#HansHolbein#HansHolbeinTheYounger#TheAmbassadors What SECRET MESSSAGES are hidden in one of Hans Holbein’s most famous works of art, The Ambassadors? Painted in 1533 during the reign of Henry VIII and depicting Jean de Dinteville and Georges de Selve, The Ambassadors has everything from a creepy anamorphic skull in the foreground, which can only be viewed properly from a certain angle, to scientific and musical instruments and discreet lines of text. So what are the hidden meanings in this painting and how should we decipher The Ambassadors? What is the geographical Holbein globe showing and how does it help to identify one of the sitters? What does the celestial globe placed elsewhere in the painting mean, what is the musical composition, why is the lute string broken, what should we make of the time keeping devices and the open arithmetic book and where is the little hidden image of Christ on the cross? Why is the skull placed in such a difficult to view place and is the painting meant to signify the religious disputes occurring across Europe at this time as the Reformation raged?
The painting now hangs in the National Gallery in London, opposite another of Holbein’s works, his portrait of Christina of Denmark, Duchess of Milan and Lorraine. It was controversially restored in 1996 with some claiming that the skull was damaged in the process but remains a highly popular image. It had a whole life before arriving at the Gallery though and as part of this art history documentary from History Calling, I’ll be tracing its provenance for you, as well as discussing its many layers of meaning. I hope you enjoy this video on one of the world’s most famous paintings. #GJWculture#Antiques#Art#ArtExplained#Paitting
It's one of the most intriguing, complex, multi-layered paintings in the world.
Seemingly all about life, death, wealth, power, religion, music and astronomy.
But what are the secret messages hidden in Hans Holbein's The Ambassadors?
And why do aspects of the image still confound art historians to this day?
In this episode of History Calling, we're going to take a look at this beautiful,
baffling and even creepy picture and discuss many of its most fascinating aspects.
Not least of which are the relationship between its sitters, were they friends or lovers,
the presence of a distorted skull in its foreground,
and how to correct the painting's optical illusion so that we can view that bizarre object properly.
Before we dive in, please remember to give the video a like and subscribe to the channel
with the notification bell switched on so you never miss an upload.
You can also join my YouTube channel membership or find me on Patreon,
Instagram and my Amazon storefront.
Over on my website, historycallingofficial.com,
you can even get two free downloads when you sign up to my mailing list
and those of you with Irish ancestry may want to check out my book
Find Your Irish Ancestors Online available from Amazon.
All the links you'll need are below for you.
The Ambassadors is an oil on oak painting by the famed Tudor court painter,
the German-born Hans Holbein the Younger.
It was created in 1533 during one of his trips to England and measures 207 cm by 209.5 cm.
The ten oak planks which make up the panel were felled in 1515 or a little later.
1515 is the latest growth ring discernible on any of the eight planks which were examined in the
1990s and the tree came from the Baltic Polish region.
The painting depicts two men standing on either side of a double shelved table full of items
with a green patterned curtain behind them and a huge anamorphic skull on the floor between them
which cannot be viewed properly from the front.
More on that later.
Each leans an elbow on the top shelf of the table and their poses roughly mirror one another.
Until the late 19th century their identities along with much of the painting's provenance
had been forgotten.
It was still known to be a Holbein thanks to a faint signature on its lower left side
and it still had its title of the Ambassadors but the rest of its story had become very obscure.
It was only re-established based on internal evidence from the image itself
and a documentary trail which showed that it had originally belonged to the man on our left.
He was Jean de Dinteville, the French ambassador to England at the time
and his companion is Georges de Selve, Bishop of Lavaux.
He was on a brief and semi-secret trip to the country between May and June 1533
giving us a very narrow time frame during which this portrait must have been planned out
and the preparatory sketches for it drawn.
After completion it was taken to de Dinteville's home in Polissy, France
and hung on the walls of his house there,
remaining with his family until 1653 before dropping out of view.
It popped up again in 1787 being sold to a Mr. J.B.P. Le Brun
who then sold it on to an English dealer by 1792
after which it made its way into the ownership of Jacob II Earl of Radnor in 1808 or 1809
and was taken to Longford Castle.
It was bought for the last time, so far at least, by the National Gallery in 1890
and now hangs there.
