's also true that he was a virtuoso with the brush,
capable of mimetic effects that few other painters could rival, especially when it came to
surfaces and textures like marble and fur. His ability to render the human form often
approached photorealism. And after his death, he slipped into obscurity. An obscurity that his work
is only just starting to escape from thanks to the internet. Welcome to Neglected by Art History,
brought to you as always by the Better Barbarians Bureau. In this series, we look at some great
artists and artworks that have been buried by time but deserve wider recognition. If you appreciate
this video, please like and subscribe. I'll be posting a lot more like this. And now,
John William Godward Part 1, The Last Painter of the Victorian Age.
John William Godward was born on the 9th of August, 1861, the eldest of five. John William
was named after his father, John Godward, who worked as an investment clerk for a life insurance
company. According to Verne G. Swanson, John seems to have been successful, though not rich.
The Godward family would have been considered respectable bourgeois and puritanical. So,
to me, that sounds like the Godward family was middle class or upper middle class by today's
standards. Also, note that Swanson points out how the family was very strict and conservative,
very conscious of their image and their standing within the community. Now today, we may look back
on the paintings of John William Godward and see these very innocuous, sweet images that seem to
painted with exquisite brushwork and think, well, these seem like pretty conservative images
compared to what we are used to in art and media. Even his nudes and scantily clad women exude a
sense of dignity that does not lean too heavily on the grosser side of sexuality. It might seem
like these would be perfectly acceptable within a Victorian context. And of course they were,
by and large, but not necessarily within a puritanical Victorian context and that, my friends,
was the context of the Godward family. So, first off, you have Godward's failure to follow in his
father's footsteps and become a respectable insurance man. Then he chooses to be an artist
with his parents think is not a respectable profession. He paints scantily clad women,
which makes them uncomfortable. Later on, he runs off to Rome with one of his models and
lives there for 10 years. That, to his parents, was downright scandalous. Some of the sources
I read say this was when his mother started to clip out his image from photographs.
And then, finally, you have the fact of his suicide. The shame was too much for his mother,
who survived him by 13 years. She made sure no trace of her son's existence would remain to
shame the Godward family name. Ironically, of course, no one remembers the Godward family name
at all unless it is in connection with that black sheep of the family, John William,
who generated in his life hundreds of incredible paintings. I could not find the exact amount,
but he was definitely prolific. Because his style was so at odds with the prevailing modernism that
flourished by the time of his death, no one was really paying attention to him anymore.
No one really wrote about him or his art. And in the century that followed, if he was mentioned
at all, it was only to ridicule him and his art as passé and pastiche. He would basically be used
as an example of everything that was bad in art. Everything a good modernist or post-modernist
should avoid. As a result of this, there is really only one book that I could find about him. Like,
literally, no one else has written a book on this guy. At least, not that you can find on Amazon.
In fact, all the websites and blogs that I looked at all seem to draw their own information from this
same book. Luckily, it is a very thorough book and I was able to get a lot out of it.
The book is called JW Godward, The Eclipse of Classicism by Vern G. Swanson. Swanson is a
professor of art history and one of the few people from the 20th century who had the balls to stand
up for Godward and his art. When I say he's from the 20th century, I don't mean he's not still alive.
I think he is. In fact, Professor Swanson, if you're watching this, thank you for writing this book.
What I mean to say is that in the 20th century, it was much harder to stand up for art like this
than it is today. Maybe that's because we were closer to the modernist era. The level of derision,
the weight of condescending attitudes of the mainstream from mainstream artists and mainstream
art critics, it was heavy, it was intense, and the effect it had was withering. Anyway, if you like
Godward's art, you should definitely buy this book. It's got hundreds of color images of his paintings
and it's very well researched. As you can see, I've already marked it up quite a bit as I was
preparing for this video. Pinning a face to John William Godward. I did say that no photos of John
William exist, but that's not quite true. No adult photos of him exist. There is this one photo of
him as a child. That's him there, on the right, beside his mother. I guess she didn't have the
heart to cut him out of this one since he was still a child here. Anyway, there are a few
candidates for self-portraits that might show what he looked like as an adult. He rarely painted
anything besides women, but he did occasionally paint a pair of lovers or would-be lovers,
and it seems reasonable to assume that he may have used himself as a model for one or more of these.
