House Bill No. 5722 BY Place, Santucci, Hopkins, Nardone ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO STATE AFFAIRS AND GOVERNMENT -- ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES (Amends the administrative procedures act and provides that on the review of an agency decision by a court upon appeal, the court shall decide questions of law without deference to any previous determination or interpretation of the law by the agency.) {LC1727/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText25/HouseText25/H5722.pdf
Subscribe to the RI House GOP YouTube Channel to receive alerts on when new video clips are added.
thank you Mr chairman members of the
committee um this legislation uh if I
recall it correctly is my stab at trying
to overturn what is known as Chevron
deference or formerly known as Chevron
difference at the federal level um
Chevron deference comes out of a what
was a a now overturned Supreme Court
president that requires that when the
judiciary is weighing the legality of a
regulation passed by say DEM Department
of Health or something like that that
the difference goes to the department so
the that the department gets to say
whether or not the regulation is
actually in in accordance with the law
as to a person trying to appeal saying
this goes outside the scope of the law
i.e the legislature did not delegate
this power to the the administrating
authority or to the regulators and so
they can't actually pass this regulation
right now generally speaking in Rland
courts they give the deference to the
administration to to the regulator and
this is on par with if you're in a
criminal case the judge if if the
defense attorney were to call an
objection the trial judge would look to
the prosecutor and say should I overturn
the objection or do I uphold the
objection that's where you would be any
any decision the judge makes it's on par
if you're going to try to go back and
forth so what this does is it it's a
very long lengthy piece of legislation
but what it does is it brings back the
ability of someone challenging the
legality of a a reg a regulation passed
by one of our departments again
specifically DEM uh department of health
things like that that they would be able
to actually challenge the legality of
the regulation as of right now the judge
gives deference to the departments and
almost always rules in their favor on
situations like this um couple of
examples I I can think of in the past um
if you look at public water sources okay
Department of Health passes a law that
says what is a department what is a
public water source well we don't
mandate we don't dictate that in g in
law we've never dictated what a public
water source is so to give you an
example my police department is right
there they have a well and they are
regulated no differently than the
Harrisville Fire District in terms of or
I should say now the Clear River utility
district in how they have to maintain
that well because they are a public
water source no different than the uh
the public utility in the town so you
can see the the mandate i mean I
understand the the need for health and
safety and things like that but is a
police department's private well really
on par with a municipal water system and
do they need to to to live up to the
same mandates or regulations that go
along with it and this this applies also
to a lot of um small restaurants i have
a restaurant in town that tried to
reopen but because the the license had
passed they had once not been because
they were grandfathered they had been
grandfathered so they did not uh but
they were not a public water source
because they were grandfathered but
because their license p the license
lapsed now all of a sudden they're a
public water uh a public water system
and they are regulated like that and the
the owner of the restaurant has no real
judicial recourse because the judiciary
always looks back and looks at the
regulator just like again if you're in a
trial if the trial judge looks to the
the opposing attorney and says "Should I
upheld this objection or should I not
upheld this objection?" And it's it's
just weighted against the the the common
person