Sword & Sorcery: Ancient Chronicles - Review

Relic Archives
18 followers
May 9, 2025
Hey everybody and welcome to Bits of Board where we're talking board games, miniatures, cards and
dice. My name's Michael and today we are finally doing a review for Sword & Sorcery Ancient
Chronicles. Now for those that don't know about this game it is a sequel to the original Sword
and Sorcery that kickstarted with Honours back in 2015. This was a high fantasy adventure game
that had its fair share of exploration and dungeon crawling and pit players up against
some very mean monsters in the process. It was a narrative driven experience ushering players
through a storyline split into parts between the base game and its expansions. Sword & Sorcery
Ancient Chronicles, this standalone expansion offers much of the same experience with new
monsters and narrative, chock-full of quests with only a few variations on the old formula.
Players still control their heroes, still romp around the map and still engage in rich dice
driven combat which safe to say borrows just a few elements from older dungeon crawl games around
like Descent whereby rolled dice not only show the outcome of an attack but also grant opportunities
to utilize extra abilities found on carried items, weapons and armor equipped. Unlike games like
Descent though the enemy figures are controlled all by the game's AI with monsters activating
after each hero. The game is tense and players can quickly become overwhelmed by the ferocity
of the monster forces but the game is never unfairly weighted against you and players should
know going in that hero death is not actually a sign of poor play and that even a handful of deaths
won't spell defeat or make a quest unwinnable with options to resurrect right around the corner
on each death. The Ancient Chronicles of base game like its predecessors contains about half of the
full storyline but don't go ahead thinking that it's only half of the full experience there is
still a fully fleshed out adventure here it's just there's going to be more to do later and also
you're kind of level capped and unable to gain your character powers after a certain point.
Fear not though that is when loot comes in and there are plenty of opportunities
to improve your character with gear. All the other character stuff will unlock in the next expansion.
Beyond gameplay Ancient Chronicles does just about everything it needs to transport you
the player into the Underrealm the dark and mysterious world which this campaign takes place.
When setting up a quest you only know the bare essentials of what's going on and there's always
a lot to be uncovered through exploration. There are randomized events like composition of monsters
order of events and on top of that we usually have a few elements hidden from setup details of which
contain within the campaign's book of secrets. Think of it like a structured choose your own
adventure novel companion for the game. Now pause if this seems like a game for you you want to see
it in action I've had a playthrough running for this one covering the first three quests of the
game if you want to go see it in action please go check it out but pay attention to the comments for
when I mess up because well more on that later. Unpause. I will begin by saying Sword and Sorcery
is one of the finest high fantasy adventure games around. Of its ilk we have Descent probably its
closest relative a very long-running adventure game series from Fantasy Flight Games. It's coming
into its third edition now but this is one of those games where hero players have to go up against
another player controlling the monsters. Sword and Sorcery you don't have to worry about that and all
those monsters are handled with the game's AI. Next we have Madara which differs a little in
theme but offers a similar gameplay experience with dice-driven combat, loot exploration,
branching objectives and narrative and tons of it. Then of course we have all of the gloom havens
which pretty much share no mechanics except the story-driven adventure side of things and then
let's say we've got Zombicide Black Plague which has all the dice rolling but a less focus on what
I would call progression and story. Now these games will come back to a little later along with my
recommendations but if you've played one or another in there it's definitely going to help paint the
picture of Ancient Chronicles by the end of the review. Now before we get into the actual meat
and veg of the review let's first take a look at that game loop overview. Over the course of a
single quest you will complete three phases of gameplay multiple times over and over again until
the quest is either won or lost. A quest is lost by running out of event cards or experiencing a
total party wipe with all characters reduced to zero hit points not being resurrected in time.
Victory conditions on the other hand are pretty much handled however the quest defines it but
it's often a result of exploration, killing a boss or reaching a total amount of time spent in the quest.
