Dennis Prager and Eric Metaxas Discuss Religion | Speeches and Events

PragerU
800 followers
9 Video Views·Apr 8, 2025
Dennis Prager and Eric Metaxas discussed religion, morality, and the Bible at the 2019 PragerU summit. Check it out!
folks you need to understand something
it's very hard for Eric and me to be
serious when we're together no no this
is actually that is the challenge
there's no intellectual challenge here
there is that it is so bad I'm serious
my wife is a witness we were invited and
it was in the by the way me wasn't I
supposed to interview you yes but I this
is a Pinot s yes it's in France don't
roll the soles of your shoes that's
considered rude in parts of the Middle
East and New York he's right
so we were so we were invited it was my
wife and I your wife didn't happen
through company but she of course was
too so there were three couples invited
that was it to have dinner with the vice
president of the United States and his
wife and his daughter it's a very
intimate dinner and it begins with my
looking at the vice president the United
States and asking him why did you invite
Eric Metaxas that's true now you have to
understand something I really like the
vice president but he's not a
knee-slapper
right it's hard to imagine joking or
it's not his job to be presidential
that's that's Trump's job to be a
knee-slapper
and I think he succeeds yes and I say
that as a fan of the man all right so I
just wanted you to know this is we're
very bonded and we really enjoy each
other a great deal and now ladies and
gentlemen Eric Metaxas
thank you very much thank you
I I have so much I want to say but
unfortunately I'm supposed to interview
Dennis I Dennis I I really Dennis said
that you know ostensibly the goal of
this time we're gonna be talking about
Dennis's new book on Genesis part of the
rationale Bible there's a little hutzpah
titling your book the rationale Bible
but Dennis made it clear to me that if
everybody doesn't walk out of this room
burning to get a copy of that book I
will have failed correct
and I thought what he's not doing well
anyway look at this he has a patch on
his jacket
Jordan Peterson can wear a snake in vest
I can wear some patches all right I may
not have his degrees but good enough
listen but if I'm gonna push your book I
figure it's only fair to push my book
Donald drains the swamp so if you are
not burning if you're not burning they
get a copy of this on your way out
Dennis will have failed but we'll leave
it there you should get it Dennis I love
you so much that this is really gonna be
tough
the Vice President being from the
Midwest had a very hard time with a
Brooklyn Jew and an a Queen's Greek
going at each other's throats
in a humorous way he he in the end the
second lady were not comprehending
comprehending for the first half right
and then and the the very sweet-natured
pastor and author Max Lucado did not
know what he had him right that's right
but we're not sorry are we not really
we're not sorry all right I've got some
questions for you fortunately aren't you
glad when I keep seeing Prager you
Prager you Prager you aren't you glad
that your parents weren't named
Lipschitz
you have no that is so intelligent there
there is no month that goes by that I do
not say something like that to my wife
what if I named Rabinowitz Rabinowitz
you that appeals to everybody
Lipschitz you there was a guy in my bunk
at Jewish camp smuggler smuggler you
wouldn't get anywhere no no I want you
to know this is eerie that you you it's
just a somet axiom and so so accurate to
have pointed this out
I seriously there is so much luck in
life I know a lot of people don't like
it I don't like it either but I'm a big
realist there is luck in life and there
is God in life both are true they don't
negate each other God made a world where
things can happen I am so lucky my name
is Dennis Prager it is I've thought
about that for the radio what if my name
were you know you're a meal smuggler
welcome to the Yurok meal smuggler show
I don't know if it would have caught on
[Music]
where Cohen slow-mo Cohen no
that's a possibility that's all right
the Greek name it taxes on every day
thrilled my last name is not
Stephanopoulos right sorry or Papa
dollars right now since since we were
going to talk about Genesis in your book
we just I think it's it would be
unseemly not to at least glancingly
reference the previous session with
Jordan Peter century that's all I had to
say about it
no I I think this is for the evangelical
Christians in the audience what he said
about how would you dare say you believe
in God because I want to ask you about
this and you were it was just it was
amazing
it was an amazing amazing amazing
session and I thank God
[Applause]
he said a few things that I want to
touch on it eventually but I really
let's just let's just start let's start
at the beginning how about Genesis by
the way can I comment on the belief in
God Karl I'll allow that thank you that
was very pretty was very profound he's
very profound man this and that's not
common unfortunately and I have I don't
know if it's in Genesis or Exodus it's
hard for me to remember but I have a
very long essay because a lot of there
are a lot of essays within the verses
where I develop an idea at length and it
is that the if you if someone tells me
they believe in God I know nothing about
them so I so resonated to that because
that is true I know nothing so the very
notion first of all does I remember when
I began radio and it was very much into
the self-realization movement in the
United States and this was I began radio
in the 80s and people call up oh you
know so I would after you believe in God
yes I do I said I'm just curious is this
God outside of you or inside of you
inside of me so then then you believe in
you I mean let's be honest I'm not I'm
not attacking you
you believe in you then I would ask her
another question does this God judge you
