Trustee of the Friends of Kenwood House, London, Helen Payne, gives an online talk on the 4 rococo paintings, 2 by François Boucher (1703 – 1770) and 2 after Boucher which hang in Kenwood House, London.
There are relatively few paintings by Boucher in London other than at the Wallace Collection, but Edward Cecil Guinness, who gave Kenwood house to the nation, acquired 3 he believed to be by Boucher in 1887 and 1888. Together with the companion 4th painting, only at Kenwood since 1991, these four ‘fêtes galantes’ hang in the Green Room at Kenwood. Helen Payne’s talk centres around the French rococo movement of the 18th century and the importance of Boucher in the French cultural canon.
Helen Payne has been actively involved with Kenwood for several years and has an MA in French and an MA in art history. Introduction and fade out music: Les Fêtes d’Hébé by Jean-Philippe Rameau (1683 – 1764), first performed in 1739. Rameau was the pre-eminent French composer of the 18th Century and in 1745 became the official court musician; he composed pieces intended to entertain, with plenty of dance music emphasising sensuality and an idealised pastoral atmosphere.
Produced by Friends of Kenwood www.friendsofkenwood.org.uk
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This talk examines the pastoral paintings of François Boucher at Kenwood House, exploring the tension between the Poussinistes and Rubenistes, the influence of French theater on the Rococo style, and the erotic symbolism within his work. It further discusses Boucher's legacy, arguing that his reputation was unfairly diminished by later neoclassical standards and historical prudery.
Hello and welcome to my talk about Boucher's paintings in the Green Room at Kenwood House.
It always seems to me that people don't pay very much attention to them.
Boucher was a prolific and varied artist but I'm going to concentrate on his pastorals because
that's what we have at Kenwood. The first thing you need to know is that of the four paintings
I'm going to talk about only two are believed to be by Francois Boucher, namely these two,
The Exchange of Produce and The Cherry Gatherers, both dated 1768. They're reasonably large at 170
centimetres by 124 centimetres. The two paintings which are not by Boucher, although copies of two
of his earlier paintings are The Flower Gatherers, dating from about 1770, and Les Pêcheurs.
Kenwood's Les Pêcheurs dates from about 1800, that is 30 years after Boucher's death. Nonetheless,
it's a fine painting and it fits beautifully with the other three and I'll explain why to you later.
So, how did these pictures get to be at Kenwood? Well, many of you already know the apocryphal
story of how Edward Cecil Guinness went shopping over the lunch hour and the enterprising salesman
at Agnew's welcomed him in and he made his first purchase. The Flower Gatherers was that first
purchase. Agnew sold it to him as a Boucher on the 23rd of June 1887. Exactly one year later,
on the 23rd of June 1888, Guinness bought The Exchange of Produce and The Cherry Gatherers,
still unsold from the previous year, for £5,500. That's over £700,000 in today's money
and it was entered in Agnew's ledger as a pair of upright landscapes. All three came from the
sale at Christie's of the 4th Earl of Lonsdale's collection and we'll come back to this art sale
at the end of my talk. All three paintings are in the schedule of the 1929 Ivor de Crestac.
Les Pêcheurs only came into the collection in 1991 on loan and it was purchased by English
Heritage for Kenwood in 1993. So the very first purchase Guinness made from Agnew's was not,
as it turned out, by the artist he thought it was by. All four paintings hang in the green room at
Kenwood along with other fancy pictures including Lawrence's Miss Murray and Reynolds' Venus Chiding
Cupid. It's been called the green room since 1831. It was called the supper room before that
and with its large windows and columns you get a sense of almost being in the outside landscape
looking south through the orangery and west towards the flower garden. This is very much
in line with 17th and 18th century architecture of much grander stately homes as opposed to
villas like Kenwood where you can sometimes find supper rooms at the top of towers looking out over
the countryside. And one other snippet before we leave the green room, the walls upon which the
Wallace collections Boucher's hung when it opened in 1900 were green. So who was Francois Boucher?
Well he lived from 1703 to 1770. He was the son of a master painter and lace designer
born in Paris and he trained first with his father then briefly with the history painter
Lemoyne and then with the engraver Jean-Francois Carr. In 1723 he won the French academy's
first prize for painting but he wasn't able to travel to Rome as was the custom immediately.
