Bordeaux Wine Basics- 2nd Growth Wines

Wine World
13 followers
2 Video Views·May 16, 2025
There were originally 12 Second Growth wines but Mouton Rothschild has been elevated to First Growth status, Leoville has been split into 3 wineries and Pichon Longueville has been split into 2 wineries so there are currently 14 Second Growth Wines.
Hello everyone, Trophy Wine Hunter. Welcome back to my wine channel. Today I'm doing another
in my Bordeaux basics series. This time I'm going to focus on the second growth wines.
So please view my previous videos on the Bordeaux 1855 classification system and the first growth
wines. Alright, the second growth wines. There are actually 15 of them, but if you recall from
my previous video, one of them, Mouton Rothschild, was elevated. So here I've got the 14, I've got 13,
I've got one bottle that I don't have here. The 14 second growth wines, I've listed them in order of
how they were ranked in the 1855 classification system. So if you recall the 1855 classification
system, wines were ranked not based on quality, but on price per barrel. So how expensive they
were in the marketplace and a bit for reputation. And if you use those metrics, then the classification
system has worked out quite well and still holds true for the first growth. The second growth is
another story. And so I'm going to go through each wine, my kind of thoughts on each wine,
and some general thoughts, and also going to talk about super seconds, which is a term that you'll
find a lot that people are going to talk about. So before I go into each individual wine,
just want to talk about historical context. You'll find that there are a lot of Margaux wines,
particularly in the second growth level. That's probably because stylistically, our taste buds
have changed. So over time, when wines first began to be produced, they were sweeter,
and they were lighter and more delicate. It was a more refined taste. When people were drinking wine,
it was seen to be a upper echelon type thing, aristocrat type thing. So many people actually
didn't really like to drink wine at all. They were just wanted to have that high end status.
And so wines were sweeter, and more subtle, and quite frankly, not the same way that we
would like in our modern day palate. So nowadays, we like a little bit more full body wines,
more alcohol wines. And so that's what you'll find that a lot of people prefer some of the
fifth growth wines to some of the second growth, because stylistically, it's a little different.
And so that's the rationale that sometimes some of the wines that are in the growth system doesn't
work because the taste buds or our taste preferences have changed over time.
Let's go through each of the wines and kind of what I thought about what my thoughts are for
each wine. So at the top of the chain is Mouton Rothschild, but it's not here because it's been
elevated to first growth status. Right after that was listed a wine called Rosenzagla. This
wine comes from the Margaux region and the bottle I have here that I previously drank is 2006.
So Rosenzagla is a winery I think that's on the uptrend. The reason that I say that is it is not
that highly priced. It was purchased by Chanel. I was fortunate to visit the winery I think in 2019
and they've done a spectacular job in revamping the winery. Everything in the winery from their
fermentation tanks, it looks immaculate. So they will take a couple of years I think to get back
to that, their soul. The only knock I have on this wine, and that's what I remember 2006,
it's a very precise wine style. I don't think it has that opulence that Margaux is known for yet,
but I think they will develop that and so that's my assessment at this point. I think it's
undervalued. I think it needs a couple more years for them to really turn it around
and in the next little while you'll see very high ratings from Rosenzagla. So there will be a price
point where I think it is very undervalued. So I like that one. The next one is a wine also from
the Margaux region called Rosengazise. And the wine I have here is 1961 which actually was
spectacular. I didn't expect it to be spectacular because you're never sure but it was an unbelievable
wine. Rosengazise in the 50s and 60s was spectacular but unfortunately I don't think
they have been able to keep up with the improvements of other wineries. And that's the
problem. Every one of these wineries, in order to keep its status or keep its level, really needs
to put in a lot of money to upgrade and to be at the same level as other wineries. Rosenzagla
has done that. I don't believe Rosengazise has made the same type of investment. And so in my
mind this is a good wine but probably not at second growth status level at this point. I think
it's fairly priced because it's not that high priced but it's a wine that is interesting but
I don't think it's the best second growth wine. But it's affordable so if you get it it's kind of
nice to get a second growth wine. The next wine is called Livre Lacasse. Many people are very familiar
with this wine. This is a vintage that I have in my hand. It's 1999. And almost every vintage of
Livre Lacasse that I've had is strong. It's a very strong wine. I've also had the fortune of visiting
the winery. Very precise wine. Really a cab drinker's delight. Heavy, full body, lots of fruit.