The first phase is the time phase. Here players will refresh their unique powers and abilities
and resolve effects like poison and bleed that have been inflicted. Heroes can also soul level up
here if they've gained enough souls and they may resurrect if they are dead and nearby a shrine.
The time phase acts as a kind of cleanup phase after which play moves into the battle phase
whereby each hero will take a hero turn and then draw an encounter card which will most likely
activate one or more enemies situated on the map beginning an enemy turn. During a hero turn a
player can take one movement action and a number of combat and action activities as determined by
the level of the hero and spoiler alert here the base game is going to be one or two activities.
Movement is kind of self-explanatory you move your character across the map the fun part here
though is that your movement can actually be interrupted with any number of action activities
or free actions helping maintain the game's flow but if you stop to use an attack activity
your movement is done. Action activities encompass a number of interactions a player can have with
the game world. They can open chests and lock doors and they can even search. On top of that
actions can also increase a hero's ability in one area or another. Heroes can dash to extend
their movement activation by one space they can focus to ensure plus one hit when they attack
or they can pray at a shrine of divine powers. So aside from those two the attack activity is next
and it's primarily used to activate a weapon currently equipped. You roll the dice as per
the weapon and then your target rolls defense. Defense involves multiple stages of resolution
but all in all it's quite nice and covers a rich array of attack effects available in the game.
Basically though for every hit rolled you get a hit that the defender will need to defend against
with all other symbols allowing the player to activate abilities on their equipment if available.
Once a player turn is done if there are enemies on the map the player draws and resolves an
encounter card and most of the time one or more enemies will activate. For each enemy you go to
their enemy scroll and check their AI. Basically you check each range condition and as soon as one
is met by at least one hero you finalize the target and carry out the attack instructions
as listed. For the enemy this may involve movement, activation of abilities, attacks
and other modifiers printed on the scroll. Once complete if there are more enemies to activate
you activate them next and if all activations have been carried out you move on to the next
hero turn. Noting here that turn order is not fixed but once a hero is activated during the
battle phase they may not activate again until next turn. Moving on though once all heroes have
activated the event phase begins and the top card of the event deck is resolved. If the card is
faced down it's flipped, resolved and returned face up to the pile with some of the events that
might come up being spawning monsters, treasures or traps and in some cases you're even directed
to the book of secrets to uncover a hidden part of the story driving the narrative. On the other
hand if the event card on the top is already faced down the card is simply discarded basically
meaning that you get a new event roughly every two rounds of gameplay. There are some exceptions
though and as I mentioned if the event cards are ever run out the game is over and you're lost.
But that's pretty much it you move back to the time phase and do it all again that's the gameplay
loop. Fairly simple right? Right? Let's just say the game throws in some added complexities which
is good but the Froger is also cursed. Review time. Sword and Sorcery Ancient Chronicles along
with the original games created probably one of the best high fantasy narrative adventures out
there. It's a camp yet serious a fun adventure that takes our heroes through a slew of different
settings where they meet all kinds of characters and enemies abound. The fact that you can set up
for a game and actually be surprised when things pop out at you that is definitely worthy of a ton
of praise because often when you play some epic board game that feels like there's this build
throughout it goes up and up and up and then snap the game is over and the narrative that you built
with all the gameplay just falls apart and becomes meaningless because that's it. That situation I
don't find happens here and while almost all of the quests lead to another the inclusion of an
ending paragraph in the Book of Secrets does wonders in bringing a fitting conclusion to the
quest as a whole even if you play as a one-shot although it does make you want to play the next
one. The quality of writing is a bit meh. Content is great and it's exciting but if I hear one more
but like I said it's camp, it's pulpy, I like it. So let's move away from the narrative move into
the actual drive of the game what makes you want to play it because narrative is great and all but
you know read a book, watch a movie. Here I want to talk about those gameplay drivers. It's pretty
damn good. Let's be real even if there was no story here I would have a great time simply chasing
the betterment of my heroes. That upgrade loop of dungeon crawling and purchasing better equipment,
leveling up, finding treasure, it's done really well here and without relying on the separation
of equipment too which is a killer. Another game I mentioned, Madara, it has a different loot deck
for each level of hero and each type of equipment that you can find and it's crazy and requires a
bunch of extra setup and organization and while it allows for some really focused character
progression I feel like that extra bookkeeping and organization is something that Sword and
Sorcery really doesn't need but that's okay. Sword and Sorcery's loot progression is simplified
somewhat and still allows for some very good character customization. My rough interpretation
of this loot system is at level one you utilize the standard equipment from the stash and if you
At level two you begin to purchase better equipment and reforge your old equipment to
become more powerful making you more likely to survive to level three. At level three you finally
get to make use of the treasure that you've looted from your journeys noting here that you've had the
opportunity to collect this treasure the whole time way back from level one so hopefully you've
decide who will use it and what powers you should pick to complement the selection.
