Hawley Hosts Facebook Whistleblower, Exposes Meta’s Stunning Complicity With China

The Influencer Wave
81 followers
The Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism is called to order.
I want to welcome everybody to today's hearing, the title of which is A Time for Truth, Oversight
of MEDA's Foreign Relations and Representations to the United States Congress.
Let me just say as we begin, this is a hearing that Facebook has tried desperately to prevent.
Facebook is one of the most powerful companies in the world.
It is one of the most powerful companies in the history of the world, and they have stopped
at absolutely nothing to prevent today's testimony.
They've absolutely gone to war to try to prevent it.
Our witness today is a whistleblower, and not just a whistleblower, but a long-time
executive at Facebook.
She worked directly with Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sanders and the Facebook brass.
She was a part of the Facebook brass, and they have gone scorched earth to prevent her
from telling what she knows.
They've sued her.
They have sought a gag order against her.
They have begged courts to take her book off of the shelves.
They tried to get it stopped from being printed in the first place.
They have threatened her, get this, with $50,000 in punitive damages every time she mentions
Facebook in public.
$50,000 every time she mentions Facebook in public, even if the statements that she is
making are true.
And even as we sit here today, Facebook is attempting her total and complete financial
ruin.
They are attempting to destroy her personally.
They are attempting to destroy her reputation.
And I think the question is, why?
Why is it that Facebook is so desperate to prevent this witness from telling what she
knows?
What is it that they are so afraid of?
Well, we're going to find out today.
And I think that we've already got a sense of it.
Sarah Wynne Williams knows the truth about Facebook.
That's what they fear.
She knows that while Mark Zuckerberg now claims to be a champion of the United States and
claims to be a free speech warrior, he in fact worked hand-in-glove with the Chinese
Communist Party for years.
He in fact made censorship his business model.
He in fact developed censorship tools for the Chinese Communist Party to use against
its own people.
He in fact made Americans' own user data available, was willing to make it available to Beijing.
The truth is, Facebook and Mark Zuckerberg have lied to the American people repeatedly.
And I think as we'll see today, they have lied to Congress as well.
It's time for this to stop.
That's why this committee has launched a full-scale investigation into the potential illegal behavior
of Facebook.
Today's hearing is one step in that investigation.
Ms. Wynne Williams' testimony is absolutely essential to that investigation.
That's why we invited her to be here today, and it is why she accepted.
Facebook does not want you to hear what she has to say.
I dare say China probably doesn't want you to hear what she has to say.
But we are going to get the truth, and we're going to get the truth starting now.
I'm delighted to have with me the ranking member both for the subcommittee and for the
full Judiciary Committee, Senator Durbin, and I'll turn it over to him.
Thank you, Ms. Wynne Williams.
We're going to have eight-minute rounds of questioning, and I will start.
Let me just start with something that you referenced, Ms. Wynne Williams, a moment ago.
Facebook Meta issued a statement again last night saying that they don't do business in
China.
Now, is that true?
Facebook Meta is not doing business in China?
Is that accurate?
That is not accurate, Chairman Hawley.
Facebook has an $18.3 billion business in China.
To give just one example, in 2014, it launched Oculus in China with a strategy of playing
dumb, and Oculus has continued to grow as a significant part of their business.
In fact, since 2014, 2015, they have launched multiple apps in China, often without, well,
always without seeking authorization from this government, not informing their shareholders,
not informing Congress, not informing the public, and now they have employees in China.
Is that accurate?
They have a partnership with Tencent in China.
Is that accurate?
Their Oculus VR business is in China.
Is that accurate?
So, tell me this.
Why has Facebook Meta been so obsessed, if I can use that word, with breaking into the
Chinese market?
What is this all about?
It is incredibly valuable for Meta.
Monetarily?
Absolutely.
So, we're really, we're talking about profit at the end of the day?
We are absolutely talking about profit.
Profit and power.
Let's talk about what Meta has been willing to do for profit and power.
