Virginia Gun Rally: Is Gun Ownership a Right? | Short Clips

PragerU
799 followers
7 Video Views·Apr 6, 2025
Tens of thousands of gun rights activists protested the left's assault on the 2nd Amendment in Virginia. A HUGE turnout!
[Music]
does an American citizen have a
constitutional right to own a gun
here's what the Second Amendment says a
well-regulated militia being necessary
to the security of a free State the
right of the people to keep and bear
arms shall not be infringed now at once
seemed to me like that language only
protected state militias and not
individuals indeed this is the view held
by the four dissenting Supreme Court
justices in the 2008 case of District of
Columbia vs. Heller a landmark case
dealing with gun ownership but the more
research I did the more I came to
realize that my initial view was
mistaken and that the founders were in
fact securing an individual right the
five justices who voted to affirm the
right to own a gun in DC vs. Heller had
indeed made the correct decision let's
look at the amendment one more time a
well-regulated militia being necessary
to the security of a free State the
right of the people to keep in bear arms
shall not be infringed we first need to
focus on the phrase the right of the
people note that the people are the only
ones whose right is secured here not the
militia or a state government this
phrase the right of the people comes up
a few times in the Constitution for
example the First Amendment refers to
the right of the people peaceably to
assemble and to petition the government
and the fourth amendment secures the
right of the people to be secure
against unreasonable searches and
seizures why then if the authors of the
Constitution felt so strongly about the
right of the people to own guns did they
include language about a well-regulated
militia these opening words of the
amendment might be called a
justification clause such clauses are
used to help explain why a right is
being secured but it's the operative
Clause that explains what right is being
secured in this case the right of the
people to keep and bear arms and what
was the word militia understood to mean
at the time
well the militia act of 1792 defined
militia to mean all white males 18 to 45
today of course militia would include
women and people of all races but it was
clearly not a reference to a small
National Guard type group and what about
the part of the amendment that says a
militia is necessary to the security of
a free State what the opponents of
personal gun ownership ask does a
personal right of gun ownership have to
do with that again historical context is
key in the 1790s the phrase free state
wasn't used to mean an individual state
like New York or Rhode Island rather it
meant what we'd call today a free
country a nation free of despotism a
free state is what the framers wanted
America to be they saw an armed
citizenry as in part a hedge against
tyranny citizens who own weapons can
protect themselves prevent tyrants from
seizing power and protect the nation
from foreign enemies this does not mean
though that this right is unlimited free
speech for example has long been subject
to some narrow and reasonable
regulations but severe restrictions on
owning a gun like severe restrictions
and free speech would violate the Second
Amendment as the founders understood it
maybe you think this understanding of
the Second Amendment is outdated today
that the Constitution needs to change as
public attitudes change the founders
included a provision for doing just that
if the public attitude really has
changed the Constitution can be amended
to reflect that change but ironically
even if we focus on current public
attitudes the case for individual gun
ownership is as strong as ever
polls consistently
that over two-thirds of Americans
believe that the Second Amendment
secures the right of citizen stone agon
and Congress and state governments have
repeatedly reaffirmed this view
including in recent decades so does the
Second Amendment secure an individual
right to bear arms it did when it was
written it has throughout American
history and it does today I'm Eugene
Wallach professor of law at UCLA for
Prager University
