The Strange Disappearance Of Umami Burger

History Of Food
342 followers
#History #Food
Umami Burger burst onto the scene in 2009, offering customers a unique fusion menu combining Japanese spices and ingredients with gourmet American burgers. The chain quickly expanded to become one of the biggest culinary success stories of the day, poised to take burgers to the next level, until it all came tumbling down like a triple stack with no toothpick. So what happened?
By https://www.youtube.com/@weirdhistoryfood
Umami Burger burst onto the scene in 2009,
offering customers a unique fusion menu combining
Japanese spices and ingredients with gourmet American burgers.
The chain quickly expanded to become
one of the biggest culinary success stories of the day,
poised to take burgers to the next level,
until it all came tumbling down like a triple stack
with no toothpick.
So what happened?
Well, today, we're cooking up the spicy rise
But before we get started, be sure to subscribe to the Weird
History Food channel.
After that, leave us a comment and let
us know what other culinary fads you
would like us to serve up next.
OK, time to figure out whether these burgers were overdone.
Adam Fleischman was an aspiring screenwriter
who moved from Maryland to LA in 1998
to write the world's best screenplay,
but instead opened a pair of wine bars, Bottle Rock
and Vinotech.
Hey, success is success.
More importantly, he was a guy who
was fascinated by the concept of umami,
a Japanese term meaning delicious, savory taste.
In 2005, while indulging in an In-N-Out Double Double,
Fleischman had his aha moment.
He realized that what made the burger so irresistible
was that deep, savory flavor we now
recognize as umami, a flavor that
wasn't found in many mainstream American fast food options.
So Fleischman dove into the culinary world
by heading to Mitsuwa Marketplace in West LA
and bought any ingredient he could
find with umami properties.
He experimented for a month in his kitchen
mixing seaweeds, miso, fish sauce, soy, cheeses,
and pungent dried fish with a blender.
His neighbors probably called the police at least once.
Then in 2009, with $40,000 he raised
by selling his wine bar, Bottle Rock,
he opened the first umami burger on South La Brea Avenue
in Los Angeles.
Umami Burger's flagship offering, the original,
wasn't just a burger.
It was a science experiment in greatness.
First, the patties were made using six ounce beef, mostly
from American Wagyu beef, that were coarsely ground in-house.
The meat was seasoned with umami dust,
a blend of dried porcini mushrooms, dried fish heads,
and other secret ingredients.
Their tomatoes are slow-baked overnight
with a soy-based sauce.
Next was the Parmesan crisp, which
was made using 18-month aged cheese
and expertly crisped up to add that extra punch of savory.
Finally came the sauces, umami master sauce,
which was a combination of soy, tamari, and miso,
and then a special umami ketchup,
which was ketchup that was amped up with more umami flavors,
like mushrooms and fish.
And finally, the bun, a Portuguese-style bun
made fresh, griddled to perfection,
and exclusively for umami, was the perfect size
to maintain a two-to-one bun-to-burger ratio,
a detail that Adam Fleischman personally obsessed over.
The burger gained so much buzz that GQ
named it Burger of the Year, giving it
an elite status underlined by prices over $10 each
and an unfriendliness to substitutions.
By 2010, umami burger wasn't just a Los Angeles phenomenon.
The exciting new fusion restaurant
was exactly what was missing in the burger world.
And Fleischman later partnered with hospitality group SBE,
Nene Capital, and Fortress Investment Group
to quickly capitalize on the brand's popularity and expand.
After multiple openings in Los Angeles,
umami burger expanded to the San Francisco Bay Area in 2011.
The original umami location closed in 2013
after its lease expired, but not because it was doing poorly.
The location was no longer adequate to support Fleischman's
aggressive growth plans.
By 2013, the chain was spreading its umami gospel
across the country and opened East Coast locations
in Miami Beach, Florida and New York
before finally reaching the Windy City later that year,
aiming to take on Chicago's culinary heavyweights.
As Fleischman said in a 2013 interview,
Chicago has become a great culinary destination,
and we wanted to be part of it.
Umami burger quickly made its mark
with locations in the West Loop and on Milwaukee Avenue.
And it didn't stop there.
Umami burger also went international.
By 2015, there were multiple locations in Japan,
including in Tokyo and Osaka, where the Japanese market was
very receptive to the umami flavor profile.
The global expansion seemed endless,
and Fleischman seemed destined to take over the culinary world
until suddenly he wasn't.
During the height of its fame, umami burger
was known for celebrity collaborations,
producing premium menu items designed
with input from a famous spokesperson.
For example, the Sam Burger was a burger
created with comedian Andy Samberg
and featured spicy sports peppers, roasted tomatoes,
smoked gouda, and roasted garlic aioli,
all stuffed between a bun.
The Alton Brown Burger was a ground beef patty
with lardon, which are thick cubes of bacon,
cheesy tots, miso maple bacon, and coffee ketchup.