Then finally at level four, the highest level for the base game, you'll be able to refine what you
have to fill in the gaps that you've missed along your journey. To me this progression just makes
so much sense. The game forces you to engage with its different systems to be able to survive
and I think it's just such a clever and elegant bit of game design. I hate using elegant but yeah
it's actually a lot of fun to see your hero get stronger and any grind that you have to get that
progression it's worthwhile. So what about mechanics? That gameplay loop we went through
earlier, time phase, battle phase, event phase, it's a real nice way of organizing all the different
pieces of information you have to manage each quest. Sometimes the game system injects something
else under one of those headings but more often than not it is very manageable. The combat loop
though, on the surface the dice driven combat is smooth. Roll for hits, activate powers, crush
defense. It's simple with a few layers but really enjoyable on its own. Like that main gameplay loop
the game system also likes to inject extra bits and pieces into the combat loop as well
and sometimes I really wish those elements could be much more streamlined. See I have this thing
and you can see it firsthand in the playthrough that I just don't deal well with having to go
back and forth between the reference and resolution. It's improved with practice especially getting back
into a sword and sorcery title but I feel it's still something worth mentioning here. See a lot
time ancient chronicles asks you to complete a series of actions in resolving an enemy attack
for example. The order of these actions is key as resolution of the first may determine something
relevant for the next and so on. So you have to do the thing, carry out all the things relating
to the thing, and then return to the reference continue doing the next thing. For me I found
myself struggling to come back from the reference because what all games have taught me is that you
Unfortunately sword and sorcery is just not that simple and it achieves a lot for it but I feel
like the flow of the game suffers because of it. On top of that the game also expects you to remember
key pieces of information that are not obviously telegraphed through running of its gameplay loops.
For example some enemies have a constant effect in play, some have things that only come up when
they defend, some only when they attack, some only when they attack with a specific weapon,
some only when they attack at night. You guys know who I'm talking about. The biggest culprit here
is my mate the Hob Gremlin, an enemy that I constantly overlook through my YouTube playthrough.
Let's take a look at him. Here we have the Hob Gremlin's AI, just a few basic sentences
Below that we have his additional rules. Here if the Hob Gremlin is attacked we should check its
Craven ability. As a part of the attack we as players need to be aware of whether or not the
enemy is in control of the area which they're defending. If they are they go from having no
defense to some defense, which is actually a pretty big difference in game. Simple, it's
reference, no worries. Moving on though we have two conditions to check when the Hob Gremlin
attacks. If it attacks with its stone blade we action robber and the defending player must make
a save or discard a random card in their inventory, ignoring the fact that this effect is a pet peeve
for me in any game. Still it also has bestial hunger, an ability that affects only the Hob
Gremlin's bite attack, and only if the attack is made at night, which is one of the event cards
that may be drawn and in play. My complaint here, aside from any fiddliness, is that while each power
relates to a specific attack from the monster, neither of these powers are referenced in the
actual attack portion of the card. There is no telegraphing. These are just things that you are
expected to remember on top of everything else that the game is throwing at you. And what's worse
with this guy, having a look at bestial hunger, if the bite wounds at night the Hob Gremlin is granted
an enemy power. And what's an enemy power you ask? Oh, it's just an additional set of rules that you
have to bear in mind whenever you activate the monster. And they're random, they could be anything.
