We often associate depression with withdrawal and low energy - but what if it hides behind a packed schedule and staying busy? Board-certified psychiatrist Dr. Judith Joseph joins Professor Sarah Berry to explore high-functioning depression.
Dr. Joseph explains how depression gets missed by medical professionals, explaining what’s really happening in the brain. She shares how traditional definitions of depression often overlook people who appear to be coping, leading many to go undiagnosed and unsupported.
We discuss how a busy, high-achieving lifestyle can actually mask the symptoms of depression - and even perpetuate it. Dr. Joseph, the first psychiatrist to run a lab focused on high-functioning depression, shares her latest findings on its causes, signs, and long-term impact. ZOE’s Chief Scientist Prof. Sarah Berry explains how food and the gut microbiome may hold the key to reducing these symptoms.
If this sounds familiar, Dr. Joseph introduces a quick self-test to help identify high-functioning depression - and outlines five practical strategies to begin healing, and Sarah gives you the foods that could help.
There are so many factors that make depression today so different than depression 30, 40 years
ago. We're not getting the things that fed our brain, that fed our bodies, because the foods
these days are ultra-processed. And that's why I think this is a new depression, and we're learning
that food is truly medicine. Dr. Judith Joseph runs the world's first study on high-functioning
depression. Her breakthroughs will be published in her 2025 book, High Functioning, but she'll
also share them with us today. She's a board-certified psychiatrist, and her lab works
around the clock to find cures for this new form of depression. We have a mental health epidemic.
You'll go into a doctor's office, you're having symptoms of depression, that you're not enjoying
things. And if you're not crying or not getting out of bed, no one's going to address it. But
you don't have to be sad to be depressed. The thing that a lot of people miss is studies show
that when you're stressed and anxious, you are going to make poor decisions. With myself, I know
when I'm stressed, I want to reach for that sugary processed food. This is where you come in with your
nutrition expertise. It's phenomenal now how much our knowledge is growing around how food impacts
our mood. Joining me as a co-host today is Professor Sarah Berry, Professor of Nutrition
at King's College London and Chief Scientist here at ZOE. There can be up to a 30% reduction
in rates of depression just by changing your diet, because we know that having these very
heavily processed foods increases the chances of having low mood. Unfortunately, yes. In your book,
you reveal five ways that we can tackle high-functioning depression. Could you talk us through those?
Welcome to ZOE, Science and Nutrition, where world-leading scientists explain how their
Judith, thank you for joining us today. Thank you for having me.
I'm really excited. This is a new topic, but we always start in the same way at ZOE, which is we
have a quick fire round of questions from our listeners. With these very strict rules, you can
say yes or no, or if you absolutely have to, you can give us a one-sentence answer. And it's designed
to be really difficult for doctors and academics. Are you willing to give it a go? Of course.
If you can't get out of bed in the morning, could you be depressed?
Absolutely. If you're out of bed every morning at 6am for a busy day, could you be depressed?
100%. Do men and women typically express depression the same way? No.
Could you improve your mood with the foods you eat? Of course.
Last question, and this one you're allowed a whole sentence for.
What is the most surprising thing you've found from your research into depression?
The most surprising thing that I've found is that you don't have to be sad to be depressed.
In the description of your new book, you describe people who look fine on the outside,
but don't feel fine on the inside. And I found that incredibly powerful,
Judith. And I'd like to talk about something that I've never mentioned on the podcast before,
actually. So frequently over the last few years, I think I felt exactly as you describe in this
book. So that on the outside, I appear fine. I'm CEO of this successful startup. I'm hosting this
amazing podcast. But on the inside, actually, I feel really numb and unable to enjoy myself.
I feel pretty overwhelmed by the pressure of making ZOE success. And it feels very alone,
right? Lots of people relying on you, and I'm sort of doing this on my own.
And in that situation, even when people say how great it is, I can't actually source any joy.
Well, pretending that I do because your expectation is just supposed to look like you're really
happy. And I know you're basically the first doctor to really start researching this as a
phenomenon. Can you start by explaining what classical depression is and what's going on in
the brain and then take us into this new form of depression you're talking about?
Well, first, thank you for sharing that story. It's vulnerable. And I think people need to hear
that. Thank you. Because you're not the person that a doctor is going to say, let's address this.
You're someone who you'll go into a doctor's office. They'll ask you symptoms of depression.
You may say yes to some of them, but then they'll ask you, are you functioning? Are you delivering?
You'll say, yep. And then they'll say, we'll see you next year. And in my lab, I was seeing cases
like this throughout the pandemic, after the pandemic, people coming in and I was checking
the box of the DSM-5. Could you explain what the DSM-5 is? So in America, in the United States,
we use the Diagnostic Statistical Manual for psychiatric conditions. And version five has
criteria for depression. So symptoms of depression in medical school, we learned it as SIGECAPS.