He earned his living producing reproductive engravings through the 1720s particularly
after drawings and paintings by Vottle. Although he was fabulously famous in his own lifetime and
although many many images by him have survived in various forms his early life is a bit murky.
This is my moment to give you a who's who. At the root of it all is Vottle and an argument.
Here is an engraving by Boucher of Vottle done in 1726 when he was earning his living
producing those engravings. The argument was between the Poussinistes and the Rubenistes
that's the followers of Poussin and the followers of Rubens and Vottle was the arch Rubeniste.
It was a battle which lasted quite a long time and Reynolds refers to it in his discourses
nearly 100 years after it began but it all started in 1671 when an argument broke out
at the French academy of painting and sculpture about whether diseigneur for the sake of speed
just think of this as drawing or line or whether color was more important. Another way of looking
at it is reason against emotion and indeed a masculine versus feminine way of painting.
A victory for the Rubeniste came when their champion the painter and theorist Roger de Pille
was elected to the academy in 1699 and the icing on the cake for the Rubeniste came when Vottle's
invocation for Syphora was accepted by the academy as his reception piece in 1717.
The problem was however that there wasn't a category for the sort of painting Vottle was
producing. It wasn't a history painting, it wasn't a landscape, it wasn't a portrait and it wasn't a
genre painting. So the academy created a new category and named Vottle as a peintre des fêtes
verlantes. While this was good for him in that it marked acceptance of him and of his style of
painting it meant he could never be recognized as a history painter therefore he would never be
considered for a professorship of the academy and this is the pool from where all directeurs
were drawn. So Vottle was the trailblazer and all this was to change because in 1765 Boucher,
a supreme Rubeniste, was elected directeur of the academy. So the first half of the 18th century was
the period of Rubeniste supremacy. It became accepted that the pleasure principle was as
equally valid as the more elevated nobler sentiment required for history painting.
The time was right because landscape, genre painting and still life had in the previous
century all become more popular so that the only spark which was needed was the beginnings of the
enlightenment to prompt a greater focus on nature, on sentiment and on naturalism and on direct
personal experience and personal observation. L'expérience vécue. Now I need to turn to
the importance of the theater. It is this expérience vécue which ties all the Rubenistes
on this slide together. These Rococo artists Tiepolo in Italy, Vottle, Boucher, Lancret,
and in England Coppa, Hayman and Mercier all had extremely close links to the theater.
I want to point that out because so much of what was happening in art in France in the 18th century
was rooted in theater and the commedia dell'arte. They were in an almost uncanny way at the
intersection of all the major components of artistic culture after 1700. And the final thing
I need to tell you about before I go back to just Boucher on his own is to give you a bit of
background on the commedia dell'arte and theater in France in the 18th century. Towards the end
of the 17th century the Académie Française standardized the French language and today
when you hear that the French Académie continues to debate whether coronavirus is masculine or
feminine, remember that it started at the end of the 17th century. The great Tradidians Corneille
and Racine had died at the end of the 17th century as had Molière. In order to tighten things up
and because the Comédie Française felt threatened, the Opéra Comique was banished in 1697.
From this prohibition sprang mine because no dialogue was allowed. Outlawing the fringe
led to a real conflict between official and unofficial forms of theater and the trouble was
that it proved impossible to suppress the subversive unofficial theater which was really
popular with all sectors of society. Such was the success of the comic theaters that operated
in the seasonal fairs in Paris that contemporary Parisian aristocracy took over for themselves
and so to turn it all upside down in the face of the establishment and the Comédie Française
it was the Comédie de l'Art at Paris fairs which became an elite dramatic form.
R. Ruben East Rococo artists moved in this outlawed theatrical milieu and the Fêtes Galantes
painted by Watteau and his followers situated in fantastical landscapes were nurtured in active
engagement with the theater. On top of that some members of the Parisian aristocracy adopted the
Fêtes Galantes as part of real life and it is recorded that some protagonists spent entire
days dressed as peasants, in other words a real maintenance of artifice. So the paintings of
in particular Fragonard and later artists were to move away from this can be read as
life as fiction and not just pretty paintings of shepherds and shepherdesses.