Opposite another of Holbein's works is a painting of the 16-year-old
Christina of Denmark, Duchess of Milan and Lorraine,
created while she was under consideration as the possible fourth wife of Henry VIII.
I'll link my video about her on screen and below if you'd like to learn more about her life.
Upon arrival at the Gallery in London,
the Ambassador's was found to be in pretty poor condition.
Over the centuries it had been dismantled and poorly reconstructed
so that the planks had warped.
It had also been damaged by damp, coated in varnish and badly restored,
resulting in some of the detailing being lost.
After an initial period of display,
it was therefore taken down and restored again to late Victorian standards
by the planing down of the warped boards so that they would fit together better
and the removal of the varnish, only to be replaced with a fresh coat.
It was put back on display in August 1891.
Unfortunately, thinning out the panels like that and placing the painting in the Gallery,
which was then much more susceptible to changes in lighting and temperature than it is now,
made it vulnerable to further cracking and warping.
These problems had become evident as early as January 1892,
but in fairness to the Victorian restorers,
they didn't know that that would happen and were following the established practices of the time.
As the decades rolled by,
the painting would suffer further splits and blistering of the paint
and had to be mended again in 1929, 1939, 1940 and 1952.
Only when air conditioning was installed in the Gallery in the 1950s
did the damage dramatically slow down,
now that the painting was not at the whim of environmental changes.
Another restoration in the 1990s removed the Victorian varnish,
which had obscured some of the darker elements of the painting,
including the signature, which is very difficult to see even today.
In fact, even standing right next to it,
I didn't notice the signature on either of the occasions when I saw this picture.
Nevertheless, by a happy accident,
I did photograph it, though I've slightly clipped it
because I was actually just aiming to photograph the floor detail.
But I've circled it out here to make it easier for you to see
and it reads Johans Holbein Pingebat 1533,
meaning Hans Holbein painted this 1533.
So now that we know something of its history,
let's take a look at the ambassador's sitters
and the other objects it shows in more detail,
bearing in mind that my discussion of the painting
shouldn't be viewed as all-encompassing.
So much has been written about this artwork
that it wouldn't be possible for me to discuss
all the theories put forward about it in one video.
This should therefore just be viewed as a selection
of the available opinions about its many meanings
and if you want to learn more,
I've left details of the sources I used for this video
in the description box below.
de Dintville's outfit is expensive and showy
with the huge sleeves, slashed red or pink fabric,
it seems to be satin,
fur trim, which the National Gallery says is lynx,
though I've also seen it called ermine,
and a wide brimmed hat with gold ornaments
and a tiny little silver skull on it.
Holbein's skills are on full display
when we see how the delicate little hairs on the fur
have been rendered
and there is also a meticulously painted tassel
hanging below the dagger the ambassador clasps,
complete with gold leaf detailing.
He is dressed to impress
and this is the kind of fashionable garb
that we also see on no less a man
than King Henry VIII himself.
In fact, this pose and outfit look quite like
Holbein's later depiction of the king
in the Lost Whitehall mural,
for which only copies
and the original preparatory cartoon survive.
Perhaps the ambassadors helped to inspire
the later image of the monarch.
We don't have any surviving drawing for the ambassadors
but infrared reflectography
did reveal evidence of underdrawing on the painting
and additional underdrawing might be hidden
beneath particularly dark lines of paint.
It has also been suggested
that this later drawing of an unidentified man
is of de Dintville,
perhaps in the later 1530s.
He was back in England in 1535, 36 and 37,
though it has also been claimed by some
as Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk,
brother-in-law of the king.
So really, who knows?
De Selve, reflecting his position
as a man of the church,
is dressed in a less eye-catching
yet still very costly outfit.
It is a fairly streamlined,
dark brown robe of brocade,
also trimmed with expensive fur
and with a pattern on the fabric
and was, according to Kate Bonford,
who wrote about the painting in 2004,
De Selve had not been consecrated as a bishop yet,
though he had been appointed,
and this is why he doesn't wear
a formal churchman's outfit.
Interestingly, the intention may have originally been
that he be dressed in a brighter red,
for during the restoration of the portrait in the 1990s,
some flecks of such paint were discovered
in the lower part of his robe.
The reason for these two men
opting to be painted together
is unknown.
