2025 Blow-up? | Nucleus Investment Insights #investment #NucleusWealth #Newyear2025 #2025outlook

Invest Insight
9 followers
So, welcome to an off-the-cuff edition of Nucleus Investment Insights and Macro Business Video
that we put together for Christmas. Largely at my insistence because I've written a piece
called Catastrophe Australia 2025 and I really wanted to explore this in a podcast to give
people a heads up of some of the risks we see bearing down on Australia and Australian assets
because they're coming not immediately but in a time frame that suggests you should be thinking
about it now so you're in place if it does happen and are not affected by it or indeed benefit from
it. And so, hence this video. Now, David, you've made the cardinal error, have you, in terms of
not only making a forecast but also time frame? Well, I'm doing minor errors. I'm doing an
off-the-cuff Christmas video. Right. And I am characterizing it as 2025
but it could equally be 2026. Yeah, to me. And in some ways, you know, it appears
more likely in 2026. So, you know, take that under advisement. Yeah. So, I'll tell you,
let me pitch my sort of version about I guess how we've been talking about this and I guess
then maybe you can dig into some of the what's changed or where you think the timing's from.
Is it, you know, big picture wise, Australia generally sort of is leveraged to the world
economy. If the world economy is going well, then Australia goes well. But it's overly leveraged to
commodities and particularly iron ore and China looks to be the key, get a cop at the most from
Trump regime. But it looks like Trump's inheriting a pretty good economy.
Looks like heading for a bit of a slow land, soft landing. Interest rates are falling gently
and unemployment isn't particularly high. So, it's a pretty goldilocks situation for him to
be stepping into. He looks like he's going to run up the credit card pretty hard. At some point,
you know, that'll become unsustainable but it's probably going to take a while and it's probably
going to take him, what, six or 12 months for his policies to even start taking any sort of real
world effect anyway. Even if he hits the ground running and within, you know, two or three months
of getting into the White House, he's got tariffs up and running and a bunch of other things
happening. The flow on effects are going to take a while to start drifting out to the rest of the
economy. And so, it's really this question about how bad will things get in China and how quickly
versus, I guess, strength he's seeing out of the US. Is that broadly or where am I seeing it
differently? Yeah, that's the broader context of it, most certainly.
So, I expect him to get the tariffs out pretty quickly and they'll probably actually cause
pretty swift harm as well. Not necessarily in and of themselves but, for instance,
what we're seeing in the steel market at the moment is a lot of front running of the tariff.
Yeah, I was going to ask that question as well. Keep going.
So, in effect, that's pull forward of demand and so once the tariffs drop, there's going to be an
air pocket on the other side of it. And that's not just steel, that's everything. That's everything.
Everything Chinese. And so, what I'm wondering is, usually you have this sort of Christmas rush
for goods and then there's a bit of an air pocket after that and you get that sort of, there's a
lull. And so, I guess what I'm wondering is maybe we don't get that lull as people are trying to
stock up before tariffs. I think so. Or it's delayed and then it's twice the size.
Yes. Yeah, exactly. When the tariffs hit, then all of a sudden it's...
So, I do think there's embedded sort of shock in what he's doing.
In normal times, I would just say, okay, well, I think steel is likely to take a hit. Iron ore is
likely to take a hit. We'll see some stimuluses offset but over the year, again, our terms of
trade will be down. But that would be manageable. It would mean an income shock to the country. In
fact, in some ways, it'd be a benefit because we've been running... We've had this private
sector recession for nearly two and a half years because of higher interest rates fighting
inflation. And so, that would be very deflationary and probably be thoroughly welcome in normal
circumstances. And sorry, let me just put that into perspective a little. So, when you say a
private sector recession, basically what we're saying is if it wasn't for NDIS and a lot of
government spending, the Australian economy would be in recession now. And it is in a per capita
recession because of how many people. Basically, on a per person basis, it's been going backwards
for... Is it a record length now? Yes. The longest stretch since the Great Depression.
Yes, of negative per person economic stats. It's just that we're bringing in more people
than we ever have before and so that's sort of keeping the whole thing together.
