The Palazzo Ducale Bascinet

HISTORIC Weapons
3 followers
Apr 22, 2025
The ca.1400 great bascinet at the Palazzo Ducale in Venice, Italy is one of the most curious medieval helmets to survive to the present day. Renowned armorer Robert "Mac" MacPherson has built the world's most accurate reproduction of this helmet with the help of Dr. Nicolas Baptiste, to better understand the real object and perhaps shed some light on the realities of a very misunderstood and often dismissed historical object.
Hi guys, welcome back. I'm Ian La Spina, and today we are going to be taking a look at one of the
most famous and curious medieval helmets in existence, the Great Bassinet at the Palazzo
du Cale, a rather unique circa 1400 surviving medieval helmet housed at the Doge's Palace
in Venice, Italy. To help us with that, I have the privilege of being able to play host to,
and ultimately to share with you, the finest reproduction of that helmet to ever exist,
recently completed by Robert McPherson in an effort to better understand the real thing,
and perhaps shed some light on how this helmet really functioned.
Not a whole lot is known about the origin of the real helmet. Today, it is publicly viewable
as part of the collection of the Palazzo du Cale, parts of which date to the time of the helmet's
original use at the turn of the 14th and 15th centuries. The earliest potential reference to
this helmet comes from a 1611 inventory of the Venice Arsenal that refers to a headpiece
described as an ancient helmet and visor, and is mentioned by both Giuseppe de Luce and Guy
Francis Laking in the early 20th century, but both confirm that the description is too vague to be
sure that it references our helmet. At some point in the helmet's history, it and another piece in
the collection at the Doge's Palace, a horse's chafron, became dubiously associated with the
equipment of Attila the Hun, a legend that for obvious reasons has no merit, but you may still
today see the helmet referenced as the helmet of Attila in some sources. In fact, one of the first
definitive references to this helmet, unmistakable thanks to the accompanying drawing, comes from
Gravenbrock, dated to the mid-18th century. It refers to the helmet as the supposed helmet of
Attila, so we know that the legend had already been attached at that early date. Another reference to
the helmet, this time from Victor Gay's 19th century Glossaire Archéologique, treats us to
another image of the helmet, and the possibility that it made its way into the Venice Arsenal
originally from Achillea, although with no previous references to its origin and no further explanation,
it is unclear why this is thought to be the case. Unfortunately, its true origins may never be known
with certainty. Due to the peculiar nature of the helmet and the fact that almost no other
survivals exist, people sometimes call its authenticity into question. However, having
established references to this helmet as already old by at least the mid-18th century, the skills
and methods employed by forgers at the time and even later are not known to be up to the task
to replicate some of the techniques required to build the helmet as it exists. The entire skull
is a single piece, the only separate component is the visor itself. The helmet bears none of the
telltale stylistic mistakes or material problems or even the more subtle warning signs that tend
to give away fakes. The construction of the real helmet is very interesting. Other forms of
contemporary and later great bassinet are most often constructed with multiple plates, usually
with riveted collar or bever plates, sometimes movable. The Palazzo di Cale skull is instead
made from one massive plate. Its general shape differs from what we think of as more typical
shapes for surviving great bassinets as well, but as we'll see through the course of the video, it's
not entirely alien in contemporary artwork. The visor retains the pointed fashion of more
traditional bassinets, and in comparison to the greater family of helmets, the ventail plates
extend out quite far laterally towards the shoulders, giving a very broad appearance that
gives the impression of a massive helmet even more immobile than the family of helmets to which
it belongs, a family of helmets already known to limit mobility. After looking at the helmet, many
people are quick to dismiss it as a curiosity or a failed one-off that was obviously unsuitable for
task. But is this really true? Can it move? How is it supposed to fit? Does it really sit down on the
shoulders or is it supported by the head and neck? Speculation only gets us so far. Lucky for us,
Robert Macpherson, or Mac as most people know him, the man who built Toby Capwell's famous Black
English armor and many other masterpieces, an armor whose cast-off scrap pile is filled with
components that most other modern armors would dream of being able to make, has had a fascination
with the Palazzo Ducale bassinet for decades. One of the best ways to learn about this helmet
would be to try it on. Unfortunately, most museums frown at the idea of handing over their treasures
for people to play dress-up with, so the next best thing is a reproduction to serve as a surrogate.