That was our acronym. Sleep, lack of interest, guilt, low energy is the E, C is concentration,
A is appetite, P is pleasure or psychomotor retardation, and S is suicide. So you have to
have five of these nine criteria plus low mood or anhedonia. But the thing that a lot of people miss
is the anhedonia part. So if a doctor asks you how you're feeling and you don't say that you're sad
and you just say, I'm okay, which is most of our auto response, right? We say, I'm okay.
And you say no to sadness. Doctors don't dwell on anhedonia. And Judith, you've said a word a
few times, anhedonia. I have never heard of that word. Could you explain what that means?
So it's actually a word that if you ask any nurse, any healthcare professional,
they know what it is. It's such an antiquated, old medical word. Okay. Have you heard of it,
Jonathan? No, no, go on. I want to know, have you heard of it? No. Most people haven't, that's okay.
It was really coined by a French psychologist. I think he may have been a psychiatrist in the
1800s. And what he was saying was this lack of pleasure and interest in things,
in people who had substance abuse and people who had depression and people who had schizophrenia.
And that's where you see a lot of anhedonia. You even see it in people with dementia. So,
older people who are going through that dementia phase and they just stop being enjoyed or excited
about things, anhedonia is prominent there. But people who have depression suffer from anhedonia.
People who have trauma suffer from anhedonia. It's a numbing of the things that make life worth
living. But it's a sneaky symptom. It's quiet. People don't walk around saying, I have anhedonia.
They say, I feel meh or bleh. And if you're not crying or not getting out of bed, no one's going
to address it. It's like, well, don't we all feel like that? And I think many of us do feel like
that. I think that many of us process or don't process pain, but many of us process pain by
self-soothing and numbing with things like drinking a lot, excessive buying, excessive use of social
media, doom scrolling, busying themselves with work just to get through, just to get things done,
just to busy from and distracting from these unpleasant feelings or this emptiness that they
feel. A lot of my patients would say that when they're not busy, when they're not working,
they feel empty or they feel restless. So, they have to be busy. And it's a distraction. So,
when you don't process these painful emotions, when you don't process the trauma,
then you may start to get numb. And anhedonia feels like a numbing of pleasure, a numbing of
interest in things that you once loved. When was the last time a doctor said, are you really
enjoying life? Do you get out of bed with like joy? No, they are in the business of eradicating
disease, not cultivating joy. And that was what was missing. A lot of patients were not meeting
the criteria for depression, but something was off. And I found that after the pandemic, I was
seeing more and more of these cases. And then I saw a term floating around on the internet,
high-functioning depression. You hear about these celebrities who died, who had a mask of happiness,
who were performing, who were doing great things, but suddenly they decided to take their lives.
They died by suicide. And a lot of their family members were saying that they were having
high-functioning depression. And doctors in very, very important newspapers were saying,
that's not even a thing. Well, if people are experiencing symptoms, but they don't meet a
criteria that probably doesn't apply to everyone these days, because a lot has happened, a lot has
changed in the world. If they don't meet this criteria for something that was classified 30
years ago, then are we just going to leave them alone? Sometimes we have to let our patients lead
us and to use the language that they identify with. So if your patient is saying that you're
having symptoms of depression, that you're not enjoying things, but you're still performing,
but you're still delivering, but you're having these symptoms, are we just going to wait for
them to stop functioning, for them to be broken to do something about it? And that's why I thought
that that term was so powerful, because it shakes to the core, what we believe, what we think
depression looks like. But we're missing people who don't meet criteria, but we could be helping
them before it gets to a crisis, before they stop functioning. And I'm passionate about this work,
because frankly, I was that person who was running a lab, taking care of employees,
taking care of a small child at home, married to a frontline worker, seeing the world fall apart,
having to help people. There was no way that I could stop. I had to keep going. So I pushed
through the pain. I suffered from high functioning depression, and I knew that I had to do something
about this. And that's why I started studying it. I have a favor to ask. 63% of people that watch
this podcast haven't hit the subscribe button, and 11% haven't yet hit the bell to turn notifications
on. We want this podcast to reach as many people as possible, as we continue our mission to improve
the health of millions. So if you've ever enjoyed this podcast, please hit the subscribe button
and turn notifications on. Doing us a small favor will really help. Thank you.
And if you went to see your doctor, what would generally happen if you're with this sort of
high functioning depression that you're talking about? What would you expect?
So there was a scale that I was using in my research studies. It was the SHAP scale. I
believe, I think it's actually developed by someone who's British. But it's an old scale,
and there are items on there that I was using in my lab. But I found that some of the scales on
there were a bit antiquated. Like in the US, many people don't drink tea, but tea shows up on that
scale. So I had to change some of the items on there to match modern day. And so things that I
asked my patients were, when you eat a meal, do you enjoy it? Most of my patients who were
suffering from high functioning depression were just eating to live. They weren't savoring their
meals. Or do you enjoy social interactions? And some of them would be saying, well,
kind of, but most of the times I wish I weren't there. I wish I would just hurry up and get
through it. Do you enjoy intimacy? And a lot of them were saying no. And so the simple pleasures
in life are just not exciting you. They're not bringing that same joy that they once did.