Here I'm showing you paintings by Hayman in England and Lancret in France. They might be
studies from life, they might be carefree aristocrats, they might or might not be products
of the artist's fantasy but they most certainly are a deliberate confusion between actual,
theatrical and fictional which makes a realist reading impossible. One more observation on the
Fêtes Galantes given that they must be taken as fiction they can't be read as a faithful reproduction
of a pre-existing reality unlike Dutch genre painting in which they partly had their roots
and with which Wattel with his Flemish origins was very familiar. So now back to Bouching.
If you remember we left him engraving Wattel's works and winning first prize at the academy in
1723. Well he finally got to Rome in 1728 in the company of Carle Vanloo. He stayed there for two
years and he was accepted into the academy on his return in 1731 aged 28. I'm showing you here on
the left his 1734 entry piece to the academy when he became a full member and I'm showing it to you
because it really illustrates the difference between Boucher's Rococo art and that of the
grand manner of history painting. In other words it goes to the heart of the differences between
The story of Rinaldo and Armida is a story of the struggle between reason and concupiscence
says Julius Bryant and as such perfect material for the champions of color over dizennio. It's worth
going into this story because Kenwood is fortunate enough to have the painting on the right executed
Boucher's Rinaldo and Armida couldn't be more different to Angelica Kauffman's
Armida in vain endeavors with her entreaties to prevent Rinaldo from departing. I hasten to add
that I am not for a moment suggesting that Kauffman was a Poussiniste. I don't know whether
she entered into the debate or not and in any case she was a woman. But I think you get the point.
Her version is painted much more in the grand manner. Note the date of hers because French
Rococo had started to show signs of dating by then and on the ascendancy were more masculine
neoclassical paintings. Think David's Oath of the Heretie or his Death of Marin. The French
Revolution was looming. For those of you who aren't familiar with the story of Rinaldo and
Armida it comes from a 16th century poem by Tasso. Rinaldo is part of the Christian army
which lay siege to Jerusalem in the first crusade of 1099. The Saracens ask Satan for help and Satan
comes in the guise of Armida a niece of the king of Damascus. Rinaldo falls in love with her then
he comes to his senses but by then she's fallen in love with him and she doesn't want him to go
off on his military mission. I think it all ends happily ever after but that's not the point here.
Look at the different moments of depiction of the story. In Boucher's painting Rinaldo has laid down
his arms and is captivated by the charms of the virgin Armida while in Kaufman's Rinaldo is
resisting her and determining to do his duty. Well after his acceptance into the academy Boucher's
career started to move forwards. He was made a full professor by 1737. Compare that to Wattel's
earlier frustration. He was very ambitious and actually very hard-working. He was a man of
prodigious energy. By his own estimation he produced 1,000 paintings and 10,000 drawings.
I'm showing you here a couple of his exquisite drawings, undated, that give you an idea of his
talent and we'll come back to that drawing of a child on the right in the Kenwood paintings later
on. He also produced a vast number of drawings in red chalk, really beautiful and I just want to
give you a sense of the sheer quantity and scalability of his work. Particularly remember
the boy hiding behind the arm in the center and the peasant girl with her apron for later when
we get to the Kenwood paintings. He produced many etchings and engravings, designs for opera sets,
designs for porcelain and look at the detail of the grapes here. We'll come back to grapes later.
He produced virtually continuous designs for tapestries, for Beauvais and for Gobelin from 1736 onwards.
He was appointed director of Gobelin in 1755. He had assistants, a wife, two daughters who both
married artists and a son who became a drawer of architectural fantasies and he was driven by a
desire to make money and live in high society. In 1765 Boucher was elected director of the Royal
Academy for painting and he was named as first painter of the king and here are examples of his
tapestry designs both for Beauvais and for Gobelin. On the left is a quick reminder of the fashion of
chinoiserie in the 18th century while on the right is the Loves of the Gods produced for the Duchess
de Bourbon in 1770 and now in the Louvre. Altogether in addition to his clear and
unquestionable artistic talent he found and tapped a rich scene. Boucher died in 1770 at work
in his studio in the Louvre. Most important of all he had a top-ranking patron Madame de Pompadour.