This could be him, or this could be him, and this is also a candidate. Now, in his baby photo, he
looks like he might have been blonde, but a lot of times hair darkens after childhood, or he may
have painted himself to look more like an idealized Italian and thus fit in with the Roman settings of
his paintings. Of these three, I think these two are most likely to be self-portraits. This guy's
face looks different to me than this guy's, plus he looks too cocky and confident to be Godward.
Godward was known to be timid, reclusive, and shy. We may want to believe the opposite when
looking at his sensually painted women, many of which exude such a palpable sense of sexuality,
but it seems that Godward was not so much a Don Juan as, well, kind of a simp. More on that later.
Anyway, when I see this painting, basically, I see a simp. This is definitely the portrayal
of a simp. He's sad. He doesn't even have the courage to gaze directly at the object of his
desire, which is placed above him. It's, uh, yeah, it's kind of sad, isn't it? Now, I'm not saying I
can't be sympathetic to the simp. Guys, we've all been there before. We've all been a simp at least
once, and Godward worshipped femininity. I mean, it's all he painted. He definitely sees feminine
beauty as an exalted thing, something that he wants to place up on a pedestal. Anyway,
if we are trying to pin a face to John William, I prefer this candidate. It also has a melancholy
air to it, but it shows the artist more as a dreamer, and in dreams, perhaps, there is a
sort of redemption, at least when those dreams go on to produce a tangible reality as wonderful
as the art of John William Godward. Godward and Alma Tadema. Now, you should know that out there
on the internet.com, you can find a lot of misleading information about Godward. I mentioned
the myth that his suicide note said, this world isn't big enough for me and Picasso, which makes
a great story, even if it isn't true. Another common myth I found was that Godward was the
student of Lawrence Alma Tadema. Several websites I looked at say this, including Wikipedia.
He was the protege of Sir Lawrence Alma Tadema, but his style of painting fell out of favor with
the rise of modern art. It's easy to see why people would assume this. Both artists painted
scenes of classical Greco-Roman subjects. Both depict light and airy atmospheres and seldom deal
with dark or depressing subject matter. Both use very fine brushwork, smooth and masterful.
Both display impeccable form, and perhaps most notably, both excel at depicting marble and fur
textures. The similarities are so great that some unscrupulous art dealers actually erased
Godward's name from some of his paintings and forged onto them the signature of Alma Tadema,
because they knew the latter would fetch a higher price. However, despite all these
similarities between the two artists' styles, we have no direct evidence in the historical record
to confirm whether Godward ever met, let alone studied with, Lawrence Alma Tadema.
Now, that is not to say that it is impossible. It certainly could have been the case. Both men's
lives overlapped, Alma Tadema being about 25 years older than Godward. We know that both men
lived in the same area of London during Godward's youth, when he would have been studying painting.
Their stylistic similarities suggest that Godward may have studied with Alma Tadema,
we just don't know for sure. Swanson goes into depth considering all the different art schools
where Godward might have studied, and Alma Tadema would have been associated with a couple of these
likely candidates. We just don't have a smoking gun, so to speak. Undoubtedly, Godward would have
known of Alma Tadema's work. Undoubtedly, he was inspired to emulate it, at the very least.