They were friends,
Bonford notes that De Selve's
somewhat casual outfit
even hints at this,
and they were both French diplomats,
but we can be certain of little else.
Haggai Keenan,
writing in Artibus and Historiae in 2002,
postulated that they were actually
romantically involved,
pointing to a letter by de Dintville
written during this period in England,
in which he expressed
no small pleasure
at the visit of De Selve in London
and asked that that visit
be kept quiet from the Duke of Montmorency,
who was the head of the King of France's household.
There was also the fact
that the French ambassador never married.
De Selve, by contrast,
wouldn't have been expected to
as he was a churchman.
Keenan points to their body language as well
as reflecting traditional ideas
of masculine and feminine,
like a marriage portrait.
De Dintville is on the left,
taking a more active and important stance,
with one foot forward
and his hand on his dagger.
De Selve is on our right,
standing slightly back,
clutching a pair of gloves
and holding closed his long robe.
We might compare their positions
to the Arnold Feeney portrait, for instance,
which also hangs in the National Gallery
and which I had to fight through
a crowd of Japanese tourists
to get a picture of,
or Christina of Denmark,
who is likewise holding gloves.
Countering this interpretation
of a romantic relationship though,
we should bear in mind
that de Dintville expressed his unhappiness
at his English posting
in the same letter mentioned a moment ago,
so a visit from a friend
would of course have been a pleasure to him.
Plus de Selve's visit was semi-secret,
which would explain the desire
to keep it quiet from Montmorency
and if the two men had been involved
in what would have been
an illicit relationship,
would either have been stupid enough
to flaunt it in a manner like this painting.
Bomford picked up on the masculine,
feminine body language too
and the similarities
to well-known portraits
of husbands and wives,
but she interpreted these features
as a sign of friendship and nothing more.
Adding that the diamond rings,
which can be seen in the pattern
of the green curtain behind them,
were also a sign of matrimony,
but in this case have been transformed
to represent the bonds of friendship.
She noted other cases
where such rings were exchanged
between men for platonic reasons,
such as one given
by Cardinal Lorenzo Campeggio
to Erasmus of Rotterdam in 1519
and said that there was quote
a lack of established pictorial conventions
for the representation of friendship
at this time,
which would help to explain
why the conventions of marriage portraits
were used instead.
In that case,
de Dintville would have been given prominence
as the older, more experienced man
and the one who was paying for the painting,
explaining his more masculine pose.
The truth is though,
that we'll probably never know
the real reason behind
this seemingly unusual pairing.
Even more perplexingly,
historians and art experts
have also struggled to understand
the collection of objects
worn by or surrounding both these men,
most of which were rare,
expensive,
open to different interpretations
and even apparently designed
to confound the viewer.
A few items at least
are quite straightforward to understand.
The hilt of de Dintville's dagger
tells us that he was in his 29th year
at the time this portrait was painted.
It says AT,
meaning Etatis Sui 29,
his age is 29.
And the order of Saint Michael of France,
which he wears around his neck,
indicates his membership of that order
and his nationality.
In a similar vein,
the book on which de Salve's elbow rests,
which was probably a bible
in reference to his line of work,
informs us that he was Etatis Sui 25.
These were some of the details
which helped to re-establish
the sitter's identities,
as did the terrestrial globe
on the lower shelf of the table,
which marks de Dintville's home
of Polissi in France.
This further confirmed
that he was the original owner
of the painting.
So far, so good,
but very little else is this clear cut.
The tabletop is covered
with a piece of expensive Turkish carpet,
and on the top shelf
we see a celestial globe
and a variety of mathematical instruments.
The first thing to note
is that these were real objects,
not imaginary ones,
and they are mostly state-of-the-art items
for the 16th century.
We can even surmise
that Holbein or de Dintville
had borrowed or bought some of them
from the king's astronomer,
the German-born Niklaus Kratzer,
who Holbein had painted back in 1528.
Why can we surmise this?
Because they appear
in Kratzer's picture as well,
and these weren't the kind of objects
that most people
would have had lying around.
The chances that someone else had them
and would be willing to loan
or sell them to the French ambassador
or to Holbein are low to nil.
They aren't even common items
to own nowadays
in the age of mass production.
So what, if anything,
is Holbein,
in conjunction with de Dintville and herself,
trying to communicate to us
with these objects?