know this God loves me but does this God
judge you know who judges you I do so
then you don't believe in the same God
as I do when someone says they believe
in God you got to ask them which one
what does that mean and then but what he
was really referring to is people will
believe in God but don't do anything
that God seems to instruct so that they
really believe in God by their by their
fruit you shall know them that's that's
my belief okay so thank you it was a
very important point that you that he
raised that you noted thank you thanks
no thank you
aha well it's interesting because we're
talking about belief in God
what I always say is the devil believes
in God he just doesn't love God and
trust God and serve God and bow the need
to God there's a difference and you can
have an intellectual belief in God and
it's frankly meaningless just as as you
said but a lot of times when people have
what they call intellectual problems or
rational issues with the Bible or God
the first place they go they don't need
to get beyond the first few chapters of
Genesis and I know how I would answer
those things I don't know
what a Jewish answer might be and I
certainly don't know what your
particular answer might be so let me ask
you and you don't have to answer
definitively but I'm curious if somebody
says to you hey you don't believe that
Adam and Eve and the snake and all that
stuff happened literally do you so why I
addressed that issue so what will you
dress it now No okay I'll get simple yes
look I addressed it in the book if you
really want to know get the one all
right there goes this is a this so I
have a I have a feeling and I felt this
and I feel what as the book comes out
this Tuesday I have a feeling this will
not satisfy anybody ironically but I
don't think it's an important question I
believe God gave these first five books
they are that they are the central
documents of both Judaism and
Christianity everything everything is
based on it everything from the creation
of the world to the ten commandments to
the Exodus to love God that's there
that's in Deuteronomy and and numbers
the earth there is love your neighbor
that's in Leviticus the the founders of
this country took a verse from Leviticus
to put on a Liberty Bell you shall
proclaim Liberty throughout the was it
the throughout this throughout the land
yes to all its in half
and I got to go from the Hebrew it's
it's it takes a little while it doesn't
right am i right thank you smart
I don't know Greek for New Testament so
I I don't claim any any other great
great
linguistic knowledge but I do finally
raise the issue of how much EF sorry
about it now I got that long he's he's
awesome okay I got you sure how much yes
I heard you yeah
so alright so in all seriousness my
Orthodox rabbi teacher of Torah at
yeshiva in in in New York Orthodox
completely Orthodox in belief and in
practice said you do not have to take a
fig of the Garden of Eden story
literally that was his position and it
is not I don't I don't know if it's
normative but I its Unitarian no
Unitarian oh he was a key would be the
last guy to be a Unitarian I'm the last
got to be a Unitarian the issue to me is
is it from God not is it literal is it
literal is not critical let's say it is
okay so with I believe it literally by
the way I have no problem with it I have
no problem with someone who does if God
could create the world it create an
animal that could talk isn't that
obvious
I mean it's like it's not like this is a
real puzzle oh I get it
God created the universe but he couldn't
make an animal talk I mean that's absurd
if you believe God created the universe
he could do whatever he wants but the
issue is what the what what did the
serpent say is infinitely more important
than whether a serpent said it that's
what matters so we the believers we
often get tripped up these people throw
these questions because you're totally
trapped if you say literal oh my god
folks you're gonna take this guy
seriously believe serpents talk and if
we say no oven how do you believe in the
text you don't even take it literally
but literal is not the issue it isn't
the issue like it isn't the issue with
Yom the word day on the day you will eat
it you will die the the ends and so God
God says this to to add to Adam right on
the day you eat from the tree of
knowledge but on the day he ate from it
he didn't die yo
obviously means on that day you will
become mortal it doesn't mean you will
die day is used as Psalm says one day in
God's eyes is a thousand years and hours
we are fighting the wrong battles that's
that's what happens when these things
are raised that's it's like what I was
in high school the the the local cynic
would go Oh Dennis you believe God is
omnipotent I go yeah uh yeah can God
make a rock so heavy he can't lift it
so that's genius the guy thought he was
a genius for asking a question with the
self negating of course it's if there's
no answer to the question it's it's an
absurd question so that's how I look at
this it's not relevant what is relevant
is what does God want me to know about
life in the Garden of Eden story that is
what I wrote by text I'm sorry what
yeah they got it they got it I would I
was thinking is something Jordan
Peterson said and I just I just tuned
out if you don't mind repeating that you
don't never mind of course I heard what
you said she um
the the issue of the fall and again we
could talk about anything but you wrote
this book about Genesis in Genesis it's
kind of like the stem cells of the Bible
there's just stuff there that is so deep
and you know you don't really need to go
past chapter 3 you could spend forever
just talking about that so when when we
talk about the fall you you're very well
aware that that Christians like me have
a certain take on that and then there
are people I don't know who coined the
phrase the Latin phrase Felix culpa the
happy fall the idea that somehow this
ended up being a good thing because God