In the 1750s she began to play the role of quasi-minister. In this portrait she has an
she was partly responsible for designing and is holding a book by Voltaire. It's a representation
of power and culture and you can see two roses at her feet which are supposed to represent her
and Louis XV. The Wallace collection's portrait of 1759, the last known portrait Boucher painted
of his patron, shows her continuing power and a linked need to project an image of her fidelity
to Louis XV. Even during the platonic last three years of their relationship
and you can see in the background a sculpture of friendship consoling love and that's a sculpture
which was commissioned by Pompadour. The love letter and its companion piece The Interrupted
Sleep, which we'll come back to again in a minute, were both designed for Madame de Pompadour
for her chateau at Bellevue. She commissioned all sorts of things from Boucher for Bellevue
and I'll just mention here that both pieces were painted after a tapestry cartoon which Boucher
designed for Bouvier in 1748. So here the painting came after the tapestry design and then
here is an armchair now in the fridge which has the love letter as its backrest decoration.
As with printing so with tapestry you can see the image is in reverse. It was commissioned
by a government minister under Louis XV, an example of Parisian society wanting to keep up
with Madame de Pompadour. And just one last thing on tapestries at this stake. Prune Court in
Worcestershire had some magnificent goblin tapestries known as the Tenture de Boucher,
the Boucher wall hangings which are now in the Met. Of nine sets of medallion tapestries
five came to England. When you look at the austere exterior of Prune Court you can see
why tapestries might have been useful for keeping the rooms warm. I mention it here because it has
a nice link with Robert Adam. Prune Court was built by Capability Brown for the 6th Earl of
Coventry when he inherited the estate in 1751. He hired Robert Adam to design some of the principal
rooms but he didn't always agree with Adam's neoclassical designs. In 1763 at the end of the
Seven Years War Coventry went to Paris and he brought back some designs from Gobelin by Boucher
to discuss with Adam. Adam adapted the designs to neoclassical ones but Coventry ignored them all,
stuck with the Rococo motifs and the tapestries went into production in 1764.
And I showed you Les Amours de Dieu earlier on which is now in the Louvre as a separate panel
but here you can see it incorporated into the room design. So now back to Kenwood. The two
paintings by Boucher were probably part of a decorative architectural scheme. They were
subsequently extended to easel paintings very much like The Love Letter and The Interrupted
Sleep which I just mentioned and they are in Washington and The Met respectively. I'm showing
you these two because here you can see the way they've been extended out from the circle. Painted
in 1768 Kenwood's paintings are late work and they've been together probably forever but at
least since 1785. Julius Bryant says that the side sections were probably painted by studio assistants
probably under Boucher's supervision for a client. The variety of hands is noticeable by detailed
brushwork contrast with the breadth of painting appropriate to the decorative panel. There is even
a question whether the exchange of produce is by Boucher at all as there are so many differences
between it and the cherry gatherers even in the signatures. The cherry gatherers here is on the
left and the exchange of produce signature is on the right. Be that as it may. In the Kenwood
paintings and indeed in the two I've just shown you The Love Letter and The Interrupted Sleep
the simplicity of the subject belies the complexity of the composition which is organized around a
Each painting has a central focus as you would expect if they were once roundels. In his final
years Boucher produced several large decorative paintings in which he revisited the subjects he
explored after his return from Italy particularly pastorales inspired by the theater. The subject
of the Kenwood paintings reprises a much earlier painting which was shown at the Salon in 1747
and let's not forget the link to porcelain. Boucher produced a template for porcelain
figures eating grapes. Here's an example produced in England after his death.