The celestial globe,
which depicts the heavens,
has aroused considerable discussion.
It represents astronomy,
one of the seven liberal arts,
and shows the constellations
of Hercules, Draco, Lyra,
Cygnus, Delphinus, Pegasus,
Cepheus, Cassiopeia, Andromeda,
and Perseus.
Does it show something of astrological
rather than just astronomical importance, though?
Mary Hervey, writing in 1900,
thought not,
citing the opinion
of the then-astronomer royal.
Hervey did add, though,
that the presence of a bird,
seemingly a rooster,
which is apparently attacking
the other birds in the image,
represented, quote,
the onslaught of France upon her foes
and their ultimate downfall in flight.
This is because the rooster
was an ancient symbol of France.
She also claims that the word
Galatia next to the bird
is meant to be Galena,
for this means rooster.
However, Ellie Decker
and Kristen Limpincott,
writing in 1999,
claim that this word
should actually be read as Galaxia
and refers to the Milky Way.
Hervey and the two later authors
also disagree on the template
for this globe.
Hervey acknowledged that the painting
will have been based on a real item,
but did not speculate
on the origins of that item.
Decker and Limpincott assert, though,
that the original was definitely
created by the mathematician,
astronomer, and geographer
Johann Schoener,
because he was, quote,
the only globe maker practicing
during the early 16th century
known to have produced
woodcut celestial globe gores,
and internal evidence in the painting
to do with how the little stars
on it are rendered
suggests that the original globe
copied by Holbein was made of wood.
Gores, by the way,
are the curved sections of wood
or whatever material is being used
which are fitted together
to make a spherical shape.
There are other indications
that the painting has copied
a Schoener globe,
including the empty hand of Perseus
and the depiction of Cassiopeia
with a crown of thorns
and holding a sickle.
There weren't many celestial globes
being produced in this era,
and the fact that these details,
which were unique to Schoener's designs,
reappear in Holbein's work
is a strong indication
that one was a copy of the other.
Decker and Limpincott
do acknowledge differences
in how the constellations
have been labelled by the two men, though,
which might suggest that the globes
are not linked after all,
but they posit that Holbein
was simply copying a version
of a Schoener globe
which has now been lost to time.
They also argue that,
Holbein's celestial globe
has been set to indicate
the terrestrial latitude
of 42 degrees north,
which, according to contemporary tables,
was the latitude of Rome.
This is important
because it rules out the possibility
that the globe is meant
to represent the date
at which the painting
was created in London.
The only other possibility
they acknowledge is that,
Whoever set the globe, in its stand,
inadvertently used the complementary scale
on the meridian ring.
If this is the case,
then the intended latitude
was 48 degrees north,
the latitude of Paris,
and, more importantly,
of De Dinfield's hometown of Polissy.
The globe further indicates
a specific time and date
of 2.40pm on the 12th of July,
but no meaning has as yet
been attached to this,
for it doesn't match up
with the birthdays of either sitter.
The cylindrical object
is a pillar or shepherd style,
and is meant to tell the time and date,
but only when placed in sunlight.
Here, however, it is indoors,
yet still has shadows on it
to indicate a date.
Eric Ive stated in his biography
of Anne Boleyn
that it shows the 11th of April,
the day Anne was recognised
as Queen in 1533.
But when I watched a video
about the portrait
by the National Gallery,
its host, Susan Hoyster,
Deputy Director and Director
of Public Engagement at the Gallery,
stated only that it could show
either April or August,
with April being the preferred option,
in her opinion,
given what we know
about when the portrait was created.
So there is some dispute here
about what we're looking at
and what we're meant to infer from it.
Decker and Limpincott say
that it shows either the 10th of April
or the 15th of August,
and that the shadowing on it, quote,
defies the laws of optics,
and makes it impossible to say
Moving on to the right of the pillar,
we have a universal equinoctial dial,
which is shown in two parts,
but which would have been used
to work out the time.
We don't know why it is disassembled,
both here and in the portrait of Kratzer,
in which it also appears.
Next, we have an orrery quadrant,
which is the white item
tucked in behind the equinoctial dial.
It is sitting on its side
and showing multiple times
so that it doesn't appear to refer
to anything specific,
or if it does,
we can no longer unpick its meaning.
Then there's a polyhedral dial
with three of its sides on clear display
and a fourth partially shown.