Well, you know, a deflationary shock would probably, in some ways, be welcome. The problem is,
in the circumstances that you're describing, this time around, is we have rolling energy shocks
underway. Now, this is driven by the East Coast gas export cartel, which, you know,
charges more or less what it likes for our own gas because it's busy sending nearly all of it
to China and just leaving us a few scraps. And what that's doing is creating a more enduring
inflation impulse in the economy and is the primary reason why the RBA is refusing to cut.
So far, you know, despite headline inflation being very comfortable back in its range,
falling fast, weak wages, as I said, virtual recession for years on end,
the RBA is still refusing to cut because we've got this energy shock bubbling away in the
background, which is keeping core inflation high. And so the RBA is suppressing households
as an offset. So you end up with a kind of acceptable inflationary outcome or inflation
outcome. But it's crazy because you have to be in a recession to have an acceptable inflation
outcome because you're paying through the nose for your own gas and electricity as a result.
Now, there's one more variable to add to that situation that transpires next year, and that is
mid-next year LNG imports begin on the East Coast of Australia. That is Squadron Energy will begin
its LNG import terminal at Paul Kemmerer. And so it will become possible to import gas into Australia
to offset our exports. And it might even be gas from Western Australia to India.
I mean, we don't know where it will come from. It's taking coal to Newcastle and it's crazy.
It's a crazy outcome, crazy policy. The issue is that we're, as we, you know, in the context
you've described where China is on the rack, the US dollar is flying because the US economy is
strong in the short term. And you will have suddenly introduced gas pricing into Australia
that is derived from Asian markets where gas is priced in US dollars and we'll be paying for it
with a falling Australian dollar. Falling iron ore troubled China and rampant US.
Now, the problem in this is if those LNG exports actually embed and become the marginal price
setter for gas on the East Coast, which they will if they're allowed to go ahead, then you end up
every time your Australian dollar falls, your gas price goes up, your electricity price goes up.
So you get an energy shock every time your currency falls. And so mid next year we'd be
in this circumstance of China falling. Normally the RBA is doing an offset, but it's facing an
energy shock and, you know, monetary policy is paralysed. And as a result, you know, you can't
cut rates and your dollar is, you know, your economy is so weak, your dollar keeps falling
anyway, pumping in more inflation. And you could almost get into a circumstance where the RBA is
forced to hike to protect the currency in what is a classic kind of emerging market scenario.
We'll be back with the investment insights very shortly.
Ucalyss Wealth is an active and passive investment manager. If you like what you're hearing and want
some help with the investing, we can do it for you via our active portfolios. Our tactical and
core portfolios use the insights shared in this podcast to construct and manage your investment.
We blend tactical portfolios to offer our combinations of international shares,
Australian shares, government bonds and cash. We vary the asset allocation with the goal of
protecting your capital in times of market uncertainty. We also have active international
and Australian share portfolios. These are chosen using our quality and value investment philosophy.
You can find out more at UcalyssWealth.com. Now back to the show.
So, I guess the question there though is, you know, one of our biggest import sources is China,
is whether they would be deflating their currency faster than what
this Rand dollar would fall, or I guess that's sort of the question about it.
It's not relevant because it's all priced in US dollars. I mean, they will be deflating their
currency. Yeah, so it's this thing we've been going on with recently where it's,
well, actually for quite some time now and largely driven out of China where,
yeah, the price of your goods is generally falling and deflationary. Sorry, your discretionary goods,
TVs and computers and, you know, your toys and things like that keep falling, but the price of
local services is sort of holding up. But I guess that's a sort of similar scenario. So,
I guess what I'm saying is even if China is deflating its currency fast, most of those goods
are, yeah, we're back in the same situation we've been with goods falling and services rising.
Yeah, and this is an energy rising. Yeah. Well, I mean, yes, you will have soft goods inflation.
