LIVE: House Budget Committee Continues Review of Budget for Fiscal Year 2025

Live News Network
1.4K followers
978 Video Views·May 19, 2025
The House Committee on the Budget continues the markup at 10 p.m. ET on May 18 to provide for reconciliation pursuant to the concurrent resolution on the budget for fiscal year 2025.
Okay, the committee will now come to order. Let me start
out of courtesy for my colleagues on both sides of the aisle.
Thank you for your patience and for being flexible and I
sincerely apologize for the inconvenience. I never want to cut your time short with your families
because it's so precious and few, those moments. I know that as a dad of three young children. So
anyway, I know this will happen, I'm sure, on both sides from time to time, but
I want to just acknowledge that. And if there's any way in the future that we can avoid these
things, you know I'll do it, Mr. Ranking Member. So any quick comment? Yeah, Mr. Chair, if you
don't mind, I do have just a couple parliamentary inquiries. Obviously, this is highly unusual.
The fact that we recessed after a failed vote Friday morning around lunchtime Friday,
now we're back here late Sunday night. So presumably, we are voting again because some folks
on your side of the aisle may have changed their mind due to some side agreements. So my
inquiry is, will the committee be able to see what side agreements have been reached?
Will they be added as either an MTI or just hear verbally,
reflecting the ways in which now apparently the bill has changed?
The deliberations have continued up to this point where we judge this reconciliation bill
or the many component parts as it relates to the budget targets that we've set.
And that is what we're voting on. Deliberations continue at this very moment. They will continue
on into the week. And I suspect right up until the time we put this big, beautiful bill on the floor
of the House. So that's what we're here to do. And we're not going to disclose the deliberations.
I'm not sure I could disclose all the deliberations.
Well, if I might, I certainly would.
I don't know anything about side deals or any deals. I just know we're at a place where we
can take a vote today and not have to be back here for multiple votes.
Yeah, I would just, in the interest of transparency, if the bill has changed and
there's been some side agreement reached, I think it's important that all the members
have the full details on that in advance of any vote. So that way we know in a transparent,
honest way exactly what we're voting on. You will get it in the manager's amendment
or like most of the members here. So I couldn't tell you what is in flux, what is fixed,
what might change or not change. As you all well know, this process is fluid and it will
go to the Rules Committee. Most likely there will be some changes. And that's the way the
process goes. So I know you appreciate that, having been through it before many times.
Finally, well, I haven't had the opportunity to be chair, but I very much look forward to
that year and a half from now. Finally, my other parliamentary inquiry, and again,
a very serious point. As you know, we all operate under the 1974 Budget and Impoundment Control Act.
It's what set up these committees, what set up Congressional Budget Office, requires a CBO score,
we don't have, unless something has happened this weekend that I'm unaware of, we don't have that
CBO score in front of us. Do you know when we will get the CBO score, both of the budget bill
that we're voting in front of us and the scoring of any changes that it looks like are going to
happen? I will look into the timing of any outstanding CBO scores. And I'm certain that
if there are outstanding scores, that those will be disclosed before our members vote,
before our members collectively, both Democrats and Republicans.
Before you vote on the floor. Yeah, yeah. But let's appreciate how far we've come.
And since you're asking me these, I think, relevant questions. We didn't even have,
the last time we did reconciliation, and the Democrats were in charge and had unified control
of Congress, it never even went through regular order, didn't even come to this committee,
so that we could even have this dialogue. We couldn't even have asked that question.
We ended up having to vote, I remember, because it was a Saturday,
and it was a 10-11 hour markup. That concludes my parliamentary comment.
Did the budget resolution come through this committee? It did not. There was not a
budget resolution substantive. There was a shell one, but there wasn't any substantive fiscal
framework from which you all and we would judge it. I'm just saying, we've run regular order.
We've done budgets twice since I've been chair, the two years that I've been chair. We'll do one
this year again for 26. And we haven't done a budget the entire time, no disrespect,
because we're getting off topic, but not one time in the last four years was there a real budget,
a 10-year budget, a budget resolution other than the shell. And I just think, we're doing
the people's business the best we can. You may disagree with it,
and we may not have all the pieces yet pulled together, but this is a response.