But this may have happened from a distance. Of course, it is likely that they may have crossed
paths, but to what extent, again, we just don't know. Personally, I think it is quite likely that
Godward studied with Alma Tadema directly because the level of skill in his rendering of marble and
fur, to me, speaks of a direct transmission of technique. Precisely because the likelihood
seems so compelling, some people seem inclined to overstate the case, as if it were something
we know for sure. But if Swanson couldn't dig up conclusive evidence, I rather doubt that anyone
else has either. It is interesting to contrast Alma Tadema with Godward. I think there really is
no contest. Alma Tadema is the superior artist for a variety of reasons, the first of which
is variety. The types of scenes Alma Tadema painted, the types of compositions, they just vary
much more than those of Godward. While Godward's paintings tend to focus on a single female figure,
Alma Tadema often has more complex arrangements with a wider range of psychological dynamics
in the figures. His brushwork is a bit looser and more open than Godward's, which has a pleasing
effect because overall his form is still very accurate and very concrete. Alma Tadema also has
a wider range of color and value. While he certainly revels in the same open airiness and
bright Greek light that Godward is addicted to, still Alma Tadema can occasionally dive into
darkness and deep shadows with more sinister implications. Obviously, Alma Tadema deserves
his own video and I will probably be doing one on him next. But I point all this out here in order
to highlight a very interesting aspect of Godward, namely, his obsessive focus on this very
restricted theme of the classical beauty. Literally, that's like all he painted. Beautiful women in
Greco-Roman settings, hundreds of them, over and over and over again. To me, this suggests two
things. One, he was probably a bit autistic. And two, there is a commercial aspect to his art.
If we want to look at Godwin's repertoire with a cynical lens, then we can say that he just pumped
out these artworks according to a prescribed formula just for the market. And certainly,
Godward was commercially successful for a while, so it's not implausible. Between the years of 1896
and 1918, his work sold easily and he became a hot commodity on the London art market.
Particularly in the four years between 1908 and 1911, art dealers began to dive for Godward's
paintings, seeing him as a cash cow. So, did he just pump out these canvases in a dry,
soulless manner just for money? The repetition of some compositions would seem to indicate that
there was an element of this at play. And yet, I think stopping our analysis at this level is
crass. It doesn't give Godward his due. The other explanation, Godward as an artistic autistic,
also bears consideration. Swanson introduces this idea. According to him, Godward exhibits
all the signs of Asperger's syndrome, a condition commonly identified today as a form of high
functioning autism. People with Asperger's are often reclusive and shy, like Godward,
and can maintain an obsessive focus on a narrow range of topics. There may be a bit of the
idiot savant thing going on here, which further explains his attention to details that might have
driven most other people mad. Another interpretation of Godward's narrow focus is offered by the
historyofart.org, which says of Godward,
It is likely that Godward's habit of painting an image of perfection and
tranquility provided an escape from his own turbulent life. His own mother was known to
be strict and highly religious, though he would never include religion within any of his own
paintings, nor would he include any of the negative emotions that he experienced through
his relationships with family members in the atmosphere of his artwork. The tranquil world
that he created helped to attract considerable support for his career, at the point at which
neoclassicism was at its peak. Just a side note here, John William Godward was not a neoclassicist.
I have often seen this term loosely applied to artists like Godward, Alma Tedema, and Waterhouse,
but I think it is a gross misapplication and misunderstanding of the term neoclassical.
I'd love to make a whole video just on this topic one day. There's really no adequate term for the
style of these artists. You'll see it labeled as academicism or academic painting, but I think
that term is intended to sound derogatory. I'm just going to refer to it as late classicism.
But again, I will have to elaborate on this more in a future video.
The Eclipse of Classicism
Coming back to the contrast between Godward and Alma Tedema, there is one more important
observation to make. Because Alma Tedema belonged to the generation preceding Godward's,
the two artists had a very different experience. Alma Tedema lived most of his life in an era where
the dominant aesthetic paradigm was one that harmonized with his own. That is to say,
Alma Tedema lived in a world that appreciated his art. His art fit perfectly into the wider
cultural tapestry in which he lived. Godward, on the other hand, had the unfortunate distinction
to be born just at the right time to witness the changing of that aesthetic paradigm.
It was really a cruel thing for Godward to be born when he was. Had he been born 20 years earlier,
it is likely that he would have died only vaguely aware of the ways in which the world of art was
changing. Most of his life would have been wrapped comfortably in the aesthetic paradigm that made
sense to him. As it was, he got to spend part of his professional life in a world that appreciated
his art and part of it in a world that reviled it. The rise of modernism must have seemed at first
like the distant rumor of a thunderstorm. In the 1870s and 1890s, far away in France,
a new strange art had reared its head. Tales of these impressionists and post-impressionists and
their bizarre antics would have been things to shrug at or laugh at, to ridicule and dismiss.