The problem is energy inflates everything. Like you're talking electricity prices,
it just inflates everything. So, you know, for instance, if we had LNG exports suddenly start
today, we've got an LNG price of, sorry, a gas price on the East Coast of about $14 Australian,
it would instantly go to $25 or $26. The electricity price would in effect double
and you would have a scale of energy shock equivalent to the Ukraine war if that pricing
was sustained over 12 months. Now, that would add 2% to the CPI all by itself before you're talking
about spillovers into other sectors. So, it's immense and it's more than enough to impact
monetary policy. Now, it wouldn't necessarily happen this year because in the forthcoming year,
because we have the fiscal firepower to offset it. And we're already doing that. We've already got
big energy rebates both to retailers to stop the wholesale electricity shock being getting
into retail bills and through direct cash giveaways to business and households,
which has actually lowered some of the energy costs over the last few years because the rebates
have been so big. My worry is that in the context that you describe, and this is where we start to
talk about timing and potentially being at 2026 instead, the problem is that, you know, as China
reels from the trade war and iron ore supply continues to come on through Simandou in Africa
and other things, we actually end up with a tumbling iron ore price, which really adds to
the federal deficit. At the same time that you're getting an energy shock through your
falling currency, you get a paralyzing monetary policy, which then adds to the deficit again.
And so you're into a scenario in which the energy inflation that simply won't go away
because you've attached your energy fuels to the currency, paralyzes both monetary and fiscal
policy simultaneously. And markets just go, well bugger you, Australia, and you get capital flight
and the Australian dollar just keeps falling. And you get, in effect, a kind of emerging market
external crisis. Now it sounds dramatic and in some ways ridiculous, but we are going through
this already, right? This is not, I'm just not kind of imagining this. We're already in this crisis.
You know, the RBA is refusing to cut because we've got too much energy inflation.
And in the next 12 months, we've got a very large deficit coming. So, you know, the dynamics
are already in play and the currency's falling like a stone. So most, a lot of that is the
broader context, of course, of China and the US and the tariffs and everything. It's not all about
this domestic problem, but you know, those dynamics are in play. The variables are there
and they're sort of swinging together in a way that, you know, is unsettling for a possible crisis
six, 12, 18 months away. And so I guess what I'm, I wanted to make this video because I think
investors should be aware that they need to protect themselves from this. And now's the time to do it
before it arrives. Because you've got, you know, even if it doesn't arrive, because the dynamics
are already in play, you don't want to wait for the Australian dollar to hit $0.55 before you
panic and think, I've got to, I've got to, you know, protect myself either A, from this coming
inflation, or B, I need to get offshore because the dollar's going to keep falling, et cetera,
et cetera. You know, at the moment, you know, the dollar broke down again last night. It's now
in the high 63s, you know, down from $0.70, not all that long ago. But this is just the start,
I think. You know, we've got, we haven't even had tariffs, we haven't had any falls in the yuan.
Well, and sort of in a way we're saying, we're describing really is saying, okay,
we've had this energy, this rolling energy, you know, stuff up from both sides of politics.
And there doesn't seem to be, and as you said, we're the biggest, you know, the thumbnail is,
you know, we're one of the world's biggest exporters, but we're the only one who doesn't
put domestic reservation or something like that to keep local prices low on the East Coast. We do
on the West Coast and lo and behold, prices are low. So I guess where I'm leading to that is,
it's effectively an extension to say, well, this is going to continue and potentially get worse.
And so the question then for investors is saying, yeah, it sounds ridiculous, but then again,
it sounded ridiculous, you know, 10 years ago to say, well, we're going to pay ourselves into
a corner where we're paying some of the highest gas prices in the world, despite being one of the
biggest gas exporters in the world. And so in terms of solutions, the Labour Party seems to be
saying, yeah, we'll subsidise it and hope for the best. And we won't pick any fights with
resources companies, because that's what led to the downfall of Kevin Rudd. And so we won't
want to do that again. And the Liberal Party is basically saying, we'll invest in nuclear power
and it should be all right by 2050. Well, that's most of the circus, but the really big clown
at the centre of it is that the LNG imports that we're talking about being the centre of this
crisis are being embraced by policymakers as the solution to the energy crisis. Yeah, that's right.