They always talk about it being very close to first growth wines. I'm going to talk a bit about
that later on in my video. But excellent wine. I think it's fair value. It is expensive
compared to Rosenzagla. So it's a fair price. You're not going to get a deal on it at this
point because everyone knows it's a great wine. But again it's an excellent wine and of the
wineries that's probably the best. So in 1855 there was one Livre winery. Now they've split
up into three. Livre Lacasse is probably the best. Probably in my opinion, again it's personal
opinion, the worst of these three wines, although it's not that bad, is Livre Poivre. And Livre Poivre
again, this is the 98 vintage that I had. My recollection of every Livre Poivre I've had is
that it's decent but it doesn't wow you. It's kind of light in style. Quite light compared to the
other two. Livre Barton and Livre Lacasse. So again, fair priced. I don't think it's going
anywhere. It's not a winery that's on the, it's kind of just stable. And that's what I think about
Ras en Gazis. I think it's kind of stable. I think Ras en Segrè is going on the uptrend. I think
Livre Lacasse is already very, at a very high level. So it's got really no room to go. It's
pretty high end right now. The last of the Livres is Livre Barton. This wine has really made it,
formerly it was very austere and very tight. In the last couple of years, probably starting with
2009 vintage, it's been making some incredible, incredible wines and they've really somehow
stylistically changed it to be a much more modern style. So I think this is also a good deal right
now. Livre Barton is not priced at the same price as Livre Lacasse. And so you're going to get a
little bit more. So I would say it is also on an uptrend. I don't think people respect it as much
as they should. And I think there's some value to be had with Livre Barton. Next wine in the
system was a wine called Dufort Vivan. I will have a picture of it. I don't have the bottle with me.
Again, my recollection of that wine is from the Margaux region, quite okay. I don't think it's
at second growth status. It's fairly affordable compared to the other wines. But again, it's not,
I guess if you like second growth wines, okay, but it's kind of like rosin disease to me. It's kind
of, historically, it might be good, but the bottles that I have have been okay, but not
definitely at the level of some of the other second growths. Next wine is a wine called
Gras Loz. And Gras Loz is, to me, again, another wine that's kind of just stable. The price of it
isn't as high as some of like Livre Lacasse. It's okay. And again, every bottle I've had
in the last little while has been okay. Even great vintages like 2000 and 05, they've been okay.
I will mention that they've changed the bottles quite a bit. This is the 66 Gras Loz, which was
really good. And that's the thing. Historically, sometimes things go, I'm talking about modern and
historically, if you go back 50 years, a lot of these wines were really, really, really good in
the 30s and 40s and 60s. But not a lot of people can drink those wines anymore. None of them are
available to be drank and a lot of them might be passed upon. But we have to talk about modern at
this point. So the next wine after that is a wine called, again, from the Margaux region,
Chateau Lascombe. Lascombe, again, most people would consider it an underperforming wine.
And so not that expensive. But not that expensive, most times I'm talking about $150, $170
when we're talking about Lievre Lacoste, we're talking probably double that. And
Res La Cegla is getting up there about in between that. So these are not expensive bottles.
Historically, they're great bottles. But at this point, they're not producing
to the quality of some of the other wines like Lievre Lacoste. And I'm going to talk about these
down here. And primarily because they really need to have some impetus to kind of try and
get the wines up to a certain level. It takes a lot, a lot of work, a lot of years and a lot of
money and a lot of dedication. So it's really tough to do that and put in that type of work
and that type of money when you can already sell your wines. Next wine is another Margaux wine
called Rancantanet. Second growth, I'm surprised actually that it's second growth. The only good
thing I can say about this wine is that it's got a great label. I love the cold label. And at the
end of this video, I will give you a chance to vote on two of the wines to see which one I will
drink next. Because I'd love I mean, you always have to continue to taste wines and I can only
base it on my previous opinions. But sometimes I haven't went back to them for a while. So I
shouldn't go back. It's peculiar because most of the wines I'm going to talk to you about at the
end of this 1855 classification system are actually now performing a little bit better
than some of the higher end wines. There's again, two reasons for that. One is just
money and how much they've spent on it and what they've done. And two, I think again,
going back to taste preference, a lot of it has to do with taste preference. And our taste
preferences are generally drier and more full body. And these wines at that time were judged
by the buyers at that time to be probably a little bit strong. And these were a little bit more
delicate, especially from the Marco region. And that's perhaps why that affected the system.
