House Bill No. 5399 BY Hopkins, Paplauskas, Chippendale, Fascia, Cotter, Messier, Tanzi, Brien, Perez, Hull ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO EDUCATION -- THE EDUCATION EQUITY AND PROPERTY TAX RELIEF ACT (Provides that a school district could elect and choose to not spend money on any mandate that is not fully funded through the state education aid formula.) {LC728/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText25/HouseText25/H5399.pdf
Subscribe to the RI House GOP YouTube Channel to receive alerts on when new video clips are added.
Good evening colleagues and thank you
chairman. As you uh mentioned I am
sitting in for Rep. Hopkins who is going
to have a very late night in
judiciary. Um I bring to you on her
behalf House Bill
5399. Uh this is the Education Equity
and Property Tax Relief Act. Um Rep.
Hopkins has worked uh very hard with her
school committee in Warwick on this
issue.
Um, and I apologize that if I if I'm um
unable to uh address all the points, but
I'm going to do my best to make sure all
of your questions and concerns are
addressed. Um, I think one of the things
that we have in common, no matter what
district we come from, is that we will
constantly hear from our school
committees about the burden of unfunded
state mandates. And
for certainly for the last 16 years, um
I've never had anyone get very specific,
any school committees get specific on
what they were looking to address. Uh
the town of or city of War rather um
hired a firm to review all of all of the
uh the statutes and and policies of RIDE
um and came up with a a document, a
binder. It was about 2 in thick of of
things. And that was the beginning of of
where this bill came from.
Um, I want to uh
first in the context of this
bill describe to you what a mandate is
in the in as we uh talk about un
unfunded mandates. is any rule,
regulation or other policy implemented
by the department, Rhode Island
Department of Education uh that requires
an action to be taken or not taken in
which uh requires a school district to
expend funds as a result of that rule,
regulation or other policy and no funds
are provided from or through the state
including but not not limited to the
foundation education aid formula to
support that action. So that's what
defines mandates as we talk about this
bill.
Um, it's important to point out that
this bill only applies to directives of
ride. It does not apply to state law,
things such as fire drills, um, you
know, obviously safety, uh, and and
other things like that that we certainly
don't want schools going
without. What does the bill cover?
So it it only covers mandates from the
right department of education that are
not fully funded. So if half of the
funds are are put forward towards that
mandate, it would not apply in this in
this bill. Um some of the examples from
that
uh the right to read train uh teacher
training requirements uh cost in in
Warwick that cost the district about
$220,000 a year uh teaching quoteunquote
the science of reading. but over many
years have not moved the needle in any
way. Uh and they've measured this and
their questions are why would we
continue with a program that is not
yielding positive results. Um another
example would be the required use of
certain vendors for certain tasks like
curriculum development and training of
employees. Uh ride mandates uh the
training and limits the vendors that the
district can use. So, and this has been
demonstrated by not just Warwick but
other districts where they can get the
exact same service and or products from
different vendors for a much uh more
agreeable price but are not permitted to
or are punished uh fined punished
however you want to monetary uh fees are
applied to them if they do not use the
vendor from the state that the state has
recommended. Um this this I'm going to
give you one more and this last one is
is I think re really puts it into into
focus. Uh we all well many of us
remember we mandate mandated uh SAT
testing at for every single student.
Um and we do it whether or not that
student has already decided that they're
going into the military or they're or
they're going into a apprentichip
program or they're not going
anywhere. But be that as it may, they're
required to take the SAT at cost to the
district. This is a double whammy
because not only is that cost uh being
borne by the taxpayers of that district,
the homeowners of that district, but
it's tanking the averages of that
school's SAT scores, because you will
have students who want to get the heck
out of this mandated test and will just
go a A
a walk out. And this has also been
documented by by these school
committees. Um what does the bill not
cover? It doesn't cover mandates that
are partially funded by the states uh by
the state rather. So if if there is a
program or a requirement that receives
state funding to some degree uh to to
support it, then that would not fall
under this. And uh one of the areas
where I think this would be most
interesting to to school districts and
most important for them to know is that
it will not apply to the CTE pathway
programs which we hear a lot about. I'm
sure you guys hear a lot about them
here.
Um, a district in order
to not pay or not uh engage in in this
mandated practice um will have to
certify to the Department of Education
in writing uh within a certain amount of
days. It's in section 2B, I think, of of
the bill. Um or maybe it's not 2B. I
don't know. That's the question. Um I
can't even stop myself.
uh by August 21st of the fiscal year
that the school is is going to be making
that spending. Um I ultimately it would
our wish would be that that RIDE would
fully fund all these you know if we feel
that these are important enough to
include in in the the policies of our uh
educators then and our education um uh
institutions then we ought to fund them.
uh if they're not going to fund them,
then we will hope that they will think a
little bit harder before they continue
to add uh uh more unfunded mandates.
Um right now, I just learned this last
night.
Um for years, uh there's been a policy
from RIDE
where a list of approved um five
highquality curricula uh will be
provided by RIDE. uh from which school
districts can choose to purchase their
uh materials and to um to teach and this
has been extended time after time after
time. Ride has actually put in for the
extensions um and they have not put in
the most recent extension. Therefore, it
is now um it is now upon these districts
to choose from these approved curricula.
The only problem is they haven't
approved five in one case. And this
person who reached out to me is a
physics teacher. Uh there is only one
approved and this one is notorious among
uh all of our school districts or many
of them anyway. And I confirm that with
a with a colleague of ours who's in the
in the business of educating children.
Um the only one that's approved is
essentially junk science. It's a physics
unit that doesn't even have any math in
it. Um and the school and the teachers
don't want to teach it. It's just not an
effective way. but this the only one
approved and they will now be mandated
to do that.
Um, this
bill has drawn a lot of great support.
Uh, and you have in your packet most
probably what I'm going to ramble off
here. Uh, and I suspect you'll continue
to get more. Uh, this came to us the
genesis was as I said earlier the
discussion in the meeting with the wars
public schools. So you'll see in your
packet uh that the school committee has
reached out. Um, we see that the Rhode
Island League of Cities and Towns has
also, uh, reached out in support. The
Coventry Public Schools, uh, which are
in my district, uh, they've reached out.
Uh, the Superintendent Association and
the Rhode Island Association of School
Committees have all also reached out and
support. And as I said, I suspect you
have,
um, even more uh, that has come in since
then.
Um certainly uh Rep. Hopkins is is wide
open to any conversation regarding uh
sub Aas or or amended language. Um it is
an important issue again that we we all
deal with and um we've had a lot of very
positive conversations with the various
stakeholders across the state about this
and there is a lot of excitement.