Top chef veteran Michael Voltaggio
created the Monte Cristo Burger, a beef patty
with gruyere cheese and prosciutto
on a deep fried custard soaked bun.
The Black Keys Burger, created by Dan Auerbach and Patrick
Carney, was a beef patty with smoked gouda,
sweet and spicy pickles, honey, mustard, and jalapeno relish.
All four of these celebrity sammies were released in 2016.
Then in 2017, we got the Mindy Burger, created by Mindy Kaling.
Her burger brought us a beef patty, pickled jalapenos,
fried onion strings, house-made sriracha aioli, lots of cheese.
Each of these burgers had a charity
attached to it that would receive
$1 for every burger sold.
While collaborations with these celebrities
might have caught some eyes, it couldn't
save the brand from its fate.
While pushing his hot new brand's meteoric rise,
Fleischmann wasn't afraid of making enemies.
In 2013, Umami Burger filed a lawsuit
against a Chicago restaurant, Poppin' Grill,
claiming trademark infringement over the use
of the name Umami Burger on its menu.
Trademark names are nothing new.
It's why competing restaurants can offer a two-patty burger
with lettuce, cheese, pickles, onions, and special sauce
on a sesame seed bun, but they can't call it a Big Mac.
But Fleischmann and his team took it a step further.
They wanted to trademark the word Umami,
which would be like McDonald's trying
to trademark the word big, which is why in October of 2020,
Umami Burger also filed a lawsuit
against Umami Fries, located in Tulsa, Oklahoma,
for trademark infringement.
Both lawsuits were settled, with the specific of the settlement
remaining confidential.
While we don't know exactly what the outcome was,
we can tell you that there isn't an Umami Burger listed
on the Poppin' Grill online menu,
while Umami Fries remained open until fairly recently.
Those weren't the only legal issues
that founder Adam Fleischmann found himself involved in.
In a bizarre case in 2023, Fleischmann
was accused of squatting in a home located
in the famous Hollywood Hills.
The owner claimed she never signed a lease with Fleischmann
because she didn't want him living there,
while Fleischmann claimed he had a verbal agreement
to live in the home.
Some free advice, you should definitely
get more than a verbal agreement before you move in
and start building that IKEA furniture.
But the case got stranger.
Fleischmann further insisted that because he only
had a verbal agreement and not a signed lease,
he didn't have to pay rent.
As the adage goes, he was trying to have his Umami cake
and eat it too.
The owner called his bluff and hired a professional squatter
removal company, at which point Fleischmann finally moved out.
By 2017, the cracks began to show.
Despite their expansion into high-profile locations
in New York and Chicago, the company
could not maintain its momentum.
The original flagship location on La Brea in LA
had already closed in 2013 because it didn't
fit their new business plan.
Another location in LA was closed by the health department
for cockroach and rodent infestations
in September of 2017.
We will assume that was also not part of the business plan.
By 2019, Umami Burger locations in New York
were shutting down one by one, with two closures in New York
City in January of that year alone.
The reasoning, according to the spokesperson
for SBE, which acquired a majority share in Umami
in 2016, some spaces just didn't fit the Umami experience
anymore.
Today, the last standing Umami Burger in Los Angeles
is at LAX, which is a far cry from the brand that
was so particular about its decor
that even its original location couldn't stack up
to its ambition, although it probably
feels right at home with the rest of the overpriced food
in the terminal.
By 2021, Umami had reduced to a mere shadow
of its former self, with a handful of locations
globally, including Tokyo, Mexico City, and Dubai,
but none in the US beyond LAX.
Umami Burger went from darling success story
to cautionary tale in roughly a decade.
So what went wrong?
It's hard to pinpoint exactly, but there
were several factors working against the chain.
First of all, the chain's global ambitions
meant investing a whole lot of money
into fewer locations spread out around the world.
Furthermore, by 2017, the market was saturated
with gourmet burger spots.
And suddenly, Umami Burger didn't seem quite as unique.
And despite its gourmet fusion menu,
Umami Burger was still facing daily competition
from places like In-N-Out, Shake Shack, and Five Guys.
And while those places kept it simple,
Umami kept trying to push the envelope,
with roasted tomatoes glazed with Umami sauce
and shiitake mushrooms sauteed in butter.
All that stuff is delicious, but for the average customer,
it's not worth $12 every time you want to grab a burger.
The profit margins just weren't there.
In the end, the final shiitake steak
in the heart of Umami Burger seems
to have been a combination of overexpansion,
Fleischmann's unlikable behavior,
and the plain fact that most people aren't
going to order a $15 burger with roasted mushrooms and fish
sauce multiple times a week.
After all, sometimes a little ketchup and mustard
can do the trick.
Just don't call it an Umami Burger.
So what do you think?
Was Umami Burger truly an innovator
or just an overpriced fad?
Let us know in the comments below.
And while you're at it, check out some of these other Weird
History Food videos.