But already, by the first decade of the 20th century, this new approach to art had spread
tendrils out from Paris to infect other metropolitan European cities like Godward's
London, the Fauves, the Blue Rider group, the Cubists. They were becoming harder to dismiss.
More and more people started taking them seriously. As Swanson puts it in his book,
even before Godward left for Rome in 1910 to 1912, the art scene in Britain had changed remarkably
from its former unified Victorian self. This we can see from the death of Sir Lawrence Alma Tadema
in 1912 when the Bloomsbury critics, such as Herbert Read, while his body still laid at rest
in St. Paul's Cathedral, disparaged the artist's saccharine, translate beautiful, predilections.
These cultural changes conspired to rob John William of what reputation he still possessed
at the height of his career. Here we can see clearly the reason Swanson chose to title his
book The Eclipse of Classicism. It is impossible that Alma Tadema would not have also noticed the
gathering storm clouds of modernism amassing on the shores of England. But he had already lived
a full life and received numerous confirmations of the public's esteem for his art. Godward,
on the other hand, had to witness the complete downfall of classic European art and the emergence
of a victorious modernism that scoffed at everything he loved. The move to Italy. It was around this
time that Godward decided to move from London to Rome. By 1912, the same year that Alma Tadema died,
Godward had transferred his permanent residence to an artist villa in Rome called the Villa
Strollferne. Not sure if I pronounced that right. It looks German to me. It contained multiple
residences with studios for working artists. His move to Rome seems to have been partly motivated
by a desire to flee from what he would have seen as the depressing developments in the London art
scene, but it was also partly because of his attachment to one of his Italian models called
Dolcissima. According to Verne Swanson, contrary to the family's contention that he passionately
ran off with his model, the author has another view. By 1910-1912, the artist's life had shrunk
in robustness dramatically. His attachment to his model, while genuine, was probably more one-way
rather than reciprocal. She probably provided the impetus for moving to Rome by her own desire to
return to Italy. Rather than being a wildly romantic decision of the heart, the dull Godward
probably pathetically followed her to Rome. This is more the Godward of fact, not fiction.
Ouch! Ouch! Ouch! That hurts! That stings, doesn't it? Oof! Our boy Godward was a simp! I mean,
I told you. That is the face of a simp. And look at Dolcissima. Doesn't she just look so
bored here? Like she's just barely tolerating the attention of this man. Poor Godward. My heart aches
for him but it is what it is. Apart from Dolcissima, Rome itself must have held some attraction to a
man who was all about the classical Greco-Roman world. We know he traveled down to Pompeii and
was keen to test the veracity of his own knowledge of Roman architecture and decorative motifs.
It is interesting that living in Rome and traveling to southern Italy did not really
change his art that much. His knowledge of classical motifs was fairly accurate before
his move and seeing many artifacts and landscapes firsthand seems mostly to have confirmed his prior
knowledge. He lived in Rome for about nine years before finally moving back to London.
We know little of what transpired during that time other than his continued artistic output.
Presumably his affair with Dolcissima would have fizzled out sometime along the way,
possibly not too long after he arrived. It seems that Rome was a bit slower to absorb the modernist
trends that were sweeping the rest of Europe, but eventually they arrived in Rome too, much to the
dismay of Godward. His last few years would have seen the Villa Strollfern crowded in on by an
array of vagabond squatters posing as avant-garde artists. When he finally moved back to London in
1921, he told a family member that Rome had lost its charm. He painted four paintings in 1921 and
six in 1922. That may seem like a lot given how detailed his paintings are, yet his average output
was 15 to 20 paintings a year, so we can see that in these last two years he was significantly less
prolific than usual. It was known that he was suffering from health problems exasperated by
chronic insomnia. In addition to this, his paintings were fetching increasingly smaller
sums by the 1920s. Finally, his art dealer informed him in 1922 that he would have to stop purchasing
Godward's works as it was becoming too difficult to sell them. Swanson writes,
this rejection by the world was the last straw and cue to leave the world. So it was that the
John William Godward chose to end his own life in December of 1922.
