LIVE : House Oversight Committee Holds Hearing on Fairness in Women's Sports

Live News Network
1.4K followers
5 Video Views·May 7, 2025
The House Oversight Committee holds a hearing titled “Unfair Play: Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports” at 2 p.m. ET on May 7.
Support transgender athletes competing in women's competitions.
Notably, Americans broadly have been polled on that question, and the response is overwhelming.
A New York Times Ipsos poll this past January found 94% of Republicans, 67% of Democrats,
and 64% of Independents agree.
Keep men out of women's sports.
Americans also re-elected President Trump in November and he spoke on their behalf in
February when he issued his executive order keeping men out of women's sports.
The United States is hosting the Summer Games in Los Angeles in 2028.
It's a great time for us to once again take the lead in protecting and preserving the
ability of women to engage in safe, fair athletic competition by keeping biological
men out of women's sports.
A United Nations report issued last August most noted female athletes worldwide have
lost out on numerous medal opportunities due to policies allowing males to compete in the
women's category.
More than 600 female athletes in more than 400 competitions have lost more than 890 medals
in 29 different sports.
I don't want any more women missing out on medal opportunities, avoiding athletic competitions,
or missing out on college scholarships.
And I don't want to see any more girls or women getting hurt.
We cannot and should not forget the gruesome injury suffered by one of our witnesses here
today, Peyton McNabb.
It happened when she was spiked in the head by a male athlete who identified as a transgender
woman.
And I'd like to ask the digital team to please play this video now.
That is sick.
This is why I look forward to fighting and winning the battle to keep men out of women's
sports alongside President Trump and brave women like Stephanie and Peyton who are here
today.
Now, you're going to hear from our Democrat colleagues who are going to fight for these
mentally ill, biological men to continue beating women and stealing their competitions, stealing
their medals, and stealing their national championships.
And with that, I yield to the ranking member, Stansbury, for her opening statement.
All right.
Well, thank you, Madam Chairwoman.
As you can see, it's going to be an interesting hearing today.
Welcome to the Oversight Committee and, in particular, the DOJ Subcommittee.
I do want to say welcome to our guests and to your families.
We do appreciate all of you coming here to tell your stories.
But I want to make clear that this hearing is actually not about oversight or DOJ, but
about spreading hate and using trans lives to distract from the real issues that Americans
are facing, from attacks on our economy to attacks on our democracy to attacks on our
communities.
So let's call this hearing what it actually is.
It's about bullying trans kids and members of the trans community to distract from the
failed policies of the Trump administration, the failed policies and exploitation of this
DOJ Subcommittee, and the GOP's own cruel agenda that is happening right now here on
Capitol Hill as they're trying to gut Medicaid, gut food assistance, gut environmental programs
to give tax breaks to billionaires.
Because that is actually what's going on behind these doors all around us.
So, as the ranking member of this Subcommittee, let me start by saying to everyone in the
trans and LGBTQ plus community who might be watching or listening today that we see you,
we love you, we respect you, we are fighting for you, and we will fight back against this
hateful agenda.
Now, I do want to point out here at the outset that we are, in fact, in the Oversight Subcommittee
on quote-unquote delivering on government efficiency.
And this is a committee here in Congress that was created this year by the GOP, supposedly
to address government efficiency.
And this hearing literally has nothing to do with that.
In fact, it has nothing to do with anything that falls under the Oversight and Accountability
Committee's jurisdiction.
This hearing is so irrelevant to this committee, it's just a complete distraction from what
is actually happening in Congress right now.
So, let's review what this Subcommittee is actually supposed to be working on, since
my friends seem to have forgotten that.
In their own rule, Rule 6 of this Committee, this Subcommittee shall quote, have oversight
jurisdiction over the federal civil service, including compensation, classification, benefits,
federal property disposal, government reorganization and operations, transparency performance,
grants management, and accounting measures generally.
That is the jurisdiction of this committee.
And I don't know about any of you, but I don't see anything in here about sports, the
Olympics, Title IX, fencing, and certainly nothing about policing the bodies of Americans.
And frankly, hearings of this Subcommittee have become so divorced from reality or anything
resembling oversight in the jurisdiction of this committee, it's basically turned into
a political campaign ad, as you just saw on these TVs.
That's what this Subcommittee has devolved into.
And frankly, I think many of us expected that that's where we would end up.
But meanwhile, Donald Trump is letting Elon Musk and his cabinet secretaries and OMB now
continue to dismantle our federal agencies, to hack our private data.
They're firing veterans and teachers and firefighters.
They're trying to break Social Security and the VA.
And there is literally no oversight happening here in this committee under the GOP.
In fact, my colleagues have failed to bring even a single administration witness here
to this committee.
