Tang Dynasty Beauty Standards: How plump was Yang Guifei?

Antique Style
15 followers
#tangdynasty #yangguifei
In this video, we uncover the truth behind the widely debated figure of Yang Guifei, one of the most famous beauties of the Tang Dynasty. Was she as plump as the legends suggest? The video delves into the changing beauty standards of the Tang Dynasty, from the delicate figures of the early period to the voluptuous ideal of the flourishing Tang era. By analyzing art, literature, and historical accounts, we explore how the depiction of Yang Guifei's appearance evolved over time and why much of it is based on later interpretations rather than solid historical evidence. Join us as we separate myth from reality and discover the deeper cultural and historical significance behind the aesthetics of the Tang Dynasty.
Welcome back, everyone.
We're diving into a topic today
that I think is going to be
pretty interesting.
We're going back in time to Tang
Dynasty China.
Yeah. And to be specific,
we're looking at beauty standards
during the reign from 618 to 907
A.D.
Talking about why
were plump women considered
beautiful during that time?
It's such a rich period.
Yeah.
Artistically, culturally, I think
we'll find some surprises along the
I think so, too.
And the really cool thing about
this is we've got poems, we've got
essays, we've got paintings,
sculptures, even figurines.
Oh, wow. Yeah.
Lots to look at.
It's a lot to unpack.
It is. And get ready for some
twists and turns, because we're
going to uncover some unexpected
connections to calligraphy,
to horses and even city
planning.
I love that.
Yeah. It's going to be a ride.
One thing I was surprised about.
Well, I guess I shouldn't have been
surprised was that Tang Dynasty
beauty standards, just like today's,
were constantly evolving.
It's not like one size fits all
back then any more than it is today.
Right. Yeah.
And it's interesting you say
that, because while we often
associate the Tang Dynasty with a
fuller figure, early Tang
actually favored a more slender
form, echoing the aesthetics
of the previous dynasties.
Those tiny waists we read about in
early Tang poems.
Exactly.
Were very much in vogue.
Yeah, they were. And you can see it
reflected in the artwork, too.
If you look at Jan Lieben's
Thirteen Emperor Scroll, those
palace maids are quite slender,
even though they have these fuller
faces.
So almost like a bridge between two
eras of beauty.
OK, so when does this shift towards
celebrating plumpness really
take hold?
Well, Empress Wu Zetian's reign from
624 to 705
AD seems to mark a
turning point.
She was obviously a powerful ruler.
Significantly, both she and her
daughter, Princess Taiping, were
described as having fuller figures.
Some even say that the Grand Buddhist
Statue at the Longmen
Grottoes was modeled after
her.
Really?
Now, whether or not that's true,
the very suggestion, I think, speaks
volumes about how influential
she was and how her image
might have influenced the perception
of beauty.
I mean, she was a trailblazer in so
many ways.
Absolutely.
I mean, why why would a preference
for a fuller figure emerge during
this time?
It's interesting to consider the
context.
Yeah.
The Tang Dynasty rulers hailed from
the north, where women were known for
their strength and horsemanship.
OK.
There's even a folk song about Liko
Bo's sister, Yongrong,
that describes her chasing horses
and hitting two targets with one
arrow.
Wow.
OK, so maybe those northern women
brought their own ideas about beauty
and strength.
That's certainly possible.
And if you want an even more
striking example.
OK.
Look no further than Princess Ping
Yang, the daughter of the founding
emperor.
OK.
She actually commanded an army.
But here's where it gets
interesting, right?
Despite their own capabilities,
these northern women might have
felt pressure to conform
to the southern ideal
of delicate beauty
that had persisted from earlier
times.
So almost like a push and pull.
Exactly.
It makes you wonder if those
northern women coming in were
sending like a subtle message like,
hey, true strength can be beautiful
too.
Right. Exactly.
But of course, no conversation about
Tang Dynasty beauty would be
complete without mentioning
Yang Guifei.
Right.
She's always held up as the epitome
of.
Yeah, Yang Guifei.
Of that era's beauty.
Yes. The beloved concubine of
Emperor Xuanzang.
But separating fact from
fiction when it comes to Yang
Guifei can be tricky.
You mean those claims about her
exact weight and height being
historical fact?
Exactly. Those numbers are often
based on speculation or
later embellishments.
It's amusing, really.
Professor Chen Ying, a renowned
scholar, once casually
suggested Yang Guifei might have
weighed 135 pounds.
When pressed, he admitted
it was just a playful guess.
So even experts get caught up in
the.
Mystique of it all.
Everyone does.
But if we stick to descriptions from
Tang sources, we get
a more nuanced picture.
Yeah. Right.
Absolutely.
What do we find?
We find phrases like, face like
a hibiscus.