We need our own gas back. We'll just import gas, right, and we'll have enough supply.
Okay, so I guess I just want to put that into the summary is, we've had 20 or 30 years now of
stuffed up energy policy, but we've managed to, you know, China really boomed in that interim.
World growth's been really good. Yeah, so we've actually managed to make it through without too
much of a worry. And also we were fighting that low demand and we had low interest rates for ages,
and so we got through the housing boom. But it seems like if we haven't broken it yet,
they're going to try for even more and see whether they can. Yeah, so I guess the export cartel,
who basically has everything they want, figures, well, nobody's pushing back yet, so we may as well
just keep going and see if we can get some more out of this. Oh, yeah. I mean, they're going to
look at this and laugh their heads off because, you know, LNG imports will bring them on,
they'll say, and we'll just ration supply further and ensure that the Asian price becomes the
marginal price setter for Australia, which is much higher. So they may cut a few volumes and
they'll get a huge price boom out of it. And the further, or the more trouble Australia gets in
with the falling Australian dollar, the more money they'll make. Yeah. And part of it is,
you go, well, if we can take effectively, you know, get it out of the ground for $5,
you know, spend another couple of dollars on turning it into liquid, put a markup on that,
stick it on a boat, put a markup on that, sail it back in and bring it back out again and get a
markup all the way through, despite the fact that saying you never had to do it in the first place.
But it doesn't really matter if you get to mark it up the whole way. I mean, this is where the
whole thing may eventually result in some rational outcome. I can't believe that we would
buy Queensland LNG, ship it south to New South Wales via an Asian market that prices in US dollars
using Australian dollars. Yeah. Like that would be, that would be so explicitly insane
that surely it becomes politically untenable at some point. But I mean, who knows? I thought this
was politically untenable 10 years ago. And yet, and yet here we are. And you're exactly right.
Because of that, you know, the gas cartel will push it as far as it can possibly go.
Because we've been such a patsy. So let's just keep going, shall we?
We'll be back again shortly. If you like what you're hearing, but want a low cost passive option,
Nucleus Wealth is the first to offer passive direct indexing in Australia. The first generation
of passive investing was index funds. The next gen was ETFs. Now direct indexing is here with
significantly more customisation and control. The benefit of direct indexing is you can add
or subtract investment themes, and we have almost 100 different options to choose from.
For example, you could buy an international share direct index portfolio that excludes fossil fuels
and arms manufacturers and has a tilt towards cybersecurity and cloud computing. Alternatively,
you could buy a portfolio with no screens and an extra exposure to nuclear power and
defence contractors. You can find out more at nucleuswealth.com. Now back to the show.
Some other stuff then. So in terms of China, China goes into effectively a recession,
and we see quite dramatic falls in the amount of iron ore that's needed.
Now, is that going to be, how do you see the RBA looking at this sort of saying,
oh, we're looking through the energy side. But in the meantime, maybe we've got Russian gas
and Russian oil starting to re-enter Europe, bringing down global prices, China, weak economy,
but Australia having its issues on the other end. What's the interplay of those forces?
So I guess what I'm positing is, so on one side, we've got some quite disastrous policies in
Australia, but Australia's managed to get lucky a few times. And is the luck going to come from
Russia re-enters the world market and starts pumping more gas and more oil back into Europe
as the Ukraine is solved and part of the deal to solve it is getting that turned back on.
China heads into some sort of recession and demand there starts to fall off and brings down
the prices. So are we going to get lucky through the misfortune of others?
