vivo X200 Pro Mini vs iPhone 16 Pro vs Pixel 9 Pro - Compact Pro Camera Test!

SilkRoad Technology
124 followers
#technology #highend #gadget #robot #apple #iphone #macbookpro #gaming #accessories #gears #samsung #tesla
Three days and 300 photos and videos later, I have the answer to the question,
which compact flagship has the best camera setup right now?
Is it the X200 Pro Mini? Is it the iPhone 16 Pro or the Pixel 9 Pro?
All right, let the battle begin. If you're here for the first time,
I'm Eshan, you're watching Tracketech English,
your destination for detailed, incisive gadget reviews.
When you take a look at the camera specs of all the three phones,
they're very similar. You get a primary camera,
you get an ultrawide and you get a telephoto.
The only difference is that the Pixel and the iPhone have a 5x telephoto,
whereas Vivo has a 3x one.
But if you want to take a look at the detailed camera specs,
pause the screen right away.
While you do that, I'll jump into the camera comparison samples.
Let's go ahead.
The primary camera on the iPhone has an edge here with the 24 MP outputs.
It is definitely more detailed. It brings out more finer textures.
It's just superior compared to Pixel and Vivo.
Vivo suffers from softness in certain areas of the image.
If you take a look at the 100% crop and overall,
the Pixel pulls in more details than Vivo.
So in my opinion, iPhone greater than Pixel greater than Vivo
when it comes to details and sharpness.
Even when you take a look at the colors captured by all the three phones,
iPhone nails it here.
The reds are the carrot and the tomato
and the greens are the beans are accurately represented here,
just like what our eyes saw.
Pixel comes in a close second.
It's almost very similar looking to the iPhone,
but it's slightly more contrasting.
But what I was surprised to see was the X200 Pro Mini
actually captures boosted colors despite shooting with the Zeiss natural mode.
There were some problems with exposure tuning that we noticed.
Sometimes it would make a brighter exposure than required.
And I think that this could be a China specific issue
and the tuning could be better when the global variant launches.
But the question to be asked here is,
is the X200 Pro Mini coming to India and globally?
Vivo, please get it here.
Now, I noticed that the iPhone's HDR tuning is the most balanced one
in terms of highlight control and shadow detail retrieval.
Pixel is also equally good in that respect.
But the problem is, if you look at it closely,
Pixel has a lot of noise and green chromatic aberration in the shadow region.
Vivo's HDR tuning is a little too aggressive in my opinion.
So what the HDR tuning does is that it wants to get a pinpoint sun
and therefore dims the rest of the image.
But where Vivo fights back is with excellent skin tone rendition.
Here, the iPhone has an overall warm look and the Pixel is just extremely cool.
Also, Pixel has a red tint and that's a problem with brown skin tones
and continues to be a huge concern.
I'm genuinely impressed by Vivo's skin tones here.
It's actually very good.
My second pick would be the iPhone and of course, finally would be Pixel.
Also, Vivo's portrait mode is the most feature rich one.
Not only can you shoot at four different focal lengths,
you also have multiple Zeiss, Bokeh, you know, lens simulations.
And when you take portraits, you get excellent skin tones,
superb edge cutout and DSLR like bokeh.
My second favorite here would be the iPhone for sure.
Pixel in comparison is definitely losing out in portraits.
And it's been a problem with Pixels for a couple of generations now
where the portrait mode quality is just not up to the mark with the other flagships.
Now, while Google needs to fix the portrait mode,
you guys fix the fact that you're not helping
track and tag English Dish 1 million.
Go ahead, hit that subscribe button if you haven't already, that is.
In low light, the Vivo X200 Pro Mini's algorithm captures the most amount of details,
even more so than the 24 MP outputs of the iPhone.
And if you want to take a look at the difference,
take a look at the 100% crop of the Klaus multi parking text
and you will notice that Vivo is much sharper here.
Even with respect to exposure, Vivo does bring out more exposure
from the darker areas of the image.
So yeah, Vivo is the best here followed by the Pixel and the iPhone,
which are both almost equally matched.
But where Pixel actually does a fantastic job is with the ultrawide angle camera.
It's the best among the three.
You get ample details and excellent exposure as well.
Plus, the color science consistency with the primary camera is incredible.
iPhone's color science consistency is also very good,
but the ultrawide angle camera captures a lot of over sharpened images,
which is a bit of a concern.
Now, while Vivo doesn't over sharpen like the iPhone,
the details are generally soft.
Regardless, between the Vivo and iPhone,
I would pick Vivo despite the fact that the color science consistency in Vivo
is not that great.
In low light ultrawide shots, Vivo's sharpening algorithm
tends to over sharpen the ultrawide images.
The iPhone's details are more natural, but the shadows are terribly underexposed.
Pixel's ultrawide angle images are not as good as the daylight ones
because at 100% crop, the details are completely softened out.
Now let's talk about the zooming capabilities of all these three phones
and we'll start off with 3x
because that is the base default optical resolution for Vivo.
And it goes without saying that Vivo captures more details
and the finer textures are very well defined.
But Google's Super S zoom does come in super handy here
because it is very close to the quality of the optical on Vivo.
Now when we move on to 5x, you get a proper 5x telephoto on Pixel and iPhone,
but Pixel captures better details than the iPhone.
And of course, since Vivo doesn't have a dedicated optical lens,
it loses out to both Pixel and iPhone.
At 6x, I expected Vivo to be better with the in-sensor crop,
but that's not really the case.