And those are the things that I ask. Now, I also ask about those other symptoms that I mentioned,
the SIGECAPS of depression, to see if people are experiencing changes in their appetite, their
sleep, their energy, guilt, and hopelessness. And I find that guilt is one of the things that I've
noticed a lot with these patients. There's a guilt if they take a break. There's this feeling as if
they're not producing enough, even though they're producing so much, like producing a podcast,
running a business. It just doesn't feel like enough. So there's this guilt to keep pushing
through and keep making more. But there's a lack of satisfaction. So this busying and this guilt
that drives people to produce in order to feel worthy is really tied to high functioning depression
and overachievers. And Judith, do you think that it's increasing in prevalence given the demands
of the modern way we live our lives? Do you think this is something that existed 100, 200 years ago?
Or do you think it is purely because of the expectations that I think are placed on so many
of us now? It's an excellent question. In medical school, we learn the biopsychosocial model.
So it sounds fancy, but it is very straightforward. Break it down.
So there are three circles. And I love this diagram because it's very easy to explain to
patients. Biologically, there are risk factors that everyone has. And biologically, you have
genetic loading. You have people who have medical conditions, physical conditions that contribute
to depression. Psychologically, you have past traumas. You have your inner resilience, your IQ,
whether or not you are pessimistic or optimistic, your attachment styles. And then socially,
the things in the environment that contribute to symptoms or disease states. So your relationships,
if they're unhealthy or stressful, that's a pressure. Your diet, which I know that you're
an expert in. Your habits, such as smoking and drinking and so forth. So the biopsychosocial
model is really important. But I think in today's day and age, in the social aspect of that model,
we do have to consider capitalism and the wage gap and the fact that the rich are just getting
richer and the poor are getting poorer. The fact that there's social media, that we have this
never-ending amount of content being thrown our way. It's a lot. So there are pressures from a
societal standpoint that were not there 30, 40 years ago. And that's why it's important to revisit
the biopsychosocial model. It's an old model, but it's a good one because it changes over time.
And you can fashion it to the patient in front of you. For example, if I have a patient who
has an autoimmune disorder, well, looking at the biopsychosocial model, I can say,
oh, I could focus on the relationships and your boyfriend who's not really treating well,
or what if the autoimmune condition is the thing that's really stressing the system here,
the biological? Let's get that under control first. Or if it's someone who's perfectly healthy
from a biological standpoint, and then psychologically they're okay, but their
current situation, let's say the job is toxic, then that's where I'm going to spend my time
and focus my efforts. So the biopsychosocial model is really important. So to answer your question,
absolutely. Capitalism, technology, all of these changes, a post-pandemic world,
these political uprisings, all of these things impact us today.
So what I'm understanding, Judith, you're saying that you can have someone who's almost like
hiding a set of underlying symptoms. And I was sort of, as I said, describing a bit my own story
reading your book. So they look very non-depressed, but what you're saying is sort of underneath
quite a few of these symptoms of depression are there, and that in a way being busy is in part a
response to this. So in some sense it's a mask, but also it's a sort of way to try and deal with
it. You feel like this is, obviously you have some purpose, there's something you're supposed
to do, so you do this. Am I sort of playing this back right? Somewhat, yeah. More of like a
prodromal state to a depression or to a physical breakdown or to a substance abuse, right? Because
eventually something's going to give. You can't continue doing that. Something will break. Either
you physically will break down or you may develop low functioning or clinical depression or, you
know, an unhealthy habit, an unhealthy addiction. So eventually this is something that we want to
prevent. In modern medicine we are in the business of fixing things, not preventing conditions.
So Judith, can we dive a little bit into your research? Because I know that you're the one
that's really led this area of high functioning depression. What do you think are the main causes
of this? I do look at what's been happening over the past couple of years, like I mentioned.
I think that in a post-pandemic world we didn't really process the pandemic, at least there's no
memorial, there's no recollection of, well let's reflect and get through this. It was more like,
let's forget that ever happened, let's just, you know, continue moving forward. And then like I
mentioned with the biopsychosocial model, the rich are just getting richer, the poor are getting poorer.
There's just so many factors that make depression today so different than depression 34 years ago.
So I think that looking even at technology, we didn't have non-stop exposure to technology.
Our brains weren't overwhelmed the way they are. Who knows what that's going to do to the adult
brain? We know already what happens to the pediatric brain, we're seeing it. I treat children as well.
And so I think that the stressors in the world are just different. You're from a nutritional
standpoint and you know that the foods these days are ultra processed. We're not getting the things
that we used to 50 years ago that fed our brain, that fed our bodies. So there are so many factors
and that's why I think this is a new depression. And I think that we have to think about the
biopsychosocial model, we have to think about preventing it because we have a mental health
epidemic on our hands. In some parts of America, there's one psychiatrist for 50,000 patients.
