China’s State Banks Sell Fake Gold and Fake US Dollars; Bank Chaos Beyond Imagination

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financement
According to High Wind News from Chinese Business View, the words Nanxiang Branch were mentioned in the chat records, so the bank involved was possibly the Nanxiang branch of a bank in Shanghai. Tencent News later confirmed the user had bought the gold bars from an branch of Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, or ICBC.
A bank in Shanghai was caught selling fake gold.
What's even more surprising is that it was a customer who uncovered the fraud.
The customer collected plenty of evidence, including surveillance footage,
leaving the bank no chance to avoid responsibility.
It's shocking that something like this could happen at a bank.
If even banks, as institutions with the highest credit,
are selling fake gold, who else can we trust? Who can we believe anymore?
The issue this man is referring to recently happened at an ICPC branch in Shanghai.
On May 7, this Chinese social media user revealed that a friend of his had bought
gold bars at a bank but found impurities inside them.
The user said,
Hey guys, my friend bought gold bars from a bank, and after melting them down,
they look like this. The teller at the bank outlet also had a harsh attitude.
The user also posted pictures showing two gold bars,
one clearly marked with the bank's name, cut open to reveal dark substances inside.
The user explained they intended to exchange the bars for jewelry
at a gold shop after picking them up from the bank.
He said,
Fortunately, we hadn't opened them yet and asked the gold shop for surveillance footage.
At first, the bank tried to blame the gold shop,
but my friend pointed out that the gold numbers and logos match the bank's records.
They urged others who previously exchanged gold bars to melt down their bars to double-check as
well. One commenter asked,
Are they selling fake gold bars? What's the dark material inside?
Others gave advice, saying,
Make sure the surveillance footage isn't lost. Get quality inspectors involved immediately.
Call the bank hotline and say you'll expose this to the media if they don't handle it properly.
The major state-owned banks always fear negative publicity.
According to high-wind news from the Chinese Business View,
the words Nanxiang Branch were mentioned in the chat records,
so the bank involved was possibly the Nanxiang Branch of a bank in Shanghai.
Tencent News later confirmed the user had bought the bars from a branch of
When contacted by the media, an employee at the bank said,
We're verifying the situation and won't comment for now.
A designated spokesperson will update on further developments.
The incident sparked significant online attention.
One commenter suggested,
Let's wait and see. If it's organized fraud, the entire batch should have issues.
If it's fabricated by the customer or online users, it should be easy to trace.
The bank sell gold bars sealed in plastic with identification labels,
certificates, and serial numbers, so investigation should be easy.
Another user said,
Even if the gold bars are fake, how are regular people supposed to know when they buy real gold?
Another user noted,
Fake gold has been common for years now.
People buying gold without verifying it are taking a huge risk.
Another commenter added,
Tungsten is the metal closest to gold in density.
Markets have seen fake gold bars with tungsten cores.
Normal weighing won't detect it.
A bank representative analyzed the possible issues that could have led to the problem.
First, during the quality inspection process,
although there are certificates, the tests are generally done by sampling batches.
Each year, the bank randomly selects gold bars from its warehouse
to be tested by third-party organizations.
So if the supplier swapped out the gold, some bars might have been missed.
Second, there could have been tampering during transportation.
Third, some bars are repurchased and then resold.
But gold companies typically don't perform destructive testing on repurchased bars,
so there's a possibility they were swapped by previous owners.
Afterward, ICBC's Jiading branch in Shanghai released a statement
saying that both gold bars were tested by the
Shanghai Institute of Measurement and Testing Technology.
Results confirmed a gold purity of 99.99% with no quality issues.
The suspected impurities were professionally cleaned off by the inspection agency
and were determined to be external substances attached after the bars were sold.
The customer accepted these findings.
ICBC emphasized that they provide buyback services for all gold bars sold
and encouraged customers to remain calm and avoid spreading rumors
to maintain a healthy online environment.
However, some content creators questioned ICBC's explanation.
One vlogger stated,
I don't really understand.
If the bank insists this is just external residue from after the gold bar was sold,
then looking at the pictures provided by the user,
it's clearly been cut open and there's black substance at the cut.
Are we supposed to believe that the user made this up
and deliberately smeared impurities on the break?
That's the only explanation if ICBC's gold is fine.
In that case, ICBC should sue the customer for spreading false rumors, right?
But so far, it looks like ICBC hasn't taken any action against the customer,
so it's hard to know who's telling the truth.
