Fragonard’s Progress of Love Series (Part 1)

Rococo Art (c.1720-1780)
4 followers
39 Video Views·Apr 25, 2025
Join Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator Xavier F. Salomon as he discusses Jean-Honoré Fragonard’s Progress of Love paintings and the capricious countess who commissioned the series, Madame du Barry, mistress of Louis XV. Delve into the tumultuous life of Du Barry, born in poverty, who famously clashed with Marie-Antoinette at Versailles. Tune in next week to discover how the Progress of Love series made its way from eighteenth-century France to the Frick’s beloved Fragonard Room.
Good evening, I am Xavier Salomon,
the Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator
at The Frick Collection in New York.
This Friday and next week, in two parts,
we're going to be talking about the Fragonard Room,
one of the most iconic spaces at The Frick Collection.
The series of canvases by Jean-Honoré Fragonard
reached The Frick Collection in 1915,
when Henry Clay Frick acquired him
after they had been put for sale
at the death of J.P. Morgan,
who owned them since 1898.
And it was the dealer Duveen
who organized for Frick to acquire them.
The room in which they're displayed today
was a room which already existed at The Frick.
The Frick was being built,
the house on 1970th Street at that time.
And so the addition of the Fragonard canvases
was a later idea by Frick after this important acquisition.
When Morgan died, he had the canvases
displayed in his house at Prince's Gate in London,
in Kensington, and they were shipped to New York
and they were on display at the Metropolitan Museum.
And it was during this exhibition
of Morgan's great artistic treasures
that Frick saw the canvases and, through Duveen,
acquired them for his house
and then for The Frick Collection.
The story of the Fragonard Room is a rather complex one
and, in fact, is set as a two-part story,
and that's what we're gonna discuss this week and next week.
So today I would like to talk about the first part
of the story of the Fragonard Room and of its creation,
and next Friday will be the second part.
This week I am pairing the Fragonard Room
not so much with a cocktail but with a very simple drink,
and the most delicious drink, probably,
just a cup of champagne.
And since we're gonna be talking about Ancien Régime France
and about kings and royal mistresses and court artists,
I would like to raise a glass of champagne
to Madame du Barry,
who will be the main protagonist of today's episode.
So the canvases were painted
by one of the most celebrated artists
active in the eighteenth century in France,
Jean-Honoré Fragonard.
Fragonard was born the son of a glove maker
in the southern town in Provence of Grasse
on the 5th of April, 1532.
He grew up in Grasse but moved as a young man to Paris
to study in the workshops
of two of the most celebrated artists in Paris,
the painters of Paris at the time,
first with Boucher and subsequently with Chardin.
And it was during the time he spent in these workshops
that he started to paint,
as it was expected of an artist of the time
in eighteenth-century France,
so to paint religious pictures
and grand mythological pictures.
And of course this is what other artists
at the time were doing,
to enter the Academy, to become court artists.
And so some of Fragonard's earliest works
are difficult to look at today
because we, of course, think of a very different painter.
This is one of his early works painted in 1751,
the Christ Washing the Feet,
done for the cathedral of his own hometown of Grasse.
But ten years later, in the 1760s and 1765,
he produces, for example, this very, very large canvas
showing a scene from antiquity
of the priest Coraeus sacrificing himself
to save the beautiful maiden Calliroi.
And this is a huge canvas which was acquired by the king,
and with the idea that it could have been turned
into a tapestry by Gobelin,
and it's still to this day in the Louvre.
In 1756, Fragonard travels to Rome.
And while in Rome, he meets the painter Hubert Robert
and a number of patrons and collectors,
and visits a number of places in Italy, in Rome, around Rome,
and he produces a series of really spectacular drawings.
This is one of them,
many of which were done at the Villa d'Este in Tivoli.
And it is there that he starts studying
these beautiful park settings and gardens,
which will become a great feature
of many of his most well-known works.
Fragonard was in Italy between 1756 and 1761.
And when he returns, for example,
he paints this very beautiful small painting,
the so-called small park, the Petit Parc,
in the Wallace Collection in London now,
which just shows a series...
It doesn't really have a subject.
It shows a series of figures around this park,
which is very much inspired by the Villa d'Este at Tivoli,
even though it's not a precise portrayal of the villa itself.
In the late 1760s, Fragonard also becomes well-known
for his fantasy figures.
And this is a series of portraits,
idealized portraits, of people from that time.
Some, there's still a debate
about who they actually represent,
but all dressed up in fancy costume.