So keep it, and I appreciate you've always been good about the fact that we have a healthy,
vigorous debate here. And I think we both agree that that's good for the process and happen to
enjoy it. I'm not looking to relitigate the last eight years or 20 years. I just mean on
the bill that's in front of us, making sure all the members know transparently just what the
heck is in this thing, because obviously it's changing back in that back room by the minute.
And then the second thing is what exactly the score is according to CBO. I think both of those
things are important for all of us. And I think if the roles were reversed, to conclude, if the
roles were reversed, you would be saying the same thing. Well, no, I wouldn't, but now I will. No,
I'm kidding. No, look, when there is a definitive change, people will know that change. When there
are definitive changes, and they will be reflected if those changes should occur in a manager's
amendment. That's just how this works. So I appreciate the inquiry, and I believe it to be
earnest and in good faith, but that's the answer. Let's get on with this business if we can.
Okay, I now recognize the Vice Chairman, Mr. Smucker of Pennsylvania, for the purposes
of a motion. Mr. Chairman, I move to reconsider the vote to report the One Big Beautiful Bill
Act to the House. Representative Smucker moves to reconsider the vote on reporting
the reconciliation bill. Question is now on the motion to reconsider offered by
Vice Chairman Smucker. Those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Those opposed signify by saying
no. No. In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it, and the motion is agreed to.
Request to report a vote. A roll call vote is requested. The clerk shall call the roll.
Mr. Norman. In an effort to move this bill forward, I'm excited about the changes we've made
and I will vote present. What are the changes? Mr. Norman, present. Wait, what changes?
Mr. McClintock. Aye. Mr. McClintock, aye. Mr. Grothman. Mr. Grothman, aye. Mr. Smucker. Aye.
Mr. Smucker, aye. Mr. Carter. Aye. Mr. Carter, aye. Mr. Klein. Aye. Mr. Klein, aye. Mr. Bergman.
Aye. Mr. Bergman, aye. Mr. Roy. This is just to reconsider, correct? Yeah, this is just to
reconsider and then we'll have a vote on the bill itself. Mr. Roy. How is Mr. Norman recorded?
Mr. Chair, Mr. Norman is recorded as present. Does the gentleman wish to change his vote?
Wish to change my vote to yes. Continue. Mr. Norman is off present and on aye. Mr. Roy,
aye. Mr. Stutzman. Aye. Mr. Stutzman, aye. Mr. Moore of Utah. Mr. Moore of Utah, aye. Mr. Estes.
Mr. Estes, aye. Mr. Burkeen. Mr. Burkeen, aye. Mr. Obernolte. Mr. Obernolte, aye. Mr. Carey.
Mr. Carey, aye. Mr. Edwards. Mr. Edwards, aye. Mr. Clyde. Mr. Clyde, aye. Ms. Houchen. Ms. Houchen,
aye mr. McDowell mr. McDowell aye mr. Gill mr. Gill aye mr. Moore of North
Carolina mr. Moore of North Carolina aye mr. Boyle mr. Boyle no mr. Doggett mr.
Doggett no mr. Scott mr. Scott no mr. Peters mr. Peters no mr. Panetta mr.
Panetta no miss Watson Coleman miss Watson Coleman no miss Plaskett miss
Plaskett no miss Escobar miss Escobar no miss Omar miss Omar no miss Ballant no
miss Ballant no miss captor miss captor no miss Jayapal miss Jayapal no miss
Chu miss Chu no mr. Tonko mr. Tonko no mr. McGarvey mr. McGarvey no mr. Amo mr.
Amo no mr. chairman mr. chairman aye are there any members who have not voted or
wish to change their vote if not the clerk will report mr. chair on the vote
there were 21 ayes and 16 noes the ayes have it the motion is agreed to the
committee will now vote to favorably report the one big beautiful house the
gentleman from Virginia there's a parliamentary inquiry go ahead according
to CBO at least one policy in the bill would reduce participation and snap by
3 million people and we're hearing we just heard that there had been changes
in the bill do we have any official estimate from CBO on how either the
present bill or the whatever the bill is we're actually voting on would increase
hunger how many people would lose their snap benefits I think the gentleman from
Virginia I don't believe it's a parliamentarian a parliamentary inquiry
I will tell you this the bill has not changed there are no formal or final
changes and we're voting on exactly what we presented the other day last Friday
so further that let's continue with the further further inquiry last inquiry
I'm gonna entertain well do we have any estimates we never got an estimate on
how many children will lose school lunch certification by losing their snap
benefits do we expect that information do we care we debated this fully mr.
