Ranking Member Hank Johnson delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
May 7, 2025
Hearing: Protecting Our Edge: Trade Secrets and the Global AI Arms Race
117 days ago, Chinese company Deep Seek
launched its flagship model Deep 6
RO1. In the following days and weeks,
American experts rung their hands and
shook their heads, many considering for
the first time the possibility that we
may be losing the so-called AI arms
race.
Deep Seek claims RO1 was developed
faster and cheaper than comparable US
models. Others argue Deep Seek at a
minimum violated OpenAI's terms of
service to obtain proprietary training
data. Where everyone seems to agree is
that AI startups should be innovating
faster. I've heard colleagues suggest we
should forget regulations, ignore IP
laws, and just focus on clearing the way
for AI companies. I agree everyone wins
when we foster American AI startups. But
I think it's a false choice to say we
can succeed only if we do so
irresponsibly.
If
you excuse me, if you walk around the
Capitol today, you can see plants
sprouting out of the soil, beginning to
grow. What you'll notice if you look
closely is some of those shoots growing
in the shade look like they're growing
faster than the others. as they race for
just a little bit of sunlight. Yes, they
grow quickly, but ultimately they grow
less hearty, more brittle, and prone to
disease. AI innovation works the same
way. As we seek ways to promote American
AI startups, we should also work to
ensure that businesses meet minimum
standards for system cyber security. We
should ask what types of transparency
are necessary to protect other IP rights
and consider how to set standards while
still protecting trade secrets. By
encouraging companies to meet best
practices and respect intellectual
property rights, we will foster hearty
competition that protects US innovation
from those who seek to undermine our
success.
The government of China has made no
secret of its intent to steal American
intellectual property and there is
bipartisan agreement that the United
States should protect its innovations
from those who seek to benefit from
American
ingenuity. There is al also a right way
and a wrong way to compete with our
adversaries.
While we don't always agree on this
committee, we have had meaningful
discussions on the right to protect
American IP from the government of
China, cyber security, cyber security
standards to keep our people and our
institutions
safe and the threat landscape to AI
innovation.
Donald Trump, on the other hand, has
acted in ways that hurt American
businesses. His ideologically
inconsistent and unpredictable tariffs
have hurt American consumers, American
businesses, and our allies. Innovation
in America suffers when the path forward
is
uncertain. For generations, American
companies have benefited from attracting
the best and the brightest from other
nations. Yet, seemingly without reason,
Trump again and again hurts American
businesses by attempting to revoke
already granted student visas and
threatening and threatening the H-1B
visa program for highly skilled
immigrants. The dilitterious impact of
these policies on AI innovation should
not be ignored. According to a recent
study, immigrants founded or co-founded
28 of the top 43 AI companies in the
United States and 70% of full-time
graduate students in fields related to
artificial intelligence are
international students. So instead of
focusing on policies that stand to
derail American innovation, we should
focus on upholding our treaties and
respecting our allies. We should
encourage our research institutions to
engage with universities around the
world. The breakneck speed of innovation
has made it easier than ever to reach
out to people around the world. Now is
not a time for
isolationism because history has shown
us that true innovation thrives on
openness. After all, groundbreaking
inventions rarely emerge when knowledge
is walled off. I thank the witnesses for
being here today and I yield back.