You said just a moment ago that Meta's dishonesty started with the betrayal of core American
values, and you mentioned that Mark Zuckerberg has pledged himself as a free speech champion.
I notice he talks a lot now in the American media about free speech.
I notice he talks a lot when he goes to the White House about free speech and how Facebook
won't censor and Facebook will protect the rights of all.
Have you ever known Mark Zuckerberg to censor on behalf of China?
Yes, Chairman Hawley.
Let's talk about a few specific instances.
In 2017, the Chinese dissident, Guo Wengui, suddenly had his Facebook profile shut down.
Now Facebook at first said that this was a temporary glitch.
Was that true to your knowledge?
No, Senator Hawley.
In fact, Facebook shut down this dissident's page.
This dissident, as you pointed out a moment ago, was living on American soil at the time.
Facebook shut down that page based on pressure from the Chinese Communist Party.
Is that accurate?
That's accurate.
Let's just take a look here at the documents.
Here's some meeting notes taken shortly after a conversation with a Mr. Chow, who's a Communist
Chinese Party member, a government official.
Here Mr. Chow asks Facebook, it says to Facebook, that they want Mr. Guo's Facebook page dealt
with.
The notes say that Chow wants Facebook in China, but there are others who don't.
So we Facebook need to take measures and do more in such situations to demonstrate we
can address mutual interests.
And then they go on to list, here's what we can do.
We can do nothing.
We can say we can do something or we can do even more than expected, but we need to provide
a response to the Chinese Communist Party on what we can do.
So here we have evidence of high level contacts between Chinese Communist Party officials
and Facebook asking for this dissident's page to be taken down.
Facebook acknowledging this pressure, saying we need to do something if we want to get
the party's cooperation, the government's cooperation.
And what happened next?
Well, Senator Hawley, one thing the Chinese Communist Party and Mark Zuckerberg share
is that they want to silence their critics.
I can say that from a personal experience.
So I think they came to the right man.
This led to a series of events where eventually this man on American soil was kicked off the
platform.
So in April of 2017, following these conversations, Facebook takes down the profile, bans it,
of Mr. Guo.
Then in September, they make that ban permanent.
Now here's the really interesting thing.
When Facebook's general counsel was asked about this directly under oath in a Senate
Intelligence Committee hearing, he sang a different tune.
Senator Rubio asked him directly, was there any pressure from the Chinese government to
block his account?
Was there any pressure to block his account?
The general counsel, Mr. Stretch, no, Senator.
We reviewed a report on that account and analyzed it through regular channels using regular
procedures.
Was this truthful testimony, Elizabeth Williams?
It's in fact an outright lie, is it not?
We just saw the documentation.
Facebook received not just a request, Facebook received direct pressure from the Chinese
Communist Party and bowed to it and discussed it internally and planned it and then lied
about it to Congress.
Let's talk about what else they've been able to do, been willing to do in order to get
this access to the Chinese market.
Let's look at some more meeting notes.
Here's a reading.
Here's a readout of a group of Facebook engineers offering to create a censorship regime that
will allow Facebook to block all traffic the Chinese Communist Party doesn't want.
Phase zero.
This is an internal chat.
Phase zero.
We identify all traffic that are currently blocked in China and we, Facebook, block them.
This is a test for us to see whether we can actually identify all traffic from China.
And then the chat continues, yes, good way to build trust.
And another conversant says, great stuff, guys.
Let's do it.
Give us some context here, Ms. Williams.
What are they talking about doing here?
When they say block all content that China wants, we, Facebook, do it for them.
What are they talking about?
They're talking about activating their censorship tools on behalf of the Chinese Communist Party.
So Facebook creates censorship tools that will allow them to assume the burden, if you
like, of censorship, where they will do all of the censoring that the Chinese government
was doing.
Facebook would do it on their behalf.
Is that right?
That's my understanding.
And here you have Facebook employees celebrating it.
Good way to build trust.
They mean build trust with the Communist Chinese Party, right?
Correct, Senator.
And great stuff, guys.
Let's do it.
Meaning they greenlit this and went forward to see if they could make it happen.