Well, the thing about this is that it kills your luck. The luck has always been that the Australian
dollar was there and would fall if there was trouble. And that would provide a great deal of
stimulus to the economy. Now, if the Australian dollar falls, it will stop interest rates falling
because you'll have an energy shock. So it disrupts the entire cyclical management
of the Australian economy. Now that's if fiscal policy can't intervene with remits,
but even in the circumstance where we've done that, it hasn't worked. The Reserve Bank is
refusing to cut rates. Yeah, despite the fact that we've got fiscal support offsetting the energy
shock. So, you know, this crisis is already happening. It's just as it's at the moment,
it's a slow moving train wreck. All I'm surmising is that it could get faster in the right
circumstances and turn into a full blown external crisis. I guess the real last domino
in the line here is house prices. You have both monetary and fiscal policy paralysed as the
currency falls, pumping in more and more inflation and your house prices crack right at the wrong
moment. We can't cut rates and your fiscal support is limited. So, you know, you end up
with credit rationing banks that can't really be bailed out, or at least only in a limited sense.
And instead of it being a massive deflationary shock, it's an inflationary shock.
And so it gets worse and worse. And so, you know, I guess that's, well, not I guess,
that's why I felt the need to make video for, you know, MBA readers and investors,
because they should be aware that this is a real risk and be preparing accordingly.
Yeah, excellent. So, in terms of preparation, international stocks seems the most likely.
Yeah, I guess what are your thoughts around there?
Well, you know, the reason we have a floating Australian dollar is to soften adjustments,
you know, business cycle adjustments. When you get an external shock or an end of cycle event,
whatever it is that transpires, the dollar falls and it helps, you know,
deflate the economy externally instead of internally. I would just recommend to people
that they use the same facility for themselves personally. Use the Australian dollar. So,
any offshore assets would be better than Australian if some of this stuff transpires.
And that might be bonds, depending on what the broader circumstances are,
or it might be stocks. I mean, that's really a call on what the global cycle is doing.
At the moment, I would say, yeah, stocks. But, you know, we don't know yet fully how the whole,
you know, Trump experiment will play out. And when there'll be a pivot to Europe, if it plays out
badly, you know. So, you know, there are lots of options in terms of how to play it. But your best
friend here is the Australian dollar, because if this crisis actually turns, well, if these dynamics
turn into crisis, then the Australian dollar is going to make you money, you know, while Australian
assets devalue versus offshore assets. Yeah, and the falling Aussie, and the worse it gets locally
in terms of that falling Aussie dollar turning into higher energy prices, turning into RVA
stock, then the better you're going to be off if you've got a significant amount of your assets
invested internationally. Correct. You know, people can use that any way they like. And,
of course, you know, they can rely on some of our services or products if they'd like.
You know, and it's certainly something that we're bearing in mind in terms of our own allocations.
So, you know, we're offering protection. Yeah, absolutely. So a couple of different ways you can
do it. There's, we've obviously got our core international fund, where we're picking the
stocks. And, you know, at the moment, we're largely a fair bit of AI in that weight loss drugs,
a lot of sort of electricity transition type companies, a lot of service companies that sort
of across those and robotics, and starting to get pick up a few renewable energy stocks just on
because they're so beaten down. And, and we actually sort of like the,
yeah, we like the outlook. So there's some stocks that are down sort of 60 70% of that in that
sector, and actually, but earnings are actually starting to pick up. So that's sort of the core
international or you can just take a global leaders, which is just the largest stocks globally.
So you pick up the top 40 top 75 stocks, whichever one you like, and you can then sort of put various
tilts around those. So you can take out extra, say, extra cybersecurity or extra,
the big sort of the big tech stocks. Or you can just take us a new dollar exposure within that.
And we've got some, yeah, a couple of different products where you can just sort of take some
extra US dollar on within those. And then for anyone invested in any of our tactical funds,
that's effectively what we're doing within those we're buying various levels of each of those
assets and, and yeah, looking to, looking to protect people's investments by using lots of
international ourselves. Yeah. Excellent. Anything else, Dave, want to mention?
Ah, just a Merry Christmas to everyone. You know, I mean, this may or may not happen
2025, 2026. I don't know. But yeah, the benefit of thinking in these terms is, as I say,
dynamics for it are already in play. And so you benefit from positioning for it now. And if it
turns into a crisis, well, it's actually turned in rather into a massive opportunity for you as
those dynamics, you know, blow off. Excellent. Thanks. We'll speak about the next one. Okay.
Nucleus Wealth. Personalised portfolios for engaged investors.