These are not real eighteenth-century clothes.
These are fantastic costumes,
somewhat Spanish in fashion and from a number of other sources.
And they're shown writing, composing music,
doing a number of different things.
There is a series of men and women.
And these are now scattered amongst various museums.
The large majority of them are, of course, at the Louvre,
but there is one, for example,
at the Metropolitan Museum in New York,
one at the National Gallery in Washington,
and some are still in private collections.
And these really are the beginning of Fragonard painting
in this really wonderful, loose way.
So you look at these and you realize
how each brushstroke is so beautifully placed
and so carefully placed,
with this idea of freshness and a very direct way of painting.
The most famous work by Fragonard from around 1767,
so from the late 1760s,
is the so-called Swing at the Wallace Collection.
And this really has all the characteristics
that will make Fragonard into this great painter
of erotic subjects, of love stories.
And so here is this beautiful woman
dressed up somewhat as a shepherdess on a swing.
There is a man pushing the swing behind on the right.
And, of course, the woman's lover at the bottom left,
looking up adoringly at her.
And while she's flying through the air
through this enchanted park,
one of her shoes sort of flies off into the distance.
And, of course, if you are in the position of the lover,
you can very much look up at her legs and up her skirt.
But this situation, this moment,
is set in a fantasy park,
somewhat inspired by the parks
that Fragonard would have seen in Italy.
This is not a specific site,
but it is one of these magical locations, creations,
where Fragonard sets many of his scenes.
And, of course, to the left is also a statue of Cupid
presiding over this amorous encounter,
over this love scene.
We now focus on the other character of today's episode,
and this is Madame du Barry.
So while Fragonard was working in Paris
and became better known
and started working for a number of prominent patrons,
he came to the attention of this woman.
And Madame du Barry's life history
is an incredible parable of fortunes and misfortunes.
And it is a truly extraordinary novel-like series of episodes.
Madame du Barry was born as a poor girl in France,
and she was baptized Jeanne Bécoux.
She was born in 1743,
so she was about 11 years younger than Fragonard,
but about the same age.
And Jeanne was the illegitimate daughter of a seamstress,
and it was unclear who her father was.
It was rumored that it may have been a priest,
but there were a number of other candidates.
And she spent her childhood in abject poverty, pretty much.
And her mother, to raise the fortune of her family,
of her life as a single mother,
took a series of lovers, a series of different jobs.
And so Jeanne grew up with a number of different people.
But as a very young woman, she became a prostitute.
And she came under the attention
of a man called Jean-Baptiste du Barry,
who was a very famous libertine in Paris at the time,
and the two became lovers.
And du Barry started promoting his mistress
to a series of other notable men
at court in France at the time,
with the idea, somehow,
that maybe Jeanne could have come
to the attention, eventually, of the king.
And that is indeed what happens.
So in 1768, when Jeanne is in her mid-twenties,
the king notices her, Louis XV.
And this is a very peculiar moment in Louis XV's life.
Just a few years earlier, in 1764,
Madame de Pompadour,
who had been his longest-standing mistress, had died.
And that same year, 1768,
the queen, Maria Lecinska, also had died.
The king, of course, was much older than young Jeanne,
but the two became lovers.
And for it to be possible
to present Madame du Barry at court,
she was married, so the young Jeanne Beku was married,
to Jean-Baptiste du Barry's brother,
the Count Guillaume du Barry.
And so she becomes a countess.
And even though this marriage was an arranged marriage
and the husband never effectively saw Jeanne,
she moved into Versailles and lived with the king
for a period of about five to six years.
Madame du Barry was the last mistress of Louis XV
and lived with him all the way until his death in 1774.
She was by his side on his deathbed
and stayed with him until that moment.
She was, of course, a very divisive figure at court.
The king's daughters and the dauphin, the heir to the throne,
and the dauphin's wife, the future queen, Marie Antoinette,
hated Madame du Barry.
There were very politicized, complicated factions at court
between the promoters and supporters of Madame du Barry
and those against.
There was a series of scandals around her presence at court.
And one of the most famous incidents
was the fact that the wife of the dauphin,
the future queen, Marie Antoinette,
refused to speak to her.
And this created almost an international political incident
between the courts of Paris and the court of Vienna.
And eventually, famously, Marie Antoinette conceded
and spoke to Madame du Barry.
And the famous sentence she uttered was,
there are many people at Versailles today.
And that's all she said to her.