So these are wines that we're coming down to that have done actually are quite quite well
known right now and probably well more well known than some of these other wines.
There's two Pichon's. And again, this was one of them. The Pichon family was split up,
the estate was split up. One side went to all the daughters, one side went off to the sons.
And so and so the one of them is Pichon Lalong, as come test. So that went to the
female side of the family. And then the other one is Pichon Veron. And this went to the male side.
Of the two wines, again, they're very similar, great wines, well priced, they kind of get full
price. So you're not going to get a value for them. Everyone knows they're great wines.
I would say in the last if you would talk historically,
and it goes back and forth within the decades, I would say, if you get older vintages,
between the 80s and the 2000s, perhaps I prefer the Pichon Lalong to the Pichon Veron.
Between 2000 to 2020, or modern age, I think Pichon Veron has performed a little bit better
in my for my taste buds. But Pichon Lalong has got the new winemaker, just in the last couple
of years that came over from Chateau Maros. And so he's a great winemaker. I've met him.
And so he's really doing some great stuff. And I was fortunate to taste 2018 vintage in Bordeaux.
They are making some incredible wines, and there's value here. I think they're going to
perform at a very, very, very high level. Pichon Veron is, I think, fully valued at this point.
Both are great wines. But if I had to choose right now, and they're the same price,
I would pick Pichon Lalong right now. They are going to really, really elevate their game.
And I think there's some value here. I think it is undervalued at this point,
whereas Pichon Veron is kind of at the right value at this point.
Next wine is one of my favorite wines is Ducoup Boucaillou. Boucaillou is kind of
with the beautiful stones that it's grown on in its vineyard. And this is one of my favorite
vintages. I still recall this vintage. 86 Ducoup is one of my favorite wines. Again,
probably full valued at this point. It's a great wine, but it also commands a high price. So
it's already at its peak. A wine like Diego Lacasse, like Pichon Veron, I think it's already
at the top of its game. And buyers recognize that already. And so you're not going to get any value
per se. They're great wines in their paper. Whereas I think with Pichon Lalong and also
Roslyn Segra, I don't think people have given them credit for their new work or their new renovations
or their new story in the last couple of years. And it takes some time for people to recognize
that. So you're going to get some value there. Next wine is Coste d'Esternel. And this is the
89 vintage, which was one of my favorites. And I will try to close up on all these bottles a
little bit later. Actually, I think there's some value here. I think cost has been underappreciated
in the recent years. So that would be the last 10 years. I think it's been underappreciated.
Historically, it's always been known as a great wine. But I think for some reason,
things go in trends, just like Chateau Lafite over the last five years was I think underappreciated
and only now is starting to appreciate in price. That same thing is happening with Coste.
Coste d'Esternel, I don't think had the same command of price because people were focusing
on how good Biobo was, how good Deku was, how good the Pichon's were. And everyone forgot about this
one. So I think it's a little undervalued. And I think I can see it coming back. It's always been
good. It's not that it's got any other. It's not that it's got some new trend. It's just for some
reason, it's been underappreciated in the marketplace. And last but not least is Chateau
Marose. Marose is good wine. I can tell you just from my personal experience, I've always found
Marose very, very tannic. And so personally, the style is very austere to me and not that homey.
It doesn't make me feel that homey. It's a very tight wine. So personally, I don't appreciate it
as much as other people. It's got, I think it's got its fans. And so I think it's full value.
So I think in that sense, there's not a lot to be had on value in that sense.
So I hope that's been useful. And now I'm going to go through just my views on Superseconds and
also just kind of pan through all these wines. So you can take a look at the labels. And then I will
also have a shot of the important ones. I don't have the bottle here, but I have had it in the past.
And I will have a little shot of the label. Okay, so here are the different labels. So again,
Margot region.
