Shields! - Top 5 Pros & Cons

Shielded Dynasty Network
2 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 28, 2025
Sword 'n board, the old classic in Dungeons & Dragons, other fantasy RPG's, historical games / movies, LARP, SCA fighting, etc. Why would you ever not use a shield or buckler? Well, it's great but no perfect...
So here are five advantages with a corresponding disadvantage each, based on martial arts techniques from medieval and renaissance manuscripts. Nothing good ever comes with zero strings attached, right? :)
All right, let's talk about shields. Shields are great. They're a popular choice in RPGs,
fantasy artwork, etc. Sword and board is about as classic as it gets, to the point where people
often wonder why would you ever not use a shield. Well, there are situations, because like everything
in life, there are pros and cons. So, I'm going to give you five pros and cons of shields.
First pro. Obvious. Coverage. Protection. You can protect yourself very well with a shield,
depending on the size, of course. Even something as small as this buckler is very versatile and
effective. You can cover your hand. If you don't have a large guard on your sword, you can close
an opening. If you don't know about openings in the historical manuals, they talk about four main
openings. Upper right, upper left, lower left, lower right. And you can really only, with a single
weapon, close one opening at a time. So, let's say, with a single sword, my sword's up here,
I've closed the upper right. The upper left, lower left, and lower right are open. Now, the lower
left opening is closed. Closed in the sense that it would be futile to attack here, because my
sword is already there. Now, add a shield to that. I can cover my lower right opening, and my lower
left, or my upper left. So, now I have an extra opening blocked off. It's not available to you.
Also, with a shield, you can do active parries, of course. And the nice thing here is it allows me to
parry and attack at the same time, because I cover myself with the shield, or buckler, and I can
strike at the same time. Whereas, if I had just a weapon, I would have to parry-counter first. This
way, I can do it both at the same time. Boom. So, that's very useful, obviously. But it comes at a
price. It obstructs movement. This is quite a large object that I now have in front of me
that I wouldn't have to deal with otherwise. If the shield is out of the way, I can cut any of
the quadrants any way I want. I have all kinds of options for cutting. With the shield, on the other
hand, it's a bit more difficult, because I have to work around it, since there's a large object
in my path. So, I can cut right to left pretty easily. If I now want to cut directly from the
left to right, it's a bit more difficult. In fact, I really can't with a large shield like this. Sure,
you could just come around here like that, but this is not what you want. This is basically
defeating the purpose of the shield. If you move your hand and your arm in front of the shield,
it's no longer protecting you. So, you want to work behind the shield to make sure that
you're actually safe. Now, what you can do is move the shield over to the other side.
That's way more difficult with this compared to a buckler, because here I can pretty easily
switch sides. So, the buckler doesn't apply as much to it as a disadvantage. This is still
harder to work with than just a single sword, of course, because here I can go anywhere I want at
any time. So, I still have to learn to work around the shield in ways that are effective and keep
protecting me. You can bind the opponent's weapon. So, if a bind occurs, there's of course things I
can do with the blade here. But the neat thing with the shield or buckler is, I can control
this separately, and now I have the opening here. If the opponent only has one sword, then
that's pretty easy for me to exploit. The drawback is that sometimes you need to use grappling in a
fight, especially if you're dealing with somebody who is good at grappling. They will want to move
in and take you down and murder you with a dagger, perhaps. So, you can't really grapple much with
the shield or buckler. You can use it to an extent to control the opponent's limbs and everything,
but when it really comes to full-on grappling, you basically have to drop it, because you don't have
that extra hand. Plus, if you have the extra free hand, there are other things you can do as well,
like half-sorting, for example. So, this is useful in very close quarters if somebody rushes me,
and instead of grappling, I just want to be like, no, how about you don't? Because this way,
I'm way too close to use my sword effectively, but half-sorting brings it into basically dagger range.
Advantage number three is you can strike with it, ideally with the rim of the shield, because that
concentrates more force, but you can do it with just about any kind of shield. Flat push is not
so effective. This, on the other hand, yeah, that would hurt, particularly if you have a little
nasty like this from Hans Tauhofer's fighting manual. This would do pretty well. You can
sort of stab with the point here. You can smash with the boss. The spikes, by the way, are not
for offensive use. They are there to catch blades. You can't really strike with them too well. The
boss protrudes too much. Drawback, much more cumbersome than a dedicated off-hand weapon,
like a parrying dagger. With this, I can do quite a bit as well. I can control the opponent's blade
and move in. I can, if need be, use this as an offensive tool. It's a little easier to work
around this as opposed to a shield or buckler. Advantage number four, it can be used to hide
attacks. Even a buckler like this can be effective at that, because if I push this out, you can't
actually see what I'm doing right now. And if I play it well, it will only come out at the last
moment. So I can move in, in this guard, and then suddenly, there it is. Of course, a larger shield
can hide even more. Boom. The con is, it's not see-through for me either. In other words, whenever
I defend with my shield against a high attack, I can't see what you're doing anymore. That is,
in fact, a common way to deal with a shield user. You would feint high, and as soon as you raise up
your shield to defend, I strike low. The legs generally tend to be vulnerable for a shield user.
In fact, there is a lot of archaeological evidence from battlefields showing plenty of injuries to
the legs, because depending on what kind of armor you have, if you have a shield, this is where
you're mainly vulnerable. Now, of course, in a duel, a good fighter is aware of this and will try to
adjust. Like, for example, if you're defending against an attack, it may be good to change the
angle as well, because if I stand in front of you and raise it up like this, I can't see anything.
But if I step over here and raise up, now I'm safe here, but I can still see from that side.
And finally, a shield is virtually indispensable on the battlefield. Basically, up to about the
Renaissance, the shield was almost everywhere. In later times, high Middle Ages as well, you may see
a two-handed weapon used with a lot of armor, with a full suit of armor. But generally on a
battlefield, you are mostly dependent on a shield if you don't have sufficient armor, because, well,
there's projectiles. There were, of course, warriors on historical battlefields that used
two-handed weapon and no shield. They were usually at higher risk. But most of the time,
shield is where it's at. They were used all throughout history, all over the world,
and for good reason. On the other hand, not very useful for civilian self-defense.
Would you want to walk around the streets going about your daily errands with this on your side,
on your back? That just wouldn't be terribly practical. An itty-bitty buckler like this,
on the other hand, is perfectly well suited for the task, because you can absolutely
have this on your belt and have it not be in the way a whole lot. So that is more useful for
civilian self-defense. Of course, it doesn't protect anywhere near as well. Basically,
it protects my hand, and that's about it, and allows me to bind and strike and all of that.
So, yeah, I hope you found this interesting. These are some of the pros and cons of shields.
I'm sure you can come up with others, and feel free to discuss down below.
Hope you like the new place, and thanks for watching. Have a good one, folks.