All I'm saying is that there is a lot to look out for. I mean, let's take just a normal situation.
Let's say we draw the activate three enemies encounter card. The Hob Gremlin might just be
one of these three enemies. You still have two others to work out when resolving one encounter.
Now, personally I'm just a little salty here because I play Sword and Sorcery solo, and this
is a lot to remember for one guy. I will note that usually in a full game with real people,
monsters are handled throughout the group, so players only really have to be aware of
maybe one set of monsters at a time. It's actually not that bad, it's just I needed to vent and
probably warn some solo players about the bookkeeping required here. Basically, returning
to my point, Ancient Chronicles starts you off with this nice clean system of doing things, and
then it messes it up for you as you get more and more into the excitement. The more enemies you
face, the tougher your competition, the more you need to make notes, check your calculations,
and be sure that you're doing the right things exactly when the game wants you to do them.
For me, this is when the game should be at its quickest and its most frantic,
because it represents the most exciting elements of gameplay. Unfortunately though,
it grinds down to a slow chug, but it is a meticulous chug, one that allows for some
really interesting monsters, really unique critters that behave all these different ways,
and if you can get your head around it, and if you can take that bookkeeping in stride,
you are going to feel so damn good moving through this campaign filled with the unique life that it
is. Now, this of course extends out further than the combat loop. There are a number of elements
of gameplay that need to be modified by pop-up rules just all the time. We have conditions to
be aware of, minion activations, which be aware are separate to monsters, and in some cases there
are even some quest-specific changes, all of which need to be internalized to play this game smoothly.
But, play it you will. But what about post-game? You've played through the campaign, what next?
I would say play it again. Experiment with your character builds. Each hero has two different
alignments, each with different powers available to them, and causes different in-game effects,
including story narrative ones as well. There are five heroes in the base box, and even if
you're playing a four-player game, that one hero change-up will affect the party dynamic.
Actually, a very quick side note here on the hero count. I'm not a fan of less than four heroes on
the board because of the way that the game scales with the different hero counts. Monster density
just sucks under four players. You're pretty much spawning half of the monsters, and it just
doesn't feel nearly as epic as it should. Just, that's the aside there. Back into replayability,
and this will go to anyone that's actually replayed a campaign-style game. Sword & Sorcery
is no different. You are going to know on that second playthrough where everything is. You'll
know the story events, you'll know what equipment to bring, and how to tackle the different monsters.
Yes, there are still a number of randomized elements, but there's nothing that's going to
scream out shock value when it comes out. Now, it's not necessarily a bad thing story-wise. It's
just like watching a movie for the second time, and gameplay-wise it just changes the way that
you play. Your actions become more directed and focused, and while you can still take the
opportunity to explore missed opportunities and fix past mistakes, it's probably more fun creating
efficient killing machines by tackling each scenario with knowledge as your main weapon.
Now, just to be clear here, there are only two real ways to play the game post-campaign.
