相機的像素其實一點也不重要

相機在握
76粉絲
3 次觀看·2025年10月13日
你需要一個6K的攝影機嗎?
你需要一個8K的攝影機嗎?
你需要一個12K的黑魔法攝影機嗎?
這將會是我認為2.8K的原因
是你真正需要的
Steve Yedlin是一個電影製作人
他製作了《The Last Jedi》
《The Knives Out》和《Looper》的電影
他和導演Ryan Johnson合作過很多年
他是一位非常有智慧的電影製作人
他做過無數的測試
對攝影機的不同解像度進行對比
他做了非常有意思的分析
為什麼解像度不再重要
他討論了為什麼
這些解像度戰爭讓我們意想不到的地方
他做了無數的測試
示範瞭如何
幾乎不可分辨的
我真的同意他
我覺得我們已經到了
這些公司想要我們購入的市場化
當然有一個爭議
是能夠增長解像度
我覺得這只是一個合理的爭議
為什麼解像度要比4K高
我真的很喜歡Sony 鏡頭
如F-X30
它們可以從6K到4K超級測試
這對所有優點和優勢都有幫助
儲存量減少
光源更好
連線減少
更好的細節
You can't really tell the difference between a really good 2.8K image and a 4K image
Unless you're talking about compression
Because especially here on YouTube, a lot of people upload in 4K
Because you have a different bit rate and a different compression
As opposed to uploading something in 1080
And Yedlin has made the case that it would render us better image quality
If we actually focused more on the compression of the image
That we're getting the stream of the image than the resolution
Because if you're just compressing 4K
Then you're going to get artifacts, you're going to get problems
Whereas if we had, especially in the streaming services
We had 2.8K be uncompressed or at a higher bit rate
We would be getting better image quality
So many films have been shot on these lower resolutions
Zodiac was shot on 2K
And I know Lady Bird was shot on 2K
I'm just thinking of movies just off the top of my mind
And for the longest time before the Alexa was forced to have internal 4K
It was upscaling 2.8K to 4K
And it looked wonderful
And I feel like a lot of things are more important than resolution, obviously
It's been said before
Our eyes are more sensitive to color
Here are some things that I think are more exciting than resolution
We have global shutter
That would be great if they could have more global shutter at affordable prices
Dual gain sensors, which not to be confused with dual ISO
Dual gain sensors work in a different way
And of course internal stabilization
That is something that would be very helpful
Overall resolution is probably overrated
I feel like there was a huge leap between standard definition and HD
But after that leap was made
I really don't see a need to keep trying to get more resolution
You hear people talking about the cinematic image
Steve Yedlin is one of the cinematographers that really knows what they're talking about
He is behind some of the best film emulations that I've ever seen
In fact the first Knives Out movie I thought was shot on film when I first saw it
And I was wrong
The attention to detail he puts into that
I believe that was only shot at 2.8K
And people talk about, especially here on this channel
I love that film emulation look
I love that older film look
We're talking about stuff that is not high resolution
We're talking about stuff that is degraded but has a beauty to it
Of being sharp without being sharp
When we get too much into the 6Ks and 12Ks
We're getting too much of that clinical, over sharpened
I don't know, it's becoming
There's nothing wrong with that
It's becoming its own sort of look
But if you're trying to get for that film look
Then the less resolution will actually be in your favor
Of course I'm talking about something above HD
Because if you start going below HD
Then you are getting into stuff that doesn't look great
I wish more cameras would focus more on giving us less compression
Than focusing on these resolutions
That are just going to be unsustainable
Especially since the higher the resolution
The more you have to compress
So if these camera manufacturers could focus more on
More uncompressed codecs
More color fidelity
And more cameras that are shooting at 10-bit
I think it'd be great
I don't know, there's been so many great movies
That are shot at 2K or less than 4K
And they still hold up today
If you absolutely need 12K to tell your story
Then I think it's either you're doing something really unique
Or you're just not prioritizing what's most important