A vlogger recalled a gold jewelry store owner in Shenzhen
talking about some issues with gold on the market.
He said,
When you buy gold, let's not even talk about counterfeiting.
If you try to sell it later, there are many obstacles.
You need to keep all the certificates.
And when you sell it, the buyer will check the gold's quality.
If they find any issues when testing the gold, you can't even complain.
Buying gold is easy, but selling it is hard.
It's a bit like insurance.
When you buy insurance, there's lots of promises.
But when it's time to file a claim,
the insurance company will tell you,
we won't cover this and we won't cover that.
Another content creator also discussed the ICBC fake gold bar incident,
noting that when customers want to return gold bars to the bank,
they usually have to return them in their original packaging.
The vlogger pointed out a major issue.
If customers can't open the packaging or cut the bars open to check,
how are they supposed to know if the gold is real?
The bank doesn't trust the customer.
But are customers supposed to blindly trust the bank?
There's no way out.
Either the bank employees will be punished
or the people spreading the rumors will.
If the gold bars sold are proven fake,
it's pretty clear why they made them.
The purpose was to trick customers into buying fake gold as if it were real.
That's textbook fraud.
But if it's just a rumor spread online,
then charges like deliberately fabricating false information
or causing trouble would easily apply.
The situation baffled him.
If he were running a gold store and was selling such gold,
not only would he have been caught immediately,
but he would have been investigated at least 800 times.
But now when it comes to checking the situation at the bank,
the response is always unclear
and further investigations are said to be ongoing.
Reports reveal that ICBC faced a similar issue in 2012.
At the time, the bank responded,
saying they strictly controlled the quality of materials,
production and sales,
ensuring no fake gold was mixed in.
Every gold bar came with a quality certificate
and the bank promised to buy back the gold bars they sold.
Other state-owned banks have also faced accusations of selling fake gold.
As early as 2016,
residents in Shenzhen reported buying Zodiac gold
from the Agricultural Bank of China's Haiwang branch.
After several years,
they discovered that some of the bars had rusted.
When they asked the bank,
it claimed the gold was real.
In some cases,
banks will buy back the gold,
but sometimes they refuse.
Mr. Liang from Sichuan bought 100 grams from a bank
while working in Beijing in 2013.
By 2019,
he noticed rust on the bar.
When he tried to return it to the Bank of China in Sichuan,
they responded that because the plastic packaging had been opened,
it no longer met the buyback conditions.
The bank's fake gold bars
have also appeared on e-commerce platforms in recent years.
For example, in March,
the paper reported that Ms. Luo bought an 18-karat gold item
for about 200 yuan from an online shop in September 2022.
The item came with a certificate from a quality inspection agency,
showing that it was AU750,
meaning it contained 75% gold.
Ms. Luo then bought 13 more 18-karat gold pieces from the same platform.
At the time,
the buyback price for 18-karat gold was 274 yuan per gram.
She was happy to think she was getting a good deal,
so she stored all the items at home and didn't wear them.
Two years later,
while cleaning,
Ms. Luo noticed that one of her pendants had tarnished.
That's when she realized she had bought counterfeit goods.
In January,
Ms. Sheng from Heilongjiang reported to Chinese media
that on January 30th,
she purchased a 100-gram gold bar from a shop on Taobao.
When it arrived,
she found it was just rolled-up paper.
After contacting the seller on the platform multiple times,
she managed to get her original amount refunded,
but no one took responsibility
for the loss caused by the rise in gold prices.
She responded by saying the shop was under investigation
and suggested she get a refund.
When fake goods are sold on e-commerce platforms,
people criticize the merchants for putting profits before ethics.
But when banks sell fake gold bars,
people are just left deeply confused.
Additionally,
ICBC,
the Agricultural Bank of China,
and the Bank of China are all state-owned banks.
These cases have happened more than once,
and the authorities have handled them by suppressing public outcry.
It's no wonder people are now so uncertain about who they can trust.
In fact,
banks in China don't just sell fake gold.
They also deal in counterfeit bills.
Today,
when I went shopping,
I felt extremely embarrassed
because someone told me my money was counterfeit.
How do we know?
Look here.
There's a mark on the bill.
If it were real,
the color here would disappear.
This makes me really upset
because I trust the Bank of China.
Shouldn't the bank's officials themselves
check whether our money is genuine or not?
Imagine I'm traveling abroad in another country
and end up trying to spend fake currency.
It would embarrass all Chinese people.
What she described actually happened last year.