This would have been used to tell the time.
Annoyingly though,
despite the clear shadows
which have been painted onto it,
it actually fails to do this
in any clear way.
Two of its sides show a time of 1030,
while another shows 930.
The spread of the hour lines is incorrect,
and the little compass you see
set into the top of the dial
indicates that it is not pointing
in the correct direction
for it to function anyway.
If this dial is meant to be telling us
something specific,
we aren't getting a message.
Finally, for this top shelf,
we have this astronomical instrument
above de Selve's elbow
called a torquetum,
which the Oxford Reference Dictionary
defines as
a medieval instrument
for measuring the position
of an astronomical object
in either equatorial, ecliptic
or terrestrial coordinate systems.
However, not enough of it is shown
to display anything specific,
and Decker and Limpincott
write that Niklaus Kratzer
must have given Holbein
a rudimentary version
of such an instrument to use
and that its appearance
in the ambassadors
is an important signpost
marking a specific step forward
in the history and dissemination
of scientific learning
during the Renaissance.
For de Dintville,
it also showed his
first-hand acquaintance
with the cutting edge
of European scientific thought.
Moving down to the lower level
of the table,
here we see the terrestrial globe
underneath the celestial one
and indeed beneath all the items
designed for examining the stars,
just as Earth is beneath the heavens.
It is seen upside down
when the painting is viewed normally,
but to make it easier to discuss,
I'm going to rotate it 180 degrees
so that you can see the details
on it more clearly.
We already know it marks out
Jean de Dintville's home
and Paris is there too,
though the city's name
is spelt with a B at the start.
Susan Foerster hypothesized
that this might be an indication
of Holbein's accent
when he spoke French
and how he thought words
were pronounced and spelt.
It is based on a real item
which has been speculated
to be another globe,
or rather published images
of the globe
belonging to Johann Schoener
and which was known
to have existed in 1523.
Certainly some of its
internal information
suggests a creation date
around that time.
It is an accurate rendering
of the planet
as it was known
in the early-ish 16th century
and crucially the presence
of two little ships
indicates the route
taken by the Spaniards
when they circumnavigated
the world between 1519 and 1522
and so it cannot predate
their return date.
The fact that Holbein
was painting it in 1533
means the original globe
had to exist by then,
giving us an 11-year range
in which it was made.
Still, the association
with Schoener has been disputed
due to differences
in cartographical knowledge
between what is shown
on the Holbein globe
and what appears
on other globes
known to have belonged
to Schoener as late as 1533
and the fact is
we aren't really sure
what item Holbein
modelled this image on.
The prominence given
to the city of Nuremberg
does at least suggest
that that is where
it was produced though
and it includes a line
set by Pope Alexander VI
to divvy up the new world
between the Spanish and Portuguese.
We can see the words
Linea divisionis castellorum et Portugalum
written on the globe as well.
Around 100 names
found on an original globe
by Schoener
also match up
with the Holbein version
but there are some
interesting additions too
which tally with places
important to Didinfiel
such as Polissi, Paris and Lyon
where he had lived and worked
plus Languedoc
where his cousin was the governor.
The globe is therefore
in many ways
a map of his life and career.
The lower level of the table
contains a lute as well
with its sixth string broken.
Mary Rasmussen
writing in the journal
Early Music in 1995
argued in line
with earlier historians
that this represents
some sort of harmony
which has been disrupted
with the break in the sixth string
being particularly noteworthy
because six was seen
as a perfect number.
Next to the lute
is a case of flutes
with one missing.
These two items
or group of items
in the case of the flutes
represent the liberal art of music
but the missing flute
has a deeper meaning
again suggesting
the lack of harmony in Europe
at the time
thanks to the upheavals
caused by the reformation.
Many of the other items
also make religious allusions
and the painting
contains a mix of Catholic
and Evangelical references.
1533 is a bit early
to talk about Protestantism
as we know it today.
A music book
sits open on the table
near to de Selve's ankles
but while he was
a Catholic church man
this is a Lutheran hymn book
by Johann Walther.
It shows a translation
by Martin Luther
father of the reformation
of Vene Sancte Spiritus
meaning O come Holy Spirit
and the Ten Commandments.
