Should we really be renaming Uranus and stop making fun of its name? How will astronomers deal with the floods of data when Vera Rubin comes online? Do little red dots found by Webb solve the mystery of supermassive black hole formation? And in our free Q&A+ on patreon, what are my personal space obsessions right now? Answering all these questions and more in this question show.
00:00 Start 00:34 [Kristin Holcomb] Do Little Red Dots explain the formation of supermassive black holes? 06:03 [AstRoephotography] How will astronomers deal with all the data from Vera Rubin? 07:55 [Ian James] Why do governments need to fund science? 11:21 [Keanan Mahoney] Should we rename Uranus? 13:23 [Julian Blake] What will ELT be able to find?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
should we rename Uranus and stop making
fun of its name how will astronomers
deal with the flood of data when Ver
Rubin comes online do little red dots
found by web solve the mystery of super
massive black hole formation and in our
free Q&A plus on Patreon what are my
personal space obsessions right now
answering all these questions and more
in this question show it's time for the
question show your questions my answers
as always wherever you are across my
channel if a question pops in your brain
just write it down i'll gather them up
and I will answer them here all right
let's get into the questions kristen
Hulcom do you think the discovery of
black holes in the middle of big red
dots explain how black holes appear in
the centers of galaxies so this thing
and it's actually it's little red dots
and this was an entirely new class of
astronomical object that was discovered
by the James Webb Space Telescope and so
when web was doing one of its surveys of
the distant universe looking at um you
know the farthest galaxies that it could
possibly see they found a bunch of these
weird red and even red you know it's an
infrared but they are redder than other
galaxies and they're very small and
astronomers are trying to figure out
what these things were and the sort of
conclusion that they've reached now is
that these are galaxies that are um
black hole heavy um so they're fairly
small probably like dwarf galaxies but
they have a surprisingly massive super
massive black hole at the hearts of them
compared to the mass of the rest of the
galaxy and then the region around the
black hole is shrouded in dust and so
that's putting out a lot of infrared
light that is then being redshifted
compared to other galaxies but this is
like we're at the very early stages of
figuring out what these things are
because it's right out of the very edge
of what James Webb can see and James
Webb is the most powerful space
telescope ever built designed for this
exact purpose but there's sort of like a
very interesting things that people are
finding early on in the universe you
know right now the Milky Way has a super
massive black hole at the heart of it
and it is about
0.1% the mass of the galaxy is tied up
in that black hole and you know people
always think oh you know what would
happen to the Milky Way if it lost its
super massive black hole like nothing it
is not the anchor it is not the bulk of
the mass of the Milky Way it is one tiny
little bit of the mass of the Milky Way
but when you go back early early early
on in the universe the ratio of black
hole to the rest of the galaxy seems to
go up and when you get all the way back
to these little red dots you're looking
at black holes that are 10% the mass of
the galaxy half the mass of the galaxy
and so one of the big fundamental
questions that James Webb is trying to
answer is how did those first galaxies
come together you know we know that
there are super massive black holes at
the hearts of pretty much every single
galaxy in the universe and so the
question is like did the black hole come
first and then it assembled a galaxy
around it or did the galaxy come
together first and then the various
black holes you know stars detonated
turned into black holes the black holes
merged together formed larger black
holes and eventually you you know it all
sunk down to the middle and you got this
super massive black hole and so if
you're seeing a much more massive black
hole compared to the mass of the galaxy
it's starting to give credence to the
idea that these super massive black
holes were starting to form
first and and then the rest of the
galaxy was starting to accrete around it
and that's weird because you know you
would think that for you'd be able to
get a super massive black hole you would
have to go through this process of
chaining together a whole bunch of
smaller you know you'd have the first
generation of stars they would explode a
supernova maybe some of them would leave
behind black holes those black holes
would find each other they would merge
into bigger black holes bigger black
holes and you would sort of go through
this geometric progression until you
finally reach things with tens of
millions hundreds of millions of times
the mass of the sun even billions of
times the mass of the sun but the other
possibility is that if the conditions
are right you could get super massive
black holes just forming directly it's
called direct collapse and what they
think well this is difficult to achieve
because as you have material that is
infalling to some region of space that
region heats up and as soon as you it
heats up to a certain point then that
blocks and prevents any further material
from infalling into it and then that
sort of puts a limit at the size of the
star that is possible to be made and you
know those limits are around 100 times
the mass of the sun and so you know how
are you going to get a super massive
black hole when you're limiting the
amount of mass to about 100 times the
mass of the sun actually those most
massive stars when they detonate they
don't leave any remnant behind so you
need smaller mass stars that can then
leave black holes that can merge
together but maybe there's some kind of
cooling effect some kind of way that
when the black holes were forming early
on in the universe out of primordial or
hydrogen and helium as that material was
falling in it was able to you know get
rid of the waste heat so that material