Scott we're gonna continue with the business at hand now the committee clerk
will you call the roll mr. chairman no more parliamentary inquiries we're gonna
finish this business okay guys the reconciliation bill that we debated and
that we discussed I just asked for the for the clerk to call the roll mr.
Norman president mr. Norman president mr. McClintock mr. McClintock I mr.
Grothman mr. Grothman I mr. Smucker mr. Smucker I mr. Carter mr. Carter I mr.
Klein mr. Klein I mr. Bergman mr. Bergman I mr. Roy mr. Roy present mr.
Stutzman mr. Stutzman I mr. Moore of Utah mr. you more of Utah I mr. Estes
mr. Estes I mr. Burkine mr. Burkine present mr. Obernolte mr. Obernolte I
mr. Carey mr. Carey I mr. Edwards mr. Edwards I mr. Clyde mr. Clyde present
miss Houchin miss Houchin I mr. McDowell mr. McDowell I mr. Gill mr.
Gill I mr. Moore of North Carolina mr. Moore of North Carolina I mr. Boyle no
mr. Boyle no mr. Doggett mr. Doggett no mr. Scott mr. Scott no mr. Peters mr.
Peters no mr. Panetta mr. Panetta no miss Watson Coleman miss Watson Coleman
no miss Plaskett no miss Plaskett no miss Escobar no miss Escobar no miss
Omar miss Omar no miss ballant no miss ballot no miss captor miss
captor no miss Jayapal mr. Jayapal no miss chew miss chew
no mr. Tonko mr. Tonko no mr. Mcgarvey mr. McGarvey no mr. Amo mr. Amo no mr.
Mr. Chairman?
Yes.
Mr. Chairman?
Aye.
Are there any members who wish to change their vote or who have not voted?
If not, the clerk shall report.
Mr. Chair, on the vote, there were 17 ayes, 16 noes, and 4 present.
The ayes have it.
The motion is agreed to.
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act is ordered, reported favorably to the House of Representatives
with a favorable recommendation.
I note for the record that a quorum is present.
Mr. Chair, now that the committee has voted on the reconciliation bill, I ask for the
requisite number of days for the minority to file its views.
So ordered.
Yes.
So request the requisite number.
Yes.
So ordered.
Thank you.
Without objection, the motion to reconsider has been laid on the table.
On the measure, just reported, staff are authorized to make any necessary technical and conforming
corrections prior to filing the bill, and the chair is authorized to offer motions to
go to conference pursuant to Clause 1 of House Rule 22 on the bill just reported, or any
companion measure from the Senate.
So ordered.
We will now vote on the postponed roll call votes on the motions to instruct.
The committee will now vote on the motion offered by Representative Ballant.
The clerk will redesignate the motion.
Motion number one offered by Representative Ballant.
Motion offered by Representative Ballant.
The clerk will call the roll.
Mr. Norman?
No.
Mr. Norman?
No.
Mr. McClintock?
No.
Mr. McClintock?
No.
Mr. Grothman?
No.
Mr. Grothman?
No.
Mr. Smucker?
No.
Mr. Smucker?
No.
Mr. Carter?
No.
Mr. Carter?
No.
Mr. Klein?
No.
Mr. Klein?
Mr. Bergman?
No.
Mr. Bergman?
No.
Mr. Roy?
No.
Mr. Roy?
No.
Mr. Stutzman?
No.
Mr. Stutzman?
No.
Mr. Moore of Utah?
No.
Mr. Moore of Utah?
No.
Mr. Estes?
No.
Mr. Estes?
No.
Mr. Burkeen?
No.
Mr. Burkeen?
No.
Mr. Obernolte?
No.
Mr. Obernolte, no. Mr. Kerry.
Mr. Kerry, no. Mr. Edwards.
Mr. Edwards, no. Mr. Clyde.
Mr. Clyde, no. Ms. Houchin.
Ms. Houchin, no. Mr. McDowell.
