Is "Follow the Science" Scientific? | Interviews

PragerU
800 followers
4 Video Views·Apr 2, 2025
Astrophysicist Brian Keating joins George Howe from The Daily Wire to discuss why anytime someone says "Follow the Science" he gets worried. They also explore what science can and can't provide to society.
This episode is part of a new series in partnership with The Daily Wire featuring in-depth discussions with PragerU experts about their 5-minute video topic.
Watch Brian Keating's new 5-Minute Video, “Follow the Science” https://www.prageru.com/video/follow-the-science/
welcome to office hours i'm georgia howe
with the daily wire
today we sit down with professor of
physics at the center for astrophysics
and space sciences at the university of
california san diego
brian keating brian is also the host of
the podcast into the impossible
brian's new prageru video is titled
follow the science
where he discusses what science can tell
us and what it can't
let's jump right in
[Music]
brian thank you so much for joining me
it's a pleasure to be with you george
i'm a longtime subscriber and fan
so i actually looked up your podcast
before doing this interview and it turns
out you
uh address basically all of my favorite
topics loop quantum gravity
hypotheses for god so and it looked like
you were kind of a hoot so i was excited
to start this interview
thank you yeah i pride myself on
diversity in the most important ways
possible
something you discussed in your video
that i'd like to start with is you
talked about how
science can create knowledge but it
can't create wisdom
and it reminds me of the phrase science
describes but it doesn't prescribe
so can you for the audience do a little
example to kind of show what you mean
by science creates knowledge but it
doesn't create wisdom
yeah i think you know it's really no
where better illustrated than if you
look at the lives of the
greatest scientists of the past hundred
years these are
uh typically men although thankfully it
is getting more common to see women
rising to the ranks of nobel laureates
however uh some of the most famous nobel
laureates in history had some of the
most odious opinions about policy
towards racial minorities towards women
and
in many respects it's uh it's really
kind of shameful
that we venerate these people for their
knowledge
so much that it really crosses the
boundary
into perceiving that they might have
some special wisdom
and i always say it's quite it's quite
dangerous to do that because if you
look to somebody purely based on their
knowledge they'll never be a person who
knows more than the internet than
a the most powerful super computer but
what's really lacking is wisdom
and there's really no substitute for
kind of
the building on life experience that
sadly so many of my fellow scientists
miss out on because they focus so much
on
their knowledge acquisition rather than
wisdom acquisition and the meaning of
what they do
rather than the value of what they do
well that makes me think a lot about
covid because
obviously this past year we've all heard
the phrase follow the science
but as your video discussed uh science
can give you data but it can't
necessarily give you a prescription for
what to do with that data i'd be
interested to hear your thoughts on that
yeah i was certainly running through the
back of my mind as a theme
that we often hear you know follow the
science or we listen to science or we're
the party of science
and you know science has no political
affiliation uh no one ever looks up at a
constellation and says oh that's the
republican constellation over there
there's a
democratic asteroid coming uh in that
direction it doesn't exist so science
should be apolitical and we don't elect
scientists to make decisions for us as
sort of
this intellectual democracy uh and as
even nobel
laureates have told me on my podcast you
know if you think we're really bright
and we have some special wisdom you've
never seen us trying to make a selection
for breakfast in the morning
that we got our nobel prizes so i think
yes it is very dangerous to say that
science belongs to
an individual or even that there is
group think you know
this this notion that we should trust
the science sometimes
again gets distorted into a message of
the the real message being you should
obey scientists
and again we never elected these people
no matter how brilliant they are no
matter
how many nobel prizes they might have we
don't elect them we elect politicians
and it's bad for politicians that we
elect the president vice president et
cetera
to derelict their duty and say we're
just going to follow the science as if
there is
uniformity of thought within science if
there was
it would be a bad day for science in
your video you also talk about what
good science is and actually i want to
play a clip of that and then i'm going
to ask you a question about it
so how do we do good science this is not
a new question
since the 17th century scientists have
employed the so-called scientific method
to guide their work it's not a perfect
guide by any means but it's pretty darn
good
the method involves one formulating a
theory
two predicting the evidence that should
be found if the theory is true
three collecting data four analyzing the
data
five refining the theory and presenting
evidence to other experts
