Beijing Housing Prices Crash, Some Drop 80%, China’s ‘Good House’ Standard Sparks Work Stoppage

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financenews
A real estate agent recently reported that home prices in eastern Beijing plummeted by 80% overnight.
What About Shanghai, One of China’s Most Resilient Markets?
Right now, Beijing's housing prices have dropped back to about August 2016 levels.
Some areas have seen drastic declines of 40% to 50%,
while the least affected areas have still dropped by at least 15%.
Nearly all residential communities in Beijing are experiencing price drops.
If prices fall back to March 2016 levels, things will get really serious.
That would signal a systemic financial risk.
At that point, selling homes would be the only option.
But the real nightmare comes if prices continue dropping.
Imagine selling your home and ending up with nothing.
Then banks start auctioning off properties, but even they can't recover their money.
This could lead to a collapse in bank balance sheets,
triggering a financial crisis similar to Japan's housing market crash in 1992.
A real estate agent recently reported that home prices in eastern Beijing
plummeted by 80% overnight.
And what about Shanghai, one of China's most resilient markets?
In Shanghai's inner ring, prices have dropped to just over 40,000 RMB per square meter.
In Channing District's Zhongshan Park area, a small, old, 53.7-square-meter,
two-bedroom apartment is now listed at only 2.58 million RMB.
Just a few years ago, it was unthinkable to buy anything near Zhongshan Park
for just over 2 million RMB.
The market simply can't sustain itself anymore.
Investors who speculated on real estate are now in deep trouble.
Some say their tears could fill a lake.
A commenter online joked,
40,000 RMB per square meter sounds cheap,
but even if prices were cut in half again, they still wouldn't be low enough.
The housing price index for March is out.
And overall, second-hand home prices are still falling.
In fact, the rate of decline appears to be accelerating.
A Chinese research institute reported that while prices for new homes showed a slight rebound in
March, this doesn't indicate a market recovery.
It's simply the result of a government intervention.
Meanwhile, second-hand home prices, which better reflect real market conditions,
continue to decline, with signs of further acceleration.
On March 31, the Ministry of Housing and Urban Rural Development
released what they called the National Standard for Residential Projects.
The key regulations include
1. New residential buildings must have a minimum floor height of 3 meters.
2. Buildings with four or more floors must have elevators.
3. Improved soundproofing for walls and floors.
4. Wider doorways for main entrances and bathrooms.
And 5. Higher railings for balconies and other exposed areas.
These new regulations will take effect on May 1,
and the government has made it clear that they are mandatory engineering construction standards,
meaning all provisions must be strictly followed.
Several state-run media outlets have claimed that this is the national standard for good houses.
Most netizens in China have expressed skepticism.
Some comments include,
What about the old houses?
Second-hand houses won't sell now.
Wouldn't it be more practical to build more affordable housing
rather than hyping up this fourth-generation housing?
Others have commented,
They're trying every trick to get people to buy houses,
but it's just taking advantage of them.
There's no regulation to restrict developers.
How much will this cost per meter?
With the current prices, most people can't afford it,
and now they're doing this.
One netizen posted that the current trend in the real estate market
is that second-hand houses are being sold at lower prices to increase transactions,
while new houses are being put on the market without much demand.
After the new good house regulations come into play,
people might prefer to wait and buy new homes built to these standards
instead of second-hand homes,
which could leave many second-hand home sellers in trouble.
Mr. Zhang, an intellectual from Beijing,
said that new rules will clearly increase developers' costs.
However, this cost will not be borne by developers
but will inevitably be passed on to the homebuyers.
Mr. Zhang believes that while the government
can encourage having elevators in buildings over four stories
and increasing ceiling heights,
it shouldn't impose these regulations as hard rules.
Developers should be allowed to decide based on the market.
He said,
I don't know if the Ministry of Housing and Urban Rural Development
has done any research before implementing this rule.
I'm not sure if it fits China's actual situation
or the real needs of the people.
He also feels that the government seems to think it has immense power,
showing a lack of respect for the market and the people.
He pointed out that many recent government policies on real estate haven't worked,
and despite the appearance of new measures,
the housing market remains stagnant.
At the National People's Congress in March,
the Chinese government's work report mentioned good houses for the first time
and emphasized stabilizing the housing market.