One of me for 50,000 people. I can barely handle 50 patients. I like to use words like the new
depression because it gets your attention. If I tell you, if I call up my colleagues who work
in the ER and I say, I have a patient who's suicidal, they'll be like, well, bring them in.
But if I call them up and I'm like, I have a patient who has anhedonia, they're like, well,
when they're suicidal, bring them in. That is not okay. But that is our current system.
I studied cultural psychiatry in different countries throughout my training and
it's so interesting because in some cultures, I would see doctors who are not psychiatrists
approaching mental health in so many creative ways. They talk to patients from a spiritual level, like
so how is your family and what are you doing in terms of making yourself happy? And they would
talk about praying and meditation and things like that. That is what we should be doing. We need to
focus on cultivating joy and purpose versus preventing disease and crisis. And when we
shift that, you won't need one of me for 50,000 people because you will be preventing this crisis
from happening. And with high functioning depression, do you see the same differences
between men and women that we see with maybe I should call it the old depression?
There are some colleagues who are at major institutions who are saying that men are particularly
at risk because men, at least in our country and in the United States, are not acculturated to
express feelings. So they are told to suck it up and you see a lot of irritability. So a lot of
times these bad actors, you see them misbehaving and they're like, oh, that guy's a jerk.
Or it's an untreated depression, right? They're irritable and angry. And irritability is one of
those other not well-known symptoms of depression. In my laboratory, some of the ratings, the clinical
rating scales that I use, look at symptoms not just of sadness but of irritability. But when
people think about irritability, they don't necessarily think of depression. So someone who's
irritable doesn't get the sympathy or the empathy. They're just a bad person. They're just in a bad
mood, right? Think about other people. But irritability is one of the hallmarks of depression
and I see that a lot in men. So I think that men express it that way and they may cope with the
depression by substance abuse. So one of my patients over the years, I'd try to do a family
true with them to see who in the family may have had depression because I talked about the biological
component, right? The biopsychosocial. And that's the family history part. And he was like, well,
no one in my family had depression, but my dad did come home and yell a lot and drank every day.
And I was like, so do you think he was happy? And then he was like, oh my gosh, never thought
of it. I just thought he was a jerk. So you're saying, I just want to make sure I understood it,
that that might be a consequence of being really unhappy, which you're saying is also close to
being depressed. And then you potentially start abusing substances or alcohol you're talking about
and then obviously, you know, someone might become an alcoholic and we know all the bad
things that come half of that, but you're saying that's not necessarily, the starting point is not
necessarily sort of innocently drinking too much and falling into this. Actually, this might be a,
like a crutch, a coping mechanism, which makes sense to me. And I can definitely think of,
you know, friends of mine for whom that's clearly been the case.
Yeah. I mean, so, so what you're saying is basically the person expressed their depression
instead of sadness with irritability and the coping with the sadness, the coping with the
emptiness that they don't necessarily identify as being sad because a lot of people who are angry
will not say that they're sad, right? They'll say I'm angry, but it really is a depression, right?
And so they'll cope with that with drinking to escape whatever they're running from.
There's a lot of comorbidity with trauma. So people who have unprocessed trauma and not trauma
in terms of what meets criteria for PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder. Trauma in
terms of emotional pain. So, you know, to meet criteria for PTSD in the DSM-5, the diagnostic
manual I'll tell you about, it has to be life-threatening or it has to be something like
a sexual assault, right? Or combat. You had to have experienced it or witnessed it to meet criteria.
But there are other things that classify as traumas that are not in the DSM-5. For example,
I had patients during the pandemic who told me that they experienced their loved one having
prolonged cancer. Well, that's traumatizing, but it didn't meet criteria for DSM-5. But no one
would deny that that is trauma, right? Or people who've been through terrible divorces or bankruptcies.
I mean, that's traumatizing, but it doesn't meet criteria for the DSM-5 diagnosis of PTSD.
So a lot of painful emotional experiences that have shaped who you are and how you perceive
yourself in the world, those are traumas. And a lot of times we don't talk about them because one
of the symptoms of trauma is shame. We somehow believe that we did something to deserve it, so
you hide it and you turn on yourself. You cope in negative ways like drinking a lot by yelling at
people. With high functioning depression, anhedonia and not processing your pain are key. And we're
not having those conversations. We are being okay with people getting through life just working
and then dying. But what's the point, right? What is the point of life if there is no purpose and
meaning? And so I may sound more like a spiritual leader than a physician. I was actually loving that.
I think my parents would say, my parents are both workaholics. I love them very much. They're
parents are both workaholics. And I think they would be like, what do you mean that there is
some purpose other than work and then dying? They're like, surely that is the primary. And
they care about their family as well. But it's interesting that you mentioned that while also
telling me maybe I am high functioning depressive. So this is all somehow linked. I feel like this is
becoming a therapy session for me now, Sarah. Well, I'm identifying a lot of this in me as well.