so in cases like covid and i also think
of maybe climate change
when we're in a situation where we're
very reliant on models because
models are all we have um what does good
science look like in those situations
where we're considering a threat for the
future or potential threat
so what's confusing sometimes for lay
people who are not scientists
is the distinction between a theory and
a model we typically think of things oh
a theory is just a kind of an opinion
that's just your theory
but actually in science the theory is a
very well tested set of hypotheses
backed by observational evidence tested
by claims and often
backed by consensus however a model
might just be a prediction made by a
single individual based on a preceding
theory or hypothesis
and so they carry very different weights
and so as i say you know kind of
channeling my inner yogi berra it's very
difficult to make predictions especially
about the future
in this case it's hard for a one-time
only situation like
our universe or like a global pandemic
which really doesn't happen all that
often
to make far-reaching implications based
on a model
of with very limited input data that's a
very big challenge
and it's and it is troubling when it is
used for political reasons rather than
for purely scientific reasons and so
that's sort of the purpose of this of
this uh prager university video
is to eliminate for the layperson what
do scientists
actually do and for that reason i'm very
proud to really uh
to convey to a to a lay audience the
meaning of what we as scientists do
and the limitations of what we do and
when
we should have some skepticism at least
in the part of the lay person
i guess a question for me as a layperson
would be how can i
tell if i'm sort of um
if the research that i'm reading say in
a magazine or whatever
if it's a good if it's good science that
i'm looking at
versus kind of shoddy science so is
there any red flags that we should look
for
or what does good science look like
would you say especially in these
situations
yeah of course you know just as the
situation itself is a one-time thing
your reaction to it let's hope is a
one-time situation that
hopefully we won't be dealing with
pandemics and so forth um
you know in the near term uh and it's
very difficult it's very difficult to
know when you hear these titles and you
hear
this uniformity and unanimity i would
say the the distinction that you should
always make is am i being asked to obey
a scientist
or listen to a scientist and as the
scientific method progresses
it's based on scientists questioning
other scientists
so i am personally very skeptical and
even when i was a layperson not
a professor for example i was very
skeptical when i would hear things like
all these scientists agree uh in x y or
z
because as i point out in the video many
different times in
human history have scientists been on
the wrong side of scientific history
even the majority of those speaking as
scientists in their day
so it's very uh it should be sort of
troubling
it doesn't affect your daily life i know
loop quantum gravity is very important
to you
georgia but to most people doesn't
really affect their day so if scientists
kind of debate about loop quantum
gravity
or the big bang or you know even things
like you know
uh the the future of artificial
intelligence and so forth
these might for now at least uh be
mostly theoretical or mostly potential
possibilities
might be metaphysically might be
theological which is very important or
philosophical
however they don't impact your daily
life when something is said to impact
your daily life
that's when you should take notice and
really dig into it and make sure you
understand
what are the motivations for scientists
making specific claims
and why should i be asked to obey a
scientist when i elected
the president vice president et cetera i
want to ask you about politics and
science
so obviously we have our petty mask wars
but i'm more concerned about
political pressure that scientists may
feel in terms of
what they should be studying and what
they can and can't get published
so can you talk a little bit about the
pressure that scientists feel behind the
scenes
if there are any um and how that affects
our ability to get good quality science
yeah scientists suffer from a whole
panoply of
different uh pressures within academia
and even outside in industry
we in academia have pressure to get into
the best colleges the best graduate
schools the best post-doctoral programs
if we're very lucky you become
professors then we have to compete for
tenure
and at all these different levels you're
competing so to speak against the
best and brightest that the world has to
offer uh from all different uh corners
of the planet
and so it's it's extremely challenging
it's very limited and unlike say
uh the boardroom of a fortune 500
company there are 500 companies in the
fortune 500
there's only one nobel prize there's
only one you know
national science foundation national
institute of health so a lot of times
there is pressure to conform to the
standard practices to the best practices
which
sometimes makes people much more
conservative you know literacy
uh than than is good for the actual
generation and perpetuation of knowledge
and i think
on the one hand we spend a pittance on
the scientific research compared to
how much we spend on lipstick and and