So the life court, of course, at Versailles
was rather complicated,
and Madame du Barry, for better or worse,
found herself in the middle of this.
Madame du Barry was a well-known lover of the arts.
And as her predecessor, Madame de Pompadour,
she launched herself into the promotion
of great works of art.
And so many portraits by her exist.
This is a bust, for example, by the sculptor Pajoux.
But she also commissioned great pieces of furniture.
This is a famous commode that was made for her.
And a guéridon, both decorated with plaques
of Sèvres porcelain.
Both of these and the bust are at the Louvre now.
But she also was a patron of painters,
and she particularly favored the painter Grose.
This is one of the most famous paintings by Grose
made for Madame du Barry,
the so-called Broken Jug.
And here is this beautiful young girl who has a jug,
and she's gone to get some water.
And the jug, of course, breaks.
And she has this sort of broken jug around,
held by her right arm.
And she holds flowers in her laps.
And of course, it's not difficult to understand
that a painting like this
would have had a very obvious double meaning
about the loss of innocence of a young girl.
And of course, Madame du Barry probably could identify
with a girl such as this in the painting very directly.
In the 1760s, in 1769,
the king gives Madame du Barry a house,
gives her the Château of Louveciennes,
just outside of Paris, to the west of Paris,
near the River Seine.
And this was an older castle, château,
which Madame du Barry then inhabits and starts decorating.
But she also decides to commission a new pavilion
next to the château,
and she asks one of the great architects of the day,
Claude-Nicolas Ledoux,
who you see here in this portrait
with one of his daughters,
to build a music pavilion,
a pavilion for music nearby, close by to the castle.
And this is a print showing what the building looked like,
a very small, beautiful,
almost sort of square pavilion,
decorated in the emerging neoclassical style.
This is the moment, really, in the 1770s
where what we now describe as the Rococo
is sort of slowly coming to an end
and merging into a more severe classical style,
which we now call neoclassicism.
And of course, the pavilion at Louveciennes
is one of these buildings.
And Madame du Barry is one of the people at court
who starts promoting a much simpler way of dressing.
And even though she's incredibly elegant,
loves jewelry,
while, of course, many of the courtiers and ladies at the court
are wearing very elaborate outfits,
she is a proponent of simple white dresses and straw hats,
which, of course, is something that later on
Marie-Antoinette herself would pick up and promote.
The pavilion at Louveciennes,
as you see from this contemporary plan,
was built in the late 1760s, early 1770s.
It was actually a very small building.
It was a range over one floor, effectively,
and it had four main rooms.
The main entrance hall, which was the main sort of salon,
and then three rooms towards the river.
This watercolor shows the great inauguration of the pavilion.
So in 1771, on the 2nd of September,
Madame du Barry invited the king for dinner at the pavilion,
and this shows the dinner in the pavilion.
And, of course, for the king to visit the house
of a simple sort of aristocrat,
effectively, as Madame du Barry was by that point through marriage,
and, you know, she was mistress entitled
but had no official role at Versailles beyond that,
was a big honor for Madame du Barry herself.
And so the fact that the king would come to her house
was a huge deal.
And the watercolor here shows precisely that event.
The decoration of the pavilion in its interior
was unbelievably lavish.
Madame du Barry paid a fortune for Pierre Gouthière,
the great sizzler d'horreur du roi,
the gilder of the works of the king,
to produce gilt bronzes for some of the fireplaces at Lussien.
This is one of them now in a private collection.
And all of the doorknobs and window knobs
and fixtures of the windows were done by Gouthière.
This is the only one that survives, a doorknob,
which is now in the Musée des Arts Decoratifs in Paris,
and you can see how beautiful it is
and how it has the initials, D.D. of Madame du Barry.
This came to the exhibition we did on Gouthière
a few years ago at the Frick Collection.
And of course, many pieces made for Madame du Barry
by Gouthière were part of that show.
The pavilion still exists outside of Paris,
but not without drastic restorations.
It was abandoned for a long time.
And in the 1930s, the perfume maker François Coty
bought the property and effectively rebuilt the pavilion.
What you see today, with the addition of an upper floor,
is a much-restored, much-changed building,
very much looking back to the plans of Ledoux.
And so here you get a sense of the space.
And to the back of the pavilion, the facade on the back,
look down to the river, to the Seine.
And this is the marvelous view you get from the pavilion,
looking down to the Seine.
And you can see all the way at the bottom right,
just sticking up from the top, the Tour Eiffel,
which, of course, wouldn't have been there
in Madame du Barry's days.