Now, I don't want to psychoanalyze his family. They belong to a different era and we have no
real way of knowing what they felt inside. However, we do know that after his suicide,
his mother destroyed anything of a personal nature that would remind her of her son,
and his brothers rarely ever spoke of him again. It seems that they were embarrassed by his life
and by his death, and not even particularly proud of his skill as an artist or his artistic legacy.
His sister, Mary Frederica Scott, was different. John William had always been closer with her.
Swanson says she, like him, was a bit of a black sheep within the family.
His affectionate nickname for her was Nin, and she is the only one who continued to speak about him
after his death, often referring to him affectionately as my brother the artist.
John William had helped support her family financially when she suddenly and unexpectedly
became a single mother. In his last will, he also made sure she received a generous portion of what
remained to him. He also left significant sums to his mother and three brothers, despite what we
must imagine would have been a strained relationship, at least between some of them.
As Swanson puts it, what was remarkable was John William's sensitivity to the needs of his family.
Another indication of Godward's character comes down to us through the recollections of Sir
William Russell Flint, a Scottish illustrator who met Godward while staying in Rome.
Flint arrived in Rome with letters of introduction from a mutual acquaintance, the artist William
Lee Hankey. Flint recalls Godward as exceedingly kind and helpful and says,
he knew all the ropes and didn't mind showing us how to use them. He goes on to recount,
I think I must have been rather stern with the models. I learned they had a nickname for me,
but I never found out what it was. Godward would not tell me, though he sniggered delightfully
whenever he thought of it. I knew his, but he knew it not. Good kind Godward. What a difference he
made to our Roman sojourn. Let these grateful words mask a tragedy. I would love to know what
Godward's nickname was amongst the models, but Flint does not divulge it. Obviously, he was
writing after Godward's suicide and he must have felt the need to protect the man's image
with his discretion, which I gotta say is a classy move. We can only imagine that whatever
the nickname was, it was probably not flattering or he would have shared it. I'm guessing it was
the early 20th century version of simp. I don't know, just throwing it out there. It seems like
the models giving nicknames to the artists was a common thing. Another of Godward's friends in Rome,
the artist Joseph Herbert Moore, was nicknamed San Giuseppe on account of the fact that he was
also very kind with the models. This Joseph Herbert Moore was close enough to Godward that
he is recorded as one of the two witnesses on Godward's will. The other witness was also a
painter, though this one was an Italian, Camillo Innocenti. The basic picture of Godward that
emerges from all this is a man who is quiet, shy, and reclusive, but good-natured and not
completely without social skills. He obviously enjoyed showing Sir William Russell Flint around
Rome's studio environment. It is thought that Joseph Herbert Moore, or San Giuseppe as the
models called him, was a close friend of Godward's and he must have been on good terms with Camillo
Innocenti as well. So, did Godward have Asperger's? I think it's likely, but was it so pronounced that
he was a total social failure? I'm guessing no. I think it was just enough to lend him the insane
level of focus he had on doing what he loved and virtually nothing else, painting beautiful women,
beautiful marble, beautiful landscapes, basically immersing himself completely in beauty as he
conceived it. And when he finally succumbed to suicide, it was not only due to depression alone,
not just because the world had turned its back on him and certainly not just because of Picasso.
It was due to a confluence of factors, not the least of which was the physical pain that he was
in from a variety of ailments that were increasing and showing no sign of abating. Anyway, there's a
lot more to say about John William Godward and his art, but this video is long enough already, so I'm
gonna save it for part two. Check in next week when we will be picking back up with a closer
examination of Godward's art as well as a look at the artwork of some of his contemporaries.
We'll ask, was he really a genius or did he maybe deserve to be brushed into the dusty waste bin
of history? What is the case for and against Godward as a top-tier artist? If you enjoyed
this video, all I'm asking is that you help me grow this channel by liking and subscribing.
It means the world to me if you do. See you next time.
