Policy Pros: How Policy Impacts Affordability in Michigan

Policy Pros
2 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 12, 2025
Hi, I'm Doug DeVos. I'm the chair of the Communications Committee for the West
Michigan Policy Forum and this is Jace Bulger who is our policy expert as well
as the former speaker of the Michigan's House of Representatives. Jace, we're
talking about a lot of subjects but this time let's talk about affordability. You
know the biggest thing in in the state or that's connected to a quality of life
is being able to enjoy your quality of life and what's the connection between
policy and when I pay at the grocery store. Boy, there's a there is a
connection but it can feel a little bit disjointed. It can feel like it's a
little bit far away but let's start with when people go to work and work hard all
day and come home at the end of the week and get their paycheck. Boy, they sure
have a right to feel like that hard work should pay off. That they can afford to
live in the house they want to live in. That they can afford the groceries. That
they can afford to take a summer vacation but groceries is a stumbling
block for a lot of people especially right now and politicians do have an
impact on that. Now they don't go out and set the price of groceries but they set
a lot of policies that go in place that affect the price of groceries. Well and
the first thing you do from a take-home pay is the tax that you pay. You know in
all this tax legislation we think about personal income tax on a regular basis
about how that impacts us but I know in business you get so many hidden taxes so
many fees and when you lean in from taxing into regulation all of a sudden
you know the cost of energy is more expensive. The cost to do this is more
expensive. Transportation goes up. All these elements are raw materials that in
the product or or maybe even the service that you're trying to create. All those
taxes add up to more costs in the system. Someone's got to pay for that. That's
right and consumers do. People do. Workers do. Always gets passed on. They
absolutely do and so there is no magic tree money tree with which those taxes
get paid by. They get paid by people when they go to the grocery store. They get
paid by people when they pay their other bills. Same with regulation that gets
input put in place when it makes it harder when it's just red tape and again
we talk about health and safety and when it's really to protect your health and
safety that makes sense but there's a lot of regulation that gets put in place
that amounts to red tape that businesses have to deal with. They have
to pay attorneys for. They have to pay employees for and when it doesn't really
add anything ultimately workers pay that when they go to places like the grocery
store and it drives up costs for what they buy. You talked about health and
safety in the workplace. I think if I break my ankle you put a cast on my
ankle. I don't need a full body cast. Sometimes regulators find something and
then they just continue to expand it and there's so many other things that you're
doing when your business and I know being in business where you're spending
your time talking to the lawyers more about how you comply in the costs and
connected to compliance with the regulation and you can see the
difference at this compliance. I have to do it but it's not adding value to the
product or service but it is adding cost. Well that's right and since we're
talking about groceries if somebody were at home and they could make a three
ingredient bread that might cost one thing if they were flour, sugar, yeast
and that's how they made bread that add water anyway. The point is a real simple
bread recipe but now if I mandate they've got to put a lot of other things
in that bread. It might not really change the effectiveness of the bread. It might
not change much the taste of the bread but now I've got to pay for all those
other things that I'm forced to put in that bread. That is much like what
happens to the price of groceries. The cost of groceries that those regulations
that couldn't put in place, those taxes that get put in place, all of that gets
baked into the price that you pay at the store. And sometimes I don't want that. If
I'm a consumer, I may want this and I want to have somebody who can
deliver that product or service in a way that I find the most value at the least
amount of cost. That's what I'm trying to do on a regular basis and and again as a
business person that's what we're trying to provide and as soon as we're
distracted, as soon as anyone in a business organization is taken away from
providing that to the end customer, you're adding cost, you're adding
complication, you're decreasing the value and that's a worse experience. Well
that's right and when customers do best is when they've got options to
choose from. When they can choose do I want to go into an all-organic store? Am
I willing to pay a premium to go to a boutique grocery store? Or do I need to
put food on the table and I want to pay the lowest possible price? When they've
got the freedom to make those choices and when those businesses have the
freedom to offer those choices, to offer what the consumer is looking for, that's
when the consumer is going to do best. I'm with you on a baseline of
regulation to keep everything safe and to look at the best practices that
everyone can share. I get that sort of thing but sometimes policy goes off for
a lot of different reasons. Who are the beneficiaries sometimes of those policies
and why does that happen? Why do these things get added? Why is it they keep
giving you the body cast? And you use that example a lot of times when
you hear a politician say we have to make sure this never happens again, ask
yourself what it is because if it was a freak accident we're all gonna lose a
lot of freedom or we're all gonna pay a lot more price to make sure that that
wild accident doesn't happen again. So I think some of that is an overreaction,
some of that is people clamoring for something not realizing what the
unintended consequence is going to be, but too often it feels like a lot of
that when I say that it's regulation is put in place to try to stifle
competition because if I'm a big employer I can deal with it, if I'm an
upstart I can't and so if I'm a big employer I might not want that upstart
to get off and running and so if I can put barriers in their way they might not
catch me. Exactly. You know one of the things that came up during COVID during
this example which I thought was a huge overreach of government policy and of
government intrusion, there was a safety level that we needed to get to but
there was a lot of things that happened beyond that. One of the things that
businesses decided, I remember getting together a lot of business leaders, we
had a lot of sessions at that time, businesses are pretty focused on keeping
their customers safe. The last thing you want to do is hurt a customer or hurt a
worker. It's bad for business in every sense of the word. We were sharing
best practices amongst ourselves. What are you doing in your situation? What do
you do in a school? What do you do in a manufacturing situation? What do you do
in a restaurant? What do you do in a store? All these industries were
talking to each other freely sharing best practices of what they found to
keep their customers safe in that sort of a time frame and finding the right
balance there is always the key. Well you know people will find that balance a
whole lot quicker than government will. We can look back and learn from history
and a lot of things that we've done in the past we realize we're kind of silly
when we look back but if people are free to make those choices they're gonna make
much better choices. Yeah absolutely. Well we're talking through the ideas of how
do we keep Michigan affordable and so thanks for the conversation Jace. I hope
you've enjoyed the topics and we'll look forward to talking to you soon.