Suggesting a full, blooming beauty
and fleshy body.
So definitely not thin.
OK.
However, we also see descriptions
like, neither too thin
nor too plump, which contradicts
the exaggerated image we
often see.
So maybe those later depictions
were influenced by the artwork.
That's possible.
They had access to.
Yeah. It seems Song Dynasty
writers looking back at Tang
artwork might have embellished her
plumpness.
Yeah.
For storytelling purposes.
Oh, so the legend grew larger than
life.
Precisely.
As legends often do.
Right.
While Zhang Huan's painting, Lady
Gugu Gong's Spring Outing,
is a Song Dynasty copy,
it's worth noting because it depicts
Yang Guifei's sister,
giving us a possible visual
reference for the family's
physique.
What can we conclude about Yang
Guifei? I mean, I feel like we
always hear.
Yeah. It seems she was likely
full-figured by today's standards.
OK.
But probably not obese, especially
given her renowned
dancing skills.
Right. I mean, you don't get to be
that renowned of a dancer.
Right.
If you can't move.
Right. You've got to be able to
move.
And this preference for a fuller
figure seems to have extended
beyond just within.
Absolutely.
Yeah. It's a very pervasive thing.
I mean, if you look at the grand
scale of the Tang Dynasty changing
itself.
OK.
With its wide roads and impressive
architecture,
spits to a fascination
with grandeur and abundance.
And remember how Emperor Xuanzang
adored plump horses?
Yes.
I mean, and his preference even
influenced the famous horse painter
Han Gan, right?
Did.
And if you look at other artwork
from the time, like Han Wang's
Five Oxen,
even the cattle are depicted as
robust.
Wow.
And full-bodied.
It's as if this fascination with
plumpness permeated every aspect
of art and culture.
I mean, it really does.
You see it at everything.
And you mentioned calligraphy, too,
right?
Yes.
This is where it gets really
interesting.
You see, calligraphy in earlier
periods favored thin,
sinewy strokes,
almost echoing those slender
figures.
There's a quote from Wei Furin,
a calligraphy master, describing
calligraphy with strong, thin
strokes as
jinshu, meaning
calligraphy with strong sinews.
Contrasting it with mozu, which
means ink pigs.
Ink pigs. I love that.
So how does this relate to the Tang
Dynasty?
Well, during the Tang Dynasty,
and especially under Emperor
Xuanzong, there was a noticeable
shift towards bolder, fuller
calligraphy styles.
So the ink pigs had their day.
They did.
Interestingly, some historians
believe Emperor Xuanzong's own
fondness for these plump characters
influenced this artistic trend.
Now, I know what you think.
Did anyone try to connect this to
Yang Gaifei?
Of course.
Right. Of course.
I was about to ask.
Well, a Ming Dynasty scholar, Wang
Shizhen, did suggest that
the emperor's love for plump
calligraphy was inspired by his
life for Yang Gaifei.
OK.
However, that doesn't hold up
chronologically.
Right. The shift in calligraphy
happened.
It happened before.
Before she came on the scene.
Exactly.
But it's interesting that somebody
made that connection.
It is.
But the fact that someone even made
that connection.
Yeah.
Shows how intertwined her image
became with this idea of
Tang Dynasty plumpness.
It's like she became a symbol.
You did.
For an entire era's aesthetic.
Yeah.
Wow. This is fascinating.
Yeah.
So we were talking about how this
preference for a fuller figure
wasn't just about aesthetics.
Right. It was very much tied to
ideas of strength and health.
Yeah. And even abundance, like a
society that had plenty.
Right.
But like all trends, even
this one eventually shifted.
Yeah. How do we explain this shift
back towards slenderness in
the later Tang period?
Was it just a change in fashion or
were there some deeper cultural
factors at play?
Well, in the middle and later Tang
Dynasty, we start to see a gradual
shift back to slenderness
becoming the fashionable ideal.
Almost a full circle moment.
Right.
If you look at the poetry and
literature of the time, you find
more and more references to slender
wastes and delicate figures.
Are there any specific examples?
Yeah.
By Julie's line,
cherry-like mouth of Fan Tzu,
willow-like slender waist of
Yao Man.
OK.
Clearly shows a preference for
slenderness.
And what about visually?
Yeah. Do we see this reflected in
the art of the late Tang period?
Absolutely.
The Legend of Bufan, a story
about a beautiful concubine,
describes her as so slender
and graceful that she seems
unable to bear the weight of her
silk clothes.
Wow. That's quite a visual.
Right.
It almost sounds like a return to
the aesthetics of the Wei and Jin
dynasties, which came before the
Tang.
It does, doesn't it?
It's as if the pendulum
is swinging back, bridging the gap
to the Song dynasty, where
slenderness became even more
pronounced.