could redeem us by creating a people
called the the Jews and on and on and on
what what is your take on the fall was
it avoidable was it part of God's
initial plan was it Plan B how do you
see it
I don't we're very we have that's not
Jewish language but it's not language
that I object to well that that's why
there was this we have sound effects for
these internet yeah and by the way that
was perfect I was too soon the fall to
break this over your head yeah when you
said something any obvious it's just the
Ritz Carlton they're not going to get
this stuff right so the reason I ask
that is because I am well aware that I'm
just I'm fascinated by the idea dentist
that that I and you know many Christians
not all but people that I would consider
serious Christians have a certain view
and I am curious about how how you frame
that and how you think of that because
the fall is ultimately meant to be
somehow sad Milton obviously was a
Christian and ends the you know Paradise
Lost lost with with wandering steps and
slow through Eden took their solitary
way you want to weep and I just wonder
how how do you and how do wise rabbis
frame that the there's no normative
Jewish answer to it nor do I present my
I don't present my my rationale Bible
commentaries a Jewish text clearly I've
been affected by my Jewish learning but
I I show quite a number of times where I
differ where with with traditional
rabbinic takes on for example this
quickly the the two midwives were told
by Pharaoh to kill all Jewish boys and
throw them in the Nile and they refused
to and that one of the greatest lines in
the Bible because they the the midwives
feared God and by the way I right there
it doesn't say the midwives love God
people are animated I think to do the
right thing at least as much by fear of
God as by love of God I'm a big fan of
fear of God
because then you don't fear other things
don't fear people in America today don't
fear the left I don't fear the left
because I fear God so I don't give a
damn what the left says and that's
that's just a factor it's a big factor
so anyway so what is the traditional
Jewish understanding is that the
midwives were actually the family of of
Moses that they and they they were
Hebrews and I have I have virtually no
doubt that they were Egyptian that they
were not Hebrews so I don't offer a
normative Jewish
I mean Jews enjoy it and I'm benefiting
from it as they should but i but it i
don't present it as and it isn't
standard the jewish take but it's also
obviously not a christian take so you're
asking me how i really how this person
takes what happened God made people I'll
tell you the part in this I'll have you
answer actually this is I've never quite
understood this sin is introduced tell
me if I'm wrong sin is introduced
according to Christian theology with the
fall right with with their eating from
the tree right okay there I've never
understood that because they already
they were free to sin sin wasn't
introduced in my understanding of the
text with the eating of the tree it was
introduced with the creation of Adam and
Eve who could sin by eating from the
tree they were capable of sin and in
fact the only sin they could commit they
were only prohibited from doing one
thing and that's the one thing they did
so how did they introduce sin is God
introduced the possibility of sin when
he made Adam and Eve see this is why I
love this guy your profound and your
wise and that's really ultimately I
guess a way of flattering myself because
I was just gonna say you're the only
person besides myself who's ever asked
that question
it seems so obvious doesn't it Dennis
you asked it and it's obvious to you and
it's obvious to me what no one ever asks
that question so what does your mom say
about me
that's brilliant I'm gonna say that in
this sue this is your suit by the way
one of Dennis's wives right am I getting
that right yes I just want to be very
clear what do you know rect I don't
anyway she's sweet little ass alright so
let me tell you I mean I'm not uh
neither proud nor ashamed obviously but
you have to laugh at your own life in
Sue's ring it says double o3 not all of
you found that funny and I totally get
that we find it very fun I know you know
I love her for the fact that she could
laugh at it folks it's not what I
planned I intended to be a good married
one time forever till I die man it
didn't work out that way so you have two
choices in life when things don't work
out the way you hope they would you
either lament it or you move on and do
as much good as you can that's it that's
what it that's the way it is in life you
know what I intended just as a quick
cheap shot he turned into a wise thing I
hate you for that what your mother said
and by the way this is this is your
first mother what she I just want to be
clear because you know I know you people
you have different rules but say that
again so I can repeat it because it's
really beautiful and in a weird way does
sum up your husband's genius go ahead
that there goes Dennis saying something
so obvious I never would have thought of
it is that not brilliant and that's the
mother-in-law of this guy
all right so seriously Dennis your
question about sin you are exactly right
and why have I never had this question
before because there's so many other
questions that that people never get to
this but the question of Adam and Eve
choosing to eat the fruit it's it's
rather obvious that their disposition it
could be argued that their disposition
was already yes in full before they ate
the fruit yes
and no one ever talks about that right
so now you know my approach and it if
you want a standard Jewish text you'll
be disappointed if you want to standard
Christian text I call it the rationale
Bible as a believer in God and the Bible
what putting aside thousands of years
not not disregarding it there's much
profundity in past commentaries but I
didn't allow that to be my guide they
could be my help but not my guide what
