Today, we delve into the heart of parenting exploring two diverse parenting philosophies amidst what can be a contentious and emotional topic. With so much confusion on the best way to raise our children well, I brought together two passionate and expert voices in the parenting sphere to help clear the mud.
Dr. Laura Markham is a clinical psychologist, mother, and advocate for Peaceful Parenting who inspires parents with practical information to choose connection and coaching over punishment and control. Abbie from “M is for Mama,” is a wife, mother of ten, and Bible-believing Christian, with 10 years of experience teaching high school Spanish, English, and ESL, who encourages parents to embrace the challenge of biblical motherhood and raise their children with love and wisdom.
Together, we'll explore the nuances, challenges, and joys of parenting through differing lenses, aiming to find common ground and understanding of one another.
Check out their books: Dr. Laura Markham: “Peaceful Parent, Happy Kids” and “Peaceful Parent Happy Siblings.” Abbie Halberstadt: “M is for Mama” and “Hard is not the same thing as Bad”
There is one phrase that I hear parents saying to their babies or toddlers all the time when
they're trying to stop an undesirable behavior. But what that parent doesn't realize is that
one phrase is actually doing the complete opposite. It is encouraging their baby or
toddler to continue to do that behavior and also do it more often. So in this video I'm
going to tell you what that one phrase is that you should never say and more importantly what
you should do and say instead. But before we cover what that phrase is make sure you click
on that free pdf document in the description box below to get a copy of the developmental
milestones you can be expecting in your baby's first year of life. So what is the phrase that
parents are saying all the time which is going to actually increase the likelihood of their baby and
toddler engaging in undesirable behaviors? It is when they say no, stop or don't do something. So
in your day-to-day life that might look like stop throwing the food off the table, don't throw your
toys, no hitting mummy, plus lots of other different varieties of the same thing. But this phrase
doesn't work for multiple reasons. Firstly when we say this phrase we as parents generally use
really really loud voices, lots of animated facial expressions, our arms are often waving
out of control and we often stop whatever we're doing to rush over to our little one to stop them
engaging in unsafe or dangerous behaviors. Now of course there's going to be times when you need to
rush over to your little one to ensure their safety but rushing over to your little one combined with
that big reaction, so the yelling, the facial expressions and the arm movements actually gives
your little one lots of attention and what they see through their eyes is mum or dad or whoever
the adult is, is being really funny. They've got really funny facial features, they're making lots
of movement with their arms and their voice sounds really cool. So for example if your little one is
sitting at the table eating some food and they're eating quite well, you might get up from the table
and go and make yourself a cup of tea. But in that moment your little one might be exploring with the
food and just accidentally or deliberately throw that food over the edge to see what happens, to see
what the food does when it lands. But what they see from you is you yell at them across the room
saying don't throw your food or stop throwing your food, you run back to the table and then you sit
down at the table and engage with them and stay at the table until they finish eating to ensure they
don't make a mess. But in doing that you've actually reinforced that behavior, you haven't told your
little one what to do but you've told them that by doing this action of dropping the food, mum or
dad is going to come rushing back to the table and then stay with me until I've finished and give me
that undivided attention. The other reason this phrase doesn't work is because it doesn't tell
them what to do. So often that undesirable behavior is happening because they either don't know how to
play with the toy or the item, they don't know what's expected of them or they don't have the
words to tell you what they want. So they can't tell you that they're finished or they're frustrated
or they're angry and unless you teach them how to play with the toy or what other words or actions
can be used, they're going to continue to do that undesirable behavior. Also kids at this age are
learning what words mean, they don't yet know them and if you are constantly using the same phrase
over and over, so saying no hitting, no hitting, no hitting every time they hit, what they are learning
and what they might start to associate is the phrase no hitting means that I actually hit because
that's what I do. Every time mummy says no hitting, I'm hitting her. So if I hear no hitting, what mummy
wants me to do or what daddy wants me to do is hit. So what you want to do is to stop an undesirable
behavior happening is to actually start to teach them what to do. So in the situation where your
little one is doing something that you don't want, the very first thing that you need to do is remain
calm. So we don't want to inadvertently encourage that behavior by having those big reactions, so
those that yelling, lots of facial expressions and lots of arm movements. You just walk over to your
little one and using a calm voice and a neutral face, what you would do is tell them what to do
and it's through telling them what to do that you're going to give them the skills to do something
else instead of that undesirable behavior. So if for example your little one is throwing blocks
across the room because they're finished playing with the blocks, what you would do is you walk
across to them, you would get down on their level, so that might mean you're crouching and you would
say it's finished, blocks go in the container until they start to copy you. Another example is
if your little one is hitting you, what you could do instead is in a really calm voice say pat pat
mummy and you would pat pat mummy and if they don't do that then that is when you would grab their
hand gently and you would start to use their hand to stroke your arm and when they do that desired
behavior what you want to do is give them lots of praise and attention so that might be smiling
and might be clapping and by doing that what you are doing is encouraging your little one
to do that behavior again. Now if your little one in that moment doesn't want to do what you're
recommending instead, so with the alternative activity, what you can use is natural consequences
in that situation. Generally natural consequences are better and that is because they are quite
quick, they're relative and they're easier for a baby and a toddler to understand. So if your
little one, once you've modeled to them that they can play with the blocks by putting the blocks on
top of each other rather than throwing them or they place them in the box if they're finished
and they still continue to throw the blocks, then you could simply approach them in a neutral voice
you would just say blocks are for building, not for throwing, blocks are going away and then you
just put the blocks away and what your little one soon learns is that every time I engage in
throwing the blocks, those blocks go away and then I'm no longer able to play with them and that is a
natural consequence of that action and it will soon help them learn that if they want to keep playing
with the toys or the blocks they need to use them appropriately otherwise mom or dad is going to put
those away. Now if your little one is throwing food off the high chair or the table and it's something
you want to stop, then click on this video here where I walk you through all the steps on how to
address this behavior so it does stop. Remember to click on that free pdf document in the description
box below and I will see you next week where I'll share more parenting tips and tricks.