Both these texts
which do not appear
next to each other
in the original publication
were common to the Catholic
and Reformed faith
suggesting reconciliation
between these two different branches
of Christianity
at a time when they were moving
further and further apart
often violently so.
They are written in German
which was of course
Holbein's native tongue
and the placement of the book
might reflect de Selve's
known interest
in healing the splits
in Western European Christianity.
We also see a partially open book
of German arithmetic
with a set square
acting as a bookmark
and a set of dividers
tucked away behind it
to our right.
The page is a copy
from a book by a man
called Peter Appian
and discusses division.
Is this another reference
to the religious divisions
across Europe?
Looking down to the floor
we see it is a geometric mosaic.
Ives speculated
that because it is
a cosmati pavement
and the only other such pavement
in England
is the 13th century example
in Westminster Abbey
where Anne Boleyn
was due to be crowned
just a matter of weeks
after this portrait
must have been begun
this is another reference
to the Queen.
It was supposedly included
because de Dintville
had been invited
by Henry VIII
to attend the coronation
something Ives calls
the high point
of the ambassador's career.
But I have to say
that I'm a bit sceptical
as the two pavements
are far from identical
and surely if the point
was to reference the coronation
Holbein would have copied
the Westminster example exactly.
As Kate Bomford says
the floor wouldn't
have been recognisable
to most of the intended viewers
of the painting either
who would have been living
in de Dintville's native France
and the inclusion
of this type of flooring in it
may have just been
to complement the overall
richness of the composition
and demonstrate Holbein's skill
in the depiction
of a complex pattern
in receding perspective.
You're free to disagree of course
and perhaps it is
a backhanded reference to Anne.
Also on the floor
we can see the loot case
tucked away beneath the table
but the most noticeable thing of all
in this lower section
of the painting
is the anamorphic skull
in the middle of it
which appears completely distended
when viewed from the front.
Anamorphism is an optical illusion
which distorts the perspective
on an item
and we can see another famous example
of the technique
in this slightly later picture
of Edward VI
which is in the National Portrait Gallery
in London
just next door
to where the ambassador's hangs.
It resolves when viewed properly
to look like this.
For many years
prior to the painting's restoration
which revealed the skull
in better detail
no one even realised
what the ambassador's skull
actually was
and at one point
it was even suggested
by one scholar
that it was a fish.
Thankfully we do now recognise it
for what it truly is
though resolving it
is rather tricky.
You can view it
from the right hand side like this
though you'll need to hold the camera
up above your head
and even then
it's not 100% fixed
I could have done with a step ladder myself
or alternatively
you can view it
from the lower left
like this
though you will have to get
right down on the ground
in front of a room full of people
whilst feeling like a complete idiot
I speak from experience.
We know from an inventory
that the picture was hanging
in the first floor grand salle
but we don't know
exactly how it was presented
and of course
it may have been moved
around different locations
in the house over the years.
Perhaps it had a little ladder
next to it
or was at times
presented on a staircase
so that 16th century viewers
could see the skull properly.
Maybe they were even given
a little glass viewing cylinder
to look at it head on
and see it correctly in that way.
For you though
if you're viewing this video
on a handheld device
or even a laptop
it is quite easy to resolve
even if I show you
a direct view of it
like this.
Just look at your screen
from the right side
and tilt it
so that you're looking down
on the skull
or look at it
from the lower left
of your screen.
You may want to pause here
for a few seconds
so that you can get
the perspective right.
The skull posed
a considerable challenge
for the 1990s restorers
as it was quite badly damaged
underneath the layers
of varnish and repaint
but they reconstructed
these areas
as best they could
and pointed out
in an article
about the restoration
that their work
can be easily removed
if desired.
Why is the skull there though?
There are numerous
possible explanations.
It resembles the one
on the Dinfield's cap
and it is the only motif
in the picture
to be repeated.
Mary Hervey said
that the Dinfield
had likely seen Holbein's
Dance of Death series of images
completed by 1526
though not published
until 1538
the last of which
is called the Arms of Death
and which features a skull
like the ones
seen in the Ambassadors.
Dinfield in this theory
then adopted the skull
as his personal badge
thus its double appearance
in the painting.
This she says
was partly because
the Ambassador was always ill
and quote
the vision of death
hovered constantly
before his eyes.