does reason in a believer say is in the
text and if it isn't there I just don't
insert it what I think we are learning
from this text is even if we were in
Utopia we would prefer we humans would
prefer suffering and freedom to an
immortality even to living in Utopia
that's that's the genius of it I so I I
call it I said I I think I write I don't
I'm not arguing with the word the fall
but my term would be the choice Wow from
my point of view that's pure heresy
but I believe in religious liberty we
believe heretical even evil harmful
things that's your freedom in America
that's correct I don't think religious
liberty is gonna last long and you're
gonna be in trouble soon if I get my way
look I think it would be silly not to
ask you because I don't know that
everyone here knows the answer and I
don't really it's an amazing thing to
take it upon yourself to write a
commentary of the Bible tell us how you
came to that place in in life where you
feel the confidence to do something like
that because it's a very brave and let's
be clear huge undertaking he's right and
it's it's almost overwhelming to be
honest the the task has been beyond
anything that I've done in terms of time
and work I fell in love with the Torah
the first five books as a young man I
realized I really loved these five books
and I write in Genesis or I think no no
I don't know if I write in one of the
two books but I think it's in Genesis I
don't believe in the Torah beak cause I
believe in God I believe in God because
I believe in the Torah that's and a
Christian could say the exact same thing
just substitute the word Bible is fine
or you could say Torah doesn't matter
either way he's good for a Christian
it's so great it's so ex nihilo the
Bible is so ex nihilo out of nothing I
regard the Bible the same way I regard
creation there is no human explanation
there's no natural explanation for the
universe there is no natural explanation
for the Bible it came out of nowhere and
I you could look it up now because it
just came out on the Jerusalem Post
I gave 15 reasons why I believe the
Taurus from God and which is amazing
that the Jerusalem Post published it
it's a secular it's a secular but it's a
big deal because the world jewelry reads
that that but you say world Jewry world
jewelry I thought you had to be like I
remember the KKK to say that world Jewry
oh that's very funny you know am I wrong
people never say world Jewry never say
Jewess there's certain words that you
just don't say them anymore so world
Jewry okay you have been I say then you
have a fertile mind there is no question
it is a term that Jews would use world
jewelry looks like I spoke but Kenny boy
can I go I use that term without getting
looks I wouldn't I would hands on the
guy and we trust the guys they what kind
of God is he does he do will he will he
light a fire for a Jew on the Sabbath
it's a lot of questions on whether we
trust that guy are you on the Sabbath
are you allowed to blow the shofar no is
that true that is good or not right so
you get a to blow the shofar that is
hilarious
I know they didn't because a lot of the
goys you they don't know what we're
talking about is they got a very
buttoned up churches they don't know
what the heck I shofar is and shame on
you Saul shame on them all so far all
right when you go home left Peterson to
Metaxas you have spanned the possibility
of human existence its
I yeah I will never debate if you if you
in Jordan we're on an island for a month
yeah I would be it would be fascinating
to see how you cake I'm not kidding I
would love to have a conversation with
him because he said a number of things
today theological things that you in in
your really tremendous self-discipline
allowing him to talk it was it was
wonderful but it was he said certain
things that go against the normative
theology like what that lean against
normative theology when he said the the
question right he would you know you
asked you believe in God and he gave you
an answer that was a non answer it was
very interesting but you know he said in
effect right now Bonhoeffer now I wrote
a biography of Bonhoeffer and Bonhoeffer
typifies this view and I have spoken
about this very much so when he said
this at resonate with me the idea that
we don't care what you say you believe
and God doesn't care what you say you
believe he cares how you live because by
how you live you show him exactly what
you believe right you can't fool him by
saying go to my church website and
there's a statement of faith and that's
what I believe are you living it out
right okay so so I get that right but to
then make the step but I wouldn't dare
say that I believe in God in a sense
because it puts this impossible burden
on me to perform the you know the labors
of Hercules otherwise I'm a hypocrite I
would have loved to tease that out
because I think messin okay well the
missing race the rubber thing he's too
he's too self lacerating you where
everyone who Belov people let's say
let's say they're a handful who truly
believe in God will still sin I mean
that's just that's just the way it is
well that's that's exactly right he's
too hard on himself he wouldn't say he's
a good person okay he is a good person
but good doesn't mean perfect and and
and
that is a very by the way though this is
a challenge to Christians because
Christians believe that normative
Christian theology is that no no Jew or
no man could fulfill the law and
therefore Christ's sacrifice was
necessary but that's making a demand
that is unrealistic as the as Jordans
was Judaism and the Torah never believed
that anybody could perfectly fulfill the
law it that's the reason that we do
penitence it's it's a given the Torah
understands you can't you can't keep
this all you have to just try although I
guess that's the reason you have animal
sacrifices why wrecked animals are all
for inadvertent sin uh-huh if you if you
an and all against God if you didn't