other things and my favorite statistic
is we spend more on lipstick than all of
nasa's budget now lipstick's important
as you can tell uh you know from my
appearance but uh but nevertheless
the future of the world we're always
told is at stake with
with things like stem and and
potentially human induced climate change
i mentioned that in the video
and so what what could be more important
and i think that then gets driven by
political decisions
budgetary decisions and yes it is a
finite game
in terms of how much funding you can get
there are winners for every proposal
there are losers for every proposal
every funding opportunity but the
fundamental dichotomy is that science is
an
infinite game you know there's you never
win science you're never like oh i want
science i got 100
scientific market share that will never
happen and so
it is a challenge to balance that
dichotomy on this on this knife edge
between doing the best high risk science
which often is high reward
but also kind of doing the mundane
things that you need to do to keep your
laboratory your graduate students etc
funded
so yes there are certain best practices
and unfortunately a lot of times it
doesn't allow for the
most beautiful of scientific things
which is serendipity when you discover
something completely unexpected
that's becoming you know less and less
common unfortunately within science
an issue i think we've had over this
past year is a breakdown in trust
between
the public and the so-called experts the
scientific community
i think a lot of people have concerns
that politics are getting into science
and that's affecting the kind of
information that we're able to get
so my question is as lay people is there
anything we can do
to help rebuild that relationship in
terms of
supporting integrity in science and
making it easier
for scientists to pursue things
boldly and honestly and with integrity
yeah it's a very very good question i
find it very challenging
when i talk to the public because they
feel like i'm doing something very
specialized
with specialized equipment and you know
they wouldn't go into a job site and
take away a jackhammer
you know from a construction worker any
more than they feel like they have a
right to know about my knowledge that
i've acquired in my laboratory
however i always point out i'm a public
servant i work for the state of
california
but anybody who's been funded by a
national science foundation grant a nasa
grant
we're funded by u.s taxpayers so never
ever forget that they
have you have a right as a taxpayer to
to sort of be included in the scientific
process to have things explained to you
in a way that you can understand them
as i quote from famed nobel laureate
richard feynman
he said you know the first principle is
that you shouldn't fool yourself
and you are the easiest person to fool
and after you have not fooled yourself
then you can work on not fooling other
scientists and not fooling
the public itself because in that sense
you're doing a real disservice to the
pursuit of truth and we as
scientists should be merchants of truth
so yes i say demand answers that you can
understand
understand that science is provisional
but that's a good thing and that science
is argumentative
provisional consensus based but ask
for things to be understood and
participate in the scientific process
and tell scientists that you support
them and that you should argue to our
government
it's one of the few things that all you
know politicians used to agree on that
supporting science was good and it was
cutting across political boundaries so
it's a safe space
for for the lay person to occupy and it
should be
to the benefit of scientists on the flip
side scientists have an obligation
to do some sort of outreach to the
public and it's typically not within our
purview we always say you know how do
you know a scientist is outgoing
because he looks at your shoes when he
talks to you instead of his own
or her own but the point uh that i'm
trying to make is we have an obligation
also to present in digestible form and i
try to do this on my youtube channel and
my podcast
to do outreach to the public because you
all pay my salary
one way or another and i am blessed to
have a job that
don't tell governor newsom i would
probably do it for free
oh that gruesome new sum all right so
brian where can we find you online
oh i'm available on twitter at dr brian
keating
uh i am also on youtube i have a
really growing list of nobel laureates
and daily wire
uh personalities i hope to get you on
the show someday george i've had ben
shapiro
michael knowles dennis prager is coming
up and i've also had nine other nobel
prize winners
in addition to michael and ben and and
and so forth so i've uh i have a
wonderful guest i'm also on uh podcast
into the impossible podcast
where we deconstruct the most
magnificent minds in the multiverse
excellent all right well thank you so
much for joining me
thank you georgia it's a real pleasure
all right that's the end of today's
office hours
make sure to tune in next week for our
conversation with a new prageru
presenter
i'm georgia howe thanks for tuning in
[Music]
thanks for watching this episode of
office hours if you'd like to watch more
interviews with prageru presenters
head over to dailywire.com subscribe and
become a member today
you