and therefore Kenwood's two paintings as well have links to a ballet pantomime for a Paris fair
written by Boucher's friend Charles-Simon Favard in 1745. The play was later reworked
as La Vallée de Montmorency and performed in Paris in 1752. So here we are back with
and don't forget what I said earlier Boucher was not only a keen member of the audience
but he was also a set designer. In the play a cherry orchard provides the setting
and an amorous little shepherd offers the shepherdess cherries or grapes and here we
have the Wallace collection's pastoral with a couple near a fountain of 1749. More grapes
being offered. So we have in these paintings popular theatre which combines Arcadian idealism,
naturalism and pastoral poetry in rustic sentimental characters. The two Kenwood paintings
not by Boucher are similarly idealized visions of rustic life indebted to Watteau's fete galante
and the amorous pursuits of either shepherds and shepherdesses or in the case of the flower
gatherers a more elegantly dressed couple who may or may not be acting. As I mentioned at the
beginning this painting was the very first painting bought by Guinness from Agnews in 1887
as a Boucher. It's now regarded as a work from Boucher's studio. The real original Boucher
known as Lovers in a Park is now in the Timken Museum in San Diego and it's huge. One of the
great beauties of PowerPoint is that I can show you the dimensions side by side of the two versions
so you can see how much smaller the Kenwood painting is. And here is a detail of the two
paintings. The Timken painting is brighter. I'm sorry it's a bit fuzzy as I blew it up but it's
the one on the left. You can see that the Kenwood version is very fine too. The Timken original
version was painted in 1758. Its companion piece is Le Pêcheur signed and dated 1759. The same
dimensions as Lovers in a Park and it's in Hamburg. The Kenwood Le Pêcheur is believed to have been
painted after Boucher's death in about 1800. The artist is unknown but after detailed paint
analysis by UCL in 1991 we can be pretty certain it's from the same workshop as Kenwood's flower
gatherers. While the quality and type of pigments used in these paintings differ slightly from those
used in the two Bouchers, it was established that the structure of all were similar. In other words
whoever painted Le Pêcheur was very familiar with Boucher's practice. And in a way I think
this is the most satisfying of all four paintings. Compositionally there's a satisfying semi-circle.
There's lots of twos, two boys, two women, two fishing rods, two peaches, two grape bunches,
one white, one red, two birds in the nest. The fact that the fisherman has his back to the viewer
even while showing the girls the size of his catch is quite sophisticated compared to some
of the other images I've shown you. And back to the boys. Unlike the boy in the exchange of produce
who is an ugly little thing, the two on the right look properly adorable. And I think bring us back
to l'expérience vécue. Do you remember that beautiful drawing of the Savoyard boy I showed
you at the beginning? So now we need to talk about sex, not sexual inferences even. We can start
with the detail of the postcoital girl in the flower gatherers. Look at it carefully. The
Timken Museum describes it thus. A young couple and their spaniel have stopped to rest while out
for a stroll. Julius Bryant goes a bit further and writes, a young couple, their elegant clothes
in disarray, their shoes lost, are resting in a park after gathering flowers in the lady's straw
bonnet, and much more. The much more is better than the Timken explanation, but it's still very coy.
We shouldn't forget that the 18th century was so perfectly at ease with in-your-face sexual
references that it's not as if anything is hidden or behind curtains, unlike in previous centuries.
I wouldn't personally say that in the cherry gatherers the symbolism is confined to the
central male genital gesture of the two cherries suspended from the young man's index finger.
There's much more which would have been spotted by Boucher's contemporaries. There's the bare feet
and legs of the girl, the overturned watering can, the ladder, the hat, more on that in a minute.
The imagery of fecundity is certainly also present in the exchange of produce. The girl offers the
young man eggs from her basket, he offers her grapes, symbols of fertility and debauchery.
There are three pairs of birds on the cottage roof, and water is spilling from the overturned
pitcher. Or is it milk? The low morals of milkmaids was a well-known 18th century motif.
I'll just remind you here about the rise of the salon in the 18th century.