And all of the large buildings you see in this photograph
wouldn't have been there, of course.
It would have been a much more rural and idyllic landscape.
So imagine this marvelous little pavilion
surrounded by a park, a huge park,
with the view to the river.
All of these trees you see below,
going all the way to the river,
are still part of the property.
So this is this sort of enchanted pavilion.
And for this enchanted pavilion,
Madame du Barry decides to commission paintings.
And even though most of the pavilion as it is today
doesn't have a lot of paintings,
so here you see that same room
where the king was entertained
on the 2nd of September, 1771.
And this is decorated with mirrors,
with stucco work, with marbles.
There is a painted ceiling,
but not many painters worked on this pavilion.
But in 1771, Madame du Barry asks Fragonard
to paint four canvases for this room.
This is the room at Louveciennes today.
And you see the window in front of you
is the window that looks towards the river.
The window to the right is, in fact,
a door that leads to the garden.
The door to the left leads into the main salon of the house.
And so for these two panels
where you see the fabric on the left and right,
and you can see from the mirrors at the back,
flanking the window,
that there were two similar, slightly curved walls,
wall sections on the opposite side.
So this was a room that had curved apse
on the opposite side of this window.
For these four spaces,
Madame du Barry asked Fragonard to paint four canvases.
And the four canvases that Fragonard painted
are what we now call the Progress of Love.
And so you have to imagine these four large, huge canvases
in this fairly small room.
The room at Louveciennes is about half the size,
probably, of the Fragonard room at the Frick.
Much, much, much smaller, much more compact, as a feeling.
And you would have been looking at these park scenes
by Fragonard while looking at a real park
outside of the windows,
of two of the windows of the pavilion.
So the four scenes represent four moments
in the love story of a couple, of a man and a woman.
And they represent these four key episodes.
So here are, in this wonderful park,
a girl who is surprised by a boy
who just sort of arrives and offers her a rose.
This is the so-called Pursuit.
The girl is probably by this fountain
with two of her friends, maybe two sisters.
And this boy arrives and surprises her.
But of course, while she's sort of running away,
she's also looking back.
And you can see that the sculptures in these paintings
are very much a commentary on what's happening below.
So this is a sculpture,
there are two cupids and a dolphin up high.
And of course, the cupids are wide awake,
looking at what's happening,
at the spark of love that is beginning
in the hearts of these two people.
The next scene is the Meeting.
And by this point, the couple,
in this case a different couple,
but all of these couples represent,
ideally, any couple who's in love,
they're meeting in secret.
So by this point, they've become lovers.
The man is climbing a ladder into this park,
and the woman is looking around,
making sure that no one is coming to surprise them.
And of course, the presiding statue in this case
is Venus, the goddess of love.
So this is a sort of very charged,
erotic encounter between the two.
And we can only imagine what is going to happen next.
We then fast-forward to the Lover Crowned.
And here are the two lovers, happily together,
being portrayed by an artist.
The bottom right, you see a painter
sketching the two lovers.
And of course, this is also almost a sort of joke
of Fragonard referring to his job
for Madame du Barry and, in some ways, the king.
And it's been said that the man,
the young man in some of these paintings,
has a certain resemblance to Louis XV.
But clearly, the cycle was a much more general idea
of the experience of love between two human beings.
And while the two lovers crown each other
with flowers and listen to music,
Cupid, of course, in the statue, is fast asleep.
He's completed his job.
The quiver is empty.
There are no arrows left.
He has completed his task.
And the final canvas is the so-called Love Letters.
And here you have the two lovers
reading all their old love letters.
There is a dog at the bottom,
which, of course, has always been a symbol of fidelity.
And the statue, in this case, is a woman holding a heart,
which has been identified also as fidelity.
But it's probably a symbol of amitié, of friendship.
And there was the sense in the eighteenth century in France
that a great love story,
once all the sexual energy was worn out, let's say,
would turn into a great friendship.
And so the example of this, of course,
was the relationship between Louis XV and Madame de Pompadour.
When that sexual chemistry wasn't there anymore,
Madame de Pompadour became the king's great friend.
And even though the king took other lovers,
Madame de Pompadour remained as the mistress entitled.
So this sort of suggests a development
in the relationship of a couple
as it was understood in the eighteenth century.
The canvases were painted between 1771 and 1772.
But Madame du Barry was a very capricious patron.
We know of many instances where she did not like
the works of art that were produced for her.