I wanted to just show the two bottles of Poirot Le Rose because it's so different. 66.
And look at the different bottle design in the label compared to 2017.
Blascombe. Again, Blascombe, I had the 2000 bottle. And again, that should be a spectacular
vintage. It was okay. And that's what I mean by kind of light. It's very delicate, but probably
not what you expect at a second-glass level. Ran Catanac. I actually love this gold label.
It's nice and simple. Then we have Pichon Baron and Pichon Lalonde. You can see I drink a lot of 86
because I really liked that vintage. It was a strong tannic vintage.
Then we have Deku Bukayu. Costesterno, 89, which also was a very nice vintage.
Really coming around to this wine. Really like that. And then Maros, 86. Again, very tight vintage.
Let's talk about this term super seconds. This is a term that kind of bothers me because this is
one of these terms that I personally feel is a wine snob gibberish. By that, I mean it doesn't
mean anything. It doesn't add to anything. It doesn't help in any way. It's just gibberish to
me. So what is a super second? It's a concept that some people say, well, there are certain
wines that taste like first growth wines, and they're so good, but they should be super seconds.
But that definition is not really that good because sometimes they include fifth growth
wines like Pointe de Canet. It includes third growth wines like Palmer. So that doesn't make
any sense at all because those wines are not even second growth wines. Also, I don't know how we can
have a super second. A second growth wine is supposed to be good already. So I don't know what
a super second means. Does that mean it should be equivalent to a first growth? If you say that,
then you don't understand the 1855 classification system. Because again, the 1855 classification
system is not about quality. It has always been about price per barrel and reputation. So what
you're saying is you would prefer any of these wines in terms of if someone had a choice and gave
you a bottle, would you prefer any of these wines to a first growth wine? And the answer, most likely
in most people's case, would be no, because the first growth wine is much more expensive than
any of these second growth wines. So that to me, that's why I think it's gibberish. Second growth
wines are supposed to be great. And there's no such thing as a super second because a second
wine should be super already. You can say that some of these wines are not at the standard of
second growth. I understand that. But again, you would never, almost never take a first growth,
a second growth wine over a first growth wine. That is to say, if I give you a choice and say,
I'm going to give you for free a bottle of wine. Between any of these wines and any of the first
growth wines, which wine would you take? In my opinion, most people, like 90% of the people
would take a first growth wine because all the first growth wines are way, way more expensive.
So as an example, I think the cheapest, any one of these wines off the yarn, $1,500 a bottle.
Lievre Lacasse, which is probably the most expensive of a second growth wine is probably $500
a bottle. So of course, if someone gave you a wine, you take the most expensive one. And
to somehow say, well, everyone in the wine industry, every buyer, every drinker in the world
is wrong. And this wine, Lievre Lacasse should be as expensive as Lafite is preposterous. That's
not what it means. So that's what I mean. It's a very confusing term. It means nothing. And
to me, it's just wine snobs wanting an extra word. Oh, you drink super seconds. Why don't
you just say you drink Lievre Lacasse? Or why don't you just drink Ducoup? It's just a word
that makes people feel that you feel better about themselves. Because I don't know. To me,
it means nothing. Like, I never talk about super seconds. I just talk about the wine.
And if you feel better, because, oh, I'm drinking super seconds, because I don't want to spend the
money to drink a first growth wine. Okay, but it doesn't. It's a first growth wine or a second
growth wine, right? And again, every super, every second growth wine should be super. So that's why
I get really bogged by this word. Okay, we come to the last part of this video, the fun part.
And I bought these two bottles because I haven't tasted them for a long time. So I'm going to put
this in the community section for a poll and ask readers what I should drink. These are two wines.
This is a Brand Caternet and Gras La Rose, 2017, both of them. Just bought them at the liquor
store. Haven't had these wines for a long time. Maybe I should give them a second chance. I kind
of didn't think they were, I kind of in this video said, well, they're not really second
growth material. I haven't had them for a long time. So let's try them out. So which one would
you like me to try out? Please put it in the vote in the community section on the poll.
Hope you've enjoyed this video. Love to hear your comments about your experience with
second growth wines. Until next time, happy drinking.