Is that accurate?
That's my understanding, Senator.
All of this, let's be clear, for a murderous regime in China, the most barbaric, most evil
regime on the face of the planet.
And our free speech champion, Mark Zuckerberg, is here with his team of engineers actively
working to make Facebook censor on their behalf.
Let me ask you this.
What about user data, Ms. Williams?
Facebook has said publicly many times we would never compromise user data.
It's a red line in the sand.
We'd never do that.
Never, never, never.
Was Facebook ever willing to share user data with the Chinese Communist Party?
Yes, Senator.
In fact, they had a plan for that, didn't they?
Here's some more documents, internal documents.
Update, I spoke with the China team yesterday.
They flagged a potential complication arising from our negotiations with the Chinese government.
I emphasize this is a Facebook document now.
These are Facebook executives.
In exchange for the ability to do operations in China, Facebook will agree to grant the
Chinese government access to Chinese user data.
There it is in black and white.
Facebook will agree to grant the Chinese government access to Chinese user data, including Hong
Kongese user data.
And then they talk about they're going to have to get their Hong Kong citizens to re-agree
to terms of service so they can slide this right by them.
This is extraordinary.
Can I just ask you, Ms. Williams, was Americans' user data ever compromised?
Do they ever plan to compromise American user data in any way, do you know?
One of the challenges with servicing a market as big as China was the internet infrastructure
that would underpin that.
So I mentioned the cable that they joined between the US and China, and that would be
very helpful in servicing this market.
But it would still mean that the service would be slow.
So they contemplated using POP servers, and POP servers is a technical data center that
brings the data closer to the end user.
The challenge with POP servers is that you can't segregate data.
It would have American data, it would have Chinese user data, and it would be on Chinese
soil.
So I want to just be clear about this.
Here in this document, Facebook is talking about making Chinese user data available to
the Chinese government because they're going to store that data in China.
Is that correct?
Correct.
But when you store that data in China, Americans who exchange messages or other information
with Chinese Facebook users, that would mean the Chinese government could get access to
the American data as well.
Is that correct?
Through the POP servers, potentially, yes.
And Facebook was willing to take that risk?
Yes.
There was a lot of discussion about this, and ultimately, yes.
I mean, this is extraordinary.
This is exactly contrary to what Facebook has represented for willing to build data
centers, store data in China.
They are willing explicitly to give the Chinese government access to it.
And if that means that American user data is also compromised, they're willing to do
that too.
All for profits in China, there was virtually nothing they weren't willing to do.
Chairman Grassley, Ms. Wynne-Williams, let me ask you a little bit more about the censorship
tools that you've been asked about today, you've testified about, that were actually
deployed in Hong Kong and Taiwan.
And let's just, if we can, let's just look again at the privacy team email.
Not that one.
That one.
Yeah, so this is, and just so members of the press understand, the committee's in possession
of this document.
We have blacked out, as you can see, we've blacked out the names of individuals here.
But in the documents, we have those names.
Of course, we'll follow all appropriate legal procedures.
But just so the press understands, the committee is committed to doing a full investigation.
We do understand and know who the people are on this chain.
We can see who they are, and we can see the full course of the discussion.
But I just want to emphasize something here.
The update is, they spoke with the China team.
They flagged a potential course of, a potential complication, of course, of negotiations with
the Chinese government.
Let's just stop there for a second.
Someone pointed out to you that Mark Zuckerberg testified under oath that he didn't know what
the Chinese government's terms would be to operate Facebook in China because they were
banned, quote unquote, in China.
So he just had no idea.
He was saying this as late as 2017, 2018.
He just had no idea what the terms would be.
That's just categorically false.
Isn't it?
Absolutely, Sam.
And this email shows that it is false, correct?
Correct.
In fact, what this email shows is, Facebook is in very regularly close contact with members
of the Chinese government, down to specifying how they want the censorship tools to work.
They're giving feedback on it, back and forth and back and forth.
And here they've agreed on a set of censorship tools to deploy in Hong Kong, down to the
TOS.