A lot of high achievers. You're doing wonderful things and people depend on you. You were just
telling me you're the top podcast in the UK. You can't let your followers down.
Nutrition podcast.
It's not uncommon for leaders like yourself to experience it.
And photo food logging lets you instantly see how meals score for your body.
You can't put a price on your health, but if you did, Zoe's worth it. Most of what we've been told
about food is wrong. Listen to your gut and feel better in weeks. Become a Zoe member today.
And Sarah, this is Zoe and you're one of the world's leading nutrition professors.
Do we know if depression can be influenced by what we eat?
So if you'd have asked me that 20 years ago, I'd say nothing. But it's phenomenal now how
much our knowledge is growing around how food impacts our mood, our mental health, anxiety,
depression and so forth. There's still so much more to learn. But we now know that we need to
stop thinking about just how food impacts our body below our neck. That actually it has such
a profound impact also on the way our brain functions. And we know from studies, for example,
that there can be up to a 30% reduction in rates of depression just by changing our diet. There's
a fantastic study called the SMILE study, which was run by Professor Fleece Jacker,
who we've had on the show before, who randomly allocated people who had major depressive
disorder either to follow a kind of Mediterranean diet or follow just a controlled typical diet.
And they saw really huge reductions in rates of depressive symptoms. 30% of people actually were
able to meet the criteria for coming off their medication. And so that's in people that have
clinically diagnosed depression. In addition to that, we know that food impacts our general mood,
our general levels of happiness and contentment. And we know this, you know, even from our own
research, Jonathan. And so Judith, we recently published a study where we compared individuals
who are following the ZOE programme, which is personalised nutrition programme, versus the
average US diet. And what we found was that for those who are following the ZOE programme,
over 30% of people reported significant improvements in their mood. And this is people
that don't necessarily have any kind of clinical diagnosis, but are saying that,
yes, I feel better. And, you know, we're starting to understand that partly it's to do with
inflammation, it's to do with reductions in oxidative stress. But what we're also really
starting to understand, I think this is what's really exciting, that there's a link between our
microbiome, which we know is heavily influenced by food and our brain function, and particularly
related to the mood areas of this as well. Mr. Judith, when I first co-founded ZOE eight
years ago, if you told me that food could have any impact really on how I feel, I would say
that's like some crazy Californian thing, like totally mad. And I think even three years ago,
when we were talking about setting up that randomised control trial, and Sarah, my co-founder
basically said, you have to do this randomised control trial of ZOE membership. If you don't
prove that it works properly, like you would anything other scientific, we won't keep working
with you. So I was like, okay, we'll have to do it. It's a bit scary, right? You have to publish
the results, as you know, as a scientist and as a CEO of a company, I was like, so if it proves it
doesn't work, I have to publish to everybody and tell them it doesn't work. It was very scary.
So I was very pleased when it turned out that ZOE membership really works, but we were very
focused on long-term health. Like a lot of this was around improving your gut microbiome and how
this would change long-term health. We were not focused, and you weren't focused, right, Sarah,
on like, how would you change mood and energy and sleep? But actually what's amazing is these were
some of the biggest changes that we saw. Now you're nodding as if you're not surprised.
Well, there's a whole field called nutritional psychiatry dedicated to that. And there are
studies out of Harvard that show the key brain foods. I'm sure you know, like those leafy greens,
blueberries, foods rich in omega-3 fatty acids, eating foods that don't promote inflammation,
right? The foods that are processed, those are inflammatory foods. So knowing where your food
comes from is also important. A lot of us don't know where our food comes from. And I'm from the
Caribbean, so my father used to say, make sure your plate is colorful. And he knew what he was
talking about, right? Did he really say that? He really did, yes. We say that a lot as well,
but I have to say that none of my parents or grandparents ever told me that my plate
should be colorful. That may be growing up in the United Kingdom versus elsewhere. So yes,
he clearly did know. So that's really interesting. Well, in Trinidad, I remember, because I was born
there, I remember waking up and I heard the milkman coming and the fishman coming. Everything
was fresh. And so when we moved to the United States, my dad would be like, we have to keep
eating fresh foods. And I don't think he knew about nutritional psychiatry because he's a pastor,
but there's something to it. Having fresh food that's not processed, that's not promoting
inflammation in your body because inflammation is not just bad for your body, it's bad for your
brain. And we're learning that food is truly medicine. So when we think about the biopsychosocial
model, right, there's an overlap between biology and social because our social habits, picking the
that we eat overlaps with our biological. So when you look at that diagram, they overlap because
the oxidative stress, the inflammation can impact the way that you feel. But it's really hard to
change what you eat. These programs that you're talking about, these studies, they're controlled.