She rejected them, she returned them, she asked for changes.
This happened on a large number of occasions.
We know of this happening over and over again.
And she did not like the Fragonards.
And we still don't know why exactly.
Was it the style?
Was it the style of these paintings that didn't quite fit
with the very neoclassical, simple pavilion?
Was Ledoux, the architect, somewhat critical of them?
Was it just Madame du Barry?
We don't know.
Did she not like the way these pictures were set
within these luscious parks?
Was it the style, the sort of more old-fashioned style,
looking back to Boucher, something that she did not like?
The canvases were installed at Louveciennes,
but soon after that returned to the painter.
And Fragonard rolled them up at his studio,
at his house at the Louvre,
and kept them there for another twenty years.
In the meantime, Madame du Barry redecorated that same room
with four canvases showing more or less the same events
about sort of encounters and lovers crowned
and sort of the relationship between a couple,
but in this case made by the painter Joseph-Marie Vien.
And these were painted as Greek scenes,
still set in luscious parks with sculptures,
following in some way the example of Fragonard,
but in this case very much in a neoclassical,
much more algid, cold style.
These canvases were eventually also removed from Louveciennes
and there are now two of them.
These two are at the Louvre and another two are in Chambéry.
But the story of Madame du Barry is a tragic one, ultimately.
In 1774, the king dies.
She is pushed out of court.
She is sent to a nunnery,
and she spends the great part of a year in this nunnery,
where she in fact becomes very close
and very good friends with many of the nuns there,
and she's beloved by the women living in the convent.
She's finally allowed to leave,
but she basically sets herself up at Louveciennes.
Louveciennes becomes her main house,
the château and the pavilion.
She spends the rest of her life based there.
She has new lovers, the main one being the Duke de Brissac,
who becomes her closest companion for the rest of her life.
But of course, what is on the horizon
with the reign of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette
is, of course, the French Revolution.
During the French Revolution,
Madame du Barry helps many of the aristocrats.
We know from most sources
that she tended to be a very generous woman,
and so many of the people who had criticized her
became also the people that she helped
to some degree during the Revolution.
She traveled to London a number of times
to try and sell her jewelry, to raise funds.
And even though she could have left France
and not return to France,
as many other aristocrats did,
she'd always decided to come back to France.
And this was, of course, her undoing.
1793 is one of the bloodiest years
of the French Revolution.
It's the year in which the king is beheaded,
first of all, on the 21st of January,
followed on the 16th of October of that same year
by Marie Antoinette.
Both are beheaded in the Place de la Concorde.
And at the end of 1793,
Madame du Barry is also arrested, put on trial,
and eventually beheaded in the same place
where the king and queen had been beheaded
on the 8th of December, 1793.
The most tragic account of her death
is the account by the female artist Elisabeth Vigée-Lébrun.
And Vigée-Lébrun knew Madame du Barry very well.
He had portrayed her a number of times
and met her and knew her well.
And Vigée-Lébrun writes in her memoirs
about the execution of Madame du Barry.
She writes,
Madame du Barry is the only woman
among the women who perished in those dreadful days
who could not stand the sight of the scaffold.
She screamed.
She begged for mercy of the horrible crowd
that stood around the scaffold.
She aroused them to such a point
that the executioner grew anxious
and hastened to complete his task.
This convinced me
that if the victim of those terrible times
had not been so proud,
had not met death with such courage,
the terror would have ended much earlier.
Men of limited intelligence
lack the imagination to be touched by inner suffering,
and the populace is more easily stirred by pity
than by admiration.
And so Madame du Barry dies on the scaffold
amongst tears and screams
in this sort of really horrible, chilling scene.
And she is buried nearby,
near the Place de la Concorde,
in a little cemetery, the Cemetery de Madeleine,
where all of the bodies of the victims of the terror
and the French Revolution
were amassed in common graves.
And the king and queen's bodies also were buried here.
And only later, with the Restoration,
the bodies of the king and queen
were moved out and buried properly at Saint-Denis.
And the new king of France built this chapel,
the Chapelle Expiatoire.
And this little chapel and park
are built on a vast mound
made of the bones of the victims of the French Revolution.
And so where you see these roses growing
and this little beautiful park,
Madame du Barry is buried somewhere there,
together with many other people.
So with the death of Madame du Barry in 1793,
it overlaps with the second part
of the story of the Fragonard Room.
But to know about what happened to the four canvases
and what Fragonard did with them in the 1790s,
you will have to join me next week
for another episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