keep the Sabbath properly if you didn't
keep the holy day properly etc but but
if you if you steal from your fellow man
you can't bring a sacrifice there's
nothing the sacrificial system is
nothing to do with the moral sphere only
only the Holies fear only the religious
fear so what is what is it you supposed
to do if they sin intentionally and they
know it what do they do well then then
there's an elaborate process of well it
depends cynic potentially against God or
sin intentionally against man how was
they both okay so if you if you if you
intentionally break the Sabbath and you
think you were wrong afterwards they're
people who will intentionally break the
Sabbath I don't care fine but if you so
that's that's not an issue you don't
really think you sinned then but if you
come to the belief that you really did
sin you worked on the Sabbath let's say
let's take a simple example the simplest
example in the world you you you you you
cheat on your wife and you know you get
wrong right and you're eaten up by the
guilt what do you do it was not
unintentional it wasn't a mistake
correct but you're sorry what do you do
well so Judaism has an elaborate their
Maimonides the greatest Jewish
philosopher as a whole elaborate n step
program first you acknowledge that you
did wrong then you tell the person that
you've done wrong to exactly what you
did you can't say the the the the modern
phraseology if I hurt
you it's nonsense you have to say I did
hurt you by doing X Y & Z that's the
next thing then you have to if you then
you have to be sorry for it you have to
ask forgiveness for it in some cases you
will have to pay some fine for it to a
person if you stole their bicycle you
will have to pay something and finally
he has a very interesting thing to
really know if you repented you have to
be put in the exact same position the
second time and pass the test what
century was Maimonides xi okay
what happens if you do that in the tenth
century okay no no I know what you're
saying yes you commit adultery now what
do you do Maimonides isn't around yet
now that's right you commit it again it
is it was a very happy century the 10th
century you happen to have picked one of
the happiest centuries in Jewish is
really very interesting question it's
incredible it's beautiful to live
guilt-free is his next book why Jews
love the 10th century
[Laughter]
Wow I guess this is so fascinating for
me because I'm getting to learn a little
bit about wait a busy life what
committed adultery before my body's okay
we have laws of the Talmud that are a
thousand years I'm just I'm just you the
guy who he is the guy who who codified
Jewish law but Jewish law pre-existed
him but if you're asking was there a
modus operandi for seeking forgiveness
right of course there was I assume there
was yes it's not alright what was the
major issue which is which is as long as
we know Judaism exists is if you hurt
your fellow man
you go to your fellow man and then you
go to God God is this is one of the only
normative Jewish beliefs in other words
across the board reform Orthodox
conservative if you hurt your fellow man
you can't ask God for forgiveness until
you got it from that person that you
hurt
Wow yeah that is why by the way it was
very there's a very interesting book out
there called the sunflower and it's
Wiesenthal the great Nazi hunter this is
a very I'll be very quick as a long
story he would this is a true story
Wiesenthal as a prisoner of the nazis
was told was taken out of line on a on a
horrible prisoner work lined in in the
czech area in czechoslovakia taken to a
nazi a Nazi soldier was dying from war
wounds young guy he said I want to just
talk to a Jew I burn Jews alive I feel
horrible for what I did I can't I need
to have forgiveness from some Jew before
I die
Wiesenthal listened and said nothing and
walked out of the room he then posed the
question to Jewish and Christian
theologians I was honored to be one of
them and asked them did I do the right
or wrong thing and all the Christians
said he should have forgiven and
virtually every Jew said you can't
forgive on behalf of others only the
others can forgive so this was a
fascinating before you speaking as a
Christian all those Christians were
wrong well yeah it's stupid I mean you
can't yeah it's not your job today and
this is a little complicated we can both
write essays and talk for a long time
about that but no it's it's um you met
Simon Wiesenthal did I meet him yeah yes
Wow in Vienna
Wow is right and I you can't imagine I
so deeply regret not having taken a
picture with him but I want I always
felt funny asking people to pose it was
stupid of me I would treasure such a
picture I'm anything yeah I'm such a
jerk I got a I got a I'm gonna forget
now hold on you would you have felt
guilty too because he's the great Simon
these at all and he went through that to
get a picture with him he'd feel
self-serving
yeah well I'm just saying I'm enough of
a jerk I got a selfie with El Eva's oh
yeah yes as I thought I thought was a
very smart thing to do well it was it
involved when people ask me and they do
as Jordan I have similar experience my
wife knows that she's with me people
come over for selfies I never resent it
and by the way I am proud to tell you I
don't think there was a single post
photo of me and there were tens of
thousands where I'm blinking I feel such
a moral obligation to keep my eyes open
for your one picture with me
that you will never see a nice closed
posed picture with me that sounds
prideful to me that sounds nice to me no
nice but the fact that you're you're
telling a full room of your fans really
takes it away takes the niceness away
it's it's you know you have your reward
here you're not going to get another
area by I have more fun with Jews and
Christians than probably any living
human being because I am truly immersed
in in Jewish life and a Christian life I
work for Christians I speak at churches