You have people on these plans, but it's really difficult to implement that in your home for some
individuals. So it's something that you don't just give a book. With my patients, I recommend
two or three books from authors that I personally know who are leaders in nutritional psychiatry,
but I tell them it's not just about reading a book. You really do have to practice it because
sometimes if you're not feeling great in life, if you're not, if you're feeling stuck, you fall back
into patterns. So you do need that reminder. That's the big challenge that we know that low mood
and what accompanies low mood, the kind of factors you've talked about. So for example,
poor sleep as well. That alters how our brain thinks about food. So we know that if you have
low mood, if you have poor sleep, for example, the reward centers in your brain are crying out
saying, okay, I need a quick fix. They're crying out for those refined carbohydrates,
those sugary foods, for example. All the foods that we know are going to make our mood even worse,
but also set us up on a rollercoaster that day that we're having these foods,
these peaks and troughs in blood glucose, then set off inflammation, et cetera, as well.
And so I think it is that real kind of catch 22. And we have to work really hard, I think,
to enable people to understand just how important food is for mood and give them small actionable
insights and tips that they can take forward. Yeah. I think what you're talking about is
similar to metacognition, like learn to think about the way that you think. So with myself,
I know when I'm stressed, I want to reach for that sugary processed food. But then I'm like,
wait, I'm thinking that way because I'm stressed. So then I'm like, I really have to stay away from
that. And I just eradicate it from my house. So I think when you work with your patients,
well, at least when I work with my clients, I really teach them, all right, let's think about
the way that we think. And let's not have those items within reach because you are going to reach
for those things. Studies show that when you're stressed and anxious, you are going to make those
poor decisions. So let's not keep it in the house whatsoever. And Sarah, one of the things that
we've been talking a lot more about just in the last couple of years is sort of ultra-processed
foods as opposed to just sort of junk food in the way that we've all known about it since we were
children. Is there any evidence that suggests that ultra-processed foods might be having an
impact on mental health beyond just the fact that they've got lots of sugar or fat in them?
Yes, this is, and again, an emerging area of research because it's a relatively new term,
the term ultra-processed food. There's some interesting research, particularly in children
and adolescents. And this is where there's some quite robust findings now that there is a
relationship between mood and depression in children and in adolescents in relation to the
amount of ultra-processed food that they're having. We need to now do studies in adults.
And these are the kinds of studies that as far as I understand are ongoing at different institutions,
at the Food and Mood Centre that Felice Jacker runs as well. So I think we're just going to see
more and more evidence come out about the relationship of these unhealthy ultra-processed
foods and our mood and depressive disorders. So Judith, I'd love to start talking about
actionable advice now because I think you've painted this picture around high functioning
depression. I bet there's loads of people like me, and apparently Sarah has been listening,
maybe I at least have some aspect of that. Could we maybe start actually with those listeners?
Imagine they are thinking about this and saying, maybe I do have high functioning depression. I
feel like some of what Judith is describing resonates. How can they identify it?
Well, I do think that I have this rating scale on my website where I break down high functioning
depression into symptoms and scores and anhedonia. And so you'll get a score of anhedonia,
which is that lack of pleasure feeling. Then you can get a score of high functioning.
So one of the most common things I see, I'll ask my clients, what did you eat for lunch today? Can
you describe it? Sandwich. Okay. What did it taste like? It's good. Let's go more into that. Well,
I don't really know. I didn't think about it. Okay. Well, tomorrow when you have lunch,
I want you to close that computer, no phones on. And I want you to just focus on that food
and practice something I call five, four, three, two, one. It sounds super cheesy and granola,
but it works. So I want you to really immerse yourself in that experience of eating that
sandwich that you said was just good. And I want you to tell me five things that you can see.
And I'm going to ask you about this the next time. So I want you to describe it.
So you may see like this red tomato and you see the green lettuce, you get the idea.
Four things that you can feel. So it could be like the bread or the texture of it or whatever
you're drinking. Three things that you hear. And I want people to be intentional about that
experience. Two things you can smell. One thing you can taste. When I practice that with people,
even in my office, I'll have like these little mints or a raisin and they're doing that.
They're not thinking about anything else. They are present in that moment and they actually
start to enjoy it versus the shoveling the food in the face and just eating to get through the day.
And it sounds so simple, but it's very difficult for people to do. That's a very quick and dirty
way to start challenging and pushing back on anhedonia. What it does is it forces you to slow
down. It forces you to savor a moment and to actually find pleasure in something that we
all have access to. We all have access to food, hopefully. And once you start with those baby
steps, then you go, I move on to people in their lives, right? People, a lot of times the mothers
that I work with, they'll say like, I just, I get home and I'm just so tired. I want to play with my
kid. Well, we're going to teach you how to be present. Even in that five minute interaction
with your child. And there's more, you do these things that you're intentional and mindful and
still in these things, you actually start deriving pleasure again. You start feeling again.