The problem faced is that the insights gained from a reproduction are only as good as the
There is a temptation to alter the design to correct perceived mistakes or fit it to a specific
individual, but any deviation from the original threatens the potential results. We don't know
exactly how it's supposed to fit. We don't know for sure what type of armor it was intended to
be worn with. We don't know if it was a helmet intended only for the tournament or a helmet for
war. We can make educated guesses, of course, but changing the helmet to fulfill a preconceived idea
of what we think the helmet is supposed to do defeats the purpose of the experiment. If the
duplicate is not an accurate match to the original, you will inevitably draw erroneous conclusions
based on the faults found in the reproduction that are not representative of the real thing.
To give ourselves a fighting chance at useful results, the copy has to be as faithful as
possible to the survival. When Mack began to plan the project in 2017, information detailed enough
to reproduce the helmet to the standard necessary simply wasn't available, so he reached out to Dr.
Nicholas Baptiste, the gentleman whom, at the time, was in charge of the research for the Palazzo
Ducale. Dr. Baptiste was able to provide critical help in supplying information, images, and hands-on
measurements of the real helmet to ensure that Mack's reproduction could be as accurate as possible.
Armed with all of this data, Mack could begin work. There is still a significant hurdle to overcome,
though. Even with all of this information, it only tells us about the helmet in its present state,
an over 600-year-old artifact with its share of dents and cracks and missing decoration,
missing parts, and so on. To learn about how the helmet would have functioned during its working
life, Mack would need to build the helmet as it was around the year 1400, not as it is.
So how do you figure out what the helmet looked like when it was first made, or what's missing?
The helmet itself gives us plenty of clues as to the missing details.
Even a casual observation of the helmet gives us some hints about the type of decoration that
was once present. On the visor, we can see pierced holes all the way around the perimeter.
You can also see slightly different patination along the edge, presenting like a faint shadow
in the shape of a narrow, constant-width band that traces its way around all of the edges.
Some of the holes found along the perimeter even retain their original brass rivets.
As we know, copper alloys, or Latin, applied borders, were a common mode of decoration
for helmets of the late 14th and early 15th century. So we can be pretty confident,
based on what we see and what remains, that this is exactly what's missing from our helmet.
With the visor raised, along the brow you can see the closely spaced holes we would expect
the helmet's liner to be sewn to. These holes continue down toward the corner of the jaw and
around the back of the head where a leather would have been installed with rivets, to attach the
liner all the way around. But we also have an additional row of holes just below the liner
holes that trace their way around the facial opening in the same arrangement as the outside
edge of the visor, cluing us in to the presence of an original decorative band here as well.
The ventail plate has several rows of holes. A few inches up there is a row that still retains
many intact flush rivets. Further toward the edge we have two closely spaced rows of holes.
The row nearest the edge appears to retain a few brass rivet heads, and the presence of the same
faded shadow along the hem indicates that Latin borders were installed here too. We know applied
borders were usually engraved with decoration, but since they are all missing, we have to look
for other clues to figure out how this might have once been embellished. The visor pivots,
and one of the hinges still retain their decorative caps. The right side specifically
has both the pivot cap and the covering on the hinge. If we look closely at the hinge,
we can make out the small engraved geometric pattern of repeating triangles that, lucky for us,
remain intact and haven't been worn away. The pattern's dimensions would fit well on the
Latin borders and is our best candidate for the original decorative motif.
What about the other rows of holes around the ventail plate? What are those for?
If the helmet itself isn't willing to give up all of its secrets that easy,
Mack would have to look further afield. Similar helmets in sculpture and illustration might
provide us with some insight into what might be going on here. The tomb of Philip the Bold,
Duke of Burgundy, and Dijon offers a strong possibility that elegantly explains the next
rows of holes. The great bassinet here is not terribly dissimilar to the Palazzo Ducale helmet,
and we get to look inside thanks to our angelic friends. We can see a quilted textile lining that
originates a few inches up the inside of the ventail, backing an integral fringe of mail.
This is a strong candidate for what's going on with the Palazzo Ducale bassinet for a variety
of reasons. It would very conveniently fit the helmet as it is, and it matches what we see in
contemporary visual sources as well, which seem to show similar arrangements, at least from what is
visible on the outside. This solution utilizes the other rows of holes as they are and is consistent
with medieval construction methods. Mack has used the innermost of the two rows of holes around the
edge to rivet a leather around the hem. The leather is the attachment point for the mail fringe.
The next row of holes up from there attaches an additional leather and serves as an anchor
point for the quilted textile liner. This cushions and stabilizes the helmet on the wearer while also
lining the mail fringe as we would expect. The mail is in turn whipped to the hem of the quilted
fabric. The other thing this mail fringe solves is the gap created by this helmet. Having a completely
rigid throat defense with no movable plates and what is a rather shallow curve along the bottom
opening when viewed from profile, the helmet wants to leave a rather significant gap open under the
chin. This was one of the things that seemed to become evident in the initial stages of planning
when we looked at some photo compositing to get a general idea of how the helmet might fit.