my audience is so overwhelmingly
Christian yet of course I'm a committed
Jew I helped found the synagogue and so
a little synagogue I cuz of i publicize
it would get to be a big synagogue and
we like it little but I it says in the
scenario are you allowed to smoke cigars
in the synagogue no we no I don't smoke
on the Shabbat cos it's the the only law
the only specifically prohibited act on
the Sabbath is lighting a fire and I
look in there on a Wednesday yeah but
nobody goes there oh oh okay yes but you
could yeah so beavering services
services but I just wanted to tell you
this is an interesting it's a funny area
II there are so many obvious
I speak of judeo-christian values all
the time I believe in them I promote
them
if we drop them our society is over but
there are some differences especially in
emphasis so I know Christians have a
much harder time saying good things
about themselves than Jews do you you're
right and I have been I'm not joking
I've been very annoyed at many
Christians for exactly that because look
I grew up in New York so culturally I'm
a Jew
all right that's correct and the and
when I see Trump boasting and boasting
and boasting I don't have the kind of a
problem with that
that a lot of people in the Midwest
would have because I find it funny and
there is what's fun there's something
but it is interesting I feel that again
that that is bad Christian theology in
other words Christians you know
everybody has their issues where they go
overboard and Christians can become over
pious and overly humble and that takes
me to a question that I wanted to ask
you Jordan Peterson said something and I
had to ask you about this he said that
the world is so tragic and dark and on
and on and on malevolent that even Jesus
on the cross had his moment to quote the
rolling stones of doubt and pain and at
a moment of doubt because he quoted the
first line of some 22 alloy alloy lama
sabachthani milo my god my god why have
you forsaken me
now it is my understanding that
traditional Jewish teaching is that when
a rabbi which which which Jesus was
quotes the first line of a sum he is in
effect referencing the entirety of the
psalm is that true have you heard that
it's very possible I have actually
always considered that an admirable
actually an asset of the New Testament
it gives the New Testament in my opinion
an argument for its authenticity to have
included a line yeah that is
uncomfortable to the believer yeah makes
more not less authentic okay you're
right except in the end there look
there's tons of stuff like that I think
in in the old and new testaments which
is why I believe the Bible is the Word
of God but it I think that in first
century Palestine if a rabbi referenced
if a rabbi spoke the first line of a
psalm he was in effect referencing for
his students whole Psalm which changes
Jordan Peterson's point of view what he
said me I think it's a stretch but I
don't think as Christian needs to defend
it it's remembered isn't isn't Christian
theology very much advocate if of the
belief that God came to earth to
experience life as a human as a man so
as a man he would have said that it's
very painful to be crucified and not to
see anything that you said fulfilled at
that moment I have come to save the
world nothing's happening and I'm
getting crucified so as a man it makes
perfect sense he would say that he
wasn't saying that as the Son of God or
as God he was saying that as a man which
which he was in Christian theology I
agree with that and I guess it just
strikes me just like when you read any
of the Psalms the idea is that David in
his prayer in the psalm or whoever the
other psalmist was they are working
through the pain with God so at first
you say my God my God why have you
forsaken me and it goes on on but then
it ends with realizing who God is and
turning you know in other words you
don't linger in that forever you that
you your faith eventually helps you
speak to yourself in whole I you may be
right um I think if you choose a verse
to say that's you mean the verse more
than you mean the chapter that's that
would be my need well because I think it
leads to some of the kind of theology
when you say Christians are afraid to to
you know to the private just say good
stuff
or to be proud but that's where it comes
from a you what you wouldn't know this
but there's a there's a hardcore
reformed theology that hangs its hat on
that verse and on a few other verses you
know I am a worm no one has done good no
not one as though the whole Bible is in
effect saying unless you're hanging your
head in perpetual guilt and shame yeah
well there's a very good Old Testament
antidote to it it's a Torah antidote
there's a verse in the Torah that says
that the Moses was the most humble man
on earth it actually says that the Moses
and we ascribe this to Moses now how so
so God Moses wrote I'm the most humble
man on earth
but why that's wait a minute that's
hilarious
I know I know but I think it's an
awesome lesson that is I don't see any
problem in a humble person knowing he's
humble telling the world I'm the
humblest guy you will ever meet okay I
answer is God dictated it to them but
but nevertheless okay but there's a
lesson to be learned there and no you're
humble of course you should know you're
humble you're striving to be something
but you don't know if you if you're it
then it doesn't make sense to rain do
you think would you would you know if
you're a good violinist somebody says
you know you're really a good violinist
me what are you talking about no I mean
there's nothing wrong so I get a kick
out of that because you know people will
say you know oh something like you know
you really got a great show Dennis on
the radio and I oh I agree if I didn't
agree what the hell am i doing
broadcasting hello dennis prager here
with a pretty crappy show today I think
people would assume trying to trying to
make your alimony payments there quat
what I didn't hear that was I'm glad I'm