You can play one shots, or you can play the campaign again. There are no procedurally
random generated dungeons here, and I feel like it would be very tough to make your own scenarios
just because the way balancing with monster powers and stuff works. The difficulty could
just go anywhere. Good luck if you try though. Actually, speaking of difficulty, there are ways
to make the game easier and harder in the box, which is really handy for that second playthrough,
but I would stick with normal difficulty and no easier, especially your first games. It really
makes you make use of the systems at hand for survivability, rather than relying on good dice
rolls. Worth noting here that there is also a paid option, being the challenge set which kind
of expands how the monsters work. Pretty sure it's going to be available at retail, if not,
definitely through their web store or the next Kickstarter. Finally, what is always the elephant
in the room with these kinds of games? Yes, it's a dice chucker and it relies on luck like nothing
else, but only if you're expecting to get through a quest without dying. There are going to be some
epic fails in there, but on the flip side, there are going to be some brutal kills, and that
randomness, its only purpose is to build tension and create interesting situations where you really
have to puzzle out the best way to attack. In no way here does luck ever get in the way of a
well-earned win, and for victory, you only really need to be aware of the tools at your character's
disposal. Weapons, armor, and most importantly, those hero powers. So, for you guys, the difference
between me recommending this game whole of heart is whether or not you actually want to take the
time to get the game details right. Here I ask if you really want to dig in and familiarize yourselves
with the monsters and heroes you control. If your answer is yes, great, get this, get the first one,
you will love them. If it's maybe, then that's cool too, get the first one and build yourself up to it.
My bookkeeping complaints for that first one are far less of a problem than there are here.
For those, but you still want an adventure or a fantasy style game, let's revisit those games I
mentioned earlier. Descent I said was one of its closest relatives, but personally, I'm probably
not going back to Descent. Sword and Sorcery has been a complete replacement for me as far as look
and feel, and while the gameplay mechanics are different, I would much prefer to battle it out
with this one. Maybe the third edition will be a game changer, but I'm happy to wait and see there,
no rush. The next option is Madara, which shares a lot of similarities gameplay wise. AI monsters,
dungeon crawling, adventure. To me, it's probably a more streamlined experience, but in a good way,
where any corners cut actually improve the gameplay and storytelling experience.
It is very anime though, and way more over the top as far as campy goodness goes. Killer game
though, so if you're into that sort of thing, there's probably no better alternative. Gloomhaven
was next, and that's the game that you should play if you want to play a fantasy game, but also want
to do math and logic problems at the same time. It has exploration and adventure for days, just
without the dice chucking and more headaches. Alright, probably same amount of headaches, but
different reasons. Speaking of dice chucking and headaches, if you want to play a board game with
your mates, be set up, ready to play in 20 minutes with a rules explanation and beer in hand,
Zombicide Black Plague is an absolute goer. It's a medieval zombie survival mayhem game,
and it's chock full of these classic social situations that you can put together, like
leaving your mates to die on the sly and stuff. A lot of fun. Like I said though, there's probably
a lot less to think about. Sword and Sorcery Ancient Chronicles is a more than worthy successor
to the first game. It builds upon pretty much everything where it can, and it takes the approach
if it ain't broke, don't fix it, and try and make it more complex if you can. This complexity is
both a blessing and a curse. On one hand, the game can handle a bunch of new monster behaviours and
situations. On the other, the game sometimes feels bogged down if you don't have the patience to slow
down with it and take it all in. Games are long, but not overly slow, and if everyone knows what
they're doing, you can get to it in around 2 hours per quest, plus minus 30 minutes depending
on the quest, but expect to double that if you're soloing, triple if you're filming. Components are
great, although you're going to want a tackle box to separate all the bits for ease of access,
and the minis are all of a great level of detail, if not a little plasticky, but they bend rather
than break, so I'm a fan. It's definitely my go-to fantasy dungeon crawler game, and if it
weren't for Madara, there would be no other competition for me. I've heard it described
as Dungeons and Dragons in a box, and I would say it's probably the closest thing out there,
especially when comparing game time to world time when in combat. Look, I think that'll about do it
there guys and gals, there are some things that I've only glossed over here, but I think I've
gone over what I need to for you to know if the game is something that you're interested in
pursuing. If you do want to know more though, hit me up in the comments below, but besides that,
we are done. Do me a favour though, smash that like button, subscribe for more content,
I'm outta here. My name's Michael, this is Bits of Board, we'll catch ya next time.