But remember how I said that that anhedonia, that numbing is probably a product of not processing
pain or it's a coping mechanism. Well, when you don't process, we don't feel that pain,
you're not going to be able to feel joy. So it is a step in feeling again and being human again.
Another common thing I hear is I'll ask my clients, how many times did you use the bathroom
today? And they'll be like, maybe once, maybe when I got here. Well, I want you to be mindful and I
want you to set alarms in your phone. You're going to take bathroom breaks like you did when you were
in first grade. And it sounds funny, but how many of us have just powered through and we had to
really go, why are we doing this to ourselves? Who's benefiting? What's the worst thing that
will happen if we actually listen to our bodies and we're kind to ourselves and use the bathroom?
So these sound like very simple things like, oh, I don't need a psychiatry degree to know that.
But sometimes you do, you need a reminder to just start feeling your body again,
to start being human again, to enjoy those basic things, those basic sensations again.
I think a lot of what you're describing to me sounds like just slow it down. And I think what
really resonates is the being present. And it's something that I've really struggled with my
children. They're now getting to their teens. And I look back and even during, you know, while
they were children, I kept thinking, I wish I could be more present. And I tried to be very
conscious about being more present, but I still really struggled. Now, in your book, you reveal
that there's five ways that we can tackle high functioning depression. Could you talk us through
those? So a lot of what I talk about with psychiatry is eradicating disease, but we
don't cultivate joy. Well, there are actually, I'm not the only one. There are a lot of people,
not a lot, but there are a couple of people like me who want to focus on joy. And the first V is
validation. So I mentioned that when I was going through my periods of high functioning depression,
I was just like pushing through pain. And I remember sitting at my desk and giving a talk
to healthcare providers who were really stressed. It was April, 2020. They were in the pandemic. No
one knew what this thing was. And I'm talking to them and I'm supposed to be helping them through
this. And I'm just thinking, I don't even know what to say. I'm scared too. But that was the
first time I actually said it out loud. I am afraid. I think I'm depressed. And that validation,
the first V is validation. Acknowledging your pain. We don't acknowledge our pain. We don't
acknowledge our negative feelings for whatever reason. It could be cultural. It could be the way
that we were raised. But the first step is really acknowledging it. And could that be just even
acknowledging it to yourself? You might not yet be ready to acknowledge it externally. The second
is venting. So that's when you actually start talking about it. So some people have someone
to talk to, but others don't feel just ready yet. If you have a therapist, great, but good luck with
that. The wait list is very long, at least in America. But you can start venting by writing.
You could start, I had one patient who was a singer and she would just start belting out
notes. Some people express it in art, but get it out. And the definition of venting is you're
letting out air, but we have to let it out because then we're holding it all in. And there's that
saying that the body keeps the score, right? And then the third is values. I used to think that
collecting all these degrees was important. I have two Ivy League degrees. I have
all these certifications. You go to my office, it's degrees everywhere. I used to think that was
what was important in life, but I'm an Island girl at heart. And when I visit Trinidad and I
put my feet in the sand and I look at the water, I'm like, wow, I value nature. Why don't I get
enough of this? I grew up in this. Why am I running from it? So now I make it a point to be out in
nature with my daughter. I value family. So I'm not going to stay in the office 30 minutes later
just to do some paperwork that when I'm on my deathbed, I'm not going to be thinking about that
paperwork, that file. I'm going to be thinking, why didn't I have 30 more minutes with my child?
So really think about what you value in life and invest in that. The things that you thought
were valuable, you're not going to be missing those when you're in your deathbed. And then
vitals. This is where you come in with your nutrition expertise. So the things that support
our body, food that feeds our brain and our body that decreases inflammation, movement. That's
another thing that people with high function depression often neglect because they're
working so hard they don't get to move. Our relationship with technology. I think that's
a vital that's missed in medicine, decreasing that. And also sleep. It's very important. It's
restorative. So there are things that support our bodies that we tend to neglect when we're
busying ourselves. And I stuck into vitals, our relationships, because like I mentioned,
if you have a toxic person in your life, relationships are the number one predictor
of longevity. So think about who you want to spend your time with. You may not be able to cut
people out completely, but you can limit the amount of exposure to them. And then the last one
is vision. We don't tend to celebrate our wins. You have the top podcast, put moments in the
calendar to celebrate it as a team. Take the time to savor a win. If you got a good research study
result, celebrate it. Don't just send an email. Look, this is what our study showed. Okay. What's
for dinner? Celebrate your wins. Where are we going for dinner tonight, Jonathan? Judith,
you're welcome to join us. Are you taking me out for dinner, Sarah? I think we've got a month's
worth of dinners for our wins. We are a long way behind on celebrating our wins. No, Zoe's very
good, actually, I think. And not just the big ones. If I get my daughter to school on time
because her school is strict, I will come home and I'll sip a cup of coffee and take time and
wow, I got her to school on time. That was hard. It's not just the big wins. I love that, the small
wins, because it's the small wins that I don't think we acknowledge, but it's the things that
are occurring hour after hour, day after day that are challenging. And Sarah, just listening to that,
I'm on the food side. I just wanted to follow up on one thing, which is I think a lot of listeners
think of this will be, well, if I am worrying about my mental health, are there any specific
foods or way of eating or anything that can actually help? So I think there's no specific
way of eating that would be different to what we would recommend for everyone, you know,
specifically for me. So we would recommend for everyone's physical and also mental health to be
following the kind of diet we encourage at ZOE. So this is a diet rich with whole foods,
whole plant-based foods, lots of colour, as your dad told you, Judith. So a diversity of different
plant-based foods that are rich in colour because they contain all these magical chemicals called
polyphenols, which we know act on anti-inflammatory pathways, lots of fibre-rich foods, so whole
grains, legumes, pulses, foods that also contain omega-3. And Judith touched on this as well.