Does that mean Terms of Service?
Correct.
So in other words, they're going to have to push out to Hong Kong users a new click thing
for them to click on, which they won't, of course, really understand or know because
it's almost impossible to decipher.
But in fact, what they're doing is, it's allowing Facebook to stand up new censorship tools
on behalf of the Chinese government.
Is that correct?
That's correct.
Now, here's another interesting point.
Back in 2012, the FTC, here in this country, the FTC entered a consent decree with Facebook
about privacy.
Do you remember, Ms. Wynne-Williams, this would have been early on in your time at the
company, but do you remember roughly any of the terms of that FTC consent decree?
Because they are relevant here.
I do, Senator.
They were intended to prevent matter from deceiving people about the extent to which
they collect and share their data.
Yes.
So the part of the order is, and let me just quote, Facebook shall, quote, shall not misrepresent
in any manner, expressly or by implication, the extent to which it maintains the privacy
or security of covered information, end quote, which is user data.
Now, Facebook is under a consent decree with the FTC on this basis, and yet they are deliberately
misrepresenting across the world the security of user data.
They are negotiating with the Chinese government to turn over user data, grant the Chinese
government access to Chinese user data, including the Hong Kongese, including Taiwan, and yet
they're representing to American government officials, no, no, no, we don't do that.
We don't do that.
In fact, they testified, they testified under oath.
We don't, we don't make user data available.
All of that was just lies.
Is that fair to say, Ms. Wynne-Williams?
Senator, many, many decisions have been made and they were all premised on the basis that
So, in addition to lying to Congress on what seems like a fairly regular basis, lying about
suppressing dissidents, lying about setting up censorship tools, they've also arguably
violated FTC consent decrees.
And we have the documentation.
This isn't just Ms. Wynne-Williams' opinion.
This isn't just her recollection.
We have the documentation with the Facebook employees, who I might add are high level
executive level employees who are planning this and doing this.
It's really, it's quite extraordinary.
This was a pattern of operations at Facebook over and over and over.
We'll come back to that, Ms. Wynne-Williams, but if you're ready, Senator Klobuchar, before
we let you go, Ms. Wynne-Williams, just one other line of questions, if I could, just
one other subject.
You actually touched on it with Senator Blackburn.
She was talking to you about the kind of research that Facebook has done and the kind of advertising
that they're willing to sell.
And to me, what's so interesting about this is we've seen, frankly, the moral bankruptcy
of this company and its leadership when it comes to China.
And we've seen them be willing to lie to Congress, lie to the American public.
We've got the documents in black and white.
We've seen them be willing to give away American user data.
But they were also trying to find out a way to make a buck on Americans, teenagers, children
in times of distress right here in the United States.
And I just want to give you an opportunity to comment on this.
Here's an internal Facebook chat where a policy, a Facebook policy director asks, is it really
accurate that Facebook is doing research into young mothers and their emotional state?
Is it your understanding that there's other research related to young mothers?
Answer, yes.
I looked at one list of research topics and saw one about young mothers and their emotional
state.
Coming down, the person says, I'm wondering about asking my apparently morally bankrupt
colleagues if they are aware of any more.
This is about Facebook's program to target ads to people when they are in emotional distress.
Is that right?
Is that what we're seeing here?
That's correct, Senator.
And that included teenage girls, as you were discussing with Senator Blackburn, those who
had maybe recently deleted a selfie, maybe not feeling very good about themselves.
And Facebook said, oh, oh, fantastic opportunity.
We could sell this to advertisers.
It apparently also included young mothers who are in moments of distress.
I mean, who knows what that might include.
Everything from the spilled oatmeal you were trying to put into your toddler's mouth.
I have three children, as I understand.
Or who knows what.
Much, much worse things.
So Facebook is constantly looking for opportunities to sell to advertisers, to make a buck, even
on their own users.
And they're doing it by tracking their users all over the place, tracking their emotional
state.
Have I got that accurate?
You've got that accurate.
And beyond that, it's things like things that often do concern teen girls, like body confidence.