Pixel's Super S zoom is genuinely super here.
iPhone comes in a close second, it's not too bad either,
but Vivo has that watercolor effect with the zoomed in shots,
especially at 6x and they don't look very good.
At 10x, Pixel again comes out on top with iPhone coming in second
and Vivo with its watercolor images coming in the last spot.
So evidently, if you want a compact pro flagship
which can actually capture great zoomed in images,
then Pixel would be the one to pick because Super S zoom is awesome.
Now selfies are slightly tough to evaluate
because all three photos out here,
you'll notice that have a unique look to them.
But technically, I feel Vivo superior
thanks to the insane amount of details that it captures.
I'd pick Vivo for selfie portraits as well.
And even in low light selfie, Vivo stands out.
My second pick would be iPhone followed by Pixel.
Pixel is good with the selfie camera,
but the problem is the contrasty outputs
where it doesn't look too natural,
whereas iPhone makes it slightly brighter than is required.
So overall, you know, Vivo has the right balance of the three.
Now when you talk about macro photography,
Vivo's super macro mode is incredible.
It can shoot macros at 3x, 6x and 10x.
iPhone's macros do look almost as good,
but Pixel definitely needs to improve.
Now the one thing that's important for, you know,
buyers of flagship phones is the fact that
these phones have fast shutter speed so that,
you know, action subjects can be shot really well.
And all the three phones are good in that regard.
So not really much to complain
and very little difference between the three.
So that's good.
I'm glad that the Vivo is also very good in this regard.
Finally, when you talk about video recording,
all the three phones can definitely shoot at 4K 60fps,
but Vivo and iPhone can actually shoot at 4K 120fps.
Yes, there's an OTA update that came
and Vivo actually can now shoot at 4K 120fps,
which is a nice thing.
But when we compare the 4K 120fps quality
on the iPhone and the Vivo,
iPhone was better than Vivo.
However, I was surprised
with the improvement in Vivo's video quality.
It is toe-to-toe with the iPhone
in terms of HDR and detail retention.
And even the overall look looks very similar.
In fact, one thing we noticed is that
the sound recording on Vivo
seems to be better than the iPhone,
except for the fact that iPhone has an audio mix feature,
which just improves sound recording quality
by leaps and bounds.
Now, in this entire scenario,
you must be wondering,
hey, Ashish, you're not talking about
the Pixel's video recording here.
Well, it's actually no match for the iPhone or Vivo.
So yeah, it comes in last.
Now, when we look at low-light video recording,
where Vivo is clearly superior than the iPhone,
it's in the brighter exposure.
So low-light video recording is actually better on Vivo.
The iPhone's low-light video recording
is more like natural looking.
It doesn't brighten the scene too much.
So it's a matter of personal preference
as to how you want the video to look.
But iPhone's advantage is the fact that
you can shoot ProRes videos
and most professionals actually prefer it
because it's extremely high quality bit rate.
Now, in low-light video recording,
Pixel's quality is not a match for the iPhone or Vivo,
but it does have this boost mode,
which actually improves
the low-light video recording quality.
However, it will take some time for it
to sort of process it and send it back to you.
When it comes to ultra-wide angle videos,
iPhone is the clear winner here,
followed by Pixel and Vivo.
While shooting telephoto videos,
again, iPhone just shoots better
at 3x, at 5x, and 10x.
Of course, Vivo's 3x is slightly more detailed
because of the dedicated 3x camera,
but overall, iPhone shoots the better telephoto videos.
Second, of course, is Vivo followed by Pixel.
Now, talking about selfie videos,
I liked Vivo and iPhone's selfie videos more than Pixel.
Pixel has some focus hunting issues
and it is also too contrasting.
Now, between the iPhone and Vivo,
Vivo does a very good job of controlling the highlights
where sometimes iPhone misses it.
So, after evaluating all the pictures,
let me break this down for you.
So, with the iPhone, what I noticed is that
it has the most balanced output
and the most reliable set of cameras
on a pro compact flagship.
Basically, what you get are great details
in daylight and low light.
It's really good with selfies
and with photos of people as well.
And it goes without saying that
it is the king of videography even today.
But there is still room for improvement,
especially in zoom performance
and with the ultra-wide angle camera.
The Pixel 9 Pro, on the other hand,
is the king of zoom.
Thanks to the super res zoom,
it's actually very, very good.
Plus, you've got a bunch of useful AI features
that actually make it better
and more fun to use as a camera phone.
But Pixel has started losing its ground,
especially considering that
it doesn't take great photos of people
and the portrait mode,
oh my god, it's a bit of a mess
and Google really needs to fix it
as soon as possible.
Now, with the Vivo X200 Pro Mini,
Vivo has actually done a fairly good job,
especially when you're shooting people,
the skin tones are good,
the portrait mode is fantastic
and it's a lot of fun to shoot with as well.
The low-light performance,
especially with the primary camera,
like you saw,
is also top of the class
and the video performance has been improved
so much so that in many scenarios,
it's almost equal to the iPhone
or sometimes even beats it.
But there are still some areas that,
you know, I want Vivo to fix
in the next Pro Mini phone,
especially with the oversharpening algorithm,
it tends to get a little aggressive
considering the fact that the sensor sizes
are not that large.
So my rating would be iPhone first,
Vivo second and Pixel in the final position.
What would your rating be?
Let me know in the comment section below.
All right, so that's it from me,
but there are lots of awesome videos
coming on Trakin Tech English.
So stay subscribed
and I'll see you guys in the next one.
Until then, keep tracking and stay safe.