It's so interesting, this idea that
beauty trends are almost cyclical.
Right.
What caused this shift back in the
Tang dynasty?
I mean, is there any one thing we
can point to?
It's difficult to pinpoint a single
cause.
Yeah.
But it was likely a combination of
factors.
Changing tastes, new influence
from other regions, and perhaps
even a desire to
differentiate themselves
from the earlier Tang.
To set themselves apart.
Yeah, exactly.
And of course, it's important to
remember that even during this
later period, there were still
exceptions to the rule.
Right?
Oh, absolutely.
You still find descriptions of
full-figured women being considered
beautiful, especially in certain
contexts.
What kind of contexts?
In the story of Ying Ying,
the female protagonist, Kui Ying Ying,
is described as having skin smooth
and plump like Jade.
That sounds lovely.
But I thought we were talking about
slenderness being back in fashion.
Right. But there's nuance to it,
right?
Li Yu offered an interesting
interpretation of why plumpness might
still be appealing in certain
situations.
Suggested that while slender figures
might be visually pleasing from afar,
a little more flesh is more
comfortable up close.
OK, that's a pretty straightforward
assessment.
It is.
And while we can't be sure if people
in the Tang dynasty thought the same
way, it does highlight the fact
that beauty standards can be complex
and multifaceted.
Right. It all depends on the context.
Exactly.
I think we've all had those moments
where we admire something
aesthetically, but then realize it's
not actually that practical in real
life.
Exactly.
And Li Yu's comment reminds
us that beauty is experienced
and perceived in different ways,
depending on the situation.
So thinking about all this, what can
we take away from this exploration of
Tang dynasty beauty standards?
Well, it seems like the key takeaway is
that beauty standards are fluid.
Right.
And dynamic, constantly being shaped
and reshaped by various forces.
The Tang dynasty is a perfect example
of this.
Yeah.
We've seen how geographic differences,
the influence of powerful figures like
Empress Wu and artistic
trends like calligraphy and painting
all contributed to how people viewed
beauty.
And we can't forget those horse riding
women of the North.
Absolutely.
They really challenge our assumptions
about women.
For sure.
In ancient China.
They remind us to look beyond
stereotypes and appreciate
the complexities of history.
Yeah.
So instead of making these sweeping
statements like plump was in or
slender was out during the Tang
dynasty, we really need to
understand the interplay of
different factors and recognize
that beauty, like most things in
history, is rarely black and white.
It's about seeing the nuances and
appreciating the dynamic nature of
beauty standards.
We've talked about shifting ideals and
powerful figures.
But what about the connection between
beauty and social status
in Tang China?
I mean, was there a link between how
people looked and where they stood
in society?
That's a great question.
If we consider the popularity of
plumpness, it's interesting to think
about how it might have been
connected to ideas of abundance and
prosperity.
Yeah.
In a society where food could be
scarce, having a fuller
figure could be seen as a sign
of wealth and well-being.
That makes sense.
The way of communicating.
Look at me.
I can afford to eat well.
Exactly.
And this wasn't just limited to
women. Remember Emperor
Xuanzang's fondness for plump
horses?
Well, horses were a symbol of power
and prestige.
So owning a strong, well-fed horse
was a very visible sign of status.
It's almost like saying, I'm so
powerful.
Even my horses are living the good
life.
Precisely.
This connection between physical
appearance and social standing
is something we see throughout
history and even today.
Think about all the products and
treatments marketed as ways
to achieve a youthful or healthy
look.
They're often linked to ideas of
success and attractiveness.
It's a reminder that beauty
standards are often intertwined
with social and economic factors.
Yeah.
What's considered beautiful can be
heavily influenced by who holds
the power.
Absolutely.
And resources.
So while we can appreciate the
artistic beauty of Tang Dynasty
paintings and sculptures.
Right.
We should remember that they also
reflect the social hierarchies
and values of that time.
Those images tell a story about
power, status and the ideals
valued in Tang society.
So we're not just looking at pretty
pictures. We're uncovering layers of
history.
Exactly.
Understanding how art, culture
and social dynamics are all
connected.
And that's what makes studying
history so rewarding.
It's not just about memorizing
dates and names, but about
understanding how people lived,
what they believed in and how those
beliefs shaped their world.
OK. Before we move on, I have one
more question.
OK.
About specific features.
We've talked about plumpness being
favored for a time in Tang
China. But were there
other specific facial
features, hairstyles or even
personality traits that were
considered attractive?
Oh, you're really digging deep now.
I am.
And you know what? There were
definitely certain features
considered desirable during the
Tang Dynasty.
Tell me everything.
What were the must have features
for a Tang Dynasty beauty icon?
Well, a full round face
was in vogue.