This gap would be bad for obvious reasons. The presence of a lightly cushioned mail fringe here
has the effect of filling this gap rather nicely and as we will examine later, serves a very
important function. We still have another set of unoccupied holes on the original helmet.
A set of three holes exist just below where the bottom edge of the visor makes contact with the
ventail plate. One at either end of the corners of the visor and one hole at the center. The central
hole is not just a round piercing though, it's been filed horizontally creating a small angular
recess in the plate. During the research stage of the reproduction, it was Tom Billeter who first
suggested the most likely candidate for these three mystery holes. He had been looking at some
other artwork and a few figures on an altarpiece seem to be wearing the possible answer. This is
the altarpiece of Bonifaci Ferrer. I want to draw your attention to two figures in particular,
one here in the central panel of the crucifixion and the other on the left panel depicting the
conversion of Paul the Apostle on the road to Damascus. If you're not looking for the detail,
it's easy to gloss over and at first glance they look like they're wearing versoons or the fabric
covering sometimes worn over a male aventail, but they also seem to have what appears to be a stop
rib affixed just below the face. If these are in fact stop ribs, it implies that there could be a
rigid defense under these coverings. With this idea in mind, a broadening search revealed other
sources that show even clearer depictions of stop ribs under the chin on certain great bassinets.
Another incredible altarpiece, this one depicting the life of Saint George, features a fabulous
painting on its central panel of a battle that shows several figures in great bassinets from the
same time period as the Palazzo Ducale helmet with very clear stop ribs affixed in just the right
place. One figure even treats us to the rivet head securing it to the ventail. The three round
mystery holes now make sense. The central hole with its filed recess is perfectly shaped to
receive the rectangular stock of a stop rib and even give it added support. Its dimensions define
the width of the original stop rib and the other two holes give us its length. The bottom edge of
the visor sits just above the central recess and the line traced by its lower edge will define the
curve of the stop rib. Mystery solved. Another interesting detail that came up during the
reconstruction was the fact that if you look carefully at the real helmet, you'll notice that
the right shoulder sits ever so slightly higher than the left. Now, when we look at most medieval
armor, there is always going to be asymmetry. Even on things that are, for all intents and purposes,
intended to be functionally symmetrical, it's simply the nature of handwork in a pre-industrial
age and a normal part of medieval craftsmanship. But, we also know that when intentional asymmetries
show up in armor, they tend to favor extra mobility on the right side to accommodate the
Was this an intentional feature or simply the result of asymmetries of handwork? The only way
to examine this further was to emulate it in the reproduction. So, in keeping with the philosophy
of the experiment, that is what Mack chose to do. It's not obvious at first, but especially from
behind, you can see how the right shoulder is hiked up just a tiny bit compared to the left.
So, now that we have this amazing reproduction of the real helmet, how does it fit? Does it work?
Well, let's put it on. Okay, so now I've got the helmet on and we can see how it actually looks on
a person in armor. As many of you know, my armor is based on early 15th century English sources,
so even though it's contemporary, it may not be the best stylistic match to an Italian helmet.
But, at the same time, arms like this, although most associated with the English style,
are not entirely unknown in Italy in the late 14th century. The basic shape of my breastplate
is fairly universal for the time, so the match may not be as bad as first assumed,
at least not where it matters most, where the helmet interacts with the rest of the armor.
Remember, we don't necessarily know what the right armor is for this helmet, so trying it on a
variety of armors is an important first step in attempting to see what works and what doesn't.
Now, lucky for me, the helmet fits fairly well. From the front, you can see how the slope of the
ventail creates a pleasing line that flows into the curve of the shoulders. When the visor is
raised, you can see how small the facial opening is. It protects as much of the face as possible
while still permitting you to see and breathe, and to speak clearly if one needed to issue commands
or respond to them. One thing you'll probably notice right away is that the ventail plates
themselves are not actually putting all of their weight on my shoulders. The majority of the
weight is being supported by my head and neck. This was something that we started to suspect in
the early stages of planning the helmet. You'll remember some of the photocompositing we tried
early on, and even with compositing the helmet onto historical figures with rather extreme
proportions, the images still seem to suggest that the geometry of the helmet would keep it
up a little bit higher than most assume. Now, photocompositing is very limited for a variety of
reasons, but now that the reproduction has been built, it seems to support the idea of the helmet
not resting entirely on the cuirass. Wait a second, can this be right? Surely such a massive
helmet would become overwhelmingly burdensome if not supported entirely by the cuirass.