could actually efficiently come together
and actually pack down into an area that
would turn directly into a black hole
and that would give you a really nice
answer so you know James Web is designed
to answer these kinds of questions and
so now finally you know we can go from
theory to actual observations and you
know I think over the coming years we
will get some really good answers to
these kinds of questions and more
astrophotography hey Fraser when LSST
comes online how will astronomers deal
with enormous amounts of data will there
be more citizen science projects based
on the LST data lsst aka Ver Rubin will
be producing a ludicrous amount of data
it would wreck your bandwidth bill if
you try to download the data so what
they're going to do is two things
they're going to create a highlight reel
of data from Ver Rubin where they're
going to have various algorithms that
are looking through the new stuff that's
being found and then it's going to be
made available in one stream and so you
go and see and it'll say like new
supernova and new asteroid and planet 9
and all of this kind of stuff and so all
the highlights will be there but then
all the underlying data will be there as
well and so if somebody wants to do a
really comprehensive survey looking for
interesting things that have happened in
the sky you know show me all of the
variable stars that occurred in this
region of the sky during this period it
will be able to find all of that but
you're going to have to run gigantic
database queries so handling all of this
data is a big chunk of what uh is like
the underlying technology that the
people who are creating this observatory
are having to manage how do you let
astronomers feasibly search through that
much information um I'm going to be
interviewing the director of Ver Rubin
in a couple of weeks so I'm these are
the kinds of questions that I'm
absolutely going to be asking them it's
time to shout out our new patrons at the
$5 level and above marty S curveball
Jacob Beiel Sage of Roa Sika Ben Brett
Corel Katherine Scott Jack Prime
Oligator and JC Woodward join our
community at
patreon.com/universe today ian James why
do governments need to fund space
science or exploration why can't it come
from private industry investing in a
product or service so many of the most
incredible inventions and discoveries
that have been made by humanity have
been made in a way where there is no
commercial purpose you know we live in
this modern age with computers and the
internet and satellites and radio waves
and semiconductors and various medical
technology and all of this stuff physics
antimatter all this came from basic
research where somebody just had a
question i how does this work how does
the human brain work how does uh how
does the universe work how does light
move how does uh what is matter made up
of uh how what happens when you mix
various chemicals together that these
are these fundamental research questions
and we don't know what the answers are
now obviously there are certain kinds of
research that does have some kind of
commercial appeal and there are plenty
of of private companies that are willing
to spend lots of money to uh to try and
solve problems that are relevant to
their businesses you know the
pharmaceutical companies are a good
example of this that they spend tens of
billions of dollars a year on research
trying to figure out new drugs that they
can then commercialize but most of the
big advances in in our overall level of
science have come from basic research
what companies out there would be
willing to spend tens of billions of
dollars to understand the very nature of
gravity right like what does that get
you like anti-gravity probably not and
yet as we better understand gravity then
maybe down the road we'll come up with
something so often the payoff for this
basic research is decades later even
centuries after is when we finally get
this and the nations that invest the
most amount in science are the ones that
get the biggest payoff it's like a very
direct like you can see that there is a
multiple of investments in science that
then turn into effects in the economy
down the road uh and the greatest
example of this is the United States
it's like historically the United States
is the biggest investor in science and
has the most advanced nation on earth
those two things are connected and so
you can never expect that private
industry is going to spend research on
on that kind of stuff you'll get some
for sure like you know deep mind spent
lots and lots of money trying to
investigate artificial intelligence and
so yeah there was some government
spending on artificial intelligence but
most of it has come from private
industry so great right um but other
stuff it is just there's no value in it
for for private companies and yet we
depend on those incredible advances so
it can just it has to come from from
some organization that isn't looking for
a return on investment and the only one
that we've been able to come up with so
far is government and I guess nonprofit
charities kenim Mahoney what is your
opinion of renaming Uranus to Kais it's
too late it's got its name there's no
going back
so like and what do you do right like do
you rename it to Kais because you just
like think people can't handle it being
a silly name is that what we're going to
do we're going to be like a nanny state
like can't people have fun can't people
both have science and be giggly children
like can't we have both i think we can
do both i think that we can calmly and
cooly discuss the fascinating science on
an ice giant planet in the outer solar
system that we're only just learning you
know the slightest things about it
because we've only had one flyby from
Voyager 2 that you know all of our
ongoing observations you know we only
just a couple of weeks ago finally
figured out its rotation rate has some
fascinating moons it is a serious place
to study and its name also sounds like a
bum isn't that funny we can you know
sounds like your butthole we can do both
it's okay you can say that we need to
send a probe to Uranus to study its
gas it's funny because it sounds like a
butthole uh but also it's an interesting