Another theory holds
that it is meant to show
the ultimate pointlessness
of worldly knowledge
represented by the many
for none of mankind's knowledge
can stop death.
Or does it show
that death is the great leveller
coming for both a nobleman
and a bishop
and ending their friendship?
Another idea is less pessimistic
that the skull symbolises
the ability of friendship
to last beyond death
for it is at the feet
of John and George
as though they have beaten it
and of course
the painting itself
has given them
a kind of immortality.
As you can see
there is no consensus
on what to make
of the skull's presence.
Next we come
to one of the most
easily missed items
on the whole painting
which is a small silver crucifix
tucked away
in the top left corner
of the composition
and nearly hidden
by the green damask curtain
in the background.
It was in fact
completely hidden by varnish
and overpainting
prior to the 1891 restoration.
This symbol of Catholicism
is surely meaningful
especially when placed
in such stark contrast
to the Lutheran motifs
in this painting
and it is interesting
that Holbein
presumably in conjunction
with his client
John de Dintville
chose to have these symbols
of two different forms
of Christianity
in the image.
By including it
the artist has also
paired death
represented by the skulls
with the idea
of the resurrection
and afterlife
giving the viewer
a sense of hope
rather than despair
at the prospect
of this life ending.
Mary Rasmussen
also claims
that it is no accident
that the skull is resolved
when you stand to the left
of the painting
directly under the crucifix.
However,
given that you can also
resolve the image
by looking at it
from the top right
I'm not convinced
by that argument.
The painting would also
need to be displayed
exceptionally high up
for you to be far enough
below the skull
to see it properly
from the left.
Remember that I had to get
right down on the ground
to make it resolve
in this way.
Had it been hanging up
high enough for me
to view the skull
in perspective
from my standing height
I doubt I could have
made out the tiny crucifix
anymore.
Returning now
to the curtain.
Though Holbein
certainly used curtains
even green curtains
in other images
such as his portraits
of Thomas More
and Sir Henry Guilford
this one is huge
taking up the entire
background of the painting.
The most basic reading
of its presence
would be simply that
Hans liked a green curtain
but there seems to be
far more going on here
than that
and its presence
and size
suggest the wealth
of de Dintville
and also that it is
dividing two realms
with the living in front of it
the dead behind it
and the crucifix
traversing the two
and representing the way
to get from one to the other
through the redemption
offered by Christ.
Heike Kienen postulated
in 2002 that
the possibility of a reality
existing behind the curtain
is underscored
that is
instead of defining
the interior bounds
of the scene
establishing a clear limit
for the viewer's gaze
the curtain suggests
the presence of a depth
beyond itself.
So to sum up
The Ambassadors
is doing many things.
On one level
it is a painting of two men
created by an artist
at the height of his powers
who's showing off
the sitter's wealth
and position
and his own ability
to create a wildly complex image.
On another
it is tellings about
de Dintville's life and career
with its references to locations
associated with him
and his skull device.
On yet another
it is an image
all about a hoped for
reconciliation
between Catholicism
and Lutheranism
as well as the contrast
between life and death
and the possibility of salvation.
It may even include references
to the marriage and coronation
of Anne Boleyn
and to the sitter's known interests
in what was then
cutting edge science
and theology.
Most of the items in it
are copied from real objects
but several are disassembled
or assembled incorrectly
to the point
that they would not have functioned.
This leaves us unable
in several cases
to use them to tell time
or work out specific locations.
Why they have been presented
in such a fashion
remains a mystery.
Bomford speculates
that the presence
of so many instruments
related to timekeeping
was meant to suggest
the passage of time
and mortality
but perhaps Holbein
just didn't know
how to set them up correctly
before painting them.
Whatever the explanation
behind the myriad of objects
observed here
and the interpretations
which can be extrapolated from them
one thing seems certain
the ambassadors
will continue to fascinate viewers
for many centuries to come.
I hope you found that overview enjoyable.
Let me know what your favourite aspect
of the ambassadors is
in the comments below
and if you're in an art history mood now
but aren't sure where to go next
might I suggest
either my art history playlist
or my video
on the anamorphic portrait
of Edward VI.
If you specifically want to go
on a Holbein bender though
then I would direct you
to my video
all about his life
or another
on his portrait of Anna Cleves.
Whatever you choose
please enjoy
and until next time
keep learning.