It turns out that the real helmet weighs about 5.3 kilos, or 11 and a half pounds.
That sounds heavy for a helmet, but is it? We have to remember that this helmet is replacing
both a bassinet and its male aventail. Many surviving bassinets without their aventails
weigh around the 3 kilo mark. Kerberg 13 with helmet and aventail is about 5.7 kilos, and Kerberg
15 over 6. The Lyle bassinet tips the scales at over 7 kilograms. Inevitably, the male fringe
would have added some weight to the original, but it's certainly not out of line with the weight of
regular bassinets equipped with traditional aventails. Some of the weight of an aventail
is borne by the shoulders of course, as is some of the male fringe on our reproduction of the
Palazzo Ducale bassinet, but on me, with my proportions and configuration of armor, the bulk
of the weight is supported by my head, just like a regular bassinet, and I would add, very comfortably
so. This opens up possibilities for the helmet. Suddenly it's not locked down hard to the shoulders
like many of us assumed of the original. It actually enables me to move the helmet in the
rotational plane very comfortably, with a modest amount of movement as I tilt my head up and down
as well. I don't get as much movement as I would in a traditional bassinet, but it's certainly
enough for most applications, and more than many other styles of medieval helmet. From the side,
it becomes obvious how beneficial the male fringe is to eliminating the gap we brought up earlier.
If the real helmet is supposed to sit up and off the shoulders to permit modest movement,
the absence of a male fringe would spell trouble. Even with a stop rib on the breastplate,
without the male fringe, a lance or sword point can easily find its way up and under the helmet.
The male fringe acts like a flexible gasket that not only keeps the visual line of the helmet
uninterrupted by an unsightly gap, but it keeps this gap well defended as the wearer moves the
helmet around. One of the most important defensive qualities of male is that it will catch and foul
the point of a weapon, so anything riding up the breastplate should get snagged in this net
of iron rings, hopefully before threatening injury to the wearer. Should it slip past,
hopefully a significant amount of energy has been taken out of the blow by the time it encounters
the stop rib of the breastplate. Another important thing to see here is that simply tilting the
helmet forward just a little has the effect of sealing the front of the ventail quite well with
the curve of the breastplate, ensuring that this gasket of male has every chance to catch an errant
point should it need to. The other important thing to realize here is that once the entire
front of the ventail is in direct contact with the cuirass, the force from a solid blow to the helmet
is partially imparted to your torso armor instead of your skull and cervical spine. This gives the
wearer the opportunity to brace to receive a blow to take advantage of that force dissipation while
still allowing for movement when needed. Now we can see how vitally important this stop rib is.
On some later great bassinets, the visor when down slightly underlaps an often movable front
collar plate, but on our helmet a different solution is needed. Without it, the ventail
offers a smooth ramp, ideal for any point or blade to slide right up and under the bottom edge
of the visor. This would be catastrophic for anyone counting on this helmet to save their life,
but with the stop rib in place, especially with a sharp point, that lance or spear point will
easily be turned aside. What about the asymmetrical right shoulder and arm movement? One thing we
wanted to look at was how the helmet interacts with the shoulder while couching a lance.
Here you can see that the helmet accommodates my shoulder quite well.
This one is tricky though and it's hard to draw any definitive conclusion. We have no real way
of knowing for sure if this slight asymmetry in the original helmet was intended or if it was
an accident that just happens to accommodate this action, but in this case it doesn't hurt anything
and it does comfortably allow for any slight hiking of my right shoulder that may result from
this position. Shoulder abduction is impeded in this style of helmet. As I raise my arms out to
the side, you will see that as I approach 90 degrees, my arm harness will make contact with
the helmet and I can no longer continue to raise my arms or I will risk pushing the helmet up and
off my own head. This would make taking any sort of overhead guard with a sword or axe like Fiore's
High Serpent challenging, and defending an overhead blow on foot could be difficult. At the same time
it's not uncommon in contemporary Italian artwork to see people fighting on foot with no rigid
shoulder defense at all. In Fiore, figures are frequently shown on foot having shed their
pauldrons and fighting with only mail on the shoulders. This would increase the range of motion
you could achieve in such a helmet while fighting on foot. The wide lateral reach of the helmet even
serves to indirectly defend a mail-clad shoulder more so than other styles of helmet. If you force
it though, you again run the risk of tipping the helmet up and off your head. This leads us to a
question of helmet retention. The real helmet is damaged in several places. In addition to the
cracks around the edge, the helmet has a rather large square shaped hole in the rear center vent
tail. This hole is a lot bigger than any of the other piercings in the helmet, but it's possible
the hole was widened at some point either during or after its working life. One thing we occasionally
see in the art of the late 14th century on traditional bassinets and then later on great
bassinets is a strap originating from the rear of the helmet. It's possible that on the real helmet,
this hole once served to fix a back strap enabling the wearer to secure the helmet to their back
defense. If we look again at our image of Philip the Bold, it appears this exact arrangement might
be at work here. This would eliminate the problem I'm experiencing with arm movement by retaining
the helmet when you push on it from below. It's also very important to remember that in many
configurations of Italian armor at this time, especially with the emergence of large pauldrons
for cavalry use, your arms are going to be considerably restricted in this range anyway.