very glad you didn't bummer
so listen listen I have you're making my
mother-in-law laugh that is a very good
it says in Genesis 1818 I looked it up
this morning I wouldn't have known where
it was but the idea obviously when when
the Lord is talking to Abraham and he is
going to make a people he's going to
make the
Jewish people the the the people of
Israel out of this one man's seed and he
says all the nations of the earth shall
be blessed by him it's the Christian
understanding that the this is God's
Redemption plan we have the fall and
then God creates a people for himself so
that he can reach the nations which is
to say every people beyond Israel but
through Israel how do you feel how's
that working out for you people crappy I
spent a lot of time in the Genesis
explaining this the Torah is completely
universal Jews have tended to
constrained that universality and this
is a tragedy of Jewish history it's
partially or is an inevitable result
because people become more insular
that's just the human trait is to be in
zero look we have neighborhoods in
America right it's Korean neighborhood
in LA he was a Chinese neighborhood
Japanese neighborhood Armenian
neighborhood Jewish neighborhood black
neighborhood I think it's terrible I'm
totally opposed to neighborhoods I think
it's a bad thing
might we have two neighbors in our
cul-de-sac one's Korean and one's Arab
and it's terrific that's the American
dream
doesn't mean you have to give up what
you are but you usually but living
people live with with the same people
they become insular it's true for all
but at but but I so it's just a yeah ok
I'm getting back there's no I know
you've raised a very big deal to me we
are we Jews is supposed to be a blessing
to the earth or the earth or the world
will be blessed through us in other
words I believe got the Jews or the
Israelites the Hebrews are the gods
third attempt to make a good world in
effect Christians would argue Jesus is
the fourth attempt if you will
Muslims would argue that Muhammad is the
fifth attempt Mormons would argue
that Joseph Smith's is a sixth attempt
this is that's why I don't laugh at any
of these notions they make sense to me
because a lot nothing seems to have
worked if the world is pretty awful in
so many ways so God God starts with the
conscience it doesn't work right we knew
people knew good from evil but it was
worthless so he destroys the world
starts again with Noah so he gives know
a series of laws about murder and so on
but what not to do that doesn't work
God's third attempt is okay now I'll
choose a certain people give them a lot
of laws they will be alight unto the
nations to use Isaiah's word and through
this people the entire world will be
blessed okay now there's no way that God
could speak that and need to take
another crack at it if if the Word of
God is true and Isaiah is God's prophet
which of course he is it seems to me
that that is a true statement right up
there for well therefore there there can
be no other fourth or fifth oh I see
what you're saying so you're sort of
challenging therefore my medians no what
I'm saying is that there shouldn't be a
fourth but no but I'm just telling you
whether whether or not God is behind the
fourth attempt I am simply explaining
that in my view that is what happened
the world is still awful God made this
attempt with the conscience didn't work
with Noah's laws didn't work with it
with choosing one people that didn't
work so we're going to have it depends
on what the poor what the point was
notice he chose one people right yeah
now Christians would say that he chose
the Jews and that out of the Jews he
would bring his Messiah and through that
Messiah the whole world would be led to
worship the god of the Jews which I
would say is the case among Christians
that's out of the Jew that's why I root
for Christians I'm a believing Jew who
is rooting for Christianity to succeed
you are bringing the world to my Torah
and
god bless you that is exactly all I
believe right that is right but but but
here again so many Christians didn't do
that
there's even worse there's a replacement
theology Jewish moves were the new
Israel look there's a lot of bad
theology we can't go into that we had a
notice but okay so wanted to make you
feel good by the way you know Jesus was
a Jew right no yeah
Mary was Italian I'd be clear on that
but I just have to ask you because
you've been around so much Christianity
you know more Christianity than most
pseudo Christians and by the way most
people who call themselves Christians
are in fact simply Gentiles okay they're
not Christians right but I just have to
ask you because you around so many
Christians do you think it could be
possible that Jesus could be the Messiah
of the Jews is it process it is possible
what am i but but that doesn't it
doesn't help the the let me explain
something could be possible that's of
course welcome what about Menachem
Schneerson could he beat them yes that's
possible
okay that's yes all right III am not
fixated on who was the Messiah is it has
never been a big big issue for me and by
the way it's not a it's not been a big
issue for most Jews in any event because
the the issue if the only claim for
Jesus that Christians made was he was
the Messiah there would not have been a
separated religion you literally would
have had Jews and Jews for Jesus that's
all it would have been it would not have
become a Gentile religion which is what
ultimately it became with the you know
smattering of Jews obviously that the
the issue was the divinity of Jesus and
the Trinity that is the that is the
arena of that's where the separation
into another religion came not over the
Messiah issue Jews thought that
what's-his-name the with the the revolt
oh my no shop nights fee yeah well
here's one that nobody here the lack of
sense yeah that's right Judah the
Maccabee you know the there was a lot of
people that were regarded you have the