Mr. McDowell, no. Mr. Gill.
Mr. Gill, no. Mr. Moore of North Carolina.
Mr. Moore of North Carolina, no.
Mr. Boyle.
Mr. Boyle, aye. Mr. Doggett.
Mr. Doggett, aye. Mr. Scott.
Mr. Scott, aye. Mr. Peters.
Mr. Peters, aye. Mr. Panetta.
Mr. Panetta, aye. Ms. Watson-Coleman.
Ms. Watson-Coleman? Aye. Ms. Plaskett? Aye. Ms. Escobar? Aye. Ms. Omar? Aye. Ms. Ballant? Aye. Ms. Captor? Aye. Ms. Jayapal? Aye. Ms. Chu? Aye. Mr. Tonko? Aye. Mr. McGarvey? Aye. Mr. Amo? Aye. Mr. Chairman? No.
Mr. Chairman? No. Are there any members who wish to vote who have an award to
change their vote? And if not, the clerk shall report. Mr. Chair, on the vote there
were 16 ayes and 21 noes. The noes have it. The motion is not agreed to. Committee
will now vote on the motion offered by Representative Amo. The clerk will
redesignate the motion. Mr. Chairman, could we get a statement of what the motion is?
Would you please restate the motion by Representative Amo? Motion number two
offered by Representative Amo. Mr. Amo moves that the committee on the budget
directives chairman to request on behalf of the committee that the rule for
consideration of the bill make an order and amendment to implement President
Trump's request to raise the income tax rate for millionaires. A motion offered
by Representative Amo. The clerk will call the roll. Mr. Norman? No. Mr. Norman? No.
Ms. Omar, aye. Ms. Ballant, aye. Ms. Ballant, aye. Ms. Kaptur, I really don't
understand why this doesn't include billionaires but I'll vote aye. Ms.
Kaptur, aye. Ms. Jayapal, it was y'all's amendment. Ms. Jayapal, aye. Ms. Chiu, aye. Ms. Chiu, aye.
Mr. Tonko, aye. Mr. Tonko, aye. Mr. McGarvey, aye. Mr. McGarvey, aye. Mr. Amo, Mr. Amo, aye.
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Chairman, no. Any member wish to change their vote or any member
who hasn't voted who'd like to vote? If not, the clerk will call the report. Mr.
Chair, on the vote there were 16 ayes and 21 noes. The noes have it. The motion is not
agreed to. The committee will now vote on the motion offered by Representative
McGarvey and if you'd restate the motion, I think that's appropriate Bobby, so if
you'd restate that motion and redesignate that motion for the purposes
of our vote. Motion number three offered by Representative McGarvey. Mr.
McGarvey moves that the committee on the budget direct its chairman to request on
behalf of the committee that the rule for consideration of the bill make an
order and amendment to strike all sections of the bill estimated by the
Congressional Budget Office to reduce participation in the Supplemental
Nutrition Assistance Program. If the clerk will call the vote. Mr. Norman, no.
Mr. Norman, no. Mr. McClintock, no. Mr. McClintock, no. Mr. Grothman, no. Mr.
Smucker, no. Mr. Smucker, no. Mr. Carter, no. Mr. Carter, no. Mr. Klein, no. Mr. Klein, no.
Mr. Bergman, no. Mr. Bergman, no. Mr. Roy, no. Mr. Roy, no. Mr. Stutzman, no. Mr.
Stutzman, no. Mr. Moore of Utah, no. Mr. Moore of Utah, no. Mr. Estes, no. Mr. Estes, no.
Mr. Burkeen, no. Mr. Burkeen, no. Mr. Obernolte, no. Mr. Obernolte, no. Mr.
Carey, no. Mr. Carey, no. Mr. Edwards, no. Mr. Edwards, no. Mr. Clyde, no. Mr. Clyde, no.
Ms. Omar, aye.
Ms. Ballant?
Yes.
Ms. Ballant, aye.
Ms. Captor?
Aye.
Ms. Captor, aye.
Ms. Jayapal?
Aye.
Ms. Jayapal, aye.
Ms. Chiu?
Aye.
Ms. Chiu, aye.
Mr. Tonko?
Aye.
Mr. Tonko, aye.