Ni Hong, the Minister of Housing and Urban Rural Development,
introduced the new good house construction guidelines
and revisions to residential project standards during a press conference.
A netizen from Shanghai's financial sector said,
I think the main purpose of this policy is to curb second-hand housing transactions.
Potential buyers may hesitate due to this so-called policy,
and second-hand housing sales are the main reason for falling prices
and homebuyers facing mortgage struggles.
He continued,
Actually, the government is contradictory.
On the one hand, it wants to increase liquidity
and encourage people to buy homes to boost the housing market.
On the other hand, it doesn't want people to buy second-hand houses
because those sales won't help developers with their cash flow issues
or ease the financial burden on local governments.
The sale prices of second-hand houses
better reflect the true state of the housing market.
So the government wants people to buy new homes instead,
especially when the market is on the verge of collapse.
Some netizens expressed support for the new policy,
particularly appreciating the focus on soundproofing.
One person said,
Finally, they're addressing the noise problem.
Nowadays, even a cough or sneeze in the middle of the night
can be heard clearly by neighbors,
especially when ordinary conversations can be heard between families.
It's very awkward and there's no privacy at all.
Another good point is that the current regulation requires elevators
in buildings starting from seven floors,
but now it will be required starting from four floors,
which is a positive change.
Davey J. Huang, an American economist,
argues that Beijing's new better home regulations
are not truly about improving housing quality,
but rather a strategic maneuver to control policy direction
and resource allocation.
He identifies four deeper motives behind the policy.
The first is market segmentation and industry reshuffling.
The new standards effectively raise the entry barrier,
cutting out underfunded and technologically weaker smaller developers.
Requirements like three-meter ceilings and mandatory elevators
are a death sentence for budget-conscious projects
in third- and fourth-tier cities.
The goal is to consolidate housing supply
within state-controlled enterprises,
ensuring that future urban residential development
remains in the hands of trusted state-owned giants
at both the central and local levels.
The second is steering demand towards core urban areas.
With the new standards in place,
many older, smaller, and lower-standard homes
will struggle to sell, especially in lower-tier cities.
This policy nudges buyers back towards first- and second-tier cities,
where demand can be more easily controlled
within a state-managed system.
By doing so, Beijing reclaims influence
over the free-flowing real estate market,
ensuring that private housing demand is funneled into locations
that align with government priorities.
The third is a narrative shift from home delivery to home quality.
China's real estate market is experiencing
a systemic collapse of trust,
with buyers increasingly worried about unfinished,
low-quality, or devalued homes.
By shifting the official discourse from delivering homes
to improving housing quality,
the government is attempting to rebuild confidence,
or at least create an illusion of hope.
Huang says that this is a propaganda tactic
aimed at distracting people from unfinished projects
and growing homeowner protests.
Instead of addressing the toxic assets
already sitting in the market,
authorities are manufacturing a vision of future improvements
to drown out frustration with present failures.
He said that this is part of a massive effort
by Beijing's authorities
to suppress the voices of the unfinished building crisis.
This is a typical example of institutional hypocrisy.
However, high institutional standards
do not guarantee proper enforcement.
Under the CCP system,
the fact that laws are available
does not mean that they will be followed.
As seen in the past,
despite regulations strictly forbidding
the misuse of pre-sale funds,
unfinished buildings have been widespread.
Similarly, while regulations claim
to protect transparent pricing,
it often comes down to connections and informal rules.
Huang questions whether with the new demands,
quality will truly be delivered as promised.
The fourth unstated reason for the new rules
is centralizing control over construction approvals.
Previously, local construction authorities
had significant autonomy over building standards
and project approvals.
With these new nationalized regulations,
Beijing is reasserting control,
ensuring that all housing projects
must conform to centrally dictated guidelines.
This recentralization of housing
strengthens the Communist Party's grip
over the real estate sector,
making all housing development
subject to direct oversight
from the Ministry of Housing
and Urban Rural Development
and the Central Technical Standards Committee.
Huang believes the immediate consequences
will include industry turmoil and construction halts,
as many existing development plans
become obsolete or require extensive revisions,
causing construction delays,
project cancellations,
and layoffs in the short term.