That's something else that they use to target weight loss or other things on children, really,
13 to 17-year-olds.
So to your knowledge, did Facebook, after this email exchange, where another user says,
I think it's a slippery slope here, and then there's the admission there is a level of
behavioral targeting.
I mean, just to be clear, I want everybody to see this.
There is a level of behavioral targeting.
I mean, these are Facebook executives.
Again, this is a policy director in this chat acknowledging that this is what Facebook is
doing.
Did it stop?
Did Facebook stop doing this?
Not to my knowledge, sir.
Yeah, in fact, we know they didn't because other whistleblowers came forward to show
that at Instagram, owned by Facebook, there was explicit targeting that goes on.
There was explicit knowledge that the Instagram product was causing, in some cases, severe
emotional distress, particularly to young girls.
Facebook kept right on doing it anyway.
Is that just because it made them a bunch of money?
Senator, as a mother of three children, it's very hard to say this, but yes, one of the
discussions I had with one of the business leaders was like, we just don't need to do
this.
As a company, Meta's now a trillion-dollar company.
It is not short of money.
It doesn't need to do this.
And what he explained to me is like, we've got the most valuable segment of the population.
Advertisers really want to reach 13 to 17-year-olds, and we have them.
We should be trumpeting it from the rooftops.
It's really just extraordinary.
I think what we've seen here is the evidence that you presented, the evidence that we have
in black and white is a company and leadership that is willing to do anything, anything,
work with America's chief competitor, work with our chief adversary, sell out other American
businesses, sell out American user data, lie to Congress, lie to the public, anything in
order to amass more power and make a buck.
Can I just ask you, you know Mark Zuckerberg very well.
You spent a lot of time with him.
He's recently tried a reinvention in which he is now a great advocate of free speech
after being an advocate of censorship in China and in this country for years, after suppressing
the Hunter Biden laptop story, after working hand in glove with the Biden administration
to suppress content on COVID, to suppress content on masks, to suppress content on election
questions, on vaccines, all of that.
Now that's all wiped away.
Now he's on Joe Rogan and says that he is Mr. Free Speech, he is Mr. MAGA, he's a whole
new man and his company, they're a whole new company.
Do you buy this latest reinvention of Mark Zuckerberg?
Senator, there are two things.
If he is such a fan of freedom of speech, why is he trying to silence me?
And the other thing is that this is a man who wears many different costumes.
When I was there, he, you know, wanted the president of China to name his first child.
He was learning Mandarin.
That was, you know, he was censoring to his heart's content.
Now his new costume is MMA fighting or whatever, you know, free speech.
We don't know what the next costume is going to be, but it'll be something different.
It's whatever gets him closest to power.
If he were here, is there anything you'd like to say to him?
Senator, I have a lot of questions for Mark Zuckerberg, but he has proven time and time
again that you cannot believe his answers.
He's lied to members of Congress.
He's lied to his employees.
And he's lied to Americans.
And that's why I'm asking this committee to hold him accountable.
Well, we're going to do that.
And I just have to say, I don't trust his latest reinvention at all.
He sat where you have sat in front of this committee multiple times in my short time
in the Senate.
Every time it's a different answer.
Every time it's a different facade.
But every time, the one consistent through line is every time it's something misleading.
Every time it's something other than the truth.
Every time it's about Mark Zuckerberg, not the American people.
It's about Mark Zuckerberg, not what's good for this country.
Not what's good for his users.
Not what is the truth.
And I, for one, am very tired of it.
So I have a message to Mark Zuckerberg as well, which is that it's time for you to tell
the truth.
You should come to this committee and take an oath and sit where Ms. Wynne Williams is
sitting now and answer this evidence.
Stop trying to silence her.
Stop trying to gag her.
Stop trying to hide behind your lawyers and millions of dollars in legal fees you're trying
to impose on her.
Stop threatening other whistleblowers.
Come to this committee.
Take the oath.
Sit there.
Let us question you and give the American people the truth.
We will be waiting for you.