scientific place of study like this is
the
name and this is the one we use this is
how we say it and like like that could
be your hill like this is the hill you
want that you just can't handle people
being
silly then you will just spend your
whole life
fighting just just just go with it
just don't fight it julian Blake what
cool science do you know is planned for
the European Southern Observatory's
Extremely Large Telescope which is now
being built in Chile the Extremely Large
Telescope which is going to be the
follow-on telescope to the Very Large
Telescope is a 39 m telescope that is
currently being built it's expected to
do first light in
2027 so it's really just a couple of
years away um and it is like it's the
biggest telescope on Earth by far uh you
know there's a couple of other super
telescopes that are going to be in the
running there's the giant Mellan
telescope uh there's the 30 m telescope
although that's been delayed but there's
going to be this whole class of new
giant telescopes and when it comes
online it will be the most powerful
telescope ever built bar none like it'll
be more powerful than Hubble uh it'll be
more powerful than James Webb although
it'll sort of be different than James
Webb and it will be a ludicrously
powerful telescope um and so like what
can it do well it can do anything a
telescope can do like it's you know it
is is just a super duper telescope uh
and so all of the kinds of operations
that astronomers are going to use
various telescopes for this one will
give them better resolution will give
them more light gathering capacity it
has all of the bells and whistles that
all of the big observatories have it has
adaptive optics it's got eight lasers
that come out of it and so it can make
all of these guide stars in the sky that
it can then use to modify the underlying
uh mirrors to be able to account for
atmospheric distortion so some of the
things that it will be able to do for
example is it will be able to
theoretically observe earth-sized worlds
orbiting around sunlike stars so you
know this holy grail of being able to
see another earth now the challenge is
that getting a coronagraph powerful
enough to be able to do that is pretty
tricky and a lot of the underlying
coronagraph technology has already been
developed for the very large telescope
these are the 8 meter telescopes the
four telescopes but new images of
exoplanets just like anything telescopes
do just better so there's a paper that
we reported on on Universe Today about a
month ago where we were looking into or
someone posted a paper about how for
example it will be able to directly
image exo Neptunes and exo Saturns and
ex Jupiters and things like that and exo
earths and that with just an hour of
time it will be able to characterize the
atmosphere of a Neptune orbiting around
another star and with 10 hours of time
it should be able to characterize the
atmosphere of a terrestrial planet
orbiting around another star so you know
these are just dreamed of capabilities
for the astronomical community so you
know it's a good thing that Ver Rubin is
going to come and we're all going to get
really excited about it because the next
big telescope that we're all going to
get super excited about is going to be
the Extremely Large Telescope did you
know that you could watch the same video
with no ads for free and get a bonus
question over on Patreon we call it Q&A
Plus and this week's bonus question is
all about what I'm obsessed with right
now all right those are all the
questions that we have this week thank
you everyone who put your questions into
the YouTube comments everybody who
showed up for the live show our
2hour live questions extravaganza which
uh we record every Monday at 5:00 p.m
somewhere in the world so I'll put a
link to where the next event is going to
be so you can find that now I'm going to
shout out some more smaller science
YouTubers but first I'd like to thank
our patrons thanks to Abe Kingston
Andrew Gross Brayley Griffing Brian Body
Carwin Chuck Hawkins Commander Block S
Nelson David Gilson David Matz Dustin
Cable Evan P Greg Phy Henshults Husen
Ward Jay Graves James Clark Jerry Matter
Jim Burke Jordan Young Josh Schultz
Marcel Smiths Michael Purcell Model Paul
Robuck Ren Kyu Rob Sean Sergeant Steven
Filer Munley Vlad Chevlin and Wolf Gang
Clots who support us at the master of
the universe level all your support
means the universe to us so I've been
really trying to use my uh influence my
following as a way to try and shout out
other YouTubers out there and I've got a
few more picks this week to direct you
at the first up is Abdar Astro and he
does uh like telescope reviews and he's
someone who I stumbled onto while I was
looking for more information about the
Sea Star that I just purchased and so
he's only got 5,000 subscribers and yet
has got just tons of content about
different kinds of telescopes the sea
star celestron and sort of lots of
guides so if you're into amateur
astronomy astrophotography check out his
channel the next one is 1 minute geology
and these people only have about 2400
subscribers and yet they're producing an
enormous amount of content these short
really detailed geology videos about
various places in the UK mostly and it's
very cool because they sort of stand in
front of a very interesting geological
formation and then give you some very
detailed information it's very technical
but also really cool uh and then the
last one that I want to share with you
is Tom Dunes UK space news with only
1,600 subscribers and so you know
there's a lot of space news about what's
happening with SpaceX and of SpaceX and
also more about SpaceX but there are
other sort of places where rockets are
being launched and there actually is a
burgeoning spaceflight industry in the
UK and Tom covers different launch
complexes different manufacturers that
are producing things and uh it's great
to see like that level of hyper
specialization uh but also like really
well polished good quality video uh good
narration so uh definitely check that
out again if you know of small YouTubers
who are producing great science topics
explanations please let me know so that
I can help give them a shout out here
all right we will see you next