Having a helmet that prevents end range shoulder abduction is not as troubling as it may seem
when it's perfectly normal for your arm and shoulder harness to stop this motion anyway.
Wait, would you lose all the head movement I've been talking about if we strapped the helmet down?
I don't think you would. As long as the strap is tight enough to prevent the helmet from coming
off, it can still be left slack enough to permit movement. It could conceivably be tightened down
hard for certain scenarios as well. This could be a good experimental modification down the line.
We also have to remember that as modern people we have this tendency to want perfect armor that
lets you do absolutely everything and anything while keeping you perfectly safe. This just isn't
how real armor works. There is always the trade-off between mobility and protection. As you increase
one, you almost invariably affect the other. Different armors are suited to different tasks,
and that means letting you do what you need to do in the role it was designed for, not necessarily
allowing you to do anything you wish you could do in any possible imagined scenario. The question
we need to be asking then becomes, can I move enough to do what the armor was intended for?
This brings us back to the role of this particular helmet and the type of armor it was supposed to
be worn with. Could this helmet have been intended exclusively for the joust? Was it a heavy cavalry
helmet? Could it have served on foot in the tournament? At war? I think there are arguments
to be made for a lot of different cases here, and we have to remember that I am just a sample size
of one. How this helmet fits me and how well I can move in it applies only to a person in my
configuration of armor with my body proportions, my neck length, my head size, etc. It could behave
very differently on someone else. It's a bit of a Cinderella slipper scenario. One of Mack's goals
from the very beginning was to try and get this helmet on as many different people as he could.
The more people who try it on, the more we might be able to gain insight into all of these questions
that we have about it. The good news is that this process has already begun. Earlier this year, the
helmet made its way to an event called The Forging, a gathering of armors hosted here in the United
States, where people from all over the world have the opportunity to come and share their
knowledge. A lot of people got to try on the helmet, and I think it's safe to say that a lot
of assumptions were challenged when they saw just what it could do in person. In early November at
the Chivalric Fighting Arts Symposium, I had the opportunity to try this helmet on a number of
armored fighters with a variety of different body shapes, heights, proportion, styles of armor,
and I photographed them in various standardized poses so that we can compare how the helmet
behaves in different positions, test how mobility changes on different people, see if the helmet
really does stand up and off the shoulders, or if certain body types and armors do cause the
helmet to sit entirely on the cuirass. We are just at the very beginning phases of trying to organize
and analyze this information, but so far what we are seeing is that this helmet is a lot more
capable than many have given it credit for in the past. The encouraging thing is that we are
finding the helmet fits on a broad range of people reasonably well while fitting others very well.
There are of course body types that just don't work with this helmet too, those with particularly
long necks for instance, but so far, the people who have tried it on, even on those with shorter
necks or robust shoulder defenses, the helmet still tends to sit mostly off the shoulders
allowing for some movement. I for one really look forward to seeing what we can learn in the future
and I hope you do too. I would like to conclude with a very special thanks to Dr. Nicholas Baptiste
whose assistance and interest enabled this reproduction to be made to such an exacting standard
and for his help with understanding the history of this piece, and of course to Mr. Robert McPherson.
A personal thanks for allowing me the privilege of playing host to what is easily one of the most
important historical reproductions in recent history, but more importantly as a man to whom
every armor enthusiast on the planet owes a great deal for his tireless dedication to his craft,
and not only for his expertise and skill, but for his overwhelming generosity in sharing what he
has learned with the rest of this community of devotees to the armorer's art. As always guys,
thank you all so much for watching. I hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, you know what to do,
and special thanks to those of you who have generously decided to support the channel on
Patreon. You have my gratitude, and I will see you all in the next one. Bye.