Omega-3 is a particular kind of fat. It's found in high amounts in oily fish. And that's really
important because we know it has a really important functional role in our brain as well.
And avoiding certain foods. I know that we want to think about what we should encourage, but I do
think we need to acknowledge, particularly when it comes to mental health and depression, that
having these very high refined carbohydrates, high sugar foods, high heavily processed foods,
like your salamis, your heavily processed red meats, for example, we know that that increases
the chances of having mental health issues, of having depression, of having low mood.
So your dad was completely right about eating the sort of food that he was eating before you
came to the States, it sounds like. Yes. I tell my patients, if you can't pronounce it, don't eat it.
Which, if you look on most food labels, is quite limiting.
Judith and Sarah, thank you. That's, I think, been amazing. Really interesting. I would like
to do a quick summary. And Judith, will you correct me if I get this wrong? Because it's
a completely new topic for me. So you started with this idea that basically you've been trained,
like most doctors, with this idea of eradicating disease and not at all about worrying about
creating joy with people who don't have joy. But actually there's sort of this epidemic of people
who are managing to function, but just have sort of got their joy switched off. And if they don't
do anything about it, they can end up getting worse. And then you end up treating them because
it's gone to a full depression or something like that. So for you, that doesn't make any sense.
And actually, this is a real thing, this high functioning depression. And if you can help
people to identify it, then what I think is exciting is just saying there are things that
can be done. The men and women don't necessarily express it in the same way. We then talk to
about food and that food really does make a difference for mental health. This is not some
woo-woo thing that, as I thought it was a decade ago, but it's real. And I think Sarah just shared
something I'd never heard before, which is there's this latest research showing that there's actually
a link specifically between ultra-processed food and depression, you said? Mood disorders in
children and adolescents. Which I think is, again, this sign that the food that we're eating is
doing really terrible things, I think, that none of us understood. And then you talked about the
fact you can do something about this. And I think my takeaway was, your number one thing you're
trying to say is, can you start to be present? And if you can be more present, you might be
able to start to connect and start to source joy. And so you talked about this noticing lunch
and paying attention to it with this rule, which I love and I know is in the book.
And then you talked about these different Vs. And interestingly, there's a pathway,
it sounded like, between just acknowledging yourself that you're unhappy and in pain,
being able to talk about it, which if you were brought up with a stiff British upper lip and a
family that didn't talk about emotions, it's really hard. It's not at all where you are,
even if it's in a very loving family, it's not what you're supposed to do.
Doing the things that you actually value, like you talked about the family and all the rest of it,
because this obsession to work hard actually maybe pulls you away from the things that you really
care about, look after your body. And then I love the last one, actually go and celebrate your wins,
because I think that is really interesting what you said. I was thinking back to this description
I was saying about times that I felt at Zoe, I think unable to celebrate any of those winds
of things that were going on is definitely part, I think, of how I would describe how I was feeling.
Excellent. That is spot on.
And Jonathan, may I celebrate what you have done in the last seven years is incredible. I'm sorry,
Judith, I know this is about high-functioning depression.
Therapy session.
Honestly, the joy that you have brought to all the zoonotists that have the pleasure
of working with you, for you, the joy that you brought to my life,
the phenomenal science we have produced. Honestly, it's like I always talk about our research
at Zoe as being like science on steroids. It's just crazy and fun and incredible.
The breakthrough is everything. And then what you're doing to all of the people that get to
listen, the millions of people that listen to your wonderful podcast, the hundreds of thousands of
people that have actually done Zoe, that are following the Zoe diet, and the new discoveries
that are helping hundreds of thousands of menopausal women as well. So well done.
You can make me cry now.
Thank you, Zoe. I appreciate that. Judith, well, we don't normally do that on the podcast. I'm like
really embarrassed and not in touch with my emotions, but I appreciate it.
We're going to go and have a private consultation, I think, after this.
Judith, thank you so much for coming on the show.
Thank you. It was my pleasure.
It was a real pleasure.
Thank you, Judith.