Mr. McGarvey?
Yes.
Mr. McGarvey, aye.
Mr. Romo?
Aye.
Mr. Romo, aye.
Mr. Chairman?
No.
Mr. Chairman, no.
Any member wish to change their vote
or vote who haven't voted?
If not, the clerk shall report.
Mr. Chair, on the vote,
there were 16 ayes and 21 noes.
The noes have it.
The motion's not agreed to.
The committee will now vote
on the motion offered by Representative Jayapal.
And if you would, again,
restate what that motion to direct is
as you redesignate the motion.
Motion number four,
offered by Representative Jayapal.
Ms. Jayapal moves that the committee on the budget
direct its chairman to request on behalf of the committee
that the rule for consideration of the bill
include a point of order prohibiting the use
of a current policy baseline
to estimate the effects of a future amendment
between the houses or conference report on the bill.
This is the one you found very compelling, Mr. Chairman.
It was compelling, I must admit.
So there's another chance for you to vote yes on it.
Even after I've slept a couple nights,
it was compelling.
But I'm gonna say, you know,
the clerk will call the roll.
Mr. Norman?
No.
Mr. Norman, no.
Mr. McClintock?
No.
Mr. McClintock, no.
Mr. Grothman?
No.
Mr. Grothman, no.
Mr. Smucker?
No.
Mr. Smucker, no.
Mr. Carter?
No.
Mr. Carter, no.
Mr. Klein?
No.
Mr. Klein, no.
Mr. Bergman?
No.
Mr. Bergman, no.
Mr. Roy?
No.
Mr. Roy, no.
Mr. Stutzman?
No.
Mr. Stutzman, no.
Mr. Moore of Utah?
No.
Mr. Moore of Utah, no.
Mr. Estes?
No.
Mr. Estes, no.
Mr. Burkein?
No.
Mr. Burkein, no.
Mr. Obernolte?
No.
Mr. Obernolte, no.
Mr. Carey?
No.
Mr. Carey, no.
Ms. Escobar?
Aye.
Ms. Escobar, aye.
Ms. Omar?
Aye.
Ms. Omar, aye.
Ms. Ballant?
Aye.
Ms. Ballant, aye.
Ms. Captor?
Aye.
Ms. Captor, aye.
Ms. Jayapal?
Aye.
Ms. Jayapal, aye.
Ms. Chu?
Aye.
Ms. Chu, aye.
Mr. Tonko?
Aye.
Mr. Tonko, aye.
Mr. McGarvey?
Aye.
Mr. McGarvey, aye.
Mr. Amo?
Aye.
Mr. Amo, aye.
Mr. Chairman?
No.
Mr. Chairman, no.
Are there any members who wish to change their vote
or vote if they haven't voted?
If not, the clerk shall report.
Mr. Chair, on the vote, there were 16 ayes and 21 noes.
The noes have it.
The motion's not agreed to.
That concludes the business of the committee today.
I want to thank the ranking member, Mr. Boyle,
for working with me to make this meeting go as smoothly
as it did, considering all things considered.
I also want to thank the Congressional Budget
Office, the Office of Legislative Counsel,
for working with us and authorizing committees,
all the authorizing committees in this process.
The CBO provided extensive support and scoring
in the instructed committee's legislative recommendation.
The Office of Legislative Counsel similarly played
a fundamental role in drafting the legislative text.
I know a lot of long hours went into hitting
our aggressive timeline, and we all appreciate
their role in this process.
Well, tonight, the House Budget Committee took
a critical step to passing the One Big Beautiful
Bill Act and making President Trump's
America First vision a reality for the American people.
So let's go forth and deliver on what we promised
the American people.
Well, Mr. Chair, since you gave a brief close,
I think it's our turn.
Well, I'd like to kind of end on that one.
Well, I respectfully disagree, and this will
not be extended.
You only spoke for a few sentences,
so I'll keep it very short.
Obviously, the members on this side have
a completely different view based on at least
what was in the bill as of Friday,
and what I certainly think will be there.
CBO saying 13,700,000 Americans, at least,
will lose their healthcare because of this bill
for billionaires that was passed.
We will continue to fight it on our side of the aisle.
Well, with that, ladies and gentlemen, we're adjourned.