A Chinese tourist exchanged 100 U.S. dollars at the Bank of China,
only to find that both bills were from before the 2009 series.
One of the counterfeit bills showed clear signs of being fake.
The tourist told the U.S. cashier,
This can't be right.
I got this money from the Bank of China.
The cashier explained that they usually don't have a counterfeit detection pen,
but feel the raised 100 printed in the corner.
Real bills have a slight bump,
but on this fake one,
it was much more pronounced.
This is not the first time Chinese tourists
have received counterfeit money from domestic banks.
Even though the victims have complained,
nothing has been done about it.
In 2016,
a company in Wuhan sent 22 employees to Dubai,
and four of them were found using fake U.S. dollars at a duty-free store.
The police confirmed the bills were counterfeit
and passed the case to the local prosecutors.
Staff from the U.S. consulate in Dubai
said that if prosecutors believed the tourists were unknowingly using fake bills,
the case would be easier to handle.
But the challenge was gathering evidence from the Chinese banks
to prove the counterfeit bills had been issued there,
which was more difficult.
Four Chinese tourists involved in the fake dollar case were devastated.
One, Yang Yu,
said that he and his colleagues
had exchanged the money at a bank in China before their trip,
and they had no idea the bills were counterfeit.
Chinese banks are not just selling fake gold and fake money.
They're also involved in a scandal
where customers cannot withdraw their own money.
In 2024,
several bank cardholders reported
that their cards were suddenly limited without their knowledge.
Many went to the bank to request higher withdrawal limits,
but some gave up and stopped using their cards altogether.
These affected customers mentioned banks like the Bank of China,
China Construction Bank,
Agricultural Bank of China,
and Jiangxi Bank.
Many believed the banks were intentionally limiting withdrawals
Bank representatives explained the move was to prevent telecom fraud.
Customers complained that they had no warning from the bank about the limits
and no text message notifications.
According to Beijing News,
one customer, Li Yun,
said she was shocked when her salary card was suddenly limited.
She had planned to withdraw a reimbursement fund from the Bank of China,
but both transfers and ATM withdrawals failed
because she exceeded the daily limit.
What surprised Li Yun even more was that another bank card,
a Jiangxi Bank iClass card mainly used for her mortgage payments,
also had a limit imposed.
Li Yun had been using these two cards for years,
typically for small purchases,
and had never faced ATM withdrawal or transfer limits before.
Both banks imposed a new daily transfer limit of 2,000 yuan on her cards
without notifying her.
Shanghai Broadcasting Television reported that some cardholders
couldn't even transfer 1,000 yuan.
These customers believed the banks were trying to limit their money flowing out.
Many customers faced difficulties withdrawing their savings,
even fixed deposits.
Some were in urgent need of money,
but were told they couldn't withdraw.
Online users were confused,
asking if it's a fixed deposit,
why couldn't they withdraw it?
Other users advised people to always get a paper deposit slip
or confirm with the bank about their deposit
instead of relying on verbal promises.
One user analyzed the situation,
saying if there's a fixed deposit certificate,
the depositor will win any lawsuit.
If there's no deposit certificate,
it's hard to say.
A fixed deposit certificate is the only proof.
Without it, it's not really a fixed deposit.
Whether this happened because the depositor was greedy for high interest rates
or due to something else from the bank staff,
it's hard to say.
Another user commented,
so what happens to the money in the end?
If I really couldn't withdraw it, I'd be devastated.
Shouldn't the bank be responsible for this?
Another user offered advice.
After reading so much news about this,
I've decided to keep my money in a regular account for the past few years.
I refuse to make any fixed deposits,
no matter how many calls the bank makes
or even if they offer gifts.
I won't fall for it.
It's like trying to take someone's eggs
while they're watching your chicken.
Eventually, it's the chicken that's gone.
Another user said,
this is happening at more than one bank in Henan.
Customers ask to make a fixed deposit,
but the bank secretly turns it into a financial product or something else.
Many people without professional knowledge are misled
and some don't even know what's happening,
blindly signing based on the bank's advice.
My relative went through this.
Luckily, her family asked for the deposit slip
and when the bank said they didn't have one,
they realized something was wrong.
They rushed to the bank and found that the deposit
had been turned into a financial product.
In reality, despite various suggestions,
it's difficult to address these issues
without changing the broader system.
If individuals are unable to withdraw their own money,
it reflects a serious problem.
This is happening in 21st century China
and it is not an isolated case.
These ongoing issues raise questions
of whether systemic changes are needed.