When Louis XIV died in 1715, many aristocrats moved back to Paris from Versailles,
and salons in Paris could range from highbrow conversations to downright orgies. The Duke
d'Orléans ruled from 1715 to 1723, while Louis XV was still in his minority, and these years
really set the tone for le batinage. Langorous, light-hearted, indolent and wildly erotic love
was part of the vocabulary, and this is what we see both in Boucher's paintings and of course
also in the most iconic of all Rococo paintings, Trigonard's Swing, or Les Hazards Heureux de
l'Escarpolette, as it was called. The happy chance of being under the swing, providing the man with
such a great view. I'll just show it to you here to highlight the lost shoe and the hat, and here
is a depiction on the right by Baudouin, Boucher's son-in-law and one of his assistants,
called Les Amants Surpris. You can see the lover escaping barefoot up the stairs, his hat is left
on the floor in front of the straw. Countless prints were made of this popular image, and often
the young girl has one shoe missing too. I don't think I need to explain any further the points
of the hat in the popular 18th century French print on the left. And back to shoes, on or off,
the two Kenwood paintings fit into the paradigm. I would argue that the exchange of produce is
much more about fidelity once they've promised themselves to each other, supported by the
domesticity of the rustic cottage and the mule, and the vertiginous heights of the ladder in the
with the barefoot peasant girl in the same pose as the drawing of the peasant girl dancing
I showed you earlier. Here transposed to more potentially wild exhilarating passion, which of
course dance can be too. And here is a close-up of spilt liquid from each of the four Kenwood paintings.
So, finally, why did these four paintings particularly appeal to Edward Cecil Guinness?
The enthusiasm for 18th century art in England had never gone away, so it was a survival of taste
rather than a revival of taste. The London market had been a profitable one for French art
ever since the end of the 18th century. That notwithstanding, maybe interest in the 18th century
had been rekindled partly by the Marquis of Hertford, who actually lived in Paris but who
collected Watteau and his successors, and then later by his son Richard Wallace. Together they
were to create the Wallace collection in 1900, and together they brought 21 paintings by Boucher to
London. It may also be that Guinness was already quite comfortable with 18th century art. He had
been a customer of Joseph Devine's father for some time and had bought tapestries from him.
Perhaps Boucher was an area where he felt at ease. Perhaps he wanted to keep up with the Joneses.
Julius Bryant links it in with his wish to leave Kenwood to the nation in the eye of the quest,
where the atmosphere of a gentleman's private park should be preserved. But that is conjecture.
It is a fact, however, that Guinness was buying them when critical taste was turning against
French Rococo art. How they all ended up in the Green Room together is rather satisfyingly linked
into brewing. All four paintings were owned by two business partners who ran London's largest and most
profitable 19th century brewery, the Lion Brewery. They were both avid collectors of French art,
and two of the early 19th century's important collectors. Through them, both flower gatherers,
the exchanger of produce, and the cherry gatherers ended up in the 4th Earl of Lonsdale's sale,
and Le Père Cher in the sale of Charles Godin. I like the idea that the four paintings were
already linked together by brewing money 50 years before Guinness bought the first three.
In conclusion, I would just like to pose the question, why is it that these paintings aren't
really examined further? And why is it that in preparing for this talk, I have found that such a
small proportion of his astonishing output is on display in the art collections of the world?
I think it might be a hangover from the prudery which has become so pervasive in Western society,
really since Boucher fell out of fashion with the French Revolution,
neoclassicism, and a stricter moral code from the 19th century. When the Wallace Collection opened,
St. James's Gazette observed, such a painter as Boucher is rather offensive by virtue of a
combination there is in him of a professed refinement and an essential coarseness more
gross than that of any Dutchman. Most critics refuse to accept Boucher as a great artist,
but acknowledge his qualities as a decorator. The Manchester Guardian referred to the
second-rate quality of his genius. Claude Phillips, the first director of the Wallace Collection,
defended him, not to recognize consummate art and the evolution of a style harmonizing
the imperfection with the architecture and decoration of a brilliant superficial period,
even when we are by instinct and training at war with it. Is not this to betray an absence
of the true critical sense? But even he was a bit lukewarm. He goes on to say that Boucher's
polysonnerie is mild and harmless enough. Polysonnerie is a great French word because
lasciviousness, frippery, foolery, and vulgarity are all wrapped up in the same word.
I think you only have to look at Boucher here to know how he would have reacted to such criticism.
Boucher's paintings have since been relegated to lower ranks, where they've been easily dismissed
as not very high art, and if not that, well, at least very frilly and old-fashioned. I hope this
morning I've helped elevate the status of Boucher so that next time you see his paintings and those
by his followers in the green room at Kenwood, you can have another think about an extraordinarily
gifted artist who did more than any other to determine the course of decorative arts
in the 18th century. Thank you very much.