They haven't brought Elon Musk.
They haven't brought a cabinet secretary.
They haven't brought a political.
They haven't brought anyone to this committee to answer to the lawless and immoral behavior
that's happening inside the administration or anything that relates to the jurisdiction
of this committee.
That's why even though we had hoped on the Democratic side for real and meaningful bipartisan
work to make the government more efficient, to make it work better for Americans, we have
to sit here week after week and fight back against this abusive and lawless and ridiculous
agenda.
And, you know, I want to just point out that there are now over 220 lawsuits against the
Trump administration and over 130 court restraining orders and injunctions against them because
of this agenda.
So why did the chairwoman decide to call this hearing today?
Why is it that we're trying to distract from an agenda that is so unpopular that two-thirds
of Americans disprove of what Doge and Elon Musk is doing?
Maybe it has something to do with the failure of the president in the first 100 days that
his approval ratings have declined by 14 percent.
Maybe it's to distract from the reality that our economy is tanking and prices are going
up.
Maybe it's because the budget that came to Congress last week doubles down on proposals
to take food out of the mouths of children.
Maybe it's because behind closed doors all around us they're trying to take away your
Medicaid and your food assistance.
So why bully trans kids?
Why take up airspace to bully a population that only makes up 0.6 percent of the population?
Because clearly they're living rent-free in the GOP's minds.
But simply put, Republicans are focused on the wrong 1 percent.
So why are they so obsessed?
Why is Trump attacking trans people?
Why is this the centerpiece of the Republicans here on Capitol Hill?
Honestly, it's weird.
And it's wrong.
And I just want to say to all of the people in the trans community who are watching, we
uplift your stories.
We are fighting for the community.
We are fighting for the rights of everyone in our communities.
And this hearing has absolutely nothing to do with the Oversight Committee.
And that is why at this time I make a motion to immediately adjourn this hearing.
The motion is not debatable.
All those in favor of adjourning signify by saying aye.
Aye.
All those opposed signify by saying no.
No.
In the opinion of the chair, the noes have it.
And a recorded vote will be asked for.
The clerk will call the roll.
Yeah, we'll pause for the clerk.
A recorded vote is ordered.
The clerk will call the roll.
Mr. Cloud.
No.
Mr. Cloud votes no.
Mr. Fallon.
Mr. Timmons.
Mr. Timmons votes no.
Mr. Burchett.
Mr. Burchett votes no.
Mr. Burleson.
Mr. Burleson votes no.
Mr. Jack.
No.
Mr. Jack votes no.
Mr. Gill.
Mr. Gill votes no.
Mr. Comer.
Mr. Comer votes no.
Ms. Norton.
Yes.
Ms. Norton votes yes.
Mr. Lynch.
Mr. Lynch votes aye.
Mr. Garcia.
Yes.
Mr. Garcia votes yes.
Mr. Kassar.
Yes.
Mr. Kassar votes yes.
Ms. Crockett.
Yes.
Ms. Crockett votes yes.
Ms. Stansbury.
Ms. Stansbury votes yes.
Ms. Green.
No.
Ms. Green votes no.
The clerk will report the tally.
Ms. Chairwoman, on this vote, the noes are seven, the ayes are six.
The noes have it and the motion to adjourn is not agreed to.
Also pursuant to committee rule 6A2, Chairman Comer refers specific responsibility
for the matter of this DOJ subcommittee hearing regarding USA Fencing hearing
to Chairman Green and the Subcommittee on Delivering on Government Efficiency.
This hearing is directly under our jurisdiction.
Without objection, Representatives McClain of Michigan, Mace of South Carolina, Crane of Arizona,
Randall of Washington, Jacobs of California, and Simon of California are waived onto the
subcommittee for the purpose of questioning the witnesses at today's committee hearing.
Madam Chair, a point of parliamentary inquiry.
What's your inquiry?
Could you please further expound about how this falls under the jurisdiction of the
of this subcommittee and the rules?
Ms. Stansbury, under committee rule 6A2, the Chairman Comer of the Oversight Committee
has referred responsibility for this hearing to the DOJ subcommittee hearing regarding USA Fencing.
So, Chairman Comer is changing the rules so that now
fencing hearings fall under Department of Government Efficiency?
Okay, this is the rule book right here, Ms. Stansbury.
I'm sure you have a copy of it.
The number two, number two in addition, each subcommittee shall have specific
responsibility for such other measures or matters as the chair of the committee refers to it.
And this is the hearing that we are having jurisdiction over.
It's an important issue that biological men stay out of women's sports,
and we'd like to hold the hearing on that today, and we're going to continue and go ahead.
I'm pleased to introduce our witnesses today.
