'The Romans of the Decadence' (1847) by T. Couture

Academic Art (c.1820–1900)
10 followers
13 Video Views·Apr 13, 2025
Painted in 1847, The Romans of the Decadence by Thomas Couture is a sweeping historical allegory that captures the excess and moral decay of the late Roman Empire. Filled with classical references and theatrical drama, the massive canvas critiques not only ancient Rome but also the political and social corruption of 19th-century France.
Housed at the Musée d'Orsay in Paris, the painting remains one of Couture’s most famous works. Its rich symbolism and narrative complexity continue to spark analysis and discussion.
To be an artist in the middle of the 19th century
was to live with competing needs.
It's probably similar, in a way, to being an artist now,
when there's a question as to whether or not
all the things that have defined what art is are still relevant.
That was exactly what the question
was in the middle of the 19th century.
What had made art relevant were things
like serious moral subjects or painting in the classical style.
But that no longer seemed to make sense
in a country crisscrossed by railroads
with a growing middle class culture, factories.
This was a culture that was in the middle
of an enormous revolution, the Industrial Revolution.
We're in the middle of an enormous museum,
the Musee d'Orsay.
And we're looking at an enormous painting.
That's true, we are.
This is Thomas Couture's The Romans of the Decadence
from 1847.
This is a museum that is dedicated
to the art and the trials that you were talking about,
what it meant to invent an art that was modern.
So the crisis for artists was, should I
embrace the modern world?
Or do I go back and paint the classical and the moralizing
and the history painting?
And what Couture has done is bring those two things
together.
He's using this ancient Roman subject
to talk about the decline of French culture.
He's criticizing the French government.
So this is so interesting, because generally when
we think of art that harks back to ancient Rome,
it's all about the heroism.
But this is about the dissolution,
the moral corruption.
This is about the indulgence of ancient Rome at its end.
And he's contrasting the figures who
are seeking luxury and pleasure against the heroicized
sculptures of these people's own heroic past,
drawing an equivalency to French culture in his day,
that France had lost the values of the Revolution
and now was slipping itself into a kind of decadence.
Symbolized not only in the sculptures of the heroes
that we see, but it's also in that architecture, which
speaks of Roman Republican ideals of what Roman culture
was able to build and achieve.
But the figures in the foreground are idle.
Look at the formal construction of the painting.
The sculptures are all upright.
There's a sense of rectitude.
The architecture is a series of uprights and horizontals
that create a perfect geometry.
But the figures, in their indulgence,
in their languid pleasure-seeking,
are a series of arabesques, of curves, of horizontals.
In a sense, they've lost their human quality.
They've become almost animal-like.
They don't seem to belong within this space.
And yet it's the debauchery that he represents clearly.
And the architecture begins to fade into the background
as though there's a sense of that noble past becoming
myth against the reality of the decadence of the Romans.
Well, that's, I think, really part of the brilliance
of this painting.
There's a clarity of line and light and shadow
in the foreground.
And because of the scale of the painting,
those figures are life-size.
We feel as if we can enter into that foreground.
That's our world.
But everything behind them, the architecture, the sculptures,
and especially the landscape, all of that
is inaccessible to us.
This painting was enormously popular
when it was exhibited in 1847.
And Couture was a very successful and important artist
during this period.
And although his personal values politically were Republican,
and by that we mean he was very much for France as a democracy
and not as a monarchy, he even advocated
as a teacher that artists pursue and paint modern life subjects.
So I think he really personally felt this conflict for artists
to look to the classical past, but also this need
to paint the contemporary world.
The other thing to keep in mind is this is 1847,
one year before France will change forever.
It's one year before the Revolution of 1848
that topples the monarchy and brings
in a brief period of France's democracy,
a period we call the Second Republic.
And as the monarchy is toppled again in France,
the art also changes.
In 1848, you have Courbet beginning
to establish the ideas of realism.
Painting the working class instead of the heroic Romans.
In 1848, one year after this is painted,
Marx and Engels will publish the Communist Manifesto.
This idea of the increasing power of the worker,
of a modern world where labor unions will begin to form,
where the nation is ruled by its cities as opposed
to an agricultural economy.
This is just a moment of extraordinary transition.
This kind of academic style will now
be seen from this point on as retrograde.
And it makes it all the more clear just how brave Courbet
was in putting all of this mythology,
all of this classical style behind him
and embracing on a scale just as large as Couture,
the working classes, the middle classes of France.
But of course, Couture is older and established
and one of the leading painters in France.
And you can see the struggle by an artist
not yet fully willing to embrace the new world
and yet knows that things must change.