OK.
Often described as moon shaped
or like a full moon.
OK.
Plump cheeks and a soft chin
were much more desirable than
a sharp jawline or high cheekbones.
And remember how we talked about
Yang Guifei being described as
having a face like a hibiscus?
Yeah, that sounds lovely.
Well, it points to another important
feature. A fair complexion, pale,
flawless skin was highly
prized and associated with beauty
and refinement.
I can see why that would be
desirable, especially in a time
before sunscreen and modern skin
care.
Right. A fair complexion was a
sign that you didn't have to work
outdoors, suggesting a life
of leisure and comfort.
It was a visible marker of your
social status.
Exactly.
And thin arched eyebrows,
often described as willow leaf or
crescent moon shaped, were
considered very stylish.
So quite the opposite of the thick,
bold brows that are popular today.
It's amazing how beauty trends can
change so drastically over time.
OK. What about hair?
Any particular hairstyles that were
all the rage in Tang China?
Oh, definitely.
Elaborate hairstyles were a major
part of Tang Dynasty fashion.
OK.
Women often wore their hair long and
styled it in intricate updos
adorned with flowers, jewels and
even gold ornaments.
Wow. That sounds super glamorous.
They were.
What do these elaborate hairstyles
look like? I mean, do we have any?
Oh, we have a good idea, thanks to
the many Tang Dynasty paintings and
figurines that depict them.
Oh, perfect.
One popular style was the cloud bun,
where the hair was piled high on the
head in a swirling cloud-like
shape.
Oh, I can just imagine how stunning
those must have looked with all
those intricate details and
sparkling ornaments.
But was it all about outer beauty?
Or were there personality traits that
were considered attractive as well?
That's an excellent point.
Grace, elegance and refinement
were all highly valued.
OK.
A woman who was well-educated,
skilled in the arts and could carry
herself with poise and confidence.
So inner beauty was just as important
as outer beauty.
Absolutely. And this emphasis on
intelligence and refinement makes
sense when you consider the cultural
flourishing that took place during
the Tang Dynasty.
Yeah.
It was a time of great artistic and
intellectual achievements.
And these qualities were reflected in
the ideals of beauty.
It's like saying beauty is more than
skin deep. It's about what's inside,
too.
Precisely.
And I think that's a valuable lesson
we can take away from exploring
Tang Dynasty beauty standards.
It reminds us that beauty is
multifaceted and encompasses
not just physical appearance,
but also intelligence, grace
and inner strength.
You know, it's amazing how much we
can learn about a society by just
looking how they viewed beauty.
Yeah. Beauty standards often act like
a mirror.
Yeah.
Reflecting the values and aspirations
of a particular time and place.
And speaking of changing beauty
standards, it really makes you wonder
what people will think about
our current ideals in the future.
Right. What will people a hundred
years from now think about our
Instagram filters?
Oh, yeah.
And perfectly posed selfies.
I can't even imagine.
I mean, it's kind of like how we look
back at some beauty practices of the
past, like foot binding
or using lead based makeup.
I mean, those are considered
fashionable at the time.
Yeah.
But today we see them as harmful.
It's a good reminder that beauty
standards aren't always about
what's healthy or natural.
They can be influenced by all sorts
of things, cultural norms,
social pressures, even marketing
and advertising.
So how do we navigate this ever
changing world of beauty standards
knowing they aren't always based on
what's best for us?
That's the big question.
There's no easy answer.
Yeah.
But I think a good place to start is
by being critical of the messages
we see and hear every day.
You mean all those ads telling us we
need to be thinner or younger?
Yeah, exactly.
It's about recognizing that those
messages are often trying to sell us
something, a product, a lifestyle,
an idea.
It's about taking a step back and
asking ourselves, is this really
what beauty means to me?
It's about recognizing that beauty is
diverse and subjective.
It's about how we feel about
ourselves, not how others.
Couldn't have said it better myself.
Embracing our individuality and
recognizing that what makes us
unique also makes us beautiful.
And maybe someday people will look
back at our era and say, wow,
they were really onto something with
that full body positivity
and self-love movement.
The fact that we're having these
conversations and questioning
outdated notions of beauty is a
positive sign.
It shows we're evolving and
redefining beauty on our own terms.
So we've explored how Tang China
viewed beauty with its emphasis on
plumpness, elegance and refinement.
Yeah.
We've seen how those ideals
reflected their values and
aspirations.
And now we turn it over to you, dear
listener.
Yes.
What qualities do you find most
attractive in yourself and others?
What does beauty mean to you?
And how do your own values and
aspirations influence your
perception of beauty?
Those are great questions to think
about. And we hope this deep dive
has given you a new perspective on
beauty, both past and present.
Thanks for joining us.