Developers must absorb higher costs
to comply with the new standards,
but with low sales and declining demand,
their financial struggles will intensify.
The midterm impact will be housing stratification.
The higher regulatory threshold
will further marginalize lower-income groups,
effectively excluding them from the housing market.
Many affordable housing options will disappear,
accelerating spatial inequality
between the rich and the poor.
Migrant workers and low-income families
will find it even harder to buy homes,
pushing them into poor living conditions
or dependence on rentals.
In the long run,
local governments may have to increase
infrastructure spending
and provide subsidized land
to state-owned developers
to ensure compliance with the new standards.
This will further drain local budgets
and deepen China's local debt crisis,
as more funds are funneled into politically driven
rather than economically viable projects.
China has long suffered from shoddy construction
and widespread regulatory corruption.
Huang points out that Beijing's housing problem
isn't just about setting higher standards,
it's about enforcing them.
China already has strict laws
banning the misuse of pre-sale funds,
yet unfinished projects are everywhere.
Price transparency rules exist,
but in practice,
real estate sales are dominated
by backdoor deals and corruption.
So while the government mandates higher ceilings
and mandatory elevators,
who ensures developers won't cut corners elsewhere?
What is the background behind the CCP
introducing this policy?
And what is the current situation
of China's real estate market?
This morning, my neighbor's house
was auctioned off by the court
because they couldn't pay the mortgage.
The couple has two young kids.
One just started primary school.
The other is still in kindergarten.
They were forced to move.
The wife was wiping away tears while packing
and the husband stood nearby,
expressionless and pale.
The kids seemed oblivious to what was going on,
still happily jumping and playing in the hallway.
It's hard to imagine how they'll manage moving forward.
They might even end up separated.
Another woman revealed that her neighbors,
a couple in Shenzhen,
had invested in 150 million RMB worth of property,
which lost 75% of its value,
causing them to lose 90 million RMB overnight.
For property speculators,
losing money doesn't deserve sympathy.
It's their own fault.
Houses are meant for those with real needs,
not for speculation.
The sky-high prices before were due to speculation
and now the market is paying the price.
This is just fate.
A real estate insider posted,
the biggest speculator in Shenzhen
has a monthly mortgage of 1.6 million RMB.
I was shocked when I heard this number.
Property prices have been falling
for the last two years
and this is just the beginning
of the collapse for speculators.
I hear that many properties in Shenzhen
are being auctioned
because speculators went bankrupt.
I think 90% of the speculators nationwide
will face a similar fate
and they'll all go under.
Buying a house in Beijing
means losing 1 million RMB a year.
That's actually a small loss.
A friend of mine bought a property in Wangjing
for 8 million RMB
with a down payment of 3.2 million RMB
and a monthly mortgage of about 28,000 RMB.
Now the property is worth only 6 million RMB,
so they've lost 2 million.
Plus there's another 60 to 70,000 RMB
in interest over the past few years.
All the hard work has gone to waste.
Now he's too scared to quit his job.
In Zhuhai,
a real estate agent shared even worse news.
Property prices here have dropped by 30 to 50%.
It's different in each area,
but the situation is bad overall.
Many communities here are ghost towns,
with vacancy rates reaching over 90%.
Some buildings have only one household
living in them,
and some have none.
Despite having all the necessary facilities,
these properties just can't sell.
Only drastic price drops
can maintain any transaction volume.
Some say that in 10 years,
properties will be worthless,
but I'd argue it won't even take that long.
Maybe in 5 years,
properties will be worth nothing.
You'll be able to buy a whole unit
for just a few thousand RMB.
Some even joked,
if you keep saying the property market is crashing,
they'll arrest you.
Others said,
in the future,
today's commercial properties
will become like industrial parks,
full of weeds and abandoned,
some already being demolished.
On real estate platforms in cities
like Beijing and Shanghai,
many property promoters
are posting high-quality videos,
claiming that prices haven't dropped.
They're promoting the idea
that the market has bottomed out,
and they're encouraging people to buy now,
or they'll regret it later.
Some even claim the government
has introduced massive benefits,
and that property prices will rebound soon.
However, a real estate agent in Shanghai
who has worked in the industry for 17 years said,
I have to risk telling everyone the truth.
Don't fall for the hype.
This so-called good house policy
isn't going to fix the market.