Jewish people including me
it's leaving orthodox Vegas thought
thought that a Turkish Jew named shop
tights fee in the 17th century was the
Messiah so that that didn't make a new
religion the shop the Sabathia n--'s as
they were known and the non Sabathia
pne's but the it was the messianic by
the way just seal know interestingly my
biggest difference with Christianity
because theology is theology I've
theological differences with some Jews
obviously Christians have Mel
theological difference you're gonna hear
from them when this book gets published
I'm telling you right now well yeah well
I may well be I hope they read it
because I think it'll did I think look I
think it'll help
it helps Jews and Christians faith but
I'll tell you the issue for me is is
whether we are saved through works or
not that's the most important the
distinction where I do believe you're
safe through I think how it rewards
people who do good to tennis yep you
know what I hate though we're at a time
I would kill to have that conversation
with you we really Amuro can can Marissa
give us five more minutes and of course
we have five more we left five more
minutes
yes okay wait a minute wait a minute in
one minute and thirty five days
applauded no I'm asking Marissa she's
the CEO okay please if five why not ten
real quick you really are Jewish he said
no this is so fascinating to me you said
about the works thing right now now this
gets to what you were saying about
Genesis in other words if the heart of
Adam and Eve was already inclined to sin
then it wasn't the act of taking the
fruit it was already there in their
heart right if the tree had disappeared
as they reached for it they were they
still sinned in their hearts right right
okay so works the real issue of works
has to do with your heart not how much
money you give to build a hospital wing
because if you're doing that to get your
name on the
Hospital Wayne God says you're not
fooling me you know you did some good
but it's really about you it's not about
me or the people suffering in the
hospital so works and faith cannot
really be cleanly separated and so
people can over focus on faith and
Christians often do and they make it
sound like works means nothing and I
disagree with those Christians and I
would argue with them all day long but I
never get to do that but the point is I
would say they're wrong because just as
Jordan Peterson said a couple hours ago
you every one of us understands that we
can never do enough we know that already
we can never do enough to please God but
it the real issue is when Jordan
Peterson said that that I'm sorry the
other thing that he said about believing
in God and you kind of have to you can't
be a phoney that's kind of basically
what he's trying to say right now is you
say oh I believe in God but you don't
act like it right and all you're saying
is you got to act like it and God judges
you on your actions but I would say that
in fact God does judge you on your
actions because your actions reveal your
faith right I think in many yeah that's
true for the believer but we have to
acknowledge that there are people who
don't believe who do good okay but again
this is not you're not interviewing me
but I would still say that those people
if it's real good
that they're doing yeah they're still
doing it from that same place oh yeah
don't mean the God yeah anyway we agree
here's the point though I just want to I
was totally honest with you about where
my difference lies but having said that
the number of wonderful human beings who
were Christian believers that I have
encountered in my in my life has been so
powerful to me since I as I said to
Jordan goodness is what matters to me
and it is so clear that it is their
Christian belief that has brought them
to that goodness that they're had of
course there's authenticity to that
belief if I have a feel
practical difference that that to me is
so secondary to the fact that look look
that tree must be beautiful if it's
produced this human being as a fruit of
it and then the number of you who are
just beautiful human beings has been a
very powerful thing in my life so I how
can I say it's not true that that I
don't theological II have the same
belief doesn't make it untrue I don't
think of it as untrue somebody asked me
of the other day what if what if Jesus
were resurrected and I said I hope he
was why would I not hope that and I
wouldn't rethink my Judaism I would
believe that God had sent a message that
guess what it doesn't end with death
that's the message anyway right and
that's a great message I hope he was
resurrected um ah I'm a fan of the idea
you hope you hope that he was
resurrected news for you yeah he was
okay I'll go now listen I've got a quick
as another cheat that's just so cheap
that I did that we're at a time are you
coming to New York this week I am you're
gonna be on my radio program I have a
crazy day settled your people have
settled this no no okay come on Mary
program I can but I can't do what I
could do it from my hotel room I can't
do what lead me to the studios no it's
too crazy a day I go on Fox and Friends
in the morning I'm in Orlando with that
previous night I do Fox I love the way
you're explaining this to all these
people here
Dennis it's okay it's an I am explaining
this I love you and you know listen
nobody I am the biggest supporter you
have in the non Greek Orthodox community
the Greek the Greek we won't go there -
if these people do not run this Jewish
supporter you have in LA cañada
California I am the tallest Jewish
supporter you have in America so okay so
yeah I'm special to you my friend
yeah Wow if these people don't run
that's their computers and go to Amazon
and get this book I will have failed and
you can't let that happen
I am so great at all my dear very taxes
ahem you are great Eric you are really
great
thank you all luck thank you
Tigers a great session it was great he's
this terrific
